Discussion Locked

The Interview and the "warm fuzzy."

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Rather than go into all the details of the interview process we'll just cut to the chase.
I met with two shift managers and the HR person for the 3 - 4 openings they were looking to fill. During the interview everything appeared to be very positive. I.E. I was asked if I could start immediately, was I flexible in work schedules, was also asked if I was flexible in work assignments and the answer was yes to all questions. I left with the impression that it was a done deal. The interview team told me that it was going to take a few days because they had to through the main office and then to the recruiting agency to finalize the start date. They said for me not to worry if they didn't get back to me in a few days.
I called the recruiting agency a few days later and found out that the hiring company "decided to pass."
No reason was given even though the job appeared to be a perfect match for the company and me. The recruiting agency was a bit miffed and feels that it's a waste of time dealing with this company's open positions. What do you think?

9 replies

by windmillf8

A good interview doesn't mean doo-dah until you actually start. The hiring company could have had some major internal flail: budget readjustment, PHB outbreak, or whatever. Or they could have located an H-1B that would work cheaper. The crooter may have been "miffed" but there may have been more than that; besides, the crooter will do business with them again anyhow, because money talks and BS walks.

by gonzalei

Yes you are right, I am finding out that this situation is "normal" it's just when it's personal that it starts the"bells ringing."
Like what did I do wrong? How could I have misjudged such a positive interview, you know what I mean. Thanks for thewords and I understand what you are saying.

by bob gately

Incompetence is not limited to non-managerial types.

Some people won't give negative feedback. The good news is you won't be working for a dysfunctional organization.

by uncle ramus

I have been in that same position a couple of times. You leave the interview feeling that everything is ok only to be disappointed. What I have learned from that is if company is going to hire you they will normally contact you that day or the very least the day after your interview. If it stretches out over week in my experience and you have not been contacted it is not normally a good sign. I cannot tell you the reasons why it is just my observation. Good luck in your search just keep soldiering on.

by tonkoch

I have been on those hiring teams you described in your posting and as others have told you there are usually all kinds of dynamics going on internally. A group decision on who to hire is a minefield. Many times the applicant may not even be the main event. Also, look at it another way. Any hiring team and/or individual that does not look you in the eye and tell you that this probably is not going to workout may not be worth a pound of salt. Move on to bigger and better.
Hang in.

by gonzalei

I went to another interview and it had the same look and feel as the "warm fuzzy" interview.
I got an application and "first dibs" assurance that I would be considered for the position.
I feel like Charley Brown attempting to kick a field goal with Lucy holding the ball.
I'll let you know via the "discussion center" on the next installment on the "Perils of ?."

by tech_prof1432

I have noticed from being on both sides, that candidates do things wrong and then don't try to learn from their mistakes. Which is my they go on a bunch of interviews and win one of the jobs.
My questions are How much did you talk vs them. (80/20,50/50,20/80)
How soon did you tell them you could start?
What kind of salary did you ask for? Did they have a range? Did you ask who you would be replacing? Did you meet any of your coworkers? Did you answer any technical questions?

by gpl

If the interviewing company is not willing to tell you that they are passing let alone what the reasons are, what do you suggest the next step is?
I have no problem asking them for reasons if I have chance.

by gonzalei

Answers to your questions, regarding "What did you do wrong? "

Q. How much did you talk vs them. (80/20,50/50,20/80)
A. approx 50/50
Q. How soon did you tell them you could start?
A. Immediately, not currently working.
Q. What kind of salary did you ask for?
A. Subject didn't come up because I'm going through at agency.
Q. Did they have a range?
A. Not applicable
Q. Did you ask who you would be replacing?
A. No, Didn't ask and didn't need to know who I was replacing.
Q. Did you meet any of your coworkers?
A. No
Q. Did you answer any technical questions?
A. No technical questions were asked, I had to initiate question regarding the network configurations, helpdesk support, new PC installations.

This discussion is closed to new replies.