8 replies
by sean wyatt
My initial impression of the blog phenomena is the ability of anyone who can type to become an author, instructor, guru, spiritual advisor or whatever without any need for qualifications or proof of credibility. Unlike forums where a single person has to work pretty hard to control content and defend their position, the blog gives a person un-interrupted flow of text un-challenged by the masses.
Questions I need to find answers to:
1. Is there a way to receive feedback on your blog without giving out your email?
2. Is there a blog scoring system to tell me which blogs I should read?
3. How do I find blogs that would interest me.
4. Is there a ratings system for blogs so I can allow the kids to read safe ones or is it a free for all?
I will report back here on what I find.
by smorty71
1. Other users can leave comments to your blog posts
2. We will be ranking blogs in a variety of ways and surfacing those rankings on the upcoming blogs page
3. We will be building out a blogs page that aggregates all of our blogs and allows you to search them or browse them by categories like newest and most popular
4. I don't know of a ratings system for blogs. Plus, I doubt the kids would be too interested in TechRepublic blogs :)
Hope this answers some of your questions,
sm
by sean wyatt
We are primarily a Dell shop but a couple years ago, I was shopping servers and my vendor quoted me a screaming deal on an IBM xSeries server. We have a smaller network so my last three server purchases have been dual processor XEONs with 2-4GB RAM, Dual Raid Arrays and other standard equipment.
The first issue occurred before the system even shipped. My vendor calls back apologizing that he made a mistake in quoting the system. It seems there was a special on the hard drives quoted but, they sold out of that sku and the replacement sku costs a lot more. He needed to change the price. I told him that was fine but that I needed to cancel the PO and send it back out for bid since a $800 price difference (8 drives @ $100 increase each) was way too much variance for me to swallow. After several discussions with the sales manager and my rep they decide to stick by the quote.
The server arrives and I happily open it up (the first thing you do when you get a new server is crack it open and look at all the cool stuff inside, warranty be damned) and to my chagrin, there is only two RAID arrays instead of three. It seems a split backplane is unavailable on the xSeries 235 and so even though I explained this need to a couple different technicians during the configuration process and even ordered a second dual channel RAID controller in anticipation of having three channels to manage. So I call up and ask what the deal is and basically get the whole that's what you ordered thing and shame on me for not being intimately familiar with IBM products and part numbers and ordering the wrong thing.
So anyway I keep the thing because I have a schedule to keep and while the optimimum configuration for the server would have been three separate arrays, our utilization will probably never tax the unit as it is. To it's credit the server has ran fine. By now you may be saying to yourself, "Hey, the problems you have had are vendor related, not IBM's." to which I reply, "Perhaps, but isn't the channel an extension of the manufacturer? And isn't the buying experience intimately tied to the manufacturer's ability to train the channel as well as provide easy to interpret product information to the end user? So while the immediate issues are vendor issues, the underlying issues are manufacturer issues and I place them at the door of IBM. Besides, there's more."
The server has been chugging away for two years and I had almost forgotten all the above issues. My new rack enclosure arrives in conjunction with my latest server purchase (the last two servers have been Dells because no one touches them on price and they actually arrive in the expected configuration. HP does not even have a server in my range of use. To support the number of drives I want in an HP server, I needed to step up to the $11K range vs. the $5-8K range I typically buy in). I ordered rack conversion kits for my two existing servers, planned my evening and got to work. I had to take down all our servers and move out the shelves they were sitting on to make way for the rack. Then I got the rack placed and footed(30 minutes), installed all the heavy UPS in the bottom(1.5 hours, they had suppot rails that had to be assembled and installed and then mount the rack ears on the units, a bit cumbersome but necessary as they could rack or tower mount), installed the new Dell server (20 minutes), installed the rack conversion kit on the other Dell and mounted it in the rack (45 minutes), and started on the IBM.
My first mistake was not unpacking all the parts and taking a look at them. I was full of false confidence having dealt with the well engineered Dell servers and assumed the IBM install would be as easy. I opened the instruction manual and began pulling covers and prepping the server for the rack mount hardware. About an hour into it I open the box with the front bezel and realize that I have the wrong kit. I'm annoyed at this point. I'm six hours into overtime (I also spent two hours moving my switches and network devices into the rack) and IBM has got me again. Again you say, "You ordered the wrong part, it's not IBM's fault." I answer politely, "Yes, but I bought it from the same vendor I purchased the server from and specified that it was for that server. It is also the same rep I have had with that vendor for three years and I expected better out of him (he's a good guy, the IBM stuff is the problem). Why should determining the proper rack kit for a given server be so difficult?"
I reassmble the server and shove it on a shelf in the rack and get everything up and running again by about 2:30 AM. The vendor provides an RMA and I return the rack kit and receive the correct one (I opened the box right away to be sure). Then I make plans to mount the IBM the same night that I transition to the new Dell I just installed. I decide to do this Friday night so I have all weekend to deal with any issues. Good thing. It took a good two hours just to get the IBM mounted up. Not only must you remove all the feet, covers and faceplate, you also must move the front LED frame, reroute a few cables, rotate some drives 90 degrees, remove fans and frames to get to cables and a lot of other crap just to turn the damn thing sideways and bolt it into a rack. Additionallly, the slider rails leave a lot to be desired. Instead of just extending the rails and setting the server into them, you must hook the server onto the rails in the front and use these throw away plastic knobs on the back that screw into the server to support it while you then screw the slide rails to the sides of the server. Meanwhile these rails are warping big time and I'm a little nervous since I'm hefting this thing up there by myself (against the directions on the box which recommends four people but hey, I allocated all the IT personnel to this task and they were all there, me) and hoping it will balace and I can get all the screws in before somethng gives way. I am also second guessing my idea to mount the heaviest damn server I have above everything else but oh well.
I get it mounted up and the rails work OK but still make me nervous when they are fully extended. I am completely unimpressed with the included cable management arm also. It consists of two metal U shaped channels with hinged mounts on the ends and attached by a chunk of rubber with some loops on it to tie cables. It did the job, but again was a poor showing versus the two Dells below it whose cable management arms were sturdy and easier to use.
Some would say that the true test of a server is how long and well it runs. This is obviously an important factor but the state of technology is such that they all should run well past their useful existence. In trying to sell me on IBM, my vendor constantly says that a lot more engineering and testing goes into HP and IBM equipment whereas Dell just takes parts from all over and bolts them together and that's why IBM and HP cost more. Really? The people at Dell lucked out then because they built a server that can mount in a rack or stand as a tower and all you have to change is the front face. There were obviously too many engineers at IBM the day they designed the rack kit for the xSeries server.
In conclusion, I cannot speak to how well Dell's enterprise level products stack up to IBM, HP or others but for small business servers, it's hard to beat Dell. As a former computer store owner and white box assembler, Dell was a four letter word to me. But after seeing my tech benches filled with HP's, Compaq's and other cheapo branded PC's but very few Dells, it became obvious who was doing it right. For PC's and small business, Dell rocks and IBM sucks!
by kaveh
I have a Dell laptop (C640). It did not charge batteries. I
emailed Dell. The next day, a Dell Tech came in to replace my motherboard, my LCD,
case ? I have a brand new C640 now. I had an HP P4 2.8 GHz laptop. It did not
last 6 months. It was top of the line. Motherboard burned. HP charges $400 for
a new motherboard. Dell rocks, HP sucks
by sean wyatt
by kaveh
flash your bios. slow down the link speed. change irq. did you try all
of those? if you did. It's 100% motherboard. If you told them some
possibilites, they think you're a tech. the'll change it right away.
by icetnet
It seems a shame that you have had so many issues with any vendor or
product. A couple of things. It sounds like you are using a
convertible rack/tower server. Changing these systems are always
a pain even the Dells. We were an IBM shop exclusively until Dell
showed us some numbers. I had zero issues with IBM and our vendor
except they could not beat Dells price points. Once we switched
to Dell, however, the consumer nature of the organization immediately
showed itself. Dell is not in the Distributed Enterprise support
business. I have had no abnormal hardware issues, but regularly
have to spend hours convincing a first level or second level Dell tech
that "Yes" the RAID drive has failed and I need a replacement and "No"
I cannot take the server down to do your BIOS confirmation testing to
prove that "Yes" the drive has failed. Don't even get me going on
backplane and motherboard failures. Suffice it to say, you are
correct the vendor is the lifeblood. Most of the servers made
today are functionally identical to a point. It is up to the
vendors to create the environment that brings us buyers back
again. Thanks for your note and good luck.
by svc4you
"The server has been chugging away for two years and I had almost forgotten all the above issues...."
Ok,so aside from your previous problems with your vendor you're also comparing 2 year old IBM equipment to the latest and greatest (at the time) that you bought from Dell? Geez, how long have you been in the IT field? 6 months? Things change rapidly in the small and midrange servers business. You should know that by now. I'm sure if you strained yourself you'd find something similar from most competitors, including IBM.
"Meanwhile these rails are warping big time and I'm a little nervous since I'm hefting this thing up there by myself (against the directions on the box which recommends four people but hey, I allocated all the IT personnel to this task and they were all there, me)"
Wow...people such as yourself never cease to amaze me. In my line of work, it's people such as yourself that cause 90% of the problems by failing to follow directions. "Oh, I hurt my back doing server work and I'll be out sick for a day or two". Gee, really? That isn't because you failed to follow instructions and get help installing a heavy piece of equipment is it?
.....and yet you blame it all on the vendor and manufacturer of the product. Well, you could always get work in India. I run into techs there just like you all the time.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending After Hours posts
Sort by Trending