Discussion Locked

The best AntiVirus program?

0 helpful
27 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I've read reviews & used many antivirus programs in DOS, Win3, 95, 98 & ME. Is there such a thing as the 'best'? The reviews only mention the power to detect/ correct most virus's. I'd like to have a bootable 1.44 mb diskette around that can detect/ disempower the most common virus, not the most exotic/ most unusual virus. Is there such a program?

Alternately, I'd like some way of using a harddisk that can give me enough time to detect/ nullify the dangerous virus, so that I'd have time/space to then destroy the virus at my leisure. Often as a pc support person, I'm called in to remove irus attack on foreign pc's.

Is this possible?

27 replies

by lord ago 1

Actually, there is no "best" virus scanner. One person(s)/place may rate a scanner as fantastic to have and yet another person(s)/place may give opposite results.Another thing is that you shouldn't rely on any one virus scanner. I have noticed that some scanners will detect/clean any given virus and some won't even detect it. I use a combonation of the Norton Anti-Virus 2000 and Mcaffe Command Line scanners. These are both easy to update,have Resuce Disk setups for your boot disk, and between the two can detect and clean quite well.The last part you mentioned, I would use maybe a Zip Drive or a Jazz Drive for something like that. You could copy infected files over to it and keep the virus contained. Then you could poke around at it all youwant.

Have Fun!!

by gregzeng

The rescue disks created will only work on the PC that they were created on, I think. They rely on the hard disk also being intact uptodate with it's antivirus protection.

by dmiles

No one Antivirus can be considered the best,depending on the the user's requirements.You can create a ERD,that can be used in MSDOS mode,using a regullar maintenance schedule.So no there is no such program that will fit into your spec's.

by john m. f. kallevik

Hi!

It would seem as if the best alternative for you would be the F-Prot Antivirus program (16-bit version). I use this on a bootable disk. You will have to "clip" off some of the files to make it fit on a 1.44" disc, but it works out ok. Alternatively, use an older version of the scanning software, but get the latest antivirus signature files to go with it. This way you can spare some room.

Hope this helps, if you can't get it to work, drop me a line, and I'll email the software to you, it being freeware for single-license users, this will not be a problem.

Hope this helps,

John M. F. Kallevik
john.kallevik@post.com

by gregzeng

"You will have to "clip" off some of the files to make it fit on a 1.44" disc, but it works out ok. Alternatively, use an older version of the scanning software, but get the latest antivirus signature files to go with it. This way you can spare someroom."
I was looking for THE perfect solution, but it seems yours is the best, where we now know that the perfect solution does not exist.

by fred king

I like and use McAfee, easy and simple, it sits there, scans on bootup and warns you when you that your lasts update was 30 days ago. Setup correctly and if allowed to will update its self. www.mcafee.com

At work we use Norton, equally as good, scans on bootup, will update itselfs if allowed to and setup right. Also warns about when last updated if longer than 30 days.
www.symantec.com

We cannot say who is the best, it just depends on what you like, and how you use them.

by gregzeng

McAfee comes in so many versions that are incompatible with each other. Often the motherboard cdrom will have a McAfee version that cannot be easily (if ever) upgraded. Norton ... tripped over an old version of NAV (floppy disk) that I had.

by rogueldr

Just my two cents here also. 8 months ago I was evaluating Virus software for our company. With 148 PC and 57 Laptops that needed protected I had to make a wise choice. After a month of testing I found McAfee and Norton to be the top two. I picked Norton as what I would use because it seemed that Norton was catching new trojans, virii, and worms atleast 1 sometimes 2 updates quicker then McAfee.

by gregzeng

Thank you. When I troubleshoot a virus-infected pc without any or without an uptodate virus protector ... I found that there is no easy solution.
Thanks for the comparison, where Norton outperformed McAfee in other ways not noted by the comparative reviews which have been published.

by lord ago 1

Actually, you're talking about the Norton scanner. Most people think that you can't use the rescue disks on another machine even though I've done this on many occasions. It's just depends on two things: 1) Don't use any software recovery that comes with it.
2) Use the "/cfg a:" switch.
It will work properly and yes I've done this lots of times.

by gregzeng

This only works on PC's that have Norton already installed on the hard disk. After the hard disk has already been infected? I don't think so.

by interpretivewoodwork

I have found McAfee to be a reliable virus scan product. Nortons works equally well BUT,
adds alot of overhead to workstation, and in some cases not compatable with os client(in our case netware)Also you can use nortons virus definitons with McAfee if you are trying to scan for a specific virus.

by gregzeng

Both McAfee & Norton's seem not to fit onto a floppy (1.44mb). Also with each update, they seem to have an ever-expanding demand on hard disk space. Will this be forever, always expanding?

by vultur

Reccommendations for DOS: There is just one program to get F-Prot. It has the best detection and cure of the bunch.
For windows 3.1: F-Prot
For Windows 9x/2000: Stick with Mcafee or Norton Antivirus.

But for the part about having a disk to detect viri. Check out F-Prot and F-Macro. These will give you great detection. (Note: Mcafee boot disk only searches for boot viri & all virus signatures is bigger than 1.44M)

F-prot also has a Quarintine directory that infected files can be moved into.

by straydog

Seems no one has every tried AVP (AntiViralPro) I have to aggree that Norton and Mcfee are the two leaders when it comes to the Big Name Brands, But I no longer use either one.
Like a fool I used PcCillin once and became Very infected. I got Nortonand it detected and Cleared over 300 Copies of the WinCih Virus from my computer. I was very happy.
Then was given a free trial copy of AVP, it found an Additional 250 more of the same Virus and Three Trojans as well.
I Ran both Norton and AVP on my system at same time for about three monthes, Any Virus that ever did try to infect my PC was caught by AVP. Its Faster than Norton. (Lest in My oppinion)
Mcfee was tested and Never found anything Good or bad no matter, I did not like the pattern updating process.
AVP can be updated daily and takes only a few minutes, they send Email telling of anything New you might need protection for.
They warned me of the Mellisa and ILoveYou Viruses before I even heard of them elsewhere. That fast. I love AVP and will recommend it to Any and Everyone.
As for F-Prot and F-Macro! Never heard of them, but I will be testing them out now that I have.
AVP does have Quarantine, and even asks that you submit any viruses to them that you might Discover. It can be set to Kill on detection, and has many Nice and easy to set and understand features.
I have not used these, but it does have Virus Rescue disk, and DOS capabilities.

You can get it at:
www.avp.com

You can get a free trail and Compair it yourself.

Good Luck, StrayDog

by hold2file

All of these features are available with Norton Anti-virus with the modification that the floppy detection (Norton Rescue) disks will generate 5 to 7 disks that include the virus definitions.
Norton takes an infected file and puts it in Quarantine.
The Anit-virus program can be set to automatically go on the net and download virus definition upgrades every two weeks.
And as a registered user you will get "You need to panic" notices when something big like the "I love you" virus hits. (They do not send out panic notices unneccessarily, however.)
If there are bios or system changes, the Norton Anti-virus program also will ask you (or the user) if this is a legitimate change or a viral corruption.
I am also using the 2000 version on my new WinME system.
The only caution is that if you are using Norton Anti-virus as a part of Norton System works, be forwarned that the OTHER programs (Speed Disk, Disk Doctor, etc.) tremendously slow down your system as a side effect of constantly monitoring your system. I deactive these utilities and ONLY use them manually when I want to have them function. I also have full anti-virus file and document monitoring only onl faster sytems. On my old P-233, the Norton AV also slowed down its operation. My "solution" was to go to a P3-733.

by gregzeng

Thank you. Checking the reviews available for multiple antivirus scanners, I suspect that there is no correct answer on Windows systems anymore,.

by hold2file

All of these features are available with Norton Anti-virus with the modification that the floppy detection (Norton Rescue) disks will generate 5 to 7 disks that include the virus definitions.
Norton takes an infected file and puts it in Quarantine.
The Anit-virus program can be set to automatically go on the net and download virus definition upgrades every two weeks.
And as a registered user you will get "You need to panic" notices when something big like the "I love you" virus hits. (They do not send out panic notices unneccessarily, however.)
If there are bios or system changes, the Norton Anti-virus program also will ask you (or the user) if this is a legitimate change or a viral corruption.
I am also using the 2000 version on my new WinME system.
The only caution is that if you are using Norton Anti-virus as a part of Norton System works, be forwarned that the OTHER programs (Speed Disk, Disk Doctor, etc.) tremendously slow down your system as a side effect of constantly monitoring your system. I deactive these utilities and ONLY use them manually when I want to have them function. I also have full anti-virus file and document monitoring only onl faster sytems. On my old P-233, the Norton AV also slowed down its operation. My "solution" was to go to a P3-733.

by gregzeng

Thank you for the hands-on warnings that Norton is too didhoneset to tell us about. Norton also is deceiving us about the updates to the floppy disks (how often?), and that floppy disks have a limited shelf life.

by bv2

Hmmm...best antivirus - well, at one time I was running F-Prot, Norton, McAfee, Panda, and Thunderbyte on the same machine. I received an e-mail from our corporate office with an embedded macro virus - The only one that caught it was F-Prot. I heartily recommend it for several reasons, the first described above. Secondly, it's the only thing this company (Command Software) does (or was, anyway). Third, the author of the program has written one thing in his life - this program (a guy in Iceland, I believe). This tells me that he has decided to fly or die on one idea, one product - no ifs, ands, or buts. It also tells me he has been able to put his full attention on this product, a rarity with any company that pumps out anti-virus programs.

by gregzeng

Panda? never heard of it. Do you have ALL 5 virus scanners running all the time? Your reply does not solve my old problem: a simple floppy disk to virus check a 'foreign' pc which is suspected of having a virus, but it does not have any adequate virus protection on it.

by bv2

At that time, yes, I was running all five at the same time. One reason that I recommend F-Prot is because, unless it has changed, it does allow the creation of a floppy disk to check for viruses - the virsu signatures take up 3 or 4 floppies, but at least it is not machine specific - that is, they are NOT rescue disks - they are a simplified version of the antivirus program that runs upon boot.

by gregzeng

t would seem as if the best alternative for you would be the F-Prot Antivirus program (16-bit version). I use this on a bootable disk. You will have to "clip" off some of the files to make it fit on a 1.44" disc, but it works out ok. Alternatively, use an older version of the scanning software, but get the latest antivirus signature files to go with it. This way you can spare some room.
john.kallevik@post.com

Your reply is not as detailed as an earlier one that was received, but on which I suspended judgement. Thank you anyway.

This discussion is closed to new replies.