Discussion Locked

Ten words or less: "I don't use Linux because..."

0 helpful
717 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

717 replies

by charliespencer

"Why wouldn't you want choice?"

I've tried this before, but I rarely articulate it clearly. Please note that I am not saying choice is bad, either explicitly or implicity.

Choice is confusing. From the choice of disto to GUI (or lack of one), assorted office suites, this package manager, that installer, etc, the variety can be overwhelming to someone who is used to "one size (trys to) fit all". If you don't have any background experience to draw on, it becomes intimidating. The constant arguing between distro factions adds to the confusion.

Choice reduces transportable skills. If I learn the Windows GUI and the Office suite, I can be reasonably certain the skills I learned will apply at the next company that uses Win / Off, or when I go to Cousin Bob's. If I learn to use one Linux GUI and one OSS suite, that doesn't mean they'll be in use the next place I work, or that Aunt Sue will have the same distro.

by apotheon

jmgarvin:
B) I once did a Debian install in less than twenty minutes and less than twenty keystrokes. That's tough to beat.

Palmetto:
You're right, sometimes choice can be confusing to the newbie. Your discussion of that confusion seems to extend beyond the state of being a neophyte, however, and I think your point falters there. By learning some basic Linux skills (use of manpages, how a package manager works, et cetera), you can then transfer skills from one toolset to another very easily. For instance, package managers all tend to have functional interface characteristics in common, and learning the differences between them is typically as easy as skimming a couple of manpages.

This is one of the reasons I advocate learning to outgrow the Windows-indoctrinated cliphobia: with the exception of a couple of filesystem quirks that can vary slightly across two or three major families of Linux distribution, Linux system administration at the command line interface is pretty much exactly the same across distributions, and pretty much the same set of basic tools will always be available -- assuming the owner of the machine didn't decide to really customize the hell out of the system to the point where it's pretty much no longer recognizable as Linux. I've been known to reconfigure my Windows systems in the past in ways that made it exceedingly difficult for other people to accomplish basic tasks, simply because the Windows defaults are so obtuse that I was able to get something like a 20% productivity boost by making such custom configurations. Linux is more flexible than Windows, so of course it's possible to make it even more different, and even more difficult for a low-skill user to make his way around, but it takes a bit of real work to get to that point. The CLI is, short of seriously perverse desire to just be different, fairly constant across installs.

by apotheon

I'm not a big fan of LSD*, either, but then I'm not a big fan of AD -- so I suppose it shouldn't be a surprise that I don't like LSD.

*: Yes, I know, it's LDS. It's a joke. Get it?

by osumiller

If your users/you are using your systems much, then you are all missing out on the true capability of the systems if you fail to do a regular defrag. Windows or horrible about just throwing things down where it wants. I was at a clients office the other day, and noticed some real speed degradation. Ran a Defrag analysis, and the Windows XP 180 GB system was 90% fraged. I can assure you that their system is running much faster now, plus the HD is doing much less work.

by apotheon

Those people do exist, just as rickk, Rob Enderle, Steve Ballmer, and George Ou exist. I don't think Penguinista is really the right term to use to combine all those different characteristics in one person. You've lumped intellectual freedom advocates in with obnoxious crusaders when, from what I've seen, the obnoxious crusaders usually don't care about fighting intellectual protectionism as much as about being a rebel without a clue that views Microsoft in particular as the root of all evil.

by charliespencer

I've edited my previous comment and removed the "proprietary Armegeddon" remark. Is that sufficient to remove the "intellectual freedom advocates" from the definition?

I don't know what's up with George Ou. I hadn't heard of him before a few months ago, and suddenly he's the regularly featured Blogger From The State of Redmond. His profile isn't very enlightening. I don't hang out anywhere but here, so maybe he's a big wheel and I'm the only one unaware of his credentials.

by apotheon

He's not exactly an industry trade rag heavyweight the way someone like Bruce Schneier (cryptography and security expert par excellence), Jakob Nielsen (best-known usability expert in the world), or Rob Enderle (most famous loud-mouthed buffoon in the IT industry) is. George isn't an unknown nobody, either, though. He's hosted panel discussions at major industry conferences, written some generally very good reports on goings-on in innovative subfields, and has a fairly extensive range of IT related knowledge. The man has almost five times as many directly relevant Google hits as me, and I'm not exactly an unknown either.

The trouble as I see it is four-fold:

1. He suffers from "not invented here" syndrome, at a step removed. Specifically, this means that he has a tendency to favor everything with which he is most familiar, and has an unfortunate tendency to denigrate things with which he is less familiar. There's a specific set of psychological mechanisms behind this that are common to humans in general, I find, but I don't really want to discuss that here as it could be perceived as insulting regardless of my intent (and it's a bit long-winded and irrelevant).

2. Despite his admirable accumulated skill and knowledge, there are holes in his understanding, just as there are holes in everyone's understanding. He tends to fill these holes with wild assumptions and rote-memorized half-baked marketing FUD that has seeped into his head from years of constant exposure to it. At least, that's what I think is going on, based on what I've seen. Either that, or he's malevolent and purposefully destructive, but I really rather doubt that.

3. He suffers from ego identification with his writings. That, too, is a common problem among humans: they create something, or say something, and develop an ego identification with their creations and/or statements so that anything that attacks the creation or the statement is perceived as an attack on the creator or speaker. I've seen this in action quite extensively here at TR, where about once every half-dozen posts he'll start accusing me of being maliciously hurtful and insulting when all I've done is called his assumptions into question.

4. He seems intentionally positioned here at TR to stir up trouble in hopes of fostering high-heat discussion threads, which in turn generates traffic, which in turn generates more advertising revenue for TechRepublic. As such, he seems even more a lackey of Bill and Steve than usual to the members of the TR community.

As I said, I wouldn't call him a heavy (or a "big wheel", as you put it), but his name is recognizable to some measurable percentage of the pundit-reading IT industry.

I think he's been positioned as the MS FUD peddler here at TR in part because Steven Warren (self-styled "Hot Button") is so tremendously bad at it.

by hopefulcoder

intellectual freedom advocates?? So IBM which funds so much on OSS (just linux) does not have even one OSS software on its own. hmmm Sun which had absolutely nor market for office, release openoffice and made it opensource, YET java is not opensource. Hmmm and the great OSS guys, they all work for free for their employer..dont they. Its just not a concept of Open source. Its just that IBM,SUN,google want to get rid of MS and capture its place.

by apotheon

Number 2 is something from which you won't get full value unless you're as familiar with the guy's public career as I am. It probably also helps that there are a couple people with whom I'm glancingly acquainted who tend to respond to any article quoting Enderle by sending emails to the authors and editors of the articles in question telling them that they should stop quoting that FUD peddler, and they tend to name me and a couple other people as examples of thoughtful and reasonable sources of quotable information.

by charliespencer

Where would I find infomation on how to use a Linux live CD to do some of these things?

We set everything up with a single partition, but your other suggestions sound interesting.

by apotheon

Microsoft has been promising an NTFS that doesn't require defragging since the mid-1990s at the latest, and still hasn't delivered. Other OSes have had filesystems that don't require defragging for years now.

by charliespencer

I haven't seen any noticable results. I'm sure if I ran a diagnostic or performance suite I'd see some results, but if the end user doesn't notice any improvement in performance, why bother?

I defrag a machine before I use it as the model for a new Ghost image. No one keeps data on the local drives, or has the privs to remove apps.

by zydeco blue

... to learn.

I've really only had the chance to use Microsoft products, and since that's what we have used everywhere I've worked, that's what I know.

I'm always looking to learn more, but without a programming background, the concept of Linux is rather intimidating. I know there are people who are enthusiastic about all different systems, so I'm basing my thoughts on the opinions of others on both sides of the fence, hence the confusion and apprehension.

by osumiller

defrag makes the hd more efficient, and thus by my way of reasoning, it could in theory extend the life of the device.

While I don't have anything in the way of data to back this with, if the drive is not operating at max speed, it should have somewhat less wear on the mechanical parts.

I have seen systems where no maintenance was occurring that the hard drives quickly had numerous bad sectors, as well as in some cases just quit spinning (note that some of these were probably due to the systems being filled with dust-bunnies).

by apotheon

I'm sure there are a couple places online that list such information, but since I haven't been doing serious single-system Windows disaster recovery for a while I haven't been keeping up with these tricks of the trade as much as I perhaps should. I can recommend two books that are quite excellent for such information, however, along with a fair bit of information unrelated to Windows:

O'Reilly's [i]Knoppix Hacks[/i]

ExtremeTech's [i]Hacking Knoppix[/i]

I'm intending to get a review of the latter of these published at TR soonish.

by charliespencer

I'm not a pundit-reader, so I didn't recognize him (or the other names you referenced). John Dvorak's column in PC Mag is about as close as I come. Thanks for the overview.

by ct4er

I don't use Linux because my SCANNER, my INTERNAL MODEM and my WIRELESS card don't work with Linux.
CT4ER

by jmgarvin

Your scanner may or may not work...but I can say (about a 99% chance) that your internal modem will work with community packages and your wireless card will work with either ndiswrapper or madwifi...

No go troll somewhere else.

by charliespencer

" ... your internal modem will work with community packages and your wireless card will work with either ndiswrapper or madwifi ..."

Apparently they worked with Windows out of the box. For many users that's important.

by mark miller

(talking about my home PCs, one of which I use for work sometimes) I don't see a reason to. I know how to run Windows XP securely so security isn't really an issue for me. I know what the virus-infected e-mails look like, so I avoid them. I run the built-in firewall to prevent worm attacks. I get updates from Windows Update regularly and install them almost as soon as they come out.

I know there are lots and lots of Windows viruses out there. One time at work 6 years ago I got caught by an e-mail worm, which was harmless (all it did was e-mail itself to my coworkers--an annoyance but nothing to write home about). That was the first and last time I had gotten any sort of infection on a computer I was using. We easily prevented future attacks by turning off the preview pane in Outlook (later corporate policy with our parent company required us to switch to Lotus Notes, which obviated any auto-execute scripts).

Anything I need to run I can run on Windows. Even if I want to use an open source tool for something, which I do occasionally, very often I can find a version that runs on Windows.

One big difference with me is I'm not an IT administrator or sysadmin. I'm a software developer. So my priorities are different. I'm not so concerned about 9999.99% uptime ratings with the OS I use (though I try to shoot for that with the software I write).

I used Unix several years ago. It's a nice, reliable OS, like Linux, but I got tired of it after a while. I find Windows to be better suited to what I use a computer for.

I think the only time I'd start using Linux by choice is if I was involved in some project and the software or tool I needed only ran on it, or if a part of the project was working with a client's existing Linux system.

by davemori

That is hardly something that is limited to Apple and Linux.

Take a good look at this discussion board. You'll find a much larger sized group of Windows zealots do the exact same thing:

Telling you why their choice is right and your choice is wrong, and implying that you are stupid for not doing exactly what they do and not using the exact same solutions that they use.

The sad thing is that too many information technology professionals generate their pride and self-worth through their belief in how adept they are in using a particular product, technology, OS or solution.

I had a Wang WP administrator a long time ago who was just as bad. I also heard endless technobabble arguments from the Novell and Banyan gurus I worked with, the DEC VMS people I worked with, the IBM MVS people I worked with, the OS/2 people I worked with, the accountants who preferred Lotus 1-2-3 over Excel, the COBOL programmers, the FORTRAN programmers, the CAD people who preferred CATIA, AutoCAD, the PowerBuilder folks I worked with, and lots more.

Nearly every technology has its place and every technology can generate value.

This latest hype on Mac and open source security is ludicrous.

We use different technologies because they generate value and they are cost effective, not because the majority of the market uses it.

We take security seriously for everything. Windows, MacOS, LinUX, Solaris, you name it, and it is not a significant burden to think beyond Windows.

We have a multiplatform, web client environment, because the solutions on different OSes and platforms create value to the company and users, and they are cost effective. It is not a significant issue to support more than one OS. As a matter of fact, or manpower and cost studies show that a selection of non-Windows platforms and solutions has actually consistently reduced our TCO and cost of operations when we look at what those costs probably would have been if we had gone with a Windows based solution.

Windows is an excellent OS, but it is not the best choice for all of our needs, just as MS SQL Server is not the best choice for everything, and just as any other OS or product you could think of is not going to be the best choice for everything.

If your people understand their business customers, know what they are doing, and have an open mind towards learning all technologies, it is not an issue to support any platform or solution.

Our open attitude about different OS and different platorms has also made us far more customer focused, and has bought us really good relationships with our customers -- so good that suggestions that IT be outsourced have consistently been very loudly dismissed by our own users.

One recent outsourcing vendor was actually laughed out of the premises by every VP in the company.

The present buzz about MacOS and LinUX vulnerabilities is more anti-Open Source hype, probably promoted by Microsoft-only aficianados that are all too common in IT.

The hard reality is that Open Source is being very successful, and it generates cost effective solutions which create value to our company.

Even if your company PREFERS to stay 100% Windows, there is no longer a viable reason for absolutely EVERY COMPANY to stay 100% Windows.

Open Source offers a huge, compelling, very cost effective alternative in many, many solutions areas.

Are there issues? Absolutely, but there are issues with every OS and every technology.

Marketshare of computer products and technologies changes, and using marketshare as a "default" ruler to measure everything, is a stupid way of basing corporate decisions.

Novell Netware, FORTRAN, COBOL, MVS IBM Mainframes, DEC Minis, dedicated word processing machines, and hundreds of other products and technologies went bye-bye. Everything loses marketshare and becomes obsolete sooner or later.

It is foolish for an IT professional to adhere to something or some company so strongly that he or she refuses to have an open mind to anything else.

If someone else's company wants to go 100% Microsoft, fine. Let them do it. But I don't want to hear lectures from anyone about what is best for our environment and our company. We have tried that route in the past. It does not work. Someone across the internet is unlikely to know beans about my company, our business, our users, our customers, our partners or our environment. Their criticisms and suggestions are not worth beans.

We don't consider the issue to be real at all.
Sure, it is a possibility. You protect by doing
the best you can.

From a strictly volume of problem point, from a disruption cost point, and from a support cost point, Microsoft Windows and Internet Explorer running on Windows cause us more grief and more cost patching, fixing supporting than either Solaris, LinUX or the MacOS.

On a cost basis and a frequency of violation basis, we could probably save more time and money and avoid a lot more unanticipated costs by throwing Microsoft Windows out of the company than throwing the MacOS or LinUX out of the company, but the issue again is that those solutions create some value to our company as well.

It is stupid to throw out anything that creates value.

We are always concerned about security, but we do not let this get leveraged into a political argument for one OS over another. We simply are committed to making sure that everything is as secure as possible.

by azerthoth

I dont use Linux because ...

I have a DVD player attached to my television. (over 75% of commercial DVD players are idiot linux boxes.)

I use a wireless router. (Many commercial routers these days have a bastardized form of linux inside)

Nope I dont use linux at all.

by smorty71

I know, I know. Stop laughing. I find that Windows meets most of my computing needs well enough that I am not willing to go out and learn another OS.

Since I am an XBOX 360 owner, I love the integration between Windows Media Center 2005 and the XBOX 360.

Sure I could use Myth TV or some other free media center app, but I like the simplicity and integration that is provided out of the box.

With that said, I realize that I don't have to support Windows machines and their vulnerabilities as part of my job. I'm sure I would be singing a different tune if I did.

But for personal use, I find Windows meets my needs.

by jbush

As I'm sure you've gathered, these live CDs allow you to boot into a fully functional modern operating system without necessarily impacting on the machine and no installation.

As a support person, I expect you can see the worth in that.

Got a machine that's been the breeding ground for virii and you don't want to boot it up for fear of propagation causing futher damage and you don't want to throw the drive into another machine?
You can run linux anti virus programs like ClamAV or BitDefender to iron out Windows targetting infections.

As Apotheon has stated elswhere, any linux administration/usage skills you pick up are easily transferrable across the entire linux family, not to mention make you a bit more comfortable working with Unix or Mac OS X (as someone who uses Windows, Mac OS and Fedora at least once a day, I think I can vouch for that).

At the end of the day, a wider range of skills or the ability to comprehend a wider range of skills is a good thing.

by jbush

That seems awfully low.
Do you mind if I ask what sort of software you use that costs so little (I assume we're talking about the home environment here)?

I would suggest (for personal use rather than as a work tool as mentioned elsewhere) that you have a look at a live CD of one of the modern distributions.

Whether you choose to implement it in your home environment is entirely up to you, of course. I know I always feel a bit better about what I'm using when I know what the options are.

Many of us dual boot Windows and linux without any problems, and the upshot of not being locked into a specific software set or operating system is very gratifying.

I know one of the key reasons I use open source software is because (at least as far as the software I use goes) I can have the freedom of platform mobility as well as the benifits of standardised software (the GIMP, Blender, Firefox, Inkscape, OpenOffice.org, Eclipse, MPlayer, jEdit, etc. all give me - more or less - the same experience across all the platforms I use), and because I'm not dealing with any proprietary data formats, I'm free to move to alternative software should I choose.

Few people spend as much time on support forums saying "My new Ubuntu installation worked out of the box!" as they would "I can't get this BSD thing to work. Grar.", which I think accounts for the perception that getting hardware to run under linux can be tricky (admittedly I've got one or two bits that took a bit of effort, but before I installed, I did some research to see what was and wasn't supported).

by charliespencer

The software I use to run a fantasy racing league is $25 annually - http://www.greenflagracing.com . Now that I think about it, that isn't even my money; it comes out of the league dues, along with the 1and1 hosting fee. I treat myself to a game or two a year from PopCap ( http://www.popcap.com/ ) occasionally - $20. That's it. I use my home box for running that league, web surfing, e-mail, MS Money, and some low end games. No MORPG, no multimedia, no DVD drive, no music, no movies, no photo editing. JPG's get saved just as they came from the camera. I have a legal copy of Office 03 I received from MS as a promo; only Word and Excel are installed.

I appreciate your suggestion, but I still haven't seen a reason to try a live CD on my home machine, much less set it up dual boot, other than as an academic exercise. Multiple platforms and proprietary formats are not issues for me. I haven't heard of many of the programs you named, but I probably don't use their MS / proprietary counterparts. I'm sure almost any distro would work with the basic hardware I have, except possibly the modem. But why bother? I could be weeding the rosebed instead.

by jbush

I used to work in a large office supplies retail chain here in Australia (I believe we opened 500 new stores during my three years there). Surprisingly enough, we used (up until about 18 months ago), a dos based point of sale and inventory system which the managers logged onto at the beginning of the day and weren't closed until the managers did the same at the end. When we actually started using windows (presumably the newer stores got newer equipment when they opened) about 6 months before that, none of the employees at my site (besides me and the managers) were aware of that change.

The point is that the sorts of occupations to which you refer run platform obscuring software and the end users (though perhaps not in smaller businesses).

I'm not saying that everybody should run out and start using Linux in the corporate environment, but I do think it's worthwhile investigating as an option for any future developments that could encompass such a move within their scope (eg: new hardware rollout, or OS upgrade rollout). At the very least, it reaffirms that you made the right choice by sticking with what you've got.

by jbush

Change for change's sake is dumb (though for learning purposes it's worthwhile).

At the end of the day, you need a reason to migrate to a new operating system, or at least a reason that might make a new operating system viable.

Personally, I don't think windows is more convenient, but then I use three (completely) different operating systems a day and am more or less used to the idiosyncrasies of each.

The only reason I choose to boot into Windows is to play Oblivion. And once Cedega supports that, I ('ll go back the the way it was before it came out and) won't bother.

by jbush

At time of manufacture any hard drive has a finite number of seeks it can make before it's dead.

Osumiller mentions that having a less fragmented drive would result in more efficient mechanical movements by the drive and thus extending its lifespan.

Sounds fairly solid, the amount of drive activity involved with the fragmentation analysis as well as the defragmentation process is waaaaay more than average use (the specifics of fragmentation vs lifespan compared to degfragmentation process vs lifespan would be interesting to know).

by mtowery

I love rebooting and several of my linux machines have been up for over a year with rebooting :)

by jbush

"My clients use Windows"
And by knowing how their operating environment can integrate with alternatives, you can offer them more insightful services and recommendations, *and* be ready should that situation change.

"My clients don't want to invest in the Linux learningcurve"
My clients generally don't want every proposal I give them (particularly when I give them three and tell them to pick). By giving your clients more options, you either a) open up new and potentially better avenues for them or b) reaffirm that they're better of sticking with what they're with.
Plus if they later decide they do want to invest in that learning curve, existing linux experience and knowledge will allow you to provide the support they require.

"I can do what I need to now..."
Now that's what I call forward thinking. If the industry suddenly turns on its head (as it has done many times in the past), you're going to be left high and dry.

You don't have to like Lunix to justify using it.

(Oh, and World of Warcraft runs with Wine 0.9.5 and above and is also supported by Cedega if that's the sort of thing you prefer. Cedega suport for Oblivion won't be far away juding from how many votes it has)

by firstpeter

"My clients use Windows"
I understand Linux. I understand what it can do. That still doesn't change the fact that my clients use Windows.

"My clients don't want to invest in the Linux learningcurve"
If you'd like some help on selling your clients on your proposals just let me know - my clients generally accept all my proposals... :) But I think you're missing the point. I know Linux. Worked with it for years. I don't use it regularly because none of my clients use it, and I prefer to actually USE the applications my clients do - I've found it allows for better support.

"I can do what I need to now..."
Keep me honest - the world is still, primarily, a Windows-based world, right? So the fact that I can do what needs to be done now is bad, how...? If the world goes Linux I'll still be in a good position - I'll just help my clients migrate over. But it ain't a Linux world yet (nor in the short-term), so...

I actually happen to like Linux - it just doesn't make any sense for me to use it (regularly, anyway). It doesn't offer me any advantages over Windows at this point, so I don't use it.

by charliespencer

I love it when people refer to anything in the IT field as intuitive. If you can find a person unfamiliar with computers, put three computers in front of him - a Mac, a Wintel box, and the Linux / GUI distro of your choice. Power up the CPU and the monitor and we'll see how "intuitive" each of them is.

by daveo2000

Way back in the Bell Labs days there was a lot of research done around user interfaces. The MAC was brought out with the icons chosen so that (according to the rather expensive research) the users made the correct choice for what they wanted to do about 95% of the time. That is why they started the Mac out with the ad "The computer for the rest of us."

by hopefulcoder

Nighthawk according to google and all anit-MS guys, changing the search option in IE7 which is nothing but a drag and drop software is too difficult for most of the computer users. I am sure you are aware of that. I dont understand how such people can type all these commands. And words it might have some dependency and most people get lost there. RPM does not install all the software as most of them still come as source files. And I am sure that if the proposed European patent law gets passes then seeing movies in linux will be officially illegal. The sound problem is just not solved. I use fedora and i have some stupid problems occasionally. To use linux you unfortunately need to be a little (a lot )more efficient with some terminal commands. And most home users just dont want or are not capable of doing it. Yes now dont ask me to use SUSE for only fedora is available in the university. And I am not novice either. I have been using it every since redhat6. And linux has not changed much. Some GUI enhancements are done but they are not stable. Support for games, music and movies is awfully low. Windows will continue to rule the home pc market for many years to come.

by hopefulcoder

and linus would be teaching his kids how to include patented software into linux and yet escape any possible lawsuits..just because they are against MS

by hopefulcoder

and the same guys will never accept the figure that almost all the applications that run in *nix can be run in windows as well !!!

by mad-h

Recover "corrupt" office docs - we had a manager who can to us with a corrput excel s/sheet, and all the vers I tried (97, 2000, 2003) bombed when opening it. Enter knoppix - boot from the CD, use open office to open it, dump to PDF, ftp over to network server (or put on a USB stick). Great if your company's software policy won't allow you to install openoffice on your PC as it's a non-intrusive (disk-writing wise) process

by contract

I love Linux I really do, but..... I still cannot get everything to work on my Fujitsu laptop. I keep reverting back to Windows for work after spending weekends trying to get everything to function. I think Linux still has a long way to go in order to make it more universally friendly, but hey, I am sure it'll get there eventually!

by jihernandez

The road to paradise is full of trouble. I have travelled from "terminals" to "PC", from Unix to MS-DOS, and , just to write, make calculations, and play, it is too expensive to start again. Call it laziness. May be true.

by lynn_beeler

I don't use Linux because it is too complicated.

My 1st thought when I saw your article. After a some further thought, I want to use my computer to carry out my requirements and not spend the required time to learn a new OS.

Lynn Beeler

by stargazerr

5.10 or the stupid name Breezy Badger. :D

I booted from the Live CD but opening up applications is mega slow, so I had to revert back to Windows :(

How about if I put out an advert to donate computer parts to the needy? Do you reckon that will speed up the time untill I acquire a computer? :p

]:)

by linux&windows

One of the problems with getting the home user to use Linux (any flavour) is the lack of good quality commercial games. I realise the argument should be that PCs are not for gaming, but that's what most of them are used for.

by mfb

I'll start with a statement and a question. Documentation is terrible. What's the advantage?

by tygyrtoo

...because heavily-commented text-based config files drive me nuts.

Why some (most) 'NIX geeks insist on writing 5 pages of drivel followed by an obscure commented commend (that MUST be entered exactly as shown and not with/without space, semicolon, comma, tab space or return/line feed) when a simple GUI window with checkboxes and options does EXACTLY the same thing faster, better and without having to read said 'NIX geek's technobabbled "instructions" is beyond me.

That's my $0.02+tx.

by jmgarvin

Jeez...if you don't like the config files, use the GUI. There are a ton of built-ins for Gnome and KDE...Hell, there are third party GUIs like webmin and SWAT (for Samba)

Problem solved.

by bill ward

of it's great security features and ease of setting up a server (I use IPCop for my firewall, and Fedora Core 4 for a backup server).

However, I DON'T use Linux for my desktop (though I sometimes have a machine in a dual boot configuration, and I do have Linux in a VMWare environment on my work machine). Main reason not to use Linux only (ok, laugh) is it's lack of support for the games that matter to me, my wife, and my kids.

I love Unix, and really like Linux... but until support improves accross the board (maybe when Microsoft goes totally Gestapo with the "Genuine Advantage" stuff for Vista...) I'll be forced to Linux.

by charliespencer

That's my point. It's more convenient for me because it's already installed, configured, and I know how to use it. Why inconvenience myself for an academic exercise?

by hal 9000

Why are you using XP now?

If Windows 3 did everything that you needed why change from that?

Why even move away from DOS onto Windows after all DOS worked well enough for the adverage user back then.

You change OS's for the same reason as everyone else to keep a job but for some reason you are limiting your ability to remian employed in the [b]Long Run[/b] and where you can be employed in the [b]Short Term[/b] as well. I'm betting that you have never applied to work for a ISP or even bothered looking for IT jobs outside your confort zone right?

While you are continuning to insist that Windows is OK I'm constantly told at MS Partner Meetings that I'm expecting [b]Too Much[/b] from an OS and Windows was never designed to work in the manner that I continually ask about.

Col

by charliespencer

HAL, I value your opinion. None of this is intended as flippant or argumentative.

The new computer came with XP. I gave my old 98 box to my parents so I couldn't legally put 98 on the new box, now could I? I'm not running much software on the XP box at home that I didn't have 98 counterparts for, so I didn't upgrade for the apps. I had W3 on the 486 box before the 98 machine. I think it's here at work, still running W3 and proprietary legacy software.

"You change OS's for the same reason as everyone else to keep a job ..."

Unlike 95, then 98, then NT, then 2K, then XP, and eventually Vista, Linux isn't required to keep my job.

" ... for some reason you are limiting your ability to remain employed in the Long Run" You're assuming I'm not upgrading my skills at all. My manager and I work on a list every year of what new and upgraded skills I should work on. Topics over the last couple of years have included Server 03, AD, SMS, and VM. Yes, most of those are MS, but we're an MS shop. Hell, I started out a COBOL programmer and was asked to transition to PC's and networking in the early 90's. That required completely overhauling my skills. Please explain how neglecting a technology we don't use limits my remaining employed in long or short term.

"I'm betting that you have never applied to work for a ISP ... " I'm betting that less than 5% of TR members have worked for an ISP. I'm sure if I had I would have a different skill set than I do now, but they probably wouldn't match the skills I need in a manufacturing plant. That can be said of any job: the skills required for one don't match the skills needed for anther.

" ... or even bothered looking for IT jobs outside your confort zone right?" Right. I've worked for three companies in 22 years in IT. At two of the three (including the current one where I have worked for thirteen years) I enjoyed considerable daily autonomy, reasonable management, pay I consider acceptable, and neither beeper nor cell phone. What's wrong with remaining with a company I enjoy working for?

" ... I'm constantly told at MS Partner Meetings that I'm expecting Too Much from an OS ... " I'm not insisting Windows is OK or that it's the answer for everybody. You can't find a post anywhere the Internet where I've said Windows is anything other than an OS that fits some people's needs, and several (including in this discussion) where I've said in some areas it's inferior to Linux. Windows fits my existing needs at the house, and I feel the advantages of switching my computer to Linux don't outweigh the time and effort involved. Your mileage may vary.

by havacigar

"who quoted 6 hoours to install a new 2003 server for 150 users and spent 10 days getting it to work part way right."

Sorry, but anyone that incompetent shouldn't be installing anything. He should have been able to do it in 5 hours.

by wannabegates

Because 90% of the world DOESN'T use LINUX.

Because I don't want to Spend $ on Linux Version of my apps. Macromedia products for example (I know that's more than 10)

by cmcarlson.com

1) Have no idea where to start...

2) have hard enough time getting all my sketchy, software to run on windows, let alone some operating system whose name sounds like it is the evil twin brother of Lexus...

3) who can afford two computers?

by jmgarvin

1) check www.distrowatch.com. A good starter is Ubuntu. You can even order the CDs from them for free.

2) A good portion of the software isn't sketchy...check it out...

3) Just dual boot!

by hal 9000

Running off a CD s the CD is slow by its very nature as CD's are slow to load. But the Live Nix's are desicned to run this way so you can get in a rescue data or bypass Passwords and the like.

That's what I always use them for as I find that things are too slow running off the CD but they do at the very least give you an idea of what's possible.

How about taking a proposal to managment asking for one of the units about to be decommissioned as a test bed for alternative OS's? You could even maybe push the idea that you would willing be a Beta Tester for Vista when it hits the streets to drive us all crazy. :p

That way as the computer isn't actually leaving the companies control they wouldn't have to go through all the trouble of replacing the HDD to keep their Security Processes intact.

Or you could attend one of the many Excorporate Auctions and pick up a unit very cheaply over here there are many companies who specalise in selling off Ex Corporate/Government computers and most of the tiume they break them up and sell as bits that way they get more for the bits than the complete computer. But to keep people walking through the doors they always have a smal range of complete Computers are reasonable prices. Or you could even hit E-Bay for an old dicommissioned server those things are practially [b]Give Away[/b] items just try to avoid the SCSI only units as they are harder to load any form of Nix to in a lot of cases.

Col

by hal 9000

This moron supplied and installed the entire system fot this one office and to make matters worse he has the contract to supply this organisation AU wide.

It's a perfect case of spending 2 Million $ to make a $25.00 saving.

They even pay his travel and accomidation expences as well. :^0

Col

by jekoski1

The lack of public support, and the software I need would not have any help desk to resolve any problems.

by hal 9000

You didn't need to install any drivers?

Or do you have one of the Off the Shelf units that come from the big makers who [b]Slipstream[/b] only the necessary drivers for the hardware that they supply and to Hell with everything else?

I've yet to find a single WiFi card that will wortk the moment that you plug it into a Windows Box without first installing the drivers rebooting and then installing the necessary software. But as you claim that they work [b]Out of the Box[/b] I must be so removed from the current technology that maybe I should just give it all up and walk away. I'd love to but unfortantly my customers and staff refuse to allow me to do this so I don't get to play with my [b]Play Toys[/b] as much a I would like and I certianly don';t get to restore any of them, I have to pay others to do this as I'm constantly called away whenever I try to do the simplest thing. I even had to pay to have someone fit a CD/MP3 player to one of my Classic Mercedes because I just didn't have the 20 minutes required to fit the thing available. :_|

Col ]:)

by charliespencer

" ... you have one of the Off the Shelf units that come from the big makers who Slipstream only the necessary drivers for the hardware ... "

I assumed that was the case when I made my comment, although I admit that was an assumption. If that is the case, I'm not defending the manufacturer's approach. My only point is that some users aren't comfortable having to do additional configuration to get the hardware to work beyond sticking in a self-installing CD, especially at the command prompt.

by hal 9000

That Auto Runs and has a GUI for the user to install from it's really no harder than doing the same thing in Windows.

Of course any Digitally Signed MS Hardware doesn't have a Nix driver supplied as this is part of the MS agreement with the Hardware Makers they are unable to support any different platforms for that particular piece of Hardware that MS accepts.

When you want to use these you need to find the right drivers and software but then again it's really no harder than downloading some updated drivers and installing under Window. There really isn't much command line work at all if you wish to stay in the GUI. It can be done or just like Windows you can run things from the command line if you want to. It's really not something that I see as a problem.

If granny wants to buy some new hardware for her Win Box it's going to require fitting and installing the drivers for so why is it any different with a Nix particuarly if it's one of the Light Weight Ones which is designed as being User Friendly as apposed to the Full Multi User Capacity that a proper Nix offers.

If you want to see something really scary for the MS folk get a copy of Corel Linux and try installing it you'll get the entire thing installed OS Software and everything in about 20 minutes and other than entering the time zone User Name & Password there is nothing else to do. This is probably why MS killed off this project as it would have killed the Windows Market in very short order.

Col

by pkr9

it removes my dependency of Microsoft
it installed with thre clicks of the mouse
it's a piece of cake to install what I installed
updates are easy stuff
all the apps I need are available.

I am not even a techie anymore. I was years ago, but now my job is tailoring IT systems to fit organisations, and finding IT systems that will fit a specific organisation, and we don't even talk product names untill the map is drawn.

Any office package is like the other, and users don't need to know what OS is under the hood of the device they use.

by pkr9

At a time all their administrative system was IBM AS/400 - the system still to beat when it comes to reliability and security.

by pkr9

Ever heard of zombie PC's ? I saw one using up 5GB's of broadband in 2 days whild the user was sleeping. He visited a P2P site ONE TIME visited a P2P site, and had his firewall disabled behind his back. They didn't want his info, they wanted his bandwith.

by stargazerr

Willingly ?

I think I am happier on my work laptop dreaming of a day I will get my own box. :p

Actually, it isnt very far now. Just 2 more months and I will be able to use the money I earn to do what I want. But buying something my company doesnt want is a good idea. Now, where the hell has my boss dissapeared to ?

Jaqui suggested buying something in Canada and that he can ship it, since I can be exempted from duties and taxes if stuff is sent from a private person to a private person. I still have to test that theory though.

]:)

by soundchaser

Maybe I don't get it, or need to be more educated in this, I don't know. I use to run Unix BSD, SCO Zenix, DEC OS's, VMS. When it came down to what I run on the PC's at my business, one of the primary concerns I had to struggle with was: What OS would allow me the most options for BUSINESS RELATED SOFTWARE. the choice was clear cut. I am not saying that different OS's don't have their advantages administration-wise, but when it comes to what I can suggest as software solutions to business problems, I choose MS. I shouldn't have to run different shells in order to make my software "look" like Windows, or run those shells to allow a Windows based product to run under Linux, Unix, or whatever.

Please, someone, tell me how I can satisfy the business software requirements running Linux without all the add-ons.

Thanks!

by charliespencer

Here's the other side of the coin. I think this is the first post of this kind in the discussion. It took longer than I thought it would.

by hal 9000

It's just with the continual backdating of Vista and MS Licensing problems and cost I can see many people wanting to switch from Windows as their Primary OS to something else in the not to distant future.

With all the CAM plants that I've done work for while they use Windows on the Desktop the designers of the final product tend to use different OS's ranging from DOS to Fully Fledged Unix depending on the hardware used and what they are making. Things like Microprocessor Controlled Lathes tend to be all DOS Bassed but when you start getting into the big Robotics they are all Unix based systems.

This is just something that I've seen over time as more and more people are getting fed up with MS and it's Pricing & Licensing Policies. The total lack of Technical Support in the Specalised areas doesn't help much either

But as for the idea that [i]if it works don't change it[/i] I was just asking why change a perfectly good OS to somethign different just because MS tells you to?

Currently I'm buying copies of XP Pro and installing NT4 onto boxes that will have a very short life and need NT4 to run a program that isn't going to be rewritten in the foreseeable future. Provided I attach the XP COA to the case this is Perfectly Legal but currently a big bug bear for some companies to accept. These CD's are never going to be used and they just see it as more of the Bully Boy Tatics from MS and are slowely getting sick & tied of doing business this way. These boxes live On Site where there is heavy Earth Moving Equipment being used to scrape the dirt to a level controlled by Laser sighting equipment all around the site and on the earthmovers and they can get the earthworks to within 2 CM's of the design so they naturally want to keep using the software as it saves them lots of money in Fuel, over removing dirt and backfilling. Of course the down side is that place is anything but clean and the computers all suffer as a result generally not being expected to last longer than 1 job and if it's a big one I'll be building several of the same computers for the job.

Of course the costs of these machines are factored into the tender for the job but it gets hard to deal with the [b]Bean Counters[/b] who insist that they don't actually need the XP Pro copy as it is effectively a throw away item and a waste of money. Which really it is. I'm even to this day still buying MS DOS from MS for some computer controlled lathes which kill the controller connected to them every 12 18 months and I do see those licenses as a Waste of Money and nothing more than a MS Tax for using the big expensive tools.

I'm constantly told that they are unwilling to pay for these Licenses but as I'm unwilling to be the bunny that MS picks on I refuse and suggest that they ring MS and ask why [b]It IS So.[/b]

On the other side of the coin stolen or destroyed computers covered by insurance don't require the selling of replacment MS Product as the Insurance Companies will not accept this and MS doesn't raise a single complaint.

I just see something wrong and wasteful in doing things like this for the customer who is paying for a unnecessary product and even it it was acceptiable they don't get any Tecincal Support from MS for the products that I'm installing. Luckly it's not an issue with the units that I sell but it very well could be to some companies.

MS answer is to [b]Migrate to XP[/b] which is really helpful when the software doesn't run on XP they expect everything to work as Windows is a 1 size fits all to their way of thinking which no OS can be.

Currently I'm working on a CAM Factory that makes bench tops and the factory floor covers 1 acre and there are 3 floors so I'm using Optical Fibre for the networking runs as there isn't one under several hundred feet all are too long for CAT Cable and the owner wants not to see any hardware or at least as little as possible and because of the RF that the machines produce WIFI is out of the question.

Currently I'm not sure of what's going in the office but I know what's gong into the Server Room and there are 2 of everything as any stopage causes the destruction of what's currently in the machines and with imported Marbel this can be very expensive so it requires UPS's on everything on the factory side of things and a massive Backup PS that will kick in if there are any power outages the UPS's are just there for safety and to cover the Gap between power sources and for filtering when the Power Sources change.

I've been working with the Designer for 3 months now and it has required weekly site inspections which is a 250 K round trip and I have to hit the builders heavilly I cought them trying to stretch a 420 MT Optical Fibre cable because it was 4 inches too short. Good thing to catch it then rather than attempting to pull another run after the event though. :D

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Shipping costs can be very high and more importantly the Voltage of the mains from the country that the unit is originating from can be a potential problem. Back when I fixed Sewing Machines I used to get a lot of calls from the States asking me exactly what needed changing to meet AU Electrical Safety requirments. In one case they changed everything except the light buld and sent it over and when it was tested the 110 V Buld exploded making the chassis live so the machine was returned to the originating point as Unsafe. That was an expensive mistake. :^0

But if freight isn't an issue I can send you one from here and if it's just the tower for a desktop it wouldn't take up much space and the wife would be as happy as Larry to see one go. The monitor wouldn't be such a good ides to ship as they are less than gentle and a Keyboard & Mouse are [b]As Cheap As Chips[/b] as I understand the Poms say. :p

I can pickup a Second Hand NB for about $480.00 AU and that is one of the decent ones not one of the old junkers that are floating around so much. Hell I could even build you a really good NB for about 2K AU which would be about 1 Pound 50 Pence if my last visit to the UK is anything to go by. Luckly the company was paying for everything otherwise I couldn't have afforded to eat let alone live or have the odd drink or 10. :D

If memory serves me correctly the UK is on 240 V AC at 50 HZ and any hardware sold here would work perfectly there with the added advantage that we have tighter electrical laws so it would be better electrically than what you are currently getting there.

Lets know if you'r interested but it all depends on the UK Import Laws. It's been a very long time since I've had anything to do with them so I'm not sure how things stand at the moment.

Col

by david.luke

I have neither time nor machines to sacrifice to the learning process. Suppose I create a spam zombie or zap my home access to the web? It may hold great promise, but how can I find time to explore it when I am being pecked to death by chickens? (Those are metaphorical chickens. No implication of coworkers was implied or should be construed. No chicken was harmed during the writing of this tirade, though some may have experienced bitterness.)

by jc williams

http://www.ubuntu.com and download the live version, burn to bootable cd and fire it up. Recently installed Ubuntu 5.10 and *really* like it. It comes with Open Office and does just about everything I want right off the cd. Those handful of things that I want that are not there are very easy to download and install.

by cwgmpls

Since the price of MS Office and MS XP is included in the price of all major brand computers, why bother with anything else?

by colonel panijk

You're referring to 5.10. Ubuntu distributions come out twice a year, in April (xx.4) and October (xx.10), where the year-2000 is the version number. That said, there was supposed to be 6.4 last month, but I haven't seen it (may have been delayed). The Ubuntu site (www.ubuntu.com) lists 5.10 as the latest downloadable version. By the way, I have found Ubuntu to be a very nice, easy to use and easy to install distribution.

by aaron a baker

I don't use it because I don't know enough about it.
I tried to install it once and by the time I had completed the step which lead to c then back to d here you had to prepare a disk I threw up my hands and said the heck with it.
Seems to me, they could have made it a little easier for we "The novices" to be able to put this on our systems.
Instead, it's a jumble and a walk into he unknown so I stayed away. "Chicken, darned right" ;) I don't mind trying something out, but I'm not about to waste a second of my life creating this disk or that disk or doing this, changing that all to accommodate a system, that I can't even begin to recognize or understand.
I had thought that If I installed it, I might gain some knowledge, "Wrong".
So nothing against Linux, you have to know it to hate it, I don't, on all counts. :)
Regards
Aaron

by jmgarvin

There are also plenty of LiveCDs out there. Most distros not only auto partition, but almost auto install. You just decide on the install "type" and away you go.

Check out Ubuntu...they'll send you a CD for free!

If you really want to get jiggy with it check out gentoo, but be warned, it requires a lot of effort the first go around.