Discussion Locked

TechRepublic editors need opinions on new quick-start guides

0 helpful
45 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Several members have expressed the need for primers (quick start-type guides) that summarize essential information allowing them to quickly familiarize themselves with a specific topic. A team of editors is working to test publishing just such a file, but in order to make these guides as helpful as we can, we need your feedback. While these files will ultimately live on TechProGuild, we will make some of them available for a short period to all TechRepublic members.

Based on what we've heard in the past, the first topic we're going to develop an alpha version for is Windows XP Professional Security. After brainstorming, editors here think it makes the most sense to include the following elements: overview, planning, setup & configuration, troubleshooting, optimizing, and a glossary. We're also creating an interactive checklist you can use. It highlights common actions IT pros should take to secure WinXP Pro environments.

How well might such a completed tool work for you? And, would you be willing to review an alpha version when we publish it? If you're interested in participating, please e-mail me at eeckel@techrepublic.com.

Thanks much,

Erik Eckel
TechRepublic Executive Editor

45 replies

by babui386

Hi,
I am currently using 2000 server in office, we have recently bought a new Apple Mac, I set up Apple mac to my server via DHCP Router, Everything is working fine, I can see the volder called MICROSOFT UAM Volume folder in Server and apple computer, the problem is permission, I can transfer file from UAM Volume folder to Apple mac desktop, but I can't copy any file from Apple mac to this folder, Error: Disk is LOCKED. Please if any one knows how to configure permission in server, please please give me email or post it here, I will be realy greatful.
Thanks
Mashkur

by jimhm

Stop with the - How can we charge more - You know once you get more ideas of what people would read - you will start charging more for the service - Just Like Gartner or MS -

KEEP IT FREE -

by Erik Eckel

JimHM,

As my note mentioned, my plans call for making these guides available free for a specific period on TechRepublic.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

Erik Eckel
TechRepublic Executive Editor

by tomsal

First I agree with Jim. Second technically you contradict yourself a bit...

"While these files will ultimately live on TechProGuild, we will make some of them available for a short period to all TechRepublic members."

That what your note read, the keyword here is *SOME*.

Here in this thread your message doesn't say *some*, it implies ALL.

Why this topic is being batted around here, I love how several of the books that TR sells for up to $89 a pop is basically a re-hash of the website. So I can PAY for a book or visit the site and get the same info?

I don't understand that.

by kalizahn

Ok, first, I have to say I think we're all off topic complaining that there might be a cost before anyone's even seen the product. Second, if we all want to keep seeing free products, we might just have to accept the fact that the men and women writing these articles and guides that we all love to read/see/use do need to collect a paycheck just like the rest of us, so we need to be prepared to show some support for the projects, especially when they do meet our needs and provide materials we can work with. I admit, I do NOT subscribe to TechPro Guild because when I did test it a few years ago, I did not find the layout of the magazine very helpful at the time, and, yes, I had usually read all the articles I was interested in before the paper version arrive, but it may time for me to check it out again, especially with the addition of pieces like the Quickstart Guides. I think these guides could be very useful, and if they do work, from what I've read, the work that the TechRepublic folks are putting in deserves acknowledgement and, yes probably even, *gasp* money!

Thanks to Erik and everyone else at TechRepublic for providing us with TONES of free information, for all your hard work, and for continuing to provide us with new and better ways to obtain the information we need.

Kali

by brilliance audio

I've never posted on a subject before, but I feel like I have to at least give a little support to Kali and the TechRepublic staff. This is the only website that I have ever paid a subscription for, and I have been a member for a couple of years now. The membership fee is within reason and I know that the information that my staff and I can get is useful, relevant, and easy to find.
I think the user guides are a great idea, and a minimal fee for access to compiled research like this is more than fair.
Keep up the good work, TechRepublic - and thanks for asking for our opinions. My $89/year has saved me countless hours searching for information I can trust before purchases; given me great tips and insight into all areas of my profession; and saved my sanity a number of times. Resellers charge more than that for a one-hour "assessment" AND you can bet that they won't be handing me templates and do-it-yourself guides - or finding any 'Gotchyas'.

Keep up the good work and the low prices. It's a great value.

by jimhm

Sorry don't believe I was off subject - this site started off free, all articles and information (books and CD's always were a charge). They gave points away, and coffee mugs - but never came up with something with the points.

Now if they wanted to - lets say that 1,000 points equals a dollar, then 89,000 point would be a year membership - which would then encourage people to participate in dicussion and answer the Q/A Technical question.

But nope - That would make it free again - or they would reduce the points awarded - I've dealt with Gartner services for over 15 years - they refine and seqment each service then charge for each segmented service. So that you may have server - but you don't have the Linux service.

I just see a repeat of that pricing model occuring here in techrepublic. Once free - now $89.00 - no discounts on books or cds to get your money back - no bonus for points they award -

The same questions were ask with Gartner services - how can we better define a service then - poof a segment service for more money.

by hal 9000

And provided that you provide the details of setting up an XP network even if only a peer to peer and the proper way to instigate security on it that would be great.

I mean to keep different users out of folders that they are not supposed to have access to and securing the entire network from intrusion from outside sources via the Internet connection.

I've seen some so called professionals setup a network with an ADSL Modem connected to a hub and then everything running off the hub with no security what so ever applied to any computer on the network.

Col

by Erik Eckel

Col Luck,

Thanks for the feedback. I'm not sure how far we'll go in describing how to set up a network (that might be an entirely separate quick start guide altogether), but we'll be sure to cover network security.

Let me know if you'd like to see an alpha version. I'd be happy to pass you a copy when it's ready.

Thanks again,

EE

by techmail.cmccubbin

Always willing to be a test bed subject. I believe the guide shoude be formatted much like the plasticized "bar charts" or cheat sheets you see for a variety of topics. Keep them simple, with a sub-topic, such as firewall configuration and then a 1-2-3 of how to do it. These should be for the basics not to cover every contingent.

Send on the tests!

by Erik Eckel

techmail@cmccubbin.com,

Thanks for your interest. I've added you to my list. I'll pass you an alpha version of our first guide when it's ready (likely early next week).

Thanks, too, for your feedback. We're working to ensure members can easily find the relevant sections they need and we're also working to break out numbered steps wherever possible.

EE

by tuckerglt

This sounds like a great idea, I have two suggestions and I will be happy to beta test the documents as well.
1)Please include either brief explanations for settings or if that is not possible then a link to a site where a person can learn the reason for a setting.
2)Make sure there is an easily printable form of the complete document without having to print each "page" indivdually.

by Erik Eckel

Tuckerglt,

Thanks for your interest in helping test our guides. Before I can add you to my list of reviewers, though, I'll need your e-mail address. If you can pass that through, I'll add you to my list and ensure you receive a copy when the first one is ready (likely early next week).

We're working to number the steps that must be completed (thereby hopefully addressing your settings question) wherever we can. We're also planning to publish the guides as PDF files, as they are easy to read and easy to print (which hopefully addresses your second question of making the document easy to print).

Please let me know of any other ideas you might have, and don't forget to send your e-mail address to me at erik.eckel@techrepublic.com.

Thanks again for your feedback,

EE

by oz_media

Well I must agree that with all the banners impressions I display each day and night, all the people who regulars exncourage to stay here and participate in discussions etc. It would be nice to see SOME free information from someone other than the peers that keep the site alive.

I can get free info from some of the world's top techs, and YES they are here and I have the privaledge of tapping into their experience as thousands of others have. If I want something from TR, I have to buy it?

Tell you what, you guys live up to YOUR end of the bargain and send out the elusive Top Geek prizes as you have said you would so many times and PERHAPS, I may encourage people to support TR by purchasing TPG memberships and goodies.

The prizes are not an issue in themselves, I have a coffee mug and don't drink coffee anymore, the point is, you gathered feedback, everyone was interested, you announced winners and.............

I guess it's a credibility issue?

by Erik Eckel

Tom,

I'm hoping to test how well these new guides help IT professionals solve real-world challenges. I have no reservations about making the guides (either some or all of them) free on TechRepublic for a period of time, if they prove helpful to IT professionals.

If I'm correct assuming you'd prefer all these guides be made free (at least for some period), then your feedback is already helping shape the manner in which these tools are delivered.

Just as TechRepublic's books, CDs, and charts have proven popular by collecting content around specific topics and offering readers an optional (other-than-online) format, I'm hoping I can introduce other items IT professionals find valuable in overcoming the daily problems they face. But to make these guides valuable, I need more feedback on exactly what elements should be included and what topics you need covered.

Feel free to e-mail me directly at erik.eckel@techrepublic.com with any other questions or thoughts you have. I appreciate your sharing your opinion.

EE

by eggy

Erik,

It sounds like a good idea. I'll stand-by to see the 'alpha' version, and following progress as well. Please let us know how/where to watch for news as things unfold.

Thanks,
Pete

by Erik Eckel

Pete,

Thanks for your interest. The more feedback I can receive on the guide, its format, and how well it addresses the topic it covers, the better.

I'll be sure to publish a link here to an alpha version when it posts.

EE

by noellejc

"Starting" often means a user does things incorrectly
and paints her/himself into the proverbial "corner".
Typical manuals do not take this into consideration,
much less give hints on how to fly over the wet paint!

How about warnings in the Quick Start Guide to help
"starters" avoid doing this?

by Erik Eckel

Thanks for sharing this idea.

Would having actual best practices handouts you could distribute to users be helpful? I think we can cover the common errors users make in the file we create, certainly, but we could also produce a separate handout IT pros pass directly to users, if you think that might help.

EE

by janiceannmichal

Even though the charts/guides are hard copy to know where to go for further reference information can be priceless. It makes it a lot easier for someone searching for specifics regarding an answer.

by Erik Eckel

Thanks for this tip.

We've created a few resources before that include links to related items. I'll pass this idea along to one of the editors on the project team. There may well be a way we could add a related resources section to the back.

EE

by bhunsinger

Sure I could help test this stuff- just so that everyone gets some chance to see it on the free side.

by Erik Eckel

BHunsinger,

I'll be sure to post a link here once the alpha version is ready (sometime next week). I'd enjoy hearing your feedback once you've had a chance to give it a look.

Thanks for your interest.

EE

by bhunsinger

First thoughts on usefulness. A pdf only format can be a pain. I have a full version of adobe acrobat and making notes or comments even with that is ... laborious. Also it can be hard to read on a laptop if you are onsite doing support. So for comments, perhaps a rtf file might help. As a final tool, perhap HTML would be a good format, especially for trouble shooting.
Maybe it's just me, but onsite, people seem to give you more respect if you are following a checklist on a laptop rather than a piece of paper. Seriously, I really like to have my support tools with me, you never know when the opportunity to be a hero will arive, and not everyone has access to broadband yet.

by bobobrien

I would be interested in participating in the review. A tool like this would help me in my consulting practice when talking to customer about security.

Bob

by Erik Eckel

bobobrien,

Thanks for your interest.

I'll add you to my e-mail list and send you a copy next week when the alpha version is ready.

EE

by homelan

I have a very small home-office setup. Three systems, peer-peer connected via WindowsXP.

by bpa_joe

I've just installed Win XP Pro at home and would like to ensure that I've plug all the holes. I'd gladly put your new security guide to the test and provide feedback.

by Erik Eckel

Thanks for your interest. I'll ensure I post a link here when the alpha version is ready.

EE

by brilliance audio

One thing that I have always wanted in a user guide is a "Gotchya" list. You know that horrible feeling in the pit of your stomach on Sunday morning about 10 a.m. when you've completely wiped the old system and are putting the finishing touches on the new system and a fatal error happens - Gotchya!

Of course, it is usually easily fixed with a hot fix or patch that is posted on the Internet that you can't access now because all networking just went south. :)

I would include a list of things that should be downloaded or configured prior to the other steps in the user guide. And with XP security, I think it would be a good idea to include the basics of the Microsoft security patch release schedule and critical patch management.

I have learned that before any installation of anything - search for "install" and the program on the tech support website and read the subject line of everything that comes up. I have survived quite nicely by finding out *first* that my particular NIC doesn't have an updated driver, a hot fix was just issued yesterday for my particular situation, etc. It might be useful to have a list of known issues, or at least a spot to look for updated information prior to using the guide. Something a little more informative than "check the readme file". :)

by Erik Eckel

k_gosh,

That's a great idea. Thanks for sharing it.

For our alpha version, we're planning on including a basic checklist at the end that you could review to ensure you didn't skip or overlook an important step. It's easy to address 22 elements, spend quite a bit of time on them, but miss a 23rd element that opens the whole network up to an attack. That's what we're hoping this guide, combined with its corresponding checklist, could help prevent.

EE

by srvctec

I'd be glad to try out the new guides and give feedback. I just became "the computer guy" at work in addition to my service technician duties and have several XP Pro machines to keep secure.

srvctec@sbcglobal.net

Kurt

by Erik Eckel

Kurt,

I appreciate your interest. I'll make sure I add you to my e-mail list for reviewers.

Thanks,

EE

by nre

I work as the academic help desk manager at a university. I would be happy to test the new guide in an environment that could you all the help it can get.

by Erik Eckel

Thanks, I'll ensure you're added to my e-mail list of reviewers.

Having a help desk perspective will certainly prove valuable.

EE

by Erik Eckel

JimHM,

You've made it clear you don't wish to pay for the resource we are developing and planning to test. I appreciate that feedback. It's certainly valuable.

Instead of debating the topic of content providers recovering production costs, though, I'd like to keep this thread focused on how my team can create a resource that you'd find helpful and valuable (and if part of making it "valuable" requires making it available free for a period of time, that's good to know).

Please keep your recommendations coming.

EE

by bswin

Quick start guides are an excellent idea, would very much like to add my two cents while still in the formative stage.

by Erik Eckel

bswin,

Thanks for your interest. I'll be sure to post a link here once the template is ready mid-week next week. We'll only be publishing an alpha version, as we'll be relying upon reader feedback to flesh out the guide.

EE

by Erik Eckel

BHunsinger,

Thanks for sharing these thoughts. We've debated other file formats, but we've hear from many members who prefer PDFs for their ease of printing.

We could create HTML files or RTFs, too, though. Ultimately we could probably create a PDF-accompanying standalone checklist as an Excel file. Might that help?

EE

by oshwick

I find Quick Start Guides useful and would be happy to get in on the early feedback reviews also.

by Erik Eckel

oshwick,

Thanks for your interest. Please be sure to check back soon, as I'll post a link here reviewers can use to access the alpha.

EE

by j sheesley

The Alpha version of our security guide for Windows XP is ready for download and evaluation! When we first looked at the topic, we wound up with about 100 pages worth of content.

We thought it would be a good idea to break it down into smaller sections, so that's what we did. We broke down Windows XP security into these areas:

? Group Policy
? File and printer sharing
? Encrypting files
? VPN
? Firewalls
? Wireless
? Desktop security
? Viruses, Worms, and Spyware

We decided to release the viruses portion first. Download it, take a look, and let us know what you think.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5138-6355-5221091.html

John Sheesley
Senior Editor

by Erik Eckel

Non TechProGuild members may download the alpha version of our first Windows XP Security TechProGuide, which covers viruses, worms and spyware, using this link (note, you'll have to cut and paste it into your browser):

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5138-22-5221091.html

Please give it a try and forward your feedback to erik.eckel@cnet.com.

Many thanks,

EE

This discussion is closed to new replies.