1. America's growth proves tax cuts work. (false)
2. Any tax cut will therefore improve growth. (false)
3. Tax cuts actually create more tax revenue. (false)
I do not dispute that extreme high taxes on the investing and managerial classes will drive down national wealth. It makes sense as an argument, though the evidence of our actually measured economic performance doesn't support it very well. For example, the 1950s were a time of great American economic power and growth, maybe the greatest ever. And it all happened under a 91% top income tax rate. At the time, the rate on capital gains was exactly half the payer's income tax rate, so you can guess how popular it was to receive payment in kind rather than in salary. Also, at the time of high rates, tax shelter scams boomed like they never have since.
The country continued to boom, in fact achieved unprecedented wealth across all social classes, throughout the 1960s. This was despite a 70% federal income tax and a 35% capital gains tax for the top earners. (And that's not even counting LBJ's 10% surtax to pay for the Vietnam war.)
Laffer curve devotees point to Kennedy's measures first, but it's hard to say conclusively what impact tax cuts had. It was something popular to do during a recession. We boomed before the recession, we continued to boom after the recession, and in fact the recession ended before Kennedy's cuts took effect. Did we grow better because of a more rational tax policy? Probably, I think, but the evidence is unclear.
The Reagan tax cuts came at the end of a long period of stagnation and inflation, arguably caused by unbalanced government growth and deficit spending in the Johnson/Nixon years. Paul Voelker, chief of the Federal Reserve under Carter and Reagan, drove inflation out of the economy by raising interest rates to 16% and letting them fall gradually over eight years. (In 1980 I got a 30 year mortgage at 12%, and in 1981 I was able to sell the house at a substantial profit, simply because I let the buyers assume my mortgage. A new mortgage would have cost at least 16%.) The resulting economic slowdown drove millions of people out of work, but as inflation fell, interest rates fell with it, and people went back to work. Reagan showed up at this precise moment with his tax cut program. Did tax cuts cause prosperity, or was it all the other stuff? Don't forget that Reagan also ordered a huge increase in government spending, financed on borrowed money. (Look up "stimulus spending" in your political dictionary. It makes you popular!)
The Reagan years saw extraordinary growth, but the new national income was concentrated at the top. Everybody (i.e., workers) was producing more wealth, but the investors and managers were keeping it for themselves. It's not surprising that as median income stagnated and top earner income boomed, taxes would increasingly be harvested from those top earners. It's where all the new money was going. Between 1982 and 1998 Fortune 500 CEO pay increased ten fold. Were they managing their companies ten times better? You could argue that, given the opportunity to keep much more of what they got, they made sure nobody else got it. Is that really a case of greed producing a social good?
It still made sense to me to cut taxes, mostly because 70% still seemed weirdly high. Also, I worked with a guy using computer services to match wealthy people up with tax shelters; I saw that you wouldn't collect money from people who'd do anything to beat the tax man. A lot of money was going into bad investments, whose sole merit was they produced fictitious tax losses. That was bad for the economy. (Guess what Ronald Reagan's 1979 tax bill was? Zero. He invested as a limited partner in a herd of beef. The partnership borrowed a huge sum of money to feed the herd, which was instantly expensed, so that the value of the partnership dropped deep in the red. Reagan's tax loss, calculated at year end, was far larger than the money he invested. Of course, he got it all back in the next year, when the fattened herd was sold for a taxable gain, but taxes deferred is money you can use, and that means money in your pocket. News of his tax game was a mild embarassment during the election, but it didn't make Jimmy Carter any more popular.)
Reagan's tax cuts definitely did not pay for themselves during the Reagan presidency. Other accountants have proved this conclusively. Maybe the distortions in income distribution helped make them pay during the Clinton presidency. When the rich guys of 1999 had all the money in the country and were driving up the price of stock that they bought from each other, it resulted in huge capital gains taxes, even though the tax rate was fairly low. (Global Crossing! PetsDotCom! Nasdaq 4500! Woo hoo!) It looked like for the first time in 30 years the government would actually run a tax surplus. Bill Clinton talked about paying the national debt down to zero. Rich guys and the Wall Street Journal started finding fault with a tax cut that actually paid for itself; they were complaining that the proportion of national income going into taxes was never so high, using statistics that seemed to argue the case, if you didn't look closely. It was at this moment of grievous over-taxation, where billionaires could be imagined to be lining the sidewalks of Wall Street with begging bowls, just asking for the simple kindness to let them keep a little more (lots more, really) of what a prosperous nation made for them, that George W. Bush showed up, with his mix of cleverness, ineptitude, and dogma. He regarded the forecasts of multiple trillions of dollars of surplus (specious forecasts, it turned out) as an opportunity to cut taxes, to the benefit of people like him and of people who would donate cash to Republicans. With the help of a stock market disaster and a terrorist nightmare attack, he made that work. We staggered through the 2000's in a sick, laggard recovery, despite the tax cuts; apparently the wealthy were stimulated not to produce a booming economy, but a booming credit hoax instead, which left us in the most dangerous financial crisis since 1930.
The record isn't clear. If you were as creative with your statistics as Arthur Laffer, you could probably support an argument that every tax cut was PRECEDED by a period of superior growth and prosperity. (That's ridiculous, but you could argue it from selected statistics.) One result of tax cuts seems to be that income distribution is more skewed toward the rich than it was since 1929, or maybe even 1899. A lot has been going on in our society besides tax cuts that influenced prosperity and income, so nothing is as clear as ideologues, left and right, would like it to be.
Another Laffer falsehood, implied, is that maximizing tax income is the proper objective of government, just as maximizing profit is the goal of business. It's not. Taxing the most possible from an economy is not an optimizing strategy. You need to figure out what your country needs in the way of government services, and then provide them, and pay for them, whether that's best for the economy or not. An economy is only one aspect of society.
However, getting to Max's original questions, I have a few rules of thumb. I think everybody should pay federal income taxes, from the burger flipper to the billionaire. Sharing in the tax burden encourages one to feel responsible for the country. Too many are getting away with paying nothing, and the electorate is getting to think that voting themselves checks from somebody else's money is proper doctrine. I think that when the total of all federal and state taxes exceeds 50% of income, however high that income might be, it has become unjust. One should be able to keep at least half of what one makes. Probably that means a federal income tax rate not to exceed 40%. I think that tax cuts have a far less stimulative effect than straightforward, predictable, uncomplicated tax policy; loopholes and special breaks are a means of gaming the system, and induce unethical behavior. I don't think long-term capital gains should be taxed at a rate lower than income; that looks to me like government telling people how they should structure their investments. Government directed private investments are rarely sound, and do not represent the optimum use of money.
Of course, the last five years have shown us that privately directed capital can make a huge mess of things, too. Gotta stay careful, stay watchful of those rascals with their hands on all of society's wealth. It's one of the other things you need a government for!
(Edited to fix typos & improve continuity)