Discussion Locked

The Next Step Towards Free Internet and True Open Source

0 helpful
72 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This discussion started as a question here:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=101&threadID=277860

Okay, so the new mission of this discussion is to set up a plan to provide practically free internet to the world or to, at a minimum, force ISPs to lower there price to a much lower level which will still be profitable for them (figure $7/month for high speed).

I think we, as a community of technical experts, can accomplish this. Here is my plan, open for discussion.

We need to first assume that we will not be able to or even allowed to run any lines across the country. We have to assume the entire communications grid is owned by the telcos and we will have to rent bandwidth from them to connect to all the various sites. But we really only require one fast connection and a wireless system per area. This is the plan on how to get there.

Step 1: everyone turn off your security features on your home wireless network. Let people access the internet through your line, it's not illegal if you allow them to and you won't be held responsible for their actions. Configure your system to give much higher priority to your computers than everyone else?s, that way you don't experience performance issues but still provide full speed to users when your line is not in use, which is probably the majority of the day.

Step 2: Local communities need to set up a local infrastructure. New apartments, new neighborhoods, and other local communities should spend some money on a tower and powerful high-speed wireless system to provide free internet to there local communities (figure a 1 mile radius reliable broadcast). The homeowners group or similar organizations could then spend some money for the entire community for one high-speed connection. Security should be disabled at this access point, ideally.

Step 3: IT fellows should create a freeware program (later to be integrated into windows and OSx) that allows you to dynamically send and receive packets on multiple connections. It needs to detect the networks and determine quickly what routes to take for a given packet.

I don't know if anyone is familiar with Ham radio, but a lot of the ham repeaters already have this setup. We just need to expand it past the hobbyists. There are allot of free long range repeaters out there, every town has at least one. We need to expand all of these to allow internet traffic, paid for by donations, state/town contributions and such. Home wireless cards will probably require an amplifier and may require you to mount your antenna on your roof.

I would effectively call this new free global wireless network fgw: free global wireless. In the long run it will take on a life of its own, perhaps creating the breading grounds for a new independent internet.

72 replies

by thumbsup2

(1) Turn off security? THAT won't happen any time soon!

(2) Communities set up infrastructure? Yeah right! Maybe, after they make sure the schools have enough money, the homeless have a roof over their heads/food in their belly and the roads/bridges have all been repaired!

(3) Asking the IT community to do it for free? How about those engineers, such as yourself, who obviously don't need to make a living taking on the task?

(4) Copy the Ham Radio setup? OK, as long as everyone who uses the new 'FGW' system is licensed in the same way the Ham Radio community is licensed and the system can be taken over by the Federal government in cases of National Emergency!

In addition, if you want anyone to take you seriously, you should learn to use the spelling and grammar checkers which are freely available.

.

by winthrop.polk

I know that a setup like this is possible. I'm not saying it can be done over night. It would probably take 30 years to get everyone access to this network.

Security at the wireless transmitter doesn't do that much, it can be beaten fairly easily anyway. A higher level device, the host, has the majority of the protected.

Well, okay, I'm not expecting Anniston AL to spend this money upfront out of city funds. I am expecting hobbyist to make existing system viable for general use and then allow other organization to expand the system.

Fine, I would do it for free. I just have limited IT experience. I could design the protocols and frequency selection algorithms and general network topologies and release them as a free design guide for local communities. You don't like freeware or something?

The system should be able to be taken over in an emergency if they use ham frequencies. But ham frequencies aren't a necessity.

by cmiller5400

[i][quote] I just have limited IT experience. [/quote][/i]

Yup, it shows.

You are absolutely MAD to open your network up like that. What little security we have in place helps make it unreachable for the casual user, an experienced hacker may be able to crack it.

You ARE liable for what happens on YOUR network. Just wait till the FBI shows up at your door with a search warrant.

I do applaud your trying to bring down prices and the "Internet for Everyone" approach.

by charliespencer

How do you plan to purchase the equipment to access it?

You assume that bandwidth will remain public and free. More likely the government will lease or auction off the use of that portion of the spectrum, using the income for the public good.

Water is free too, if you live by a river or lake. How do you plan to pay for the pipes to get it into the house?

by charliespencer

How did you calculate your $7 per month figure for ISP profitability?

"Step 1: everyone turn off your security features on your home wireless network. Let people access the internet through your line, it's not illegal ..."

Ooo-kay. First, that's a bad idea because of the possible security threat to your own systems. Second, it may well be illegal because it probably violates your terms of service agreement with your ISP. Third, that may make it free for my neighbors, but I'm stuck paying the bill for those deadbeats. What's in it for me, besides the privilege of competing with them for bandwidth?

"Step 2: Local communities need to set up a local infrastructure. New apartments, new naborhoods, and other local communities should spend a few thousand dollars on a tower and powerfull highspeed wireless system to provide free internet to there local communities (figure a 1 mile radius reliable transmition)."

A few thousand dollars won't pay for the hardware to cover a 1 mile radius, that's for sure. The tower alone will cost far more than that, and that's without any communications equipment. Then there's the question of who's going to pay for the maintenance and support of this infrastructure. If it's free, where's the maintenance funding coming from? Also, people are screaming now about too many cell towers and wind power towers; you're never going to get agreement to drop one down every square mile.

"The homeowners group or similar organizations could then spend, say, $300 a month..."

That's $3600 a year; a big chunk of money for many homeowner groups. Also, you're just shifting the individual's cost from reducing their bill from an ISP to increasing their dues to the HOA.

"I would effectively call this new free global wireless network..."

What's free about it? I'm either paying for it through my homeowner's dues or through municipal taxes.

by winthrop.polk

There are a lot of reasons for doing this. Look, the internet is getting more and more regulated and most of us are aware that traffic is scanned for "terrorist activity". Who knows what they are really scanning for?

I pulled the $7 out of my ...
The point is the prices for the services are practically identical, but the means of providing the service is different; leading me to believe price fixing is occurring.

Another option would be to do this via satellite. Yeah yeah, funding is a problem but this is still doable. I think it costs around $10 million to put a satellite in orbit.

Look, I just think that a lot of these things should be made free to the public for the good of the country as a whole. I do not think that toll roads should be allowed to exist. I think healthcare should be relatively free, paid for by taxes, like most other developed nations do. I also think that state universities should be free. I don't want to eliminate capitalism, I just want it to either be regulated for the protection of the country, or we can do it ourselves, without the middle men.

You say it may violate the terms of service; I disagree. I don't know about everyone else, but when I signed up for high speed comcast it was a verbal agreement which didn't specify number of users, only bandwidth usable. So in effect, when your not using it your still paying for it so why not let others use it instead of giving AT&T and comcast free profit.

by charliespencer

"I just think that a lot of these things should be made free to the public for the good of the country as a whole. I do not think that toll roads should be allowed to exist. I think healthcare should be relatively free, paid for by taxes, like most other developed nations do. I also think that state universities should be free."

If something is paid for by taxes, it isn't free. Believe it or not, that money the government spends comes out of our pockets! Really, I'm not joking. Shocking, but true.

If we get rid of toll roads and make universities free, who's going to pay to have the road maintained and the salaries of the university staff? These things have to be paid for, whether directly by the user (toll road drivers, college attendees), indirectly by taxes (spreading the cost across all taxpayers whether they use the service or not), or some combination of the two.

Nothing in your plan as described above is free. Free software is one thing. Anybody with a cheap computer and a free compiler can write code with almost no overhead costs. Collaboration with others is almost free; if one has to one can swap code around on physical media via snail mail. Free physical infrastructure is another matter entirely. Someone has to pay for those towers, access points, routers, etc, the labor to install them, the parts and labor to maintain them, insurance on the towers, the legal staff to file the necessary paperwork to erect the towers and fight the inevitable protests, etc. You're not going to persuade tower manufacturers, installers, network technicians, environmental experts, lawyers, insurers, etc. to do all this out of the goodness of their hearts.

The government doesn't currently provide water or sewer for free, and they're far more essential to life than an Internet connection. EXACTLY how do you propose to fund your project?

by p51mustang23

Individuals should be allowed to connect directly to the internet without a middleman, if possible. The big companies have way too much power over the net. As technology advances I think there will soon be ways that allow individuals to connect dirrectly to a server; no going through an ISP. And the internet, being what it is, I just dont think they will be able to regulate it forever.

And government survillience of the net? thats scary stuff! However, the only way(imo) to get government out of the internet is to shrink it(gov't) down. Right now all of our data has to travel through the same ISPs.

And if state colleges were free they would go to hell, and taxes would SKYROCKET. But that's off-topic.

Just a side note, but I hear that comcast used to block BitTorrent files from traveling on their network. Sound like censorship?

by dumphrey

providing internet to all citizens? If through schools or libraries if no where else?
The availability of high speed internet is still almost zero in many rural areas still. So these areas would be left out of the loop.
Lets leave price completely out of the picture and just focus on the HOW.
1) How would we provide a strong wireless signal o remote areas with no high speed access.
2) What technology do we use to connect this web together? Is it its one network with gateways to the internet? Or just large wireless bridges to the internet? Does it piggy back on existing infra structure or need its own, new infrastructure?
3) Who will manage and oversee the maintenance of equipment?

Also, you need to make sure *nix and BSDs are included in your app development.

America is freakin' huge. This project would be ginormous...

Projects like this exist on much smaller scale, the trick is how do you make it scale up to a national level.

by winthrop.polk

I have heard talk of the government setting things up like this, but I think, as expected, they are getting a lot of resistance from ISPs. Rural areas can get high-speed satellite service, but latency is a little ridiculous. With this plan, they eventually wouldn't be left out. Just as hams put up a free for all ham satellite transceiver (which never really worked well) we could do the same for them, eventually. Unimportant though, moving on. I agree, ignore price; it doesn't factor into this thought process.

1&2) It would take some experimentation and different areas would implement it differently. Usually just install the equipment on an existing tower or build a tower and run an Ethernet connection up to it with additional equipment of course and an ISP service. Network cards currently in use would probably need to be replaced with higher powered equipment on the users end. That?s about it. For really long distances the frequency could be shifted to use atmospheric bounce or installation of more repeaters. To connect the webs, to create a second in depend www if that is an intent, one can use the existing repeater infrastructure and expand it. Currently there is a repeater structure which I believe runs from Florida to Virginia to help hams communicate. There will probably be only one gateway to the internet per area. Existing infrastructure already allows it in certain areas but only for hams and it's currently dialup speeds or, rarely, high-speed which I have seen.

3) The tower owners which will be a variety of people and groups. When I get my house, I plan to install a ham tower and set this system up. Eventually, when enough of us do this and allow others to connect to it (using there own higher powered transceivers), apartments and communities might do the same to provide internet to the community as an added bonus of signing a lease to attract customers.

What is *nix? Sorry, I deal mainly with hardware software development and not operation.

America is huge, and this will take a while. Like I say, this isn't a Manhattan project, but it will build with time. Ultimately, if everyone right now turned of the security on there wireless internet transceivers, we would have 80% of it completed, though in a different manner than originally intended. I realize this won't happen, but there are plenty of insecure wireless access points out there already. It's not illegal to access them, but it is illegal to crack the passwords, which I don't condone.

I agree, this already exists on smaller scales but still occurs throughout the USA. All we need is a few more ham towers (say 100 more, pulling that number out of my @$$) to set the system up, well and far, and then shift the frequency to a public one not requiring a license and your done.

by charliespencer

is a generic term for a class of similar operating systems: Unix, Linux, BSD, OS X, etc. Dumphrey was pointing out you need to consider non-Windows systems, a small but significant portion of home and SOHO users. Many of those users are already into uncompensated open source software development and so may be more willing to buy into your plan than Windows users.

by ---tk---

"Projects like this exist on much smaller scale, the trick is how do you make it scale up to a national level."

Get a whole bunch of "out of the box" thinkers, in a whole bunch of little areas into one non-profit organization, and have little cells pop up all over the place.... eventually it will be wide spread. Worry about the people on the out skirts later...

by winthrop.polk

Agreed. Eventually it should act like a mesh network. If the mesh gets large enough, you could have an entirely new and independant wireless web with access points to the www.

by winthrop.polk

You state the obvious; I am looking for the less obvious. Yes, if something is paid for by taxes it isn't free, but it is relatively free. By free, I mean that no profit will be made by the controlling entity, or, a "fair" profit can be made at best, not a ridiculous profit. The government doesn't "directly" make money on the construction or use of roads. Companies have somehow been allowed to construct roads and maintain ownership for the purpose of making a ridiculously large profit for many many years where the government could have provided it. In comparing a company own toll road with a government owned toll road, yes I consider the government owned road "relatively free".

As related to state universities, they are currently supposed to be relatively free in that they should not be making a profit. If there ever is a profit, it should but rarely does go to new building, tuition reduction, etc. I don't think there is anything more important for our nations than education, and people have limited funds and the price is rising fast.

In terms of physical structures, we don't need much more than is already in existence. Like I said, every town has ham towers put up by clubs and such. These organizations exist mainly to learn about electronics and a number of these clubs have already experimented with the technology. As each area would decide to implement a plan like this, they would most likely contact the local ham club and ask to run some equipment to their tower (Ethernet connection, signal converter, transmitter, and antenna). The ham club would probably say, "no, but what a great idea, we will implement it for you if you help with the cost". Like I said, eventually, after many years, most towns will end up with free wireless to anyone who has the proper higher powered equipment.

This isn't intended to be an instant Manhattan project. It's intended to be a design guide for local communities which will eventually result in sufficient numbers to start to prompt new neighborhood and apartment communities to implement similar systems to add a bonus to a customer?s selection process (my apartment currently gives free water and sewer, even though I know it is added into the cost of rent; but if I use it a lot, yes I can get a certain amount for free [not relative]). If the hobbyists get the system big and popular enough, I think this will occur; similar to the way starbucks and other companies provide free wireless today to attract customers. All I am really saying is that this existing system of wireless networks needs to be amplified to cover a larger area, first by hobbyists, then, eventually, by community groups and maybe even city groups.

by charliespencer

you need to stop using the word 'free' as a synonym for 'non-profit'. Your use of the word does not match what the rest of English speaking America has defined. It doesn't even match the definition of the word as used by the open source software community.

There's nothing free about what you're discussing. You're merely shifting the costs around and spreading them over time. Somebody somewhere is paying for it. Good luck rounding up all those Samaritans you think are going to do all this work for you.

by winthrop.polk

Starbucks doesn't provide non-for-profit wireless, they provide free wireless according to there signs. I am only proposing to do the same on a larger scale. Others including homeowners, ham operators and eventually communities and cities should do the same and if they do and the aforementioned software package works anyone will be able to access the internet from anywhere for free. Yes, if you want a dedicated line run to your house for a variety of reasons you will still have to pay for it through your ISP. But this system will be competition for the ISPs and they will be force to lower there price. If you?re a good person you will leave your wireless gateway open for others to use and secure it when you need the bandwidth or give your computers priority. I have a wireless system to use with my laptop which I leave open for other apartment owners to use as they like. There have been as many as 5 people on my network using it at one time and as most of you know there are plenty of other open wireless networks in every community. It's not nor will it ever be illegal to transmit or receive signals wireless, so long as you use free legal portions of the spectrum. It is however illegal to break the password of a secure wireless system, which I am not condoning by any means. In terms of security, you don?t need to protect the internet, just your computer. The only security provided with wireless transceivers is password protection, which isn?t anything special, and can be implemented on your local network rather than the wireless network which should be your access point to the internet as well.

by winthrop.polk

Like they purchase there modems and wireless cards today. I'm not saying I am going to provide anyone with free personal hardware, but free public hardware will be provided just as free ham repeaters (paid for by clubs with sponsors) and free radio signals (paid for by advertisers) are provided to the communities today.

There will always be free bandwidth within each spectrum section. Always! If not, people will have to broadcast on illegal frequencies to use walky-talkies, ham equipment, wireless telephones, CBs, wireless internet access, etc. These device all work on free portions of the spectrum, they just regulate the max power output allowed to minimize interference. Granted, you probably couldn't do this on the ham frequencies for the general public because of licensing requirements, but it is already setup in certain areas for hams to use. All that is needed is a frequency switch here to allow the general public to access the internet through these free towers. Granted, hams probably won't want to do this until the system is wide spread throughout the ham community and the speed of the internet takes another large leap, but it is doable; it's already being done.

In terms of the river analogy, it isn?t really relevant but, yes one could easily get free water. If you live by a lake or river, just run a pipe to your basement and add a small pump and water processing facility; add a carbon filtration system and I guarantee you will be getting cleaner water than the city provides. I would do this if I ever made it big. It would probably cost $20k-$40k not including the pipe run but would provide you with free cleaner water for life. Unfortunately, I doubt the government will allow you to do this just as they don't allow you to camp unless it?s a designated campground.

by charliespencer

"...free public hardware will be provided just as free ham repeaters (paid for by clubs with sponsors) and free radio signals (paid for by advertisers) are provided to the communities today."

How do you think advertisers pay for radio? By factoring the advertising cost into the price of the products or services they sell. Somebody somewhere is paying for it, one way or the other.

I stepped across the hall and spoke to our in-house amateur radio aficionado. According to him, most clubs in this area don't have a tower. The locals here have their repeater on the city water tower and have to pay an annual lease fee. That fee is covered by their club dues, not by any sponsorship. So much for 'free' towers. He did say they'd be happy to take sponsorship money if you can arrange such a deal...

"There will always be free bandwidth within each spectrum section."

Bandwidth is the least of your problems.

"...one could easily get free water. If you live by a lake or river, just run a pipe to your basement and add a small pump and water processing facility; add a carbon filtration system ..."

One more time, that isn't free. You have to factor the cost of the delivery system into each gallon you use. Over time that cost will become less per gallon, but you're going to have to spend a lot of money before you get that first gallon out of the ground. That's basic Economics 101. The cost will never reach zero because you're having to regularly buy filters.

My ham buddy did raise one issue: Who's paying for the electricity to run all this infrastructure equipment? Is Boondock Power & Light paying for this out of the goodness of their hearts? The amateur radio groups certainly aren't.

by winthrop.polk

As stated in another thread of this post, yes nothing in the world is truly free; but there are relatively free things. Yes the aforementioned water is free. If you want the convenience of running it to your house and cleaning it, it will cost. Once an infrastructure is setup, operation is relatively free except for maintenance and operations costs which can be expensive for systems. But if you know the system will be running anyway without actually being used (like most personal wireless systems during the day and often ham equipment), you should provide it to others for free; yes I said free. If I give you a ham sandwich and I say it's free, relative to you it is free and I could care less that I cost me a buck or two, it was going to go bad anyway. But yes, nothing is truly free; I only shifted the cost of the ham sandwich. In which case ?free? shouldn?t be part of the English language but ?relatively free? should be. Everything in the universe is relative; understand the context of what you?re reading. Yes I want people, hams, communities, and cities to pickup this cost. But like I said, if you?re not using every single bit of bandwidth on your home network, you?re still paying for it. Why not provide it to others.

If you are not willing to put a little back into the community to set this up, there is no reason to consider you relevant to this conversion, no offense and I appreciate your input. I just want to talk to people who are willing. Later, when the system is viable, you may want to get in on it. You can still use the system anytime you want, lol. I know there are a lot of people out there who are willing to put a little into this and there are a lot of people who aren?t but still would use the system. Let?s change direction and go to the last post by Dumphry which is a good lead in.

by thumbsup2

re: Water, you said "It would probably cost $20k-$40k not including the pipe run but would provide you with free cleaner water for life. Unfortunately, I doubt the government will allow you to do this just as they don't allow you to camp unless it?s a designated campground."

Fortunately, the waters running through a state belong to all of the people in the state, not just one individual who wants to take what they want, when they want, regardless of the repercussions to anybody else down stream. Permits are required in order to withdraw water from any surface water source and those are in high demand/short supply. Most rivers and streams are already over-allocated, so getting a permit to withdraw water, even for drinking purposes, is near impossible.

So, the point is, no matter how much money you had, you couldn't just do what you wanted to do. And, these are all laws on the books for over a century, enforceable and punishable by fines and/or a stretch in the slammer!

Your 'free ISP' idea is much the same. Frequencies ARE regulated. Some are available to the public. But, when you capture some it to resell (and you WOULD have to resell to cover expenses), you are no longer 'the public'. You are a for-profit business!

by winthrop.polk

Well,

I wouldn't sell the service; it would be free just as any local ham has free special internet access if systems are setup locally. I would be providing a public service.

It is sad though, that one can't take water out of a river. Over population is to blame here I guess. But it is funny. You really wouldn't be using any more water than you buy from the water company so you?re not going to be causing any shortages, in the ideal water model anyway. I guess I just really hate middle men. You could still pull it out of the ground though? Any quantity? I doubt it; I?m pretty sure you need a permit for that too.

You know, the law makes sense for businesses, corporations and people who are profiting from the water. But it doesn't make sense for the average homeowner who is not treated as fairly as the industries. Industrial facilities use 100s of tons of water per minute, and humans use a few liters per day. So shouldn't the government be forced to issue a relatively percapita equal amount of permits for individual use as they do for industrial use (and industrial use is HUGE!). For example, they issue a permit to a power plant that allows them to use 1,000,000 tons per day. Shouldn?t they also be force to issue 1,000,000 permits for 1 ton each for citizen use?

by charliespencer

"Starbucks ... provide free wireless according to there signs."

SIGNS LIE. Starbucks gets a bill from their ISP, divides that bill by the number of cups of coffee they sell each month, and adds those pennies to the cost of every cup. Everyone who buys a cup of coffee pays for that Internet access connection. It's included in the cost of the coffee whether you use the service or not. If you don't buy coffee, others are paying for the service for you. Econ 101.

"Others including homeowners, ham operators and eventually communities and cities should do the same on a larger scale."

Then who do you propose they charge, or do you suggest they pay for all this infrastructure out of their own pockets? They don't have customers like Starbucks does, so the money is going to have to come from somewhere. Sooner or later this wireless system you're proposing is going to tie into wire somewhere; who's paying for that connection?

"If you?re a good person you will leave your wireless gateway open for others to use and secure it when you need the bandwidth or give your computers priority."

Then, like the Starbucks customers who pay for the coffee, you're subsidizing those who use the wireless connection without making a purchase. In your book that makes you 'good'; in mine it makes you a naive fool. You may be willing to pay the bill for others, but I'm not. If my neighbor's want to use my wireless connection, they can damn well split the cost with me. I manage a fantasy racing league that costs about $95 a year to run, a lot less than your annual ISP connection. If you think I don't pass those costs on to the players, or think I personally absorb the minimal $5 annual charge for even one of them, you're wrong.

by charliespencer

"If you are not willing to put a little back into the community to set this up, there is no reason to consider you relevant to this conversion, no offense and I appreciate your input. I just want to talk to people who are willing."

So far, the only ones who've responded to your idea without contempt are Dumphrey and little old irrelevant me. My responses aren't just to point out the economic hurdles to what you're discussing. I'm trying to keep the topic alive so others will see it. I'm not sure where you hope to find these "people who are willing", but so far none of them have chimed in here at TR.

by winthrop.polk

Maybe I'm wrong, but I don't think that star bucks, the library, police stations and other organizations that use wireless internet would be responsible for a hacker who used their access point to do malicious stuff, whether they had security or not. If what you?re saying is true, then all people owning a wireless network are in trouble. Lots of hacker types break there passwords to use the connection illegally. I don't think the homeowner is or should be held responsible for this.

by charliespencer

As previously noted, law enforcement agencies don't know who's using the connection. If the ISP reports kiddie porn going through your IP address, it's going to be your problem proving to the authorities that it was someone else on your connection.

by winthrop.polk

I didn't think our society has failed us that much; this point where you have ?guilty until proven innocent?. Even the FBI knows it is highly likely the figurative person was just hacked, but they put the responsibility on them to prove their innocence. Unbelievable. Yet plausible deniability and executive privileges still exist for the wealthy. What a world.

by ---tk---

There are a few problems here. Child porn, we cant turn a blind eye to the freaks in this world, that hide in all the small dark places. If they accessed the network, and accessed that crap, it would be tracked back to you! - a Proxy with word filtering, user name and password, and port blocking would take care of this (most of it)....

Also if some butt head decided to try to break through the Gov. firewalls and routers, to access some high security database, the FBI would be at your front door really quick!

Also as far as how much it costs to the actual ISP its more like 2 bucks /per month.... Which was told to me by an actual employee that was fixing the line into my house. They price it so high, because they actually lose money on their IP phone service.... Time warner Cable...

Also you would need to find an ISP to go along with this(would be cheaper in the beginning till you have the right amounts of funds to bang it out)... You could word it to them, providing internet access to those who can't afford it...

In all do reality I think it can be done, but it would have to start out on a very small scale. And you would probably need to set up a non-profit to fund it. So people can donate to that organization, and not you!

I would seriously prefer that it be achieved by citizens vs. the Gov.

by winthrop.polk

Any technology can be used for good or evil. Child porn is evil. But the internet should be free and open. I cannot nor do I want to account for this type of user in this system, though he may use it. The government has that responsibility; I would be messing it up for everyone else who is not an evil person. Besides, child porn was actually more widespread before the internet (lol, okay, I pulled that one out of my @$$ as well, but it is conceivable). It would be a good idea to do a word search on all communications for those key words. I would probably just want to send the user a scary message like ?the FCC is aware of your location and is coming? and perhaps they will find the guy using triangulation. Nothing will ever stop those guys because they are self perpetuating and every equation has more than one solution. They should be brought to justice, however, I do feel that the priority should be to catch the people creating the child porn (which appears to be lost in the governments mission) rather than prioritizing the distribution which will all know, once a video or file is out there it aint ever going away.

The FBI should come to my door if that happens. They should be allowed full access to files and such. But they should not hold me responsible for the public service I provide. If a child molester does his evil things in a park, is the park owner held responsible? No, but he is questioned which is fine with me.

$2/month sounds right; wouldn?t be surprised if it?s lower. That?s one reason I?m pissed because I pay $45/month, which isn?t an honest profit. Who?s losing monkey on IP phone service? That isn?t right. Comcast and AT&T make a profit from it.

Good advice on getting the ISP to go along, at least with your social engineering. But really, all I need to do is call them up and say I need so and so bandwidth, give me a price. That should be it. They don?t really need to know anymore. I have yet to sign any contracts with any of my utilities.

Thanks for the pointers, that post actually helped. It does need to be done on a small scale. I'm thinking I can do it for the Chattanooga area with 1 or 2 70? towers. Of course, only hams currently have the equipment to access it, but I can create a site for local chattanoogians to tell them what to purchase if they want to access, and I am sure some will. Who knows where it will go from there. I agree, this should be a citizen run project. I really do want to provide this for free, but a non for profit donations only company is a great idea to help.

by charliespencer

"...I?m pissed because I pay $45/month, which isn?t an honest profit."

An "honest profit" is what the traffic will bear. Comcast, Time-Warner, AT&T, etc. are all in business to make money. They are charged with this by their shareholders. If the shareholders decide they want to operate at a reduced profit, they can vote in a new board to change the company's approach at the annual meeting. If you have a retirement fund, 401K, or otherwise invest in a mutual fund, you're probably a shareholder who benefits from those 'dishonest' profits. Be sure to divest if the profits offend you.

Last time I checked millions of people live full and contented lives without an Internet connection.

by karlkeip

I have several computers at my place and my access point is the hub for all of them. Wide open secureity would give outsiders access to my LAN. That's not an adventure I would want to try.

Furthermore, most people are not going to be able to get past the idea that they are paying for the connection while everyone around them is freeloading.

by winthrop.polk

Some people are willing to pay a public service to people, some aren't. My mom for example won't throw anything out and won't give it to goodwil. She just hords everything hoping to sell it at a garage sale. Then there is me who gives everything I can to goodwl to get ride of the crap I'm not using. Samething in the electronic frontier. BitTorrent, BBSs, proxies, wikipedia, university internet access are all but a few examples of free electronic public works projects, which are GREAT for a society. Some people will do it and when enough of them do and you take advantage of this global wireless system, I wouldn't be surprised if you decided to help out; way way later.

About your system, your wireless access point only provides password protection and in your configuration you would have to implement a pass word on all your computers and remove the passwords that exist on the path to the internet. This isn't really the intent though, and not an ideal subsystem for the global system. Ideally (which is probably to much of a pain and expense for you not to mention other obvious factors), you should simple connect the modem to the line, and connect the wirerless transceiver to the modem; then access the internet wirelessly with all your computers individually.

by hal 9000

You are responsible for what comes through your Internet Connection so if you leave a WiFi Access Point Open and do not establish Black Lists which prevent certain sites being visited and downloaded from you are Guilty.

[b]Plain & Simple.[/b]

A Crime has been committed and in the Case of Kidd Porn or even Terrorist Activity for example is the Owners Responsibility to Secure that Access Point and the Guilty Party is never going to willingly put their hand up and confess if they know that they can get away with a [b]I didn't do it Excuse.[/b] All that they would be required to do if that was the case is to use a different computer like a NB and hide it then claim that they didn't do it.

The point here is you own that Access Point you are responsible for what comes through it just the same as you own that car and are responsible for what it does while you are in control of it. If you where to leave it on the side of the road with the car unlocked and the motor running and someone took it you are more responsible for what it does than if it was stolen after being broken into.

By leaving it on the side of the road unlocked with the motor running you have given consent for anyone to take it and do as they please where as if you secure it and it gets stolen you are not responsible for what it ends up being involved in.

In the case of Electronic Ownership you own the Access Point and everything that comes through it if you do not secure it. It is your responsibility to look after your items not someone else.

In the case of Starbucks and so on they do not just leave a WiFi Access Point open for all to use they employ Stringent Security and Black Lists which prevent the Listed Sited being visited or data downloaded from them. In the case of the Security Services when these sites are attempted to be accessed they will take lists of Identifying items to mark the Culprit and do everything possible to track down and Apprehend the Criminal.

Col

by hal 9000

Well in my case I don't want to go to Jail for Downloading Kiddy Porn and end up on the Sexual Offenders List as a Pervert who is known by everyone who cares to bother looking.

There is also the cost of Excess Usage involved as many do not have a Open ISP Plan that just allows whatever they want to download to be downloaded. After a certain limit it starts to cost the Owner of that Connection More Money.

I personally have a 30 Gig Per Month Limit I can burn that up in under a day when required and then for the next 2 GIG I pay 15 cents per MEG which works out to $300.00 then it becomes free again but at a reduced speed.

So I pay $100.00 per months for Fast Cable Internet then if I go over the 30 GIG Limit I pay up to another $300.00 three times the months Cable Bill then have it reduced to Dial Up Speeds.

Personally if I wanted or needed a $400.00 per month ISP Plan I would have it but I don't see why I should pay that type of money so someone else can mooch off me and do as they please at my expense. If someone was to ask I don't have a problem with allowing them to use it but when they sneak around and steal I do have a problem.

Col

by hal 9000

Only a [b]Stark Raving Lunatic[/b] would consider doing something like this willingly.

You are leaving yourself open to all sorts of Legal Problems arising and no way to defend yourself when a Prosecution is Launched as you are at the very least an Accessory to any Crime committed. In the Case of Suspected Terror Activity the Authorities will jump on you from great heights quite quickly and because of what you are doing you are admitting Guilt before any Investigation is Launched.

At the very least you are [b]Supporting Terrorists or Child Molesters[/b] nice thought there isn't it? But it's true no matter what happens by doing this you have no control who uses your ISP or what is downloaded or transmitted. You could have been responsible for allowing certain people to communicate and or plan their intentions to commit Acts of Terrorism in posting White Powder in the Postal Service to disrupt your country or even hijack aircraft and fly them into buildings.

By leaving WiFi Points open you have [b]No Control[/b] over what it is used for but all the responsibility when something wrong happens.

I hope you enjoy the prospect of long term Impressment and Life Long Requirements of Reporting your activities to Police. Not to mention a Life Long Ban from using Computer Technology.

Col

by tony hopkinson

Aside from the fact that you are wide open to being hacked, the connection you are paying will be used for illegal activity.

Even if you are not found guilty, you get taken away in a police car you don't see your PC again until it's obolete. You could get vists from social services, your children may be put on an at risk register, your finances turned over, your friends and family questioned....

No what you want is to become a mini ISP, allow controlled access to services you offer through your wireless connection.

Think of P2P over wireless....

The big telcos and tossers like the RIAA would go absolutely mental....

Something to do DNS, hmmm....

by charliespencer

I'm still under the impression that a wired connection, be it cable or DSL, is still faster than a wireless connection in terms of the home environment. Are affordable home 802.11n systems that much faster than .11g?

by oh smeg

The 802 System is considerably slower than Wired connections but the Broadband Wireless is delivered over the 3G Phone Network and as such is not limited by the 802 Technology.

It is up there with the Cable connections and is far cheaper to roll out for the ISP's so that is the way they are going here to save the costs of rolling out Cable to new Suburbs or extending the Cable Infrastructure further.

Col

by tony hopkinson

But if we lived next door and had our own wireless and linked up. In a controlled fashion of course not matey boy's free for all. We don't need no stinking ISP. :D
We could however become each other's proxies if desired.

Expand the concept and you have a home user mesh like a P2P network using our own kit, subject to no control but that which we wish.

There are big questions on what you could do, and aside from direct explicit trust DNS, authorisation, security, quotas and routing are problems to solve.

There's no technical reason why it couldn't be done though.

I know a couple of guys who link up and watch the movies on each others xboxes, saves them getting off their asses nipping next door and borrowing the DVD.

by winthrop.polk

You don't have your signal contained by twisted shield pairs so your get more interference and more error correction. Wireless in general can be actually faster than wired connections if designed as such; but I doubt there are any consumer setups like this.

by oz_media

Any wireless router or switch results in about 10% bandwidth overall.

that's why I got rid of mine, convenient but slower, and that 10% makes a huge difference when you are transferring 12-20 gigs overseas a few times a week.

I just installed RJ45 jacks all through my apartment, landlord didn't mind, it's an upgrade afterall and I knew what I was doing.

by oz_media

Wouldn't it be etter if you were using someone else's andwidth though?

Who would be the handful of people that offer THEIR bandwidth unsecured? Why wouldn't everyone just look for someoen else's router to use? Of course when they are all too slow, you'd go and get your own, then secure it so nobody else oculd use it and we are back to square one.

With fewer subscribers and the same amount of andwidth used, do people really think the cost wouldn't go up to a few hundred a month, for the por guy who shares his router anyway.:D

Add a higher monthly rate and then the bandwidth overuse charges and it's not a very good system at all.

by dr dij

in the BANDWIDTH FAIRY!!!

This is a special breed, a 'techno-fairy', skilled in polishing dark fiber ends (and if you use dark energy to transmit the free internet on, I suppose the Telcos will never know).

The BANDWIDTH FAIRY dances around at night, staying late with unpaid overtime and knows all protocols. Rumor is the BF just got CCIE certified, has petabytes of photographic memory, and a built in protocol analyzer in (his)her fingertip!

The bandwidth fairy also mystimagically makes illegal copies of videos and music download at LIGHT SPEED, Captn - without affecting anyone else's internet use! (make it so mumbles Jean Luc - turn on the tri-desic wormhole with tachyon beams, Broccoli and Wesley so Voyager can hear us in the delta quadrant).

Having a parts replicator and a helium-3 powered fusion reactor to power it all, (S)he doesn't even need to charge for parts! (ok, some of the cisco clone parts are made in china so they don't cost much anyway)

In all fairness to Winthrop, innovative companies are developing mesh wireless routers. These would be handy in rural areas, extending connectivity from the edge of broadband wired connections out to areas via wireless mesh routers where no wired broadband available. Until such time as they become free or incredibly cheap, rural neighbors would likely form formal or informal telecom co-ops to fund these, paid by those seeking connection to place them at their own place to extend conx further and at wired location at neighbors to extend to them.

by hal 9000

But that could be because you failed to make any mention of Anti-Light the Photon Equivalent of Matter and Anti Matter. :p

Anti Light is far easier to transport and produces a larger amount of energy when it comes into contact with Light. Naturally enough the Cable ISP's refuse to acknowledge the Existence of Anti Light as their Infrastructure then would become a Weapon of Mass Destruction across the Globe. :p

Col

by lucasmarin

you guys making this story up, i dont know... it reminds me of school, when they thaught us how people were mocking columbus cristofol, when he said the world was round.
this type of discussion always arise when someone try to make things better, or to expand knowledge to the unknown... i wish everybody believed for real that "everything is possible".

by .martin.

I think something of the like will happen in the not too distant future, but maybe not now.

I think we are all still a little scared of what might happen.

by winthrop.polk

I could and will happen eventually. I am trying to do what the universities, the military and individuals did in the 1980s. That is, I am trying to setup the backbone and concepts of this system to first be used by technical hobbyist and eventually everyone else when the information is disseminated.

by charliespencer

Not being a cellular customer or responsible for it's use at work, I often miss changes in that technology.

by hal 9000

I have several who I have to sort out Global Roaming for all around the Planet on occasions and that is a nightmare to do but when it comes to just the same country it's easy. Well in compression at least.

Col

by winthrop.polk

WTF are yall saying. lol. The last paragraph of your post was actually useful, so why the gibberish?

by winthrop.polk

If I can be held responsible for what goes in and out of my access point, then the ISP can be held just as responsible for what goes in and out of their access point (which is in series with my access point). All this child porn and terrorist activities goes through there systems just as it goes through mine and if there security can't stop it mine certainly can't. With or without security, this will always be possible; no system is 100% secure.

by hal 9000

And they are the ones who report it to the Authorities.

After all they are not responsible for what their customers do just the same as when you sell something you are not responsible for what the seller choses to do with the item you sell.

Unless of course you specifically sell something who's sole purpose is to circumvent something and perform a crime. :0

The [b]Sorry Dave I can not allow you to do that[/b] argument doesn't work here as the Masses would scream out that they are being Censored.

However in the case of Kiddy Porn provided you can supply the name of the Perp you are OK. But with Open WiFi Access points the trail stops at the owner of that open WiFi Port and they are the one responsible for what comes through it. In the case of Terrorist Activity once you accept that every bit of Telephony Communication is monitored and tracked when it throws up a Red Light just who do you really think that the Authorities will pay a visit to when they want to stop something going on? Your argument just doesn't fit with the Real World as it's a crime to use the Post or Telephone System to commit a Crime but this is very rarely Policed where as the ISP are Obligated to Report Activity to the Authorities and to prevent themselves problems you had better believe that they will be unwilling to take the wrap for something that they have no control over. Best case scenario if they catch your WiFi Point doing something like this they will terminate your Account but the Reality is they will leave it open Monitor the Traffic and freely give this to the Authorities to prevent problems for themselves.

Col

by winthrop.polk

I consider it dishonest because no competition exists for these systems in a given area. If I want high speed cable internet, I can only go to one provider. The model of supply and demand is irrelevant if no competition exists. And no, I cannot live without internet, metaphorically of course, just as I cannot live without gas in this society. So that's why I consider it a dishonest profit (not to mention the fact the told me it would be free installation and it wasn't free; Then one week later the equipment they installed failed, because it was crappy equipment, and they charged me a ton to come out and fix there mistakes; Also they charged me on my first bill for a movie I didn't watch; I called them 3 times and everyone I talked to said they agree the $120 worth of charges should be removed, but that they didn't have the authority to remove the charges or escalate the call; I have a complaint files with the BBB, awaiting a result). See this one of many examples where Comcast is trying to make an unfair profit:

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=96311177

Also, I consider it an unfair profit because there profit margin is ridiculously high. I'm not saying it is illegal, just unfair because I have no other options and they can charge anything they want.

There is a way to do business fairly, though it has been a while since this has occurred in this country. Hopefully OBAMA will increase regulation. The whole conservative liberal divide really isn't over more or less government; It is really other more or less government for big business, that?s the issue. Laws for individuals are debatable, but the majority of them are not (e.g. rape, murder, stealing, etc.)

by winthrop.polk

I care about right and wrong, the law is supposed to reflect that. Everything is fine with them investigating me if something like this occurs, but if I am convicted of any wrong doing, this is not right I tell you. Like you say, if I intentionally set up the system for kiddies porn yes I should be held responsible; but I'm not! I just want people to have a good free reliable widespread and truly anonymous way of accessing the internet. What they do with it is between them and the law. Granted I am an idealist and this has gotten me into trouble, but I can't be any other way, it's who I am. If I own a gun shop and someone buys a gun and kills someone, I would not be held responsible as I shouldn't be. I would be talked to though, which is fine and cooperable.

by charliespencer

was implying your plan is a fantasy. HAL and I were just adding out contribution to the lunacy.

Incidentally, you can stop peer mailing me on this subject. If a topic begins on a discussion, that's the only place I will discuss it. To do so via private e-mail deprives other readers of the full discussion.

Oh, and bulletin boards didn't cost much more to run than a stand-alone computer with it's own incoming phone line, and they weren't all free.

by charliespencer

Are four different things.

"I care about right and wrong, the law is supposed to reflect that. ... I just want people to have a good free reliable widespread and truly anonymous way of accessing the internet. What they do with it is between them and the law."

The law isn't about right and wrong; it's about what lawmakers have determined is or isn't a crime.

As to what people do being between them and the law, you've inserted yourself between those users and the public airwaves. You're providing the transmission medium. If / when the Feds show up, you probably will be able to eventually convince them you're not the criminal. If you're lucky they'll camp out in your apartment and monitor the traffic through your router to determine the actual criminal. They'll probably be there a few months since they'll want plenty of evidence and to determine if there's more than one, track the criminal's other activity, etc. If you bake them cookies every day they may only charge you with being an accessory and let you off with probation and community service; I suggest you use that time teaching others to secure their communications.

If you're willing to take that chance, leave your wireless connection unsecure. I'm still reasonably sure this violates the terms of service of your ISP. That's a case for civil court, not criminal, but that's one you don't stand a chance of winning and will only cost you money, not time.

by winthrop.polk

Yes, I would be perfectly happy to let the FBI in if they show me some evidence that proves my system is being used for kiddie porn. But lets move away from the kiddie porn argument. In the end, I will probably be required to creat a new or modify an existing bottom layer protocol to accomplish what I want. There is no reason I couldn't simply require people to register for an account.

by hal 9000

Is exactly what you don't want here isn't it?

After all if they register what's to stop a charge being applied latter?

And it's not only Kiddy Porn it's all Legal Instances just with Kiddy Porn the results against the person involved are fairly dramatic. But with the Patriotic Act that may no longer be the issue and you could have the Feds bust in and charge you before they even investigate anything.

After sitting in a Jail for 8 months or longer while they do the Investigation isn't much fun and much more importantly just how many do you honestly believe will believe that you are Innocent of the Crime after they release you?

Do you remember OJ?

The Law said he was Innocent but that is about the only group who claim to believe that. :0

Col

by winthrop.polk

However, I would really only be required to do what Comcast and AT&T do. People could still easy be anonymous. For example, when I call to set up service, they ask certain information such as address, name, etc. but never actually verify it with any form of ID. It's all usually done over the phone or internet. So, there is no reason people couldn't just give them false information. Now, this won't accomplish much if you?re setting it up at home since the address will be required to be valid to start the service and the address is linked to you. Perhaps it would work well if you had anonymous access to a for sale house or abandoned office complex, but you would still have to pay and this would only accomplish being anonymous. For this system, there is no central address requiring service installation so all information can be falsified if the user's primary goal is anonymity and is required to register. The only way he/she could be track is with triangulation.

Yes, there is the danger that this Idea will be stolen to make a profit rather than it's original intent. So I would prefer to stay away from registering requirements.

I have an idea that would add significant cost but, I think, would provide sufficient protection for me if something illegal happens on my network. What if I setup my own triangulation system and log where each transmission comes from. The user would of course be informed of this, and could move their location accordingly; but at least I have a record of where the transmission came from. This would probably only be required in the first stages of this system development when "they" will be watching me specifically for providing this loop whole service.

This is just an idea. Really though, they can't hold me to a higher standard than they do starbucks or any other free wifi provider. Starbucks undoubtedly has some security in regards to detecting kiddie porn words and preventing access to certain illegal sites. But even this can be overcome by use of a proxy and encryption. Any system can be hacked. I am 99% positive that some one somewhere has used these free wifi spots for illegal activity. I do not think that the owner would be held responsible.

Besides, I plan to access this system the same way everyone else does so their will be no distinction between them and me and I could not be held responsible. They could make it a pain in the @$$, but I don't think I would ever be convicted nor should I be.

by hal 9000

Like Starbucks are held responsible for what goes through their systems. So to that end they put in place a very advanced Security System to prevent any Illegal Content being Accessed.

The same applies to Corporate entities as well if someone downloads Illegal Material from the Net on their Systems the Corporation is Held Responsible and can be prosecuted. Though the chances of a Business being sent to Jail is remote but their Principals are responsible and the ones who will face any charges that arise, and they will certainly help the Authorities as much as possible to catch the offender but they will still wear a substantial Fine.

Many People have served or are serving time for Illegal Content being access through their Internet connection. Just because you have never heard of this doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

If you want proof of this walk into an Airport open your NB up connect to the Hot spot there and Google [b]Aircraft Bombs[/b] and see just how long you are left alone. It will not be very long.

Col

by winthrop.polk

True true. But the authorities who investigate such situations have to have the understanding the no computer system is ever secure. If starbucks provides free wifi but doesn't put any protections in place, then yes, they could be held responsible due to negligence. However, if they do implement security to the best of their ability, they shouldn't be held responsible. If they are really going to hold them responsible, they should really just outlaw the internet all together, since every access point is easily compromised by an outside user. If what you are saying is true, there are a lot of innocent people in prison and that's terrible. "Innocence is a term used to indicate a state of moral purity or general lack of guilt, with respect to any kind of crime, sin, or wrongdoing. Its antonym is corruption. In a legal context, innocence refers to the lack of guilt of an individual, with respect to a crime." I use the first definition here. There are many laws in this country that are unjust, but are still laws all the same. Most of them are not enforced. For example, it is currently illegal to spit on the ground in Dodge City Kansas and areas of Virgina (perhaps elsewhere to). The development of society?s laws is an evolutionary process, with many wrong turns and u-turns. Right and wrong has to be factored into the thought process, though it rarely is.

Definitely take a look at this:
http://www.idiotlaws.com/

http://www.idiotlaws.com/you-may-not-use-your-bathroom-if-the-window-is-open/
This one definitely shows that thought has to be put into the process.

By the way, it isn't illegal to search aircraft bomb in an airport, though I wouldn't be surprised if you end up in Guantanimo Bay within a day. I wouldn?t be surprise in the least if this post has already been flagged by the FBI simply for the key words it contains. Hi FBI guy! No malicious intent here. Just discussion. Go profile someone else and destroy there freedoms instead. But we still write. I am not willing to give up my freedoms. ?We hold these truths to be self evident??

by hal 9000

But just for your information the FBI doesn't monitor Telephony it lacks the resources and manpower to do this work. There is however another larger Organization in your country who does monitor all Telephony transactions across most of the world and then gives out reverent bits to interested parties.

I used to work for them many years ago so I have some small idea of what they actually do and how they do it.

Col

by winthrop.polk

Well, in terms of telephone communications probably not; but if they had the ability they would be allowed to under the patriot act. Heck, we know that most telephone corporations have already been forced to hand over phone lists; so they know who we call, but maybe not what we say. I can guarantee they are working on this type of software, perhaps using dictation software that can then be searched and sorted. But everything else including email, internet traffic and such, yes, I do think they monitor this. I think they monitored it before the patriot act; it was just illegal at that time. The sad part is that I doubt they are really intending these systems to be geared towards terrorists. They are intended to monitor law abiding citizens who might have dirt on politicians or large corporate entities and are put in place as a means of control. I mean really, do we think that terrorists wouldn?t be $m@rt enuff 2 cood there comms 2 b harder 2 search???? It?s obviously intended to monitor people who would not take this precaution because they don?t think they are going to be monitors since they aren?t terrorists.

by hal 9000

And it's not illegal in any way shape or form. This is not new and even when Digital Cell Phones where introduced they had to be delayed to allow the Listening Technology to be installed and set up correctly.

OH and BTW Telephony means any communication over Telephone Systems so that covers everything from Phone Calls to Electronic transmission and even 128 Bit Encrypted Software couldn't be introduced till the Governments of the World could read it if they wanted to.
This type of thing is always covered by Federal Law never State Law as it is the Federal Government who pays to run these listening posts. :D

Col

by oz_media

If teleco's were all regulated the same way, if all line cost thoughout the day remained a constant, if all systems were provided my a government run monopoly, if everyone in the world would jusy get along and not seek to harm one another, it's possible.

As the CO systems in the US and Canada are VERY different animals, it is not feasible. As Eruopean and Asian networks are also very different, it wouldn't work. You would need a global regulator/service provider, let me guess, a US company would need do that as they would be the only trustworthy ones in your/many opinions. However with deregulation less than 30 years old, it would be a terrible step back in time to $4.00 per minute overseas phone calls.

So who would manage and fix said shared lines generating far less revenue than before?

Who would bill for such lines and in what currency? Is this your new way of increasing value of the petrodollar again?

The gloal trading currency would become the broadbandollar?

And what part of globalization do you see as becoming independent internet access? Are you planning on buying out the railway companies worldwide that own a share of all fibre optics lines buried in terra nova (alongside THEIR railroads tracks of course)? Do you then cut out the nearly 40 companies that invested in TAT cables over the last 40 years?

And you think monthly costs are high now?

Nice joke anyway, but hardly anything to be actually considered or pondered, unless on acid.

by griffinwebnet

It almost sounds like what you are trying to achieve is similar to the way cell phones work. you have many high broadcasting Wireless towers sending signal, then you have each target device sitting there and pulling signal, often from more than one. its brilliant

by midnightdawn

A small group of people have joined together at a rare moment in the history of the World Wide Web and are about to put a theory very close to yours to the test. Using the existing IPv4 Private IP system in its final days to create a loop hole of about 16380 users who will have a semi-free internet connection. Wired or wireless, will not matter, as we will effectively creating a VLAN to stream information through a single usage port. (This system is currently used by EVERY state education facility [as in, every byte of information sent, to every single computer, on every single campus in the state, runs through one port Except of course they do not use VLANS {in most cases}])

This will effectively, profitably (for a short time to cover hardware costs), and perhaps revolutionarily create a mini-semi-free-ISP. I am not able to speak of too many of the details, but I would just like to reinvigorate this board by getting the word out there that this concept is being tested, and is (at the least) being concept tested.

by seanferd

It was a slow and painful death the first time around.

Someone is paying for the packets. There is no free.

by midnightdawn

A small group of people have joined together at a rare moment in the history of the World Wide Web and are about to put a theory very close to yours to the test. Using the existing IPv4 Private IP system in its final days to create a loop hole of about 16380 users who will have a semi-free internet connection. Wired or wireless, will not matter, as we will effectively creating a VLAN to stream information through a single usage port. (This system is currently used by EVERY state education facility [as in, every byte of information sent, to every single computer, on every single campus in the state, runs through one port Except of course they do not use VLANS {in most cases}])

This will effectively, profitably (for a short time to cover hardware costs), and perhaps revolutionarily create a mini-semi-free-ISP. I am not able to speak of too many of the details, but I would just like to reinvigorate this board by getting the word out there that this concept is being tested, and is (at the least) being introduced into the real world.

Also, sorry for the double post, I registered here to post on this board, and am still getting used to this forum....

by jdogtotherescue

i love the idea of giving away stuff for free because i like to take stuff for free. I'm on board for this idea mainly because i see it as we the people standing up and taking back control over our interests. we dont need our controllers help doing what we want. its time they step aside and let us do our own thing. its just too bad that we cant use cabling. I prefer a hard wired connection when i can have one because it is just more stable but if this free global wireless got to be a big enough thing it might be like the old days of sticking a tv antenna on your roof to pick up the news or whatever else was on. you have my hands in this project if it ever got going.

This discussion is closed to new replies.