Discussion Locked

The time has come for maxwell edison to leave TR.

0 helpful
123 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

123 replies

by nentech

I am beginning to think you don?t like him :D

So tell us who told you about this discussion B-)

by steffi28

I'm going to ignore both of you from now on so :p there!!

I'll just go sit in the corner and cry :_|

(oh and Schwarzkopf)

by onbliss

The first reaction on reading that post was that somebody stole Max's password :-) I guessed he must have come from another thread after having a discussion with you :-) But the ideas represented the Max that I know @ TR. But his "STFU" was shocking especially when addressed to apotheon (another great contributor to this forum).

To be honest, I have reduced my reading any exchange between Max and you. Both of you just try to excel each other in needless insults. I often wanted to jump in and call a time out. But it was not my business. Since you created a thread, I have chosen to put in my 2 cents.

Max presence at TR is invaluable to me. His arguments have helped me in (re)checking, developing, (re)framing some of my thoughts, ideas & arguments. Of course I disagree with him, and sometimes find him unnecessarily rude. Sometimes his comments border on being troll-like-comments. All said and done, I have gained a lot watching and reading him.

My only distress is that Max and Neil seemed to have softened towards each other and I sense some kind of mutual respect blossoming into boring discussions :-) We need to keep those two on different sides, if you want to read some good arguments about say if the Sun should raise on the North or South!! Those two can come up some real good reasons in support of either or one of those directions.

So I urge everybody to keep Neil and Max at each other's throats :-) Any kind of instigation towards that end would be welcomed by me.

Max and you have lost respect towards each other. So maybe you guys should just reduce getting into each other's face.

by nentech

I promise not to go blonde :(

Even if blondes have more fun :D

So don?t take offence or a post or a gate :p

Now what was I talking about was it farming? ?:|

O dear wrong web site B-)

by jdclyde

You have no such right or reasonable expectation.

You CAN express yourself, but if you do so publicly you can expect to here about it from others around you, both the good and the bad.

Remember, they have free expression too.

There are some expressions that should be criticized at every turn.

by charliespencer

Don't post to his topics, and ignore him if he posts to yours. It's not that difficult.

apotheon's a big boy. I've never known him to have trouble defending himself. Max's post was a bit harsh, but appy's discussion-starter was surprisingly "pitiful me". I'd miss him if he left, but I'm not sure I understand his problem with the site.

by steffi28

I am still not talking to you :p

(If I were you I'd enjoy the silence while it lasts :p )

by w2ktechman

Oh, sorry... I had an evil streak!!!

Edited to add: Not my fault! Hal brainwashed me to say it! (suspicion anyway)

by hal 9000

Max had several hundred thousand Tech Points, well in excess of 400K if I remember correctly and was listed as a Gold Member and though no where near The Chas amount he was one of the top people here at TR.

I'm guessing that with the change and the fact that Max didn't see much use for Tech Points other than being able to offer 100K for a problem that you run into at work for a quick answer there is very little need for him to visit the Q&A section now that it's all been messed up.

From my prospective we seem to be getting hit with End User Questions, Students asking for step by step instructions on how to do something or people unable to do their jobs and expecting us to help them out while they get the money for our brain work. I can see why Maxwell wouldn't have much of an interest in the Q&A section any more.

Col

by midniteone

- and kindly stop slagging off us newbies.

I may be a mere user with pretensions to understanding the IT (and a boss who expects VFM out of the spreadsheets and databases at my disposal) but I joined up here to learn from the counsels of the mighty.

As such, I may occasionally chuck in an opinion or I may just read and digest. Or when you people are squabbling away in a cheap and nasty thread like this one, I can go looking for something more illuminating.

On the other hand, when I need help I ask for it and I make sure to acknowledge it when it's given. If I knew enough to help someone else I'd do it.

If some of you have been here long enough that you think you've heard all the questions before, fine. If you're overworked/overstressed etc., and don't have time to help someone out, then fine, I can well understand that. Just try and remember that you once knew as little as we do (I guess!) and don't (as you are in the above text) try and make us the scapegoat for someone else's ranting and raving. Whatever he is, good/bad/indifferent, I'd guess he was like it long before we came along.

by jdclyde

both to yourself and to Col.

That 666 next to his avatar (while clearly identifying his personality) is also the number of times he correctly answered a users question AND was given credit by the user. FYI, the average for answers NOT rated by the users is around 60%. That 666 is about 40% of the efforts he has given to users over the years, for free.

And there is a difference between getting stuck and needing a hand, and coming in and asking someone to spoon feed you the step-by-step answer so they can go back and look the hero.

I have been to many tech sites where your answer will be a link to a site for you to go read the answer yourself. People here go much further than that.

Next time get some information before offering a worthless opinion. An uninformed opinion is worse than no opinion.

by midniteone

- because that's not actually a fair representation of what I said.

(Deep breath) I have no criticism of Col (sorry to be personal but I'm looking at JDC's reply not the avatar) and whatever help he's given in the past (and didn't intende to make one) - he seems like a nice guy and I am more than willing to acknowledge what you say about him!

I don't even question the idea that un-named people may go for the easy option and poach the expertise of others because I've seen it done (I've been around a few years myself and it's not confined to the IT field either!)

I don't know many tech sites - strike that, I do, but they have been neither helpful nor memorable which is why I've wound up here - so I take your word on what you say about that.

On another occasion I might argue with your final sentence (there is a difference between opinions and facts and a variation in their relationship to the real world) but that would be getting into philosophy which is hardly the issue.

What I WAS trying to say is that

(a) I believe the original generalisation to be unfair (you may argue as you seem to have the same view of the current crop of questions)

(b) I can well understand that if that IS your perception then regardless of what you/he/they have done before then someone might get fed up with doing it, especially if they feel they're being taken advantage of (there is a sharper way of describing what they believe is being done to them but I don't want to end my short career here by being edited out!)and

(c) even it WAS to be a fair justification then it hardly gives an adequate argument for the original subject (maxwell?) to turn stroppy with all and sundry, which is the way I read the original post. Whatever either of them have done in the past, and Col seems to have weathered the storm with more grace and patience than maxwell, while making a significant contribution to the development and welfare of others, then losing patience/positivity/enthusiasm for it doesn't mean someone can turn around and lash out at everyone else.

Which I thought was the original subject of the thread.

There, end of response/explication. Someone will probably tell me I've got all the names wrong now. All I'm trying to do is put a 'newbie' 's point of view - it is possible to try and learn positively and not just leech off one's betters - whatever the rest of you may believe at this point. You are welcome to condemn me for naivety, but don't nail me for slagging off someone else's achievements when I did nothing of the kind.

by jdclyde

Sorry if the generic use of "you" had you thinking there was a bit target painted on your forehead.

I stand behind the last statement as intended, of getting to know the people before you comment on them.

Sandy and Max have had some angry words, and walking in half way through a fight and hearing one side is hardly giving you a good picture of either.

The two are very much alike in their tolerance for people that disagree with them, even if many of their political thoughts are polar opposites. You can see where this would be a mix like oil and water.

by hal 9000

OK maybe the above statement was too general in outlook but at the time I had just finished attempting to explain to someone that they need to know what to ask when they ask a question. If I remember correctly I had jut been hit with something like [i]I've got 2,000 square foot of floor space what Router do I need?[/i] as a question.

It's more than a bit vague and indecisive isn't it? Then at the same time someone claiming to be a LAN Admin asking for step by step directions for joining a computer to a domain. Neither of these questions are reasonable to ask and are just the tip of the Iceberg. While I really don't have a problem helping people when they are in genuine need I don't like feeling used either and those 2 questions are perfect examples of what is going wrong with TR now.

Once Upon A Time in a Galaxy Far Far Away we used to answer questions about Technical Issues and try to find solutions for people and at the same time learn something along the way. But now the Q&A Section seems to be predominately used by home users or end users who don't have a clue what they are talking about. This is fine if they say so and you can then try to word a reply in a manner that they can understand or in terms that are so general that they are easily understood.

Maybe it's just me but I'm getting sick & tied of answering a question to someone who claims that they are a professional only to be asked what a NB is, after they have asked a question about Lap Tops. :0

Or telling someone else that they don't need 2 routers on the one LAN as they will be isolating one part of the LAN from the rest and then spending time explaining what they are doing and also explaining that they are effectively creating a Child section on the LAN which isn't technically correct but is about the only term that comes close to what they are doing. These same people will then spend ages looking up a term like that but not look up the original question and then jump on you for misleading them. What I should have said is that this is exactly the same as creating a Child Domain but that would also be misleading when there are using a Peer to Peer LAN. Some people seem to think that they deserve an answer no matter what and to be lead step by step through a setup when they can not be bothered to tell you the Make & Models of things like Routers but somehow we are still supposed to know exactly what they require.

Things like this get a bit tiring and do cause quite a few people to walk away from the Q&A Section here and I really don't blame them for this. Then there are others who will repost a question 30 minutes after they originally posted the same question and expect an immediate answer because we have to answer their questions, at least that's how they feel and it's not right. The same people will look at the site activity and Peer Mail members of the top 10 asking questions directly as well believing that we are somehow responsible for answering their questions.

Generally speaking I don't mind helping when I can but I don't like being used and I don't think that anyone would be happy with a situation like that happening often.

The night before I made the above post I had received several E-Mails from someone here all about 30 minutes apart and the first one was a question which arrived here in AU around 3.00 AM then more demanding e-mails not requesting an immediate reply but demanding a reply now not when I'm awake or anything like that. This person wanted an answer now and to hell with what anyone else was doing. When I got up the next morning I sent off an answer and all I got in return was a complaint that it took so long to get an answer from me. I then made a mental note to block that particular sender and ignore them in the future.

But the ones that I really like are the people who ask a question in the Q&A Section then they want a better explanation so they Peer Mail me about something that I've said so I expand on the reply and forward it along only to have the message bounced because the E-Mail address that they are using doesn't exist. I'm not sure how TR qualifies these people for membership but it's more than a slight nuisance when it happens.

Anyway if you have any problem feel free to ask me if I can be of any assistance I will try to help you out as I don't have a problem with helping people in genuine need but as I've said above I don't like feeling used and quite a lot of what happens now is abuse of the system that was put in place to make life easier for people who needed help or wanted to ask a question of a delicate nature away from a Public Forum that is open to the world.

Cheers

Col

by tonythetiger

[i]You mean you don't mind if someone curses you in your face just because it's the only way he/she can do it ?[/i]

... we won't, on occasion, run across something we don't like. (If there were, what would happen on those days when you might not particularly like yourself?)

There's another quote that's relevant

"Life is 10% what happens to you and 90% how you react to it". - Charles Swindoll

by tonythetiger

That's just something used as an excuse by someone wanting to avoid personal responsibility for doing something they [b]wanted[/b] and [b]chose[/b] to do.

by midniteone

picked up both of your posts in quick succession, also had a pm giving me some of the context (and telling me, albeit subtly, I'm shooting from the hip again) - a bad habit and one I thought I'd got away from.

Having also tapped into a lot of history I get a better feel for all of this, and although I stand by some of my indignation on behalf of us technically challenged folk, I really hadn't got the whole Q&A thing in perspective.

Sorry guys, there's an old proverb that says 'measure twice, cut once' - just slipped my mind there for a while.

This discussion is closed to new replies.