Discussion Locked

Terminal Server

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
What are your opinions on Terminal Server? Is it really a better solution than the traditional Desktop?

11 replies

by dwilcox22

I use Terminal server, but the main purpose of the server is to distribute a secure application. Terminal server gives me the security that I require for this application.

by rjackson

Terminal Server is a tool that fits certain sections of the office. Routine, low power apps (data entry, word processing, etc.) are great for terminals. Graphics, photo software and other processor, memory and storage hogs are not. There are remote solutions that Terminal Server seem to have been created for.
Is it the ultimate answer?? No. Is it an answer?? Depends on the question.

by joshuaj

Serveral customers we have use Metaframe and Terminal service to replace old workstations or problem workstations with Winterm dumb terminals. They don't require any maintence and hardly every break down. With that said, obviously you need to keep your server in top condition or it defeats the purpose of going this route.

by ticktock

To answer the first question If you have to support a large network with a lot of keyboard dummies this tool is great, for fast deployement of apps from dev to desktop it is great.The secound question about graphics and photo software .Farm your servers and dedicate one to each type of hungry app and hey presto you can control them too.Add MetaFrame to the mix it helps.but watch out for printing it is a problem. There is work arounds for this.
MetaFrame brings a whole wack of bandwidth to the game

by mteal

In my humble opinion, Metaframe extends the capabilities and performance of terminal server to more than warrant it's inclusion on any but the smallest WTS networks. Working in a refinery with several hundred WTS clients would be a nightmare withoutit.

That being said, I'll state the obvious by saying that even though network traffic will be reduced in many cases by apps not being loaded over the network, the simple fact that basically everything now will be done over the network has to be taken into account.

by lickity40

This is an interesting topic to me since I've recently been challenged with making a purchase -- one choice being Win2000 Server with Terminal Server. Allow me to describe my situation.

Currently running Novell 3.12 on a 486/33 and Novell 4.11 on a Pent200x2. I will be purchasing an HP server -- probably Pent600 and either NT or Win2000. The workstations are Pent 800's -- nice.

The purpose of this upgrade will be to run our accounting package upgrade, (currently American Fundware under Win-Kit), to a true 32-bit version.

At first they recommended NT but now are suggesting Win2000 with Terminal Server. When I asked why they gave 3 reasons. First, easier to manage the app. Secondly, less demand on the workstations and thirdly, great for remote access.

When I countered with, "I only have 5 users using this application and they are all within 50' from me and they have powerful processors on their workstations and none use remote access and doesn't this create much higher net traffic?", they simply responded with...we still recommend it.

Any advice out here?

Thanks in advance,

Rick Forsythe
Systems Administrator
Associated Services for the blind

by pallan

Sounds like you're getting the "just because we said so" answer from your vendor. My advice? Force them to give you a real, verifiable reason. Terminal Server has its uses, but at first glance it seems like a waste for you. There is a significant amount of administrative upkeep that just isn't required of other solutions.

by ticktock

Rick after reading your note I would advise you to change you vendor.Any vendor that is dealing with a organization like yours and is not taking into account that a budget will be of prime concern will only lead you done the garden path.Win 2000 is a new release and even in a company like where I work a lot of RD goes into moving platforms.And so far my test on 2000 have shown up weak points that we can not take the risk with.Terminal server has Great points and with citrix in place your network bandwidth is maintaned at a meger 12k per station.but beware the server must be a strong and reliable box as you will be setting up a single point of failure.Although data recovery and rebuild time is fast.Security can be made nice and tight.What Iam saying is If you really whant to change go the NT route and add citrix on top. This will give you a solid base and the best of both Protocols .Watch out for printing it is a problem

by charleslloyd

I manage 19 NT 4.0 TS servers and am currently converting to W2000 TS all with Citrix MetaFrame 1.8 serving about 1700 users from East to West coast. Terminal Server is great for managing orgs with basic desktops on varied workstations (DOS,W9x,NT,
etc). For small user groups, prob. less than 20-25 I don't recommend it. Adds a new complex level of NT management. Sounds as if Rick's 5 users have enough desktop horsepower (Pent-800's)to run app from an NT Application server.

by lickity40

It's always good when the pros in this business concur with my way of thinking.

However, since I was able to obtain a very generous donation from Microsoft for the Server 2000 OS, Windows 2000 Pro and T/S CALS, I think I'm going to call my vendor's bluff and accept their recommendation for our accounting software package upgrade just for the experience. If it doesn't work out for us, I'll tell them that WE told you so and use our new, robust server for something else :)

Thanks again!

Rick Forsythe

This discussion is closed to new replies.