25 replies
by kochikvp
Welcome to my World Wide Webquarters! I hope to make this a place where Business and Technology intersect with plain, good horse sense! Having been somewhat hopelessly opinionated all my life, I've finally found this great tool to snare hapless strangers into reading my views on just about every topic under the sun (and a few beyond). I'll unabashedly air my views on the challenges facing today's organizations, how technology impacts business and society, why people behave as they do,....ad infinitum*.
A wise soul has said that how much you benefit from what comes out of a horse depends on which end of it you are standing. Though I'm a late arrival on the blogging scene, I promise to make up for the lateness in diligence, prolificity - and.... yes, sheer equine intelligence.
So read on, hapless stranger, and may your tribe (and wisdom) increase!
______________________________________
* but not, it is hoped, ad nauseum!
by kochikvp
Corporate Icons...and longevity.
My first post is on a somewhat poignant note. The Economist, in its Feb 17th 2005 issue stated that Verizon?s buyout of MCI will result in a combined firm with sales of $90 billion. A couple of issues earlier the same magazine, in its superbly written article on AT&T?s changing fortunes had declared that the SBC-AT&T merger, with combined revenues of $70 billion, ?creates America's largest telecoms firm?. Looks like SBC got to rejoice for a whole two weeks.
More soberingly, this brings home the increasing rapidity with which things change in the technology industry ? AT&T?s reign as the big boy on the block had lasted several decades during the last century.
Another fallout from the imminent (?) demise of AT&T as an independent firm is the loss of a corporate icon - one of America?s greatest and most enduring. For that reason at least, let us hope that SBC-AT&T decides to badge itself as AT&T. Otherwise, AT&T will join a list of hallowed technology names that are now mere memories ? Digital, Sperry, Burroughs, Compaq,? The high-tech industry sure is no place to be sentimental.
by kochikvp
The End of Corporate Computing and other Fables
Nicholas Carr is back and at his contrarian best with The End of Corporate Computing in this Spring's MIT Sloan Review*. He posits that Information Technology (IT) is in transition: from an asset owned and hosted by corporations for their own use, to a utility that is supplied centrally by specialized companies. His argument takes the concept of utility computing to its logical extreme, and holds that the corporate data center will go the way of the dodo.
Nick is wonderfully eloquent, and his argumentative skills are admirable. His case would have been very persuasive, had it been based more solidly in reality. As with his earlier article IT Doesn't Matter, he overstates his case here too. Business software often automates complex and firm-specific business processes, and does not easily lend itself to centralization with a utility supplier. It is difficult to imagine a car factory carrying out its manufacturing planning or control thru a subscribed utility, or an investment bank performing securities analysis on a vendor's computer sitting hundreds of miles away. The author's vision may, however be seen as providing a general direction in which computing will evolve.
Summing up, the horse sense view is: It appears far-fetched to state that utility computing will render the conventional model of each firm hosting its own IT applications extinct, or even that it will become the dominant mode of IT use in corporations. Utility computing may gain traction over the next few years for applications that are not highly firm-specific, where business-criticality and security requirements are moderate / low, and where speed of response is not highly material.
_____________________________________________
* Francis Fukuyama's epochal The End of History seems to have caught everybody's imagination so much that it has spawned an entire genre that is going strong even 15 years on! I remember lapping it up the article as a young, gawky research scholar, and the furore that followed it's publication!
by kochikvp
Blogging's Future: Up, Up and Away?
Beyond a doubt, blogging has a bright future. It's tempting to get carried away by all the exuberance being generated.
Bill Gates says blogging "will fundamentally change how we document our lives". Technorati's CEO David Sifry says that there are 11 blog posts being made every second!
While this may well be true, we must resist the temptation to get carried away. Let's analyze blogging's prospects as a 'personal technology', or a technology that individuals use to improve their effectiveness or productivity, or simply to have fun.
All successful personal technologies that gain widespread use (be it the humble pen, the telephone or the iPod), bear certain hallmarks: they are easy to use, fulfil a basic need, and provide a new way to express an existing behavior or habit. Technologies that make the cut on these three respects tend to 'take-off', with their use surging steeply*.
Blogging certainly fulfils a basic need, the need for self-expression and social interaction. It is also more powerful in many respects than other technologies that meet similar needs - the telephone, email or online chatting - in that it is more 'permanent', and allows visibility to anyone who can access the Web. It also provides a new way to exercise our natural propensity to form groups with like-minded folks, by allowing us to form 'virtual communities' on the Web. It also allows people to 'discover' others with similar tastes, wherever they may be in the world.
Well, that leaves ease of use. I am afraid blogging is somewhat less stellar in this respect - while it is simpler than creating personal Web pages, it still lags far behind the telephone and email in ease of use. So, ease of use is the first thing that needs to improve about blogs (I hope the blog tool-makers are listening).
If one is tempted to argue that blogging is already very successful, one only needs to pause to consider the numbers: by most estimates there are around 80 million blogs in the world as of today, while the number of telephones world-wide (fixed-line and mobile) is around 2 billion. This is not to take anything away from the success of blogging, but only to establish (an admittedly somewhat crude) benchmark!
However, we've looked at only half the picture so far - becoming successful. Success brings its own problems, and sure enough, blogging too will need to overcome a couple of challenges that success brings with it:
Better ways to manage 'blog clutter'.
Even with the current number of blogs out there, it is becoming difficult for people to navigate the blogosphere. Telephones or email don't need to solve this problem as they are 'push' technologies, which means that you *want* to restrict who can contact you using these technologies. However, if blogs are to truly live up to their promise of allowing the 'discovery' of like-minded folks, then blog search engines should (and will) get smarter.
Search is of course not the only way to manage clutter - for example, Business Week's Heather Green talks about creating 'influential blogger' lists.
Blogging needs to find ways to enable diverse communication needs
Blogging tools already do a half-decent job of allowing the sharing of digital content. However, as camera phones proliferate, sharing pictures and movies will increasingly become mainstream. Also blogging from heterogenous devices (phones and home appliances come to mind) is likely to need support.
Of course, this piece only addresses blogging as a 'personal technology'. Analysis of its prospects in business - which are fledgling at the moment - is the subject of a different discussion altogether!
_______________
*This is driven by Metcalfe's Law, which holds that the usefulness of something increases exponentially as the number of users goes up.
by kochikvp
Excitement in the Ether
An intriguing suggestion (dismissed as a rumor by Nokia) has appeared over the weekend - that Cisco is eyeing an acquisition of Nokia, evidently driven by a desire to strengthen its wireless infrastructure business. At a superficial level, this sounds plausible - companies worldwide have amassed unprecedented cash hoards (see, for example, The Economist and Business Week), due in part to central bankers' generosity in keeping real interest rates at historic lows, and we can well expect to see a rash of acquisitions in the near future. Also, Cisco certainly is one of the cash-rich giants around, and has amply proven its acquistion credentials.
However, we must pause and ask, how much business sense does this make? As Marek Pawlowski points out, Nokia's business is in making handsets more than wireless networking equipment, and Cisco will be hard put to rationalize buying all of Nokia just to get its wireless infrastructure manufacturing business.
Neither does such a deal appear to make a lot of sense for Nokia, which does not strike me as an overly enthusiastic acquisition target - at 34% of the world market, its handsets outsell those of the nearest competitor (Motorola/Samsung) by 2 to 1. And that is hardly a market that is shrinking - worldwide handset shipments are likely to double over the next 5 years to 1.2 billion.
The backdrop is not very promising either - recent megamergers in the tech space have hardly been stellar. HP / Compaq and AOL / Time Warner come to mind.
And given the size of the deal, even a veteran with Cisco's admittedly high 'Acquisition Quotient' is likely to be overreaching with this buy.
by kochikvp
Blogging: Just How Much of a Phenomenon?
Towards a measure for the success of blogging
In a previous post , I talked about bloggings future. Here we will try and arrive at a measure" for how successful blogging has become, and how much more it is capable of achieving.
It is pertinent to note that we are not talking about measuring the success of a specific blog, but of blogging as a phenomenon.
Before tackling the admittedly difficult question of measuring its success, lets pause and ask, What is blogging? At one level, it is a tool which individuals use for communication and self-expression. Indeed, this was the only use conceived initially. As its usage soared, it also emerged as a tool for on-line 'communities' to interact and disseminate news or useful information. The most recent emerging use (completely unanticipated in the early years of blogging's existence) is for commercial organizations to interact with various stakeholders.
Thus, a reasonably general definition of blogging would appear to be, a technology that lends itself for use by individuals, communities or organizations as a means of communication, information dissemination or interaction.
How do we go about establishing a measure of the success of anything? One way is to identify its "potential", and measure what proportion of that potential has been achieved. For example, if your company sells flat-panel TVs, the potential market would probably be equal to the number of households in the world having a household income of more than a certain figure. If you are trying to popularize a new 'world language' that you have invented, the potential probably corresponds to every human in the world speaking the language. If you sell beer, the potential sales would probably correspond to each adult in the world drinking 150 liters a year!*
However, it is frequently difficult to assess potential in this manner. A surrogate, more practical approach would be to identify the 'best' achieved by anybody so far. If you are an athlete, your 'best achievable' may be the current world record in your event. In the TV example above, the best achievable may be the sales volume achieved by the market-leading company.
Thus, the problem reduces to discovering the 'best achievable' usage of blogging. To do this, we must stretch our imagination a bit and ask, what are the "best" technologies** that meet roughly the same needs that blogging does, and what is the usage they have achieved? The best technologies we have that allow communication, information dissemination or interaction are probably telephones, email, and conventional web sites.
The number of telephone lines (fixed and mobile) in the world is estimated at around 2.1 billion. Similarly, the number of email users is in the region of 600 million.
How many websites exist in the world? Yahoo indexes 19 billion web pages, while Google indexes about 9 billion. Taking the smaller of the two, and assuming the average website has around 20 pages, the number of websites may be approximated as about 500 million.
Lets be conservative, taking the smallest of the 3 figures (for telephones, email users and websites) which is 500 million. To be play it even safer, let us assume that many websites represent uses that blogs just cannot. So let us say that the figure of 500 million overstates the figure we are looking for by 90%. This leaves 250 million (assuming many websites are defunct, etc.). It appears safe to say that this represents the usage that blogging must achieve. Thus, the best achievable number of blogs is, at the very least, 250 million. The current number of around 80 million thus suggests that blogging has covered about a third of the distance to its best achievable usage.
Of course, we will be shortchanging blogging if we end this analysis without considering time frames. While telephones have taken 20+ years to reach their current usage (counting only from the time mobile phones were invented), email has taken 15+ years, and the web 10+ years, blogging has been around only 6 years or so.
To dwell a bit on how technologies evolve over time, let us look at an elegant concept, the 'S' curve. What this says, very simply, is that every technology has an initial period during which it grows very slowly. As it improves and gains usage, it crosses an 'inflexion point', beyond which growth takes off rapidly***. Further down, the technology reaches a maturity stage where growth once again slackens. Metcalfe's Law, which holds that the usefulness of something goes up exponentially with the number of its users, applies during the high growth section.
Thus, in S- curve terms, blogging can be thought of as having crossed the inflexion point, and being about 30% of the way to the peak. In other words, 70% of its potential is yet to be achieved.
______________________________________________________
* If that sounds high, the Czech are reputed to drink 167 liters per capita per year!
** As is clear from the context, we use best not as an indicator of quality but to mean the one that has achieved the greatest or most widespread use.
*** Not all technologies, of course, actually cross the inflexion point - many (indeed, most) die out well before they reach that point.
by kochikvp
Surging Profits, Booming Markets
(...and Frowning Prophets?!)
Or, Is It All Too Good To Last?
Companies all over the world have been seeing bumper profits over the last year. The Economist reports that corporate profits have been outpacing GDP growth on both sides of the Atlantic, as well as in the Asia-Pacific. Business Week informs us that companies all over have surpassed profit growth expectations, and are flush with over a trillion dollars in cash. Technology companies are especially doing well - Microsoft, Dell, Intel, Oracle alone have amassed large surpluses.
What factors have led to this? Outsourcing to cheaper destinations is producing savings that go straight to the bottomline. Low-cost goods and services from China and India are keeping inflation low, freeing up spending money in consumers' hands which shows up as increased demand for all types of products that companies sell. Better use of technology is helping too, as companies have got smarter and more finicky about how well they use technology.
Meanwhile, the China-India effect* is helping produce some related, and largely pleasant, macroeconomic developments:
- the low inflation, caused by these countries "exporting deflation", is also keeping interest rates low worldwide
- thanks to more money in consumers' hands and low interest rates, people are investing in asset-building with renewed vigor - particularly in stocks and houses
- this in turn is leading to steep rises in asset prices and, most economists agree, asset price bubbles in most countries
- the resulting 'wealth effect' (people feel richer as their stock portfolios and real estate values shoot up) is further spurring consumer spending, as people spend more when they feel wealthier!
Can this last, and what can go wrong? This is admittedly a happy state of affairs. But while profits and asset prices are soaring, some worries are rising too.
- the asset price bubble can burst (or at least deflate)
- continued sluggishness and job growth stagnation in the EU countries can drag down world GDP growth
- economic policy responses from Governments need to be right (low-cost products can keep inflation low only in the short term - in the long term, only macroeconomic policy matters)
- consumer spending may slowdown in the US, the current engine of growth
- resistance to outsourcing can build up (on grounds of job losses, security concerns,...)
- worrisome or cataclysmic geopolitical events can happen (such as energy supply volatility, terrorism, nuclear arsenal buildup etc.)
- imbalances have been accumulating in the world economy, setting up stresses which may get released in unexpected ways and at unexpected times. (China's recent devaluation of the Yuan, although widely criticized as too little and too late, is a welcome step towards reducing one such imbalance). However even Alan Greenspan, that doyen of economic prophets, has admitted that there are forces at work in the world economy that we do not fully understand. Indian Finance Minister P Chidambaram said last week that he would be "worried" if the Bombay Stock Exchange's key Sensex did not stop its rampaging rise soon (the market duly lost some of its ardor).
If anything, all of this shows the world of business and economics has been changing - and so far, the positive effects outnumber the negatives. In general, history teaches that happy positive cycles such as the above tend to be fragile (and often too good to be true). This one looks robust, but how long it can last, only time will tell. Meanwhile, let us hope that we do all the right things to prolong the boom as long as possible, and cushion the fall when it comes.
_______________________________________________________________________________
* The China-India buzz has been getting hotter. Business Week ran a cover story on the two countries recently. Business Week's Mike Mandel is also addressing the question of how the US should perceive the two countries' ascendant R&D prowess.
by kochikvp
An Informed Technology Consumer Be
What is the link between Information Technology and productivity?
Information Technology's beneficial effects on business are myriad. It has not only enabled mightily successful businesses such as ebay, Amazon and Yahoo!, but has allowed us to discover and take advantage of amazing phenomena such as the "Long Tail", first posited by Chris Andersen of Wired magazine.
However, let's focus on a pointed question: how much, if at all, has information technology (IT) contributed to the productivity of businesses? Productivity is the efficiency with which output is produced by a given set of inputs - so, for example, if the productivity of a bus factory is increasing, it means the factory is able to crank out more buses per worker (or per hour or per dollar). IT's effect on productivity has been a matter of considerable debate, both academic and popular.
Before answering this question, let us ask, What is technology?* The most general definition is, "the sum total of knowledge, skills, techniques and tools available to humankind". Defined in this way, it is hardly surprising that technology should boost productivity - that is merely another way of saying that better knowledge, skill and so forth improves our ability to squeeze more output from whatever we put in. In fact, this has been true since the stone age (if not earlier)!
Of course, here we are restricting ourselves to Information Technology, which we may define (specializing the above) as, "the application of knowledge, skills, techniques and tools to create, store and use information". By common understanding, IT includes computing, networking and communication technologies. Let's examine some evidence.
A paper by the Research and Market Analysis group of the New York Federal Reserve finds that productivity did increase across US industries during 1995-99** in comparison to the previous 5 years, and while the entire gain in productivity could not be attributed to techology, there was a "robust link" between the two (these US Fed folks have a wonderful penchant for using the right word - I am a great admirer of the language they use!).
Business Week's Michael Mandel sees the unmistakable hand of technology in the strong growth of US multifactor productivity in the last two years. A study by the McKinsey Global Institute is more circumspect, concluding that IT boosts productivity, but only when tailored to an organization's business processes. It also discovers that innovation is a strong driver of productivity growth, and IT boosts productivity to the extent that it enables this innovation. MIT Sloan School's Professor Erik Brynjolfsson finds that the amount of IT used in a company correlates well with it's overall productivity, and notes an emerging agreement among economists that "IT has been the biggest single factor driving the productivity resurgence, although debate continues about the exact magnitude of its contribution". He cautions that IT helps only when combined with judicious, complementary investments. Christopher Koch of CIO magazine echoes this cautious sentiment.
Taking another tack, outsourcing, which has enabled companies to achieve the same output with fewer inputs (of labor, primarily), is itself strongly facilitated by IT - both because automated business processes are more amenable to being done remotely, and because the outsourcing itself is carried out using networking and communication technologies. Here too, the experience is replete with admonitions to the effect that outsourcing realises its avowed benefits only when done judiciously, with a strategic perspective.
So, the answer to our question is: IT has certainly been a strong (if not the strongest) driver of productivity growth in business. However (and such conclusions usually include a 'however'!), IT really delivers benefits only when integrated well into the organization's business context and processes. As with anything else, it helps to be an informed buyer.
________________________________________________________
* In keeping with the "horse sense" tradition, we revisit the basics.
** Given the amount of data such studies need to ferret out and crunch, detailed analyses of productivity gains tend to come only with a lag of a few years.
by kochikvp
Apple of our iPods
I am not normally inclined to write about the achievements of individuals - less so in eulogizing terms, and even less so when they are alive. Neither am I particularly enamoured of the Apple breed of computers or the iPod, having hardly used either.
However, there comes a time when exceptions to general rules must be made, and this is such a time. Beyond a doubt, one of the most amazing - and inspiring - tales in the annals of the technology industry is that of Steve Jobs. Let me hasten to add that I know almost nothing of him as a person - for all I know, he may be cold, aloof and unfriendly (and perhaps he even snores!). However, I do not care about those things - based on the public record of his achievements alone, he is clearly one of the most incredible role models for anyone with more than a passing interest in technology.
Let's count the ways. He pioneered an entire industry (Personal Computers), started a very successful company (Apple), actually managed to get thrown out of the very company he started (surely a feat achieved by the rarest few!), and then started another pioneering company (Pixar). He then proceeded to make a comeback to Apple more than a decade later, battled and defeated cancer, and then refashioned Apple, which many had written off, all over again into a powerhouse of innovation.
Busi
ness Week reports that today, "Apple makes wildly imaginative products with a consistency few companies rival".
My favorite part of this story is of course, the history of how Apple started. Steve Wozniak and Jobs's garage-to-riches story is now the stuff of legend. These guys had, between them, the foresight to realize that there would indeed be a market for low-cost personal computers (virtually unknown at the time), the technical wizardry to create a working PC, and the business acumen to build an industry. Along the way, they pioneered some of the most well-known concepts in personal computing.
A window into his life which is both poignant and revealing is this year's commencement address he gave at Stanford University - Stay Hungry, Stay Foolish. Reading the transcript, we realize why getting evicted from the company he founded didn't faze him one bit, as none other than his own mother had rejected him (and even before he was born, to boot!). We see the beginnings of his business acumen, in that he managed to survive with virtually no income after dropping out of college. We note his incredible ability to live the hard life - he used to get one good meal a week, and only by walking 7 miles to the Hare Krishna temple. He even talks about the lessons that getting fired from his own company taught him! His near-death brush with cancer is recounted.
As with many other people who were legends in their lifetime, we see an ability to compress many lifetimes into one.
by kochikvp
Oracle's Strategy: Shrink-SAPped Software?
Oracle's acquisition binge sets up a two-horse race in the packaged software business
As I noted in an earlier post, mergers are happening at a breakneck pace, particularly in the technology space, where the coffers are overflowing. Oracle's Siebel buyout is the latest big-ticket deal. As with the PeopleSoft buy, this deal marks a home-coming of sorts (both PeopleSoft and Siebel were started by ex-Oracle execs).
With this string of acquisitions, Oracle has emerged as a behemoth in the business, and is increasingly positioned to combat Germany's SAP, the industry leader. This business is thus increasingly turning into a two-horse race (IBM does not play in this space, while Microsoft appears content to be a bit player (although it considered acquiring SAP at one time).
For its part, SAP appears unruffled for now. SAP CEO Henning Kagermann says in
Business Week
that this as a desperate (and futile) catch-up strategy by Larry Ellison. And he mayhave a point. Oracle has just bought up a complex set of offerings, with conflicting and overlapping features and technologies. It has a big challenge on its hands figuring out how to integrate them, and may not necessarily get them all to work well together. In the meanwhile, unless Oracle provides clarity on what its future porfolio is going to look like (something it hasn't yet done), existing and potential customers are going to be jittery, wondering if what they have bought, or are planning to buy, will be discontinued. Strategically too, Oracle will be preoccupied for a while with its internal integration issues. SAP, on the other hand, has a better chance of being seen as consistent and coherent in its strategy.
Consolidation in the enterprise packaged software business has been driven primarily by - apart from overflowing money bins - the fact that customers are tiring of the "best of breed" (often euphemism for a mongrel!) approach, and expect a single vendor to take full responsibility for their entire IT applications portfolio. Another driver is the big players' hunger for revenue growth. A notable irony is that during the 1990s the packaged enterprise software business (then called ERP), was widely expected to replace custom, or bespoke application development. The acquisitions suggest the opposite - they seem to bear out Peter Drucker's classic observation that acquisitions are a sign of an industry in search of growth.
The IT landscape thus continues to churn, and not just with acquisitions. China is making its presence felt (the IBM - Lenovo deal), and so is India, with its offshore powerhouses. Neither are all the acquisitions blockbusters - there are smaller, less noticed ones too, such as Seagate's buyout of Mirra.
There may be a pattern to all the churn. The entire IT industry appears headed towards what
The Economist
referred to sometime back as the platform wars. As customers increasingly look for vendors who can take responsibility for the entire IT portfolio, they choose to rally round big players ? interestingly, this seems a bit like a return to the old days of proprietary, closed computing platforms, albeit with a different reason - the need for fewer integration headaches.
In this great end-game, four big industry players - IBM, Microsoft, Oracle and SAP - seem destined to be the stars, with everyone else assigned bit roles. Will it really pan out this way, and who will win?
by kochikvp
by kochikvp
Blogging: Just How Much of a Phenomenon?
Towards a measure for the success of blogging
In a previous post , I talked about blogging?s future. Here we will try and arrive at a ?measure" for how successful blogging has become, and how much more it is capable of achieving.
It is pertinent to note that we are not talking about measuring the success of a specific blog, but of blogging as a phenomenon.
Before tackling the admittedly difficult question of measuring its success, let?s pause and ask,
What is blogging?
At one level, it is a tool which individuals use for communication and self-expression. Indeed, this was the only use conceived initially. As its usage soared, it also emerged as a tool for on-line 'communities' to interact and disseminate news or useful information. The most recent emerging use (completely unanticipated in the early years of blogging's existence) is for commercial organizations to interact with various stakeholders.
Thus, a reasonably general definition of blogging would appear to be, a technology that lends itself for use by individuals, communities or organizations as a means of communication, information dissemination or interaction.
How do we go about establishing a measure of the success of anything? One way is to identify its "potential", and measure what proportion of that potential has been achieved. For example, if your company sells flat-panel TVs, the potential market would probably be equal to the number of households in the world having a household income of more than a certain figure. If you are trying to popularize a new 'world language' that you have invented, the potential probably corresponds to every human in the world speaking the language. If you sell beer, the potential sales would probably correspond to each adult in the world drinking 150 liters a year!*
However, it is frequently difficult to assess potential in this manner. A surrogate, more practical approach would be to identify the 'best' achieved by anybody so far. If you are an athlete, your 'best achievable' may be the current world record in your event. In the TV example above, the ?best achievable? may be the sales volume achieved by the market-leading company.
Thus, the problem reduces to discovering the 'best achievable' usage of blogging. To do this, we must stretch our imagination a bit and ask, what are the "best" technologies** that meet roughly the same needs that blogging does, and what is the usage they have achieved? The ?best? technologies we have that allow communication, information dissemination or interaction are probably telephones, email, and conventional web sites.
The number of telephone lines (fixed and mobile) in the world is estimated at around 2.1 billion. Similarly, the number of email users is in the region of 600 million.
How many websites exist in the world? Yahoo indexes 19 billion web pages, while Google indexes about 9 billion. Taking the smaller of the two, and assuming the average website has around 20 pages, the number of websites may be approximated as about 500 million.
Let?s be conservative, taking the smallest of the 3 figures (for telephones, email users and websites) which is 500 million. To be play it even safer, let us assume that many websites represent uses that blogs just cannot. So let us say that the figure of 500 million overstates the figure we are looking for by 90%. This leaves 250 million (assuming many websites are defunct, etc.). It appears safe to say that this represents the usage that blogging must achieve. Thus, the ?best achievable? number of blogs is, at the very least, 250 million. The current number of around 80 million thus suggests that blogging has covered about a third of the distance to its ?best achievable? usage.
Of course, we will be shortchanging blogging if we end this analysis without considering time frames. While telephones have taken 20+ years to reach their current usage (counting only from the time mobile phones were invented), email has taken 15+ years, and the web 10+ years, blogging has been around only 6 years or so.
To dwell a bit on how technologies evolve over time, let us look at an elegant concept, the 'S' curve. What this says, very simply, is that every technology has an initial period during which it grows very slowly. As it improves and gains usage, it crosses an 'inflexion point', beyond which growth takes off rapidly***. Further down, the technology reaches a maturity stage where growth once again slackens. Metcalfe's Law, which holds that the usefulness of something goes up exponentially with the number of its users, applies during the high growth section.
Thus, in S- curve terms, blogging can be thought of as having crossed the inflexion point, and being about 30% of the way to the peak. In other words, 70% of its potential is yet to be achieved.
______________________________________________________
* If that sounds high, the Czech are reputed to drink 167 liters per capita per year!
** As is clear from the context, we use ?best? not as an indicator of quality but to mean ?the one that has achieved the greatest or most widespread use?.
*** Not all technologies, of course, actually cross the inflexion point - many (indeed, most) die out well before they reach that point.
by kochikvp
An Enlightening Initiative from IBM
IBM's program to help science education is an object lesson to the tech industry at large, but perhaps conceals an inadvertent irony.
Many have decried the declining trend of math and science education, and have sounded dire warnings that the technology industry will grind to a halt if something is not done about it. Luckily, some are now putting their money where their mouths are.
IBM has this week begun a program that supports its employees in the US who want to transition into science teaching. The new program, says MSNBC, "reflects tech industry fears that U.S. students are falling behind peers from Bangalore to Beijing in the sciences". Of course, IBM is not the first to act. Microsoft has an "Innovative Teachers" professional development program, which includes $50 million in software grants for educational institutions.
Not surprisingly, these two companies also rank at the top of the most favored places to work in the tech industry. Perhaps it just goes to show that comapanies that take an enlightened approach to their role in society take an enlightened approach to their employees as well. Stanley Litow, head of the IBM Foundation, says that many other companies are watching keenly and may follow suit.
Such programs are particularly valuable as the US tech industry is clearly down from its halcyon days of untrammeled growth - starting salaries for college graduates have shown marked declines between 2001-05, the biggest decline being in Electrical and Computer Science & Engineering.
But where's the irony? Litow's comment that "Over a quarter-million math and science teachers are needed, and it's hard to tell where the pipeline is", got me thinking. Perhaps the pipeline is precisely in those locations which the US is concerned about being overtaken by!
Think about it. It is now possible for students in the US being taught online by tutors sitting in Bangalore or Manila. And it's already happening. And given the obvious pecuniary advantages, it is not unlikely that teachers in these countries would gravitate to such an occupation in larger numbers.
The irony is that, it is not inconceivable that in the near future, outsourcing destinations for tech jobs such as India may find their growth stifled by a scarcity of high quality tech graduates. This scarcity will be caused in good measure by good science teachers being preoccupied with training students overseas. And what will allow the teachers to thus divert their skills? The same technology and forces of globalization that drove the offshoring of jobs from the West, and created demand for tech jobs in India in the first place! Now, why do I have the feeling that this is not the last irony that this new, globablized world is going to serve up?
by kochikvp
An Enlightening Initiative from IBM
IBM's program to help science education is an object lesson to the tech industry at large, but perhaps conceals an inadvertent irony.
Many have decried the declining trend of math and science education, and have sounded dire warnings that the technology industry will grind to a halt if something is not done about it. Luckily, some are now putting their money where their mouths are.
IBM has this week begun a program that supports its employees in the US who want to transition into science teaching. The new program, says MSNBC, "reflects tech industry fears that U.S. students are falling behind peers from Bangalore to Beijing in the sciences". Of course, IBM is not the first to act. Microsoft has an "Innovative Teachers" professional development program, which includes $50 million in software grants for educational institutions.
Not surprisingly, these two companies also rank at the top of the most favored places to work in the tech industry. Perhaps it just goes to show that comapanies that take an enlightened approach to their role in society take an enlightened approach to their employees as well. Stanley Litow, head of the IBM Foundation, says that many other companies are watching keenly and may follow suit.
Such programs are particularly valuable as the US tech industry is clearly down from its halcyon days of untrammeled growth - starting salaries for college graduates have shown marked declines between 2001-05, the biggest decline being in Electrical and Computer Science & Engineering.
But where's the irony? Litow's comment that "Over a quarter-million math and science teachers are needed, and it's hard to tell where the pipeline is", got me thinking. Perhaps the pipeline is precisely in those locations which the US is concerned about being overtaken by!
Think about it. It is now possible for students in the US being taught online by tutors sitting in Bangalore or Manila. And it's already happening. And given the obvious pecuniary advantages, it is not unlikely that teachers in these countries would gravitate to such an occupation in larger numbers.
The irony is that, it is not inconceivable that in the near future, outsourcing destinations for tech jobs such as India may find their growth stifled by a scarcity of high quality tech graduates. This scarcity will be caused in good measure by good science teachers being preoccupied with training students overseas. And what will allow the teachers to thus divert their skills? The same technology and forces of globalization that drove the offshoring of jobs from the West, and created demand for tech jobs in India in the first place! Now, why do I have the feeling that this is not the last irony that this new, globablized world is going to serve up?
by kochikvp
eBay's Skype buy: Not Just a Recipe for Hype....
Does this deal signal the next logical step in the evolution of ecommerce?
Even as the dust settles on eBay's purchase of Skype, there is considerable befuddlement among analysts and observers as to the strategic motivation behind the buy. The consternation arises not only from what people see as an apparent lack of synergy between online auctions and IP telephony, but also from the seemingly exorbitant price paid - upto $4.1 Billion. Some may be tempted to wonder whether eBay hasn't landed itself with a winner's curse!*.
Surprising as the deal initially appeared, a semblance of rationale is beginning to emerge. For one thing, this deal is entirely consistent with eBay's aspirations of being one of the internet honchos, along with Amazon, Yahoo and Google.
More fundamentally, it may be the logical next step in the evolution of ecommerce. How?
- By allowing buyers and sellers to communicate instantly, an integrated eBay-Skype platform could smoothen buyer-seller interaction which is a critical component for ecommerce.
- By allowing real-time, synchronous online auctions ? these would be just like regular auctions where aspiring buyers attempt to outbid each other, with one difference ? the bidders may be sitting in different continents and bidding via telephones / videoconferencing equipment. Achieving this using conventional telephony is prohibitively expensive, but costs virtually nothing using VoIP.
eBay hasn't said this is in the roadmap, but it appears likely.
____________________________________________________
* defined by the wikipedia as a phenomenon that occurs in auctions, where the person who bids the highest frequently ends up paying a price that is more than the "true" value (or at least worries that he has done so). People have researched the winner's curse phenomenon in eBay auctions.
by kochikvp
A Hazy Picture for Home Entertainment
Sadly, sometimes the price of technological innovation is confusion
There is perhaps no aspect of life where technological innovation is set to produce more flux than the home entertainment space. And I'm not talking about the video iPod. I'm talking about how the humble home has become the battleground in the fight between all the behemoths of hte technology and entertainment industry. And all because of the blazing speed of technological innovation.
Cable service providers are getting into providing telephony, and telecom service providers are in turn getting into TV-over -IP (or IPTV). BusinessWeek writes that "The new holy grail of the communications industry is the triple play: the ability to offer customers data, video, and voice".
In the broader home entertainment space, competing visions have emerged. Computer industry stalwarts such as Microsoft and Intel are pitching a scenario where the PC will be the entertainment hub which will house, and control the flow of, all content such as songs, films and TV programs. Media and content companies such as recording companies, film and TV studios are recalcitrant about such a picture, as they foresee large-scale piracy and potential loss of revenue from content. They would like to see content being housed on disks, as it is today, with plenty of technological bells and whistles to ensure that it is not pirated.
The real battle that is assuming Armageddon-like proportions is one that has all the giants of the technology and entertainment industry arrayed: the DVD wars. This pits Sony's Blu-Ray format in one corner with Toshiba's HD-DVD format in the other. This battle royale is for who will control the next generation DVD format. At stake, aside from multi-billion dollar revenues, is nothing short of the future of Sony and Toshiba as powerful players in the electronics space, and perhaps that of Microsoft and Intel as potential rulers in this space.
In the midst of it all, of course, and quite forgotten, is the hapless consumer. Can you imagine the fate of the poor bloke who plonks down his hard-earned cash (or credit!) to buy a player supporting the format that will end up on the losing side of this battle? At all costs, all the companies concerned must ensure that only one standard makes it to market.
For consumers, the advice is: unless you are a pioneer, or 'early adopter', and willing to risk being saddled with potentially useless devices, wait until there is more clarity in this space before you make any investment
by kochikvp
VoIP and Valhalla
A true "killer-app" in the making
VoIP (Voice over Internet Protocol) has already been hailed as the death knell for POTS (Plain Old Telephone Services). But there is another application of VoIP that makes simple, one-to-one voice communication seem pale in comparison. And that is, web-based collaboration using VoIP.
Ok, what's so life-enhancing about web-based collaboration, and what does VoIP have to do with it anyway? Web-based collaboration is, of course, groups of people located at geographically separate distances working as a team to achieve a common goal. It's happening now, but a big barrier is the cost of communication. And that's where VoIP comes in - by reducing the cost of voice communication to almost nothing, it's going to open up a great deal of new areas. Imagine the possibilities - medicine-at-a-distance (the services of expert surgeons can be utlised anywhere in the world); learning (likewise the services of tutors); leisure (family and friends can be virtually together for as long as they want to be); after-sales service; consultancy and advisory services of various kinds ...in short, it will be a giant leap towards the long-proclaimed 'death of distance'.
What the lowered cost does is, it allows these things, which may be happening in pockets now, to happen on a really large scale, and render distance almost irrelevant. Of course, it will take a while for VoIP to really become free, and another void to be filled is that collaboration software needs improvements. But we can really begin to see these things in 2-3 years' time.
It is, at least partly, for this reason that VoIP companies have become the hottest property on the planet. No wonder eBay paid an astronomical price (up to $ 4 Billion) for Skype. Microsoft too is acquiring VoIP companies by the handful.
In a lighter vein, with all the talk of killer-apps and VoIP-induced death, one can't help feeling that Valhalla, that great hall in the sky where the glorious dead feast all night, had better start thinking about expansion plans.
by kochikvp
The Incredibly Shrinking Printed Word
The printing industry, once the victim of powerful resistance, is today itself resisting change.
This sounds a bit like another of those apocalyptic predictions of doom / gloom that we see all too often, but the demise of the printed word appears to be at hand (or at least, visible on the distant horizon). Amazon has introduced Amazon Upgrade which enables online access to a book that is purchased. Microsoft is helping the British Library to digitize and make available via MSN Book Search, 25 million pages (roughly 100,000 books) from the British Library?s collection over the next year. The most well-known - and widely feared - initiative on this front is of course, the Google Print (now Google Book Search) initiative.
Why is it happening now? Because the technological capability is only now beginning to become available - to scan, store, index, and deliver online the humongous content locked up in the world's books would have been unimaginable a few years ago.
This flurry of digitization of content is shaking the foundations of publishing as we have known it for the last couple of centuries. Will this mean that authors and publishers will no longer be able to control who accesses their creations? How will revenue be earned on published content? The economics of the publishing industry, and also the very concept of copyrights and ownership of Intellectual Property rights to published content, are being threatened.
There is, of course, huge resistance from the publishing industry, which can hardly be expected to take such a threat to its revenues, and its very future, lying down. Ironically, this is a throwback to the resistance that emanated, particularly from the Church, to Gutenberg's invention of the printing press. The irony is that this time around, the resistance comes not from the those who are afraid of printing, but the printing industry itself! So the printing industry has come full circle, from being the fugitives to the entrenched interests resisting change.
It is widely expected that all the resistance is going to see some scaling back of most of these initiatives.
Overall, the horse sense view on this would be that, any initiative that helps information flow more freely, and releases knowledge from its silos is to be lauded. After all, history teaches us that the darkest ages were those where knowledge was the most monopolised by powerful interests. And I'm sure most of us have had the disconcerting experience of searching for a term or a concept on the internet, only to find that the precise information we want is locked up in some printed book or journal. An added benefit is that we no longer need fear that the priceless works of ancient and medieval authors will be forever lost one day.
I guess those of us in the technology industry should also see this as further proof of how, as technology advances, it inexorably impacts the social and cultural fabric of life too.
It's going to be a big, game-changing battle. But what it is, at the bottom of it all, is Power to the People. And one can scarcely argue with that!
by kochikvp
Corporate Longevity (Revisited)
Of declining companies and brands (but maybe not the big ones?)
In an earlier post, I wrote about once-mighty icons of the technology industry - Digital, Sperry, Burroughs, Compaq - who are but mere memories today. However, here's a scary fact from the McKinsey Quarterly in its Ten Trends to watch in 2006: it says that the probability that a company in an industry's top revenue quartile will not be there in five years is as high as 30 percent! So clearly, the phenomenon of high mortality is not confined to the technology industry but is applicable to the corporate world in general.
And what's more, this has been an accelerating trend for decades. Back in 1999, Marina Whitman wrote in the Harvard Business Press book New World, New Rules: The Changing Role of the American Corporation:
"Only about 4 percent of the Fortune 500?the largest U.S. industrial companies?had turned over annually during the 1960s and 1970s, but by the 1980s the average annual rate of turnover had doubled to 8 percent".
Also, James Surowiecki writes in Wired magazine , that while the number of brands on US grocery store shelves has trebled since 1991, customer loyalty to brands has been on a precipitous decline, and even the loyal ones are less willing to pay hefty premiums for brands perceived as high quality.
So, it's no big wonder that companies decline and die with alarming regularity. Don't get too wedded to your favorite newspaper or brand of toothpaste - you may be forced to change it every few years!
However, all is not lost - here is a heartening observation: Surprisingly, since the Fortune 500 list of the largest American corporations was first published in 1954, only 3 companies - General Motors, Exxon Mobil and Walmart - have held the No. 1 position. So maybe there's some truth to the belief that size means stability!
by kochikvp
The Crystal Ball - in Need of Fixing!
Our ability to foresee emerging technologies is amiss. Can we do something about it?
We've all heard of Cassandra, Pollyanna and Rip van Winkle, right*? And we thought they were mythical characters, or at the very least, existed in dark, unenlightened times. Well, we may just need to do a rethink on that.
It's not very edifying to know this, but we in modern science, technology and business, make mistakes in foreseeing emerging developments - particularly of the technological kind - that fit into patterns that uncannily resemble these hoary old mythical characters! And with all the latest knowledge at our disposal!
Read how in my Computerworld column,
Re-engineering the Crystal Ball
. The piece also proffers simple, easy-to-use pointers on overcoming our deficiences in foreseeing emerging technologies.
Some technologies currently in the exuberance phase that appear less alluring when subjected to this scrutiny include eXtreme Programming, Utility Computing or Software-as-a-service, Open Source, the Tablet PC, Agent technologies and the Semantic web. A few technologies which, based on these pointers, are shown to merit strong consideration for widespread corporate adoption: Wikis, Micropayment technology, Grid computing, Podcasting, the iPod, VoIP-based collaboration technologies, Human speech recognition, Electronic auctions and Prediction markets.
Foreseeing - technologies or any other developments for that matter - has always been an exercise of the hit and miss kind - see a couple of pieces that agree, here , here and here. I'd like to think that I've done my mite in bringing some badly-needed horse sense to this crucial activity!
__________________________________________________________
* In case you haven't, or have forgotten: Cassandra was the one known for making baleful predictions. Pollyanna was the opposite - always cheerful. And Mr. van Winkle - well, he was just oblivious to what was happening in the world around him.
by kochikvp
Do You Know Who Owns Your Company?
Globalization and the Law of Unintended Consequences
The acquisition of a British company by a Dubai-based company this month has US lawmakers in a tizzy. Why?
The British company is the Peninsular and Oriental Steam Navigation Company (better known as P&O), which is being acquired by Dubai Ports World for $6.8 Billion. And no, the brouhaha has nothing to do with sentiment, although P&O is a hoary old company and one of the great names in shipping. It is because this acquisition will give DP World control over significant operations at six major US ports.
A similar lather resulted when a Chinese company tried to buy the US company Unocal recently. These are however cases where tracing true ownership was fairly straightforward. As globalization goes deeper, this is likely to change.
This brings home the sobering lesson: In an increasingly globalized world, corporate ownership will get more and more opaque. Who knows who owns the company which is headquartered in a tax haven, and that just bought 3% of your equity?
This is one more big challenge (not that they needed any more) for company promoters, regulators, shareholders, and anyone with a stake in good corporate governance.
by kochikvp
How Common Sense is Uncommon, and Why Computers Need it Badly
When I first learnt about computers in college in 1982, it seemed logical to me that computers must have common sense. However, that turned out to be far from true. I was astounded at the level of detail that a computer programmer must get down to, in writing a program to solve even the most trivial problem. While things have improved in the intervening two-and-a-half decades, programming computers to solve problems remains a task for people with specialized knowledge, and so-called 'High-level' programming languages remain far, far less sophisticated than natural languages.
That state of affairs, however, is not due to lack of effort by the Computer Science research community. Much work has focused on Natural-language (NL) processing, or figuring out how to make computers smart enough to allow humans to interact with them as though they were other people. This may sound easy enough, but has turned out to be stupefyingly complex - for example, there probably isn't a computer in the world today that could read and understand the previous sentence (the greatest difficulty it would find would be to understand that the word "they" in that sentence refers to computers, and not humans, which is the immediately preceding noun in that sentence!).
NL processing is crucial if we are to ever make computers truly easier for humans to use, in applications ranging from teaching kids to making cars easier to drive.
It is thus that the story of Cyc, a brainchild of former Stanford Professor Michael Lenat, is staggering. This project has soldiered on for two whole decades in search of the laudable goal of imparting common sense to computers. An excerpt from their site:
"Natural-language (NL) processing is among the most studied -- and most intractable -- challenges of software engineering. Consider the following pair of sentences:
Fred saw the plane flying over Zurich.
Fred saw the mountains flying over Zurich.
Humans have little difficulty in recognizing that in the first sentence, "flying" probably refers to the plane, while in the second sentence, "flying" almost certainly refers to Fred. Traditional NL systems will have difficulty resolving this syntactic ambiguity, but because Cyc knows that planes fly and mountains do not, it will be able to reject nonsensical interpretations. It's difficult to see how this could be done without relying on a large database of common sense."
Cyc has two things: a Knowledge Base (KB), which consists of what Cyc "knows", and an Inference Engine(IE), which Cyc uses to make sense of what it knows. The Cyc KB contains nearly two hundred thousand terms and several hundred thousand assertions, or rules, connecting these terms. New assertions are continually added to the KB by human workers. The whole project is still far from achieving it's goal, but it's making progress.
MIT's Open Mind Project is another example of an initiative directed towards making computers understand things that human beings take for granted.
It has been said that common sense is uncommon (even among humans). But that is no excuse for computers not to have plenty of it. Maybe one of these days, we'll actually see a computer that talks - and listens to - common sense!
by kochikvp
Power to the people
Social Computing is the name given to a slew of technologies that collectively allow people to pool their knowledge, keep in touch with and interact better with others who belong to their community. Two key principles of social computing (or social software) are that it is highly participatory, and it is evolutionary ? which taken together mean content that constantly moves in such a direction as to better reflect the knowledge, beliefs, opinions and /or aspirations of a community. Wikis, blogs, sites that allow sharing such as flickr.com, networking sites such as ryze.com and linkedin.com, and sites that allow more complex social interactions, such as myspace.com are increasingly being seen as the 'Killer-app' of Web 2.0, much as email - itself a key enabler of social computing - was to the original Web.
The stellar rise in the popularity of email in the 90s (the number of users skyrocketed from a few thousand at the beginning of that decade, to several hundred million at the end of it) clearly provides a pointer to the potential that social computing has - people are ever eager to take up technologies that will help them meet their social needs better.
Another sign of coming of age of a new technology bubbling up from the masses is large corporations taking note of that technology. And sure enough, Yahoo is doing its bit on the social computing front, having acquired sites such as del.ici.ous. Now, the real big 'un is weighing in. Says Business Week,
"Microsoft's Office SharePoint Server 2007, due in October, will include a new technology called Knowledge Network, designed to help co-workers find colleagues with the expertise they need. For workers who opt in, Knowledge Network automatically scans their contact lists, e-mails, and e-mail distribution lists to create a profile. That way, co-workers can search for expertise among their colleagues to gain specific knowledge that can help with business decision-making".
This of course, is nothing new to the Knowledge Management (KM) fraternity, which has always striven to support people-to-people sharing techologies. Sure enough, a lot of what has been learnt and practised by KM thinkers and practitioners over the past few years is finding expression now in the traction that social computing is getting. So, it's no surprise that the Economist Intelligence Unit, in its report, Foresight 2020: Economic, Industrial and Corporate Trends identifies Knowledge Management as one of the 5 trends that will shape the world of business and economy in the coming 15 years.
In sum, all of this goes to show that technology is making progress towards meeting its basic premise, which is more power to the people!
by kochikvp
Reports that the internet has killed serendipity are greatly exaggerated
A vigorous debate* has been sparked by an op-ed article written by Dr. William McKeen, a University of Florida Professor of Journalism, which in essence argues that the internet has made information so easy to find that the joy of stumbling on information that you didn't know existed has been killed off.
I recommend the following to anybody who thinks the internet has consigned serendipity** to the dustbin: next time you visit any website, just look around at the various links on whichever page you are on. You are certain to see at least one or two links that, while being unrelated to your current search, look like they may offer something interesting enough to check out. Use the "Open link in new window" feature to open the page to which that link leads without distracting you from whatever topic you are currently trying to get information on. Later on, when you have some leisure on your hands, you can go back to these windows lying open on your desktop and read those pages. I do this all the time, and because of this, end up getting information on far more topics from each surfing session than I ever set out to get. Long live Serendipity.
Nevertheless, the perception that serendipity has lost out in the internet age has, in my opinion, some basis. The reasons have to do with both technology and mindset:
1. Low bandwidth ensures that the cost of "internet digression" such as the above is often prohibitive.
2. Newer web access devices such as handhelds, mobile phones, etc. suffer from limitations that make it difficult to digress in the above manner.
3. Above all, the attention deficit nature of our society ensures that we just do not want to digress as above. In the old days when we used to visit libraries to dig for information, we were just more willing to allow ourselves to digress. And that is the real reason for the perceived loss of serendipity.
As with many other developments - technological or otherwise - that we regard as the bane of society, it is not so much that things around us have changed - it is that we have changed!
__________________________________________
* See, for example,
Nicholas Carr's blog
** Incidentally, the word serendipity comes from an old name for the island of Sri Lanka,
Serendip
.
by kochikvp
Premature Obituaries are flying thick and fast
The human race appears to have a peculiar fixation with proclamations of death (including its own - I recall at least a dozen predictions of the end of the world from the 1970s thru the 1990s - complete with precise date and time!).
I wrote a couple of days ago about the premature reports of the death of serendipity. Well, the latest occupant of the deathbed appears to be the Wikipedia. Nicholas Carr writes,
"
Wikipedia, the encyclopedia that "anyone can edit," was a nice experiment in the "democratization" of publishing, but it didn't quite work out. Wikipedia is dead. There was a time when, indeed, pretty much anyone could edit pretty much anything on Wikipedia. A few months ago,... the Wikipedian powers-that-be abandoned the work's founding ideal of being the "ULTIMATE 'open' format" and tightened the restrictions on editing. The administrators adopted an "official policy" of what they called, in good Orwellian fashion, "semi-protection" to prevent "vandals" (also known as people) from messing with their open encyclopedia. The end came last Friday. That's when Wikipedia's founder, Jimmy Wales, proposed "that we eliminate the requirement that semi-protected articles have to announce themselves as such to the general public."
"
This suggestion has, predictably enough, been widely and vociferously pilloried. Let me share my view: As I wrote in the Wisdom of the Wiki, it appears easy to scoff at the notion of an encyclopedia - which by definition is supposed to be the epitome of accuracy, authority, and accountability - that was created in such an apparently loose, disorganized and open manner, allowing any unschooled person with an internet connection to update it. However, amazing as it may seem, we must accept that the Wikipedia has come to be a truly reliable and authoritative source of knowledge - anyone who goes thru it in any degree of detail will be able to attest to that.
Thus, proclamations of its death, if any, must be done based on establishing that it no longer serves the purpose of providing a reliable reference source, or at least that it has abandoned the spirit of what constitutes a 'wiki'. Proclaiming its death based on a change in the administrative procedure that makes it somewhat less 'open' is, apart from being unnecessarily alarmist, completely unjustified, given that it continues to be as reliable as ever, and continues to be a wiki in spirit.
In addition, the change in administrative procedure is not surprising or unfamiliar to anyone who has created such a repository that depends on submissions from a large number of contributors: in the initial stages, the focus is on getting a large volume of content, and so you allow a very high degree of openness. As the volume of content builds up, the focus steadily shifts toward quality, and so you tighten the contribution mechanism. And that is what seems to be happening at the greatest Wiki of 'em all.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending After Hours posts
Sort by Trending