Discussion Locked

Those Pesky Bios Passwords Again

0 helpful
51 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

A while back, I was *skewered* here by a (probably drunk) member for making the newbie-member mistake of answering the dreaded question, how do I bust this bios password? I immediately used the EDIT feature and removed my answer, aware then of TR's "policy" against answering password questions. And I acknowledge that it was a goofy mistake to have answered the question.

But (unless the ads change somehow), look at this page: https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=101&threadID=258324&messageID=2458157

No fewer than four "Sponsored Links" that lead TRs guests straight to methods for breaking BIOS passwords.

Now come on! Just a *bit* of hypocrisy here?

INKY

51 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Virtually all the password questions get those type of 'sponsored links', and I have seen it noticed and mentioned by other members.
Still, even if I knew how to break a password I wouldn't tell here on the boards. What the site advertisers do, what TR does in the way of choosing advertisers, and what I do are quite different things.

It is rather disconerting, all the same.

by tig2

The "Sponsored Links" are content driven. So if a thread is
about password hacking, those are the links that are served.
But TR has no control over them and they change every time
a thread is viewed.

by inky960

TR has "no control" over the ads that appear on its own website? What about ZDNet, which owns TR? Someone is in control! And by the way, the "thread" I started (about motherboard vs. hard disk problems) made NO mention of BIOS passwords, yet it immediately (with no responses) drew the hacker ads. I mentioned "BIOS," in my question, so I guess that's enough to draw the ad, eh?

Hey-ho, it seems that the finger-wagging member who lambasted my behind would lambast ZDNet or TR, if she's *really* on such a lofty moral plane. 'Tain't no difference, Missy, whence the foul information comes.

by dawgit

I would guess. That does make it possible for the rest of us (the TR members) to, well be members. And of course we all know that advertisers are always honest, trustworthy, and above board on the matters..... (choke-choke, ahem, ;) ) So as for ?Just a *bit* of hypocrisy here?, no not really, while TR might need money, it is the TR members that have unilaterally developed the philosophy of not helping ?Crackers?, not of the edible, animal variety. It's just the way most of us are put together. (programed :0 ) Since you've now been around awhile, you might have noticed that. I do agree with the ?Boxy? 1, but it is TR's house we play in, so they can do whatever they want. Just my .02 ? -d

edited to add: while I don't particularly remember your post on the matter, (they're had been a lot for awhile there) if I had been the one to set you off, I don't drink.

by maxwell edison

I might have been one of the first TR members to post a message (5 or 6+ years ago) refusing to answer a password question, openly speculating that such questions might have malicious motives. I even suggested to other TR members that such questions might be best left unanswered.

Since then, and especially lately (or so it seems), the regular TR members have pretty much formed an unwritten rule amongst themselves that no one would (or should) ask or answer any questions about passwords. The reason, of course, is that many such inquiries have (or could have) malicious intent; but in all honesty, there?s really no way of knowing. I?ll even admit to forgetting a password that I set myself on an NT Server years ago, and I had to scour the Internet looking for a way around it.

You?ll be given any number of reasons, and the answers will make any number of claims ? one of which is that it?s against TR policy to post information about getting around/resetting passwords. I?d bet a dollar to dirt, however, that there is no such written TR policy prohibiting such a thing, so whoever made that claim was grossly mistaken.

I would say, however, that most of the questions asking about how to get around passwords are dripping with suspicion, such as those from a brand new member and it was the first thing ever posted by them; or it?s asked in such a way that it sounds more like a teenager trying to get around a parent?s password than it does an IT pro with a legitimate reason. As such, none of us would answer those suspicious sounding inquiries, and probably, rightfully so.

But against TR policy? I think not. If anyone can post a link to the official policy and/or a legitimate TechRepublic representative saying as much, I?ll both stand corrected and pay them the buck I offered.

Actually, from my observations, some TR members have become down-right rude to people asking about ways by which passwords might be circumvented. One recent instance was both humorous and sad when a TR member actually defamed an original TR founder and TR editor who posted a blog piece on resetting passwords. (Defamation, by the way, IS against TR policy, and this particular member did indeed defame the writer.)

http://blogs.techrepublic.com.com/window-on-windows/?p=639

http://www.cnetnetworks.com/editorial/terms.html?tag=tr.ft.co

It appears to me that you may have been blind-sided by an overzealous, albeit well intentioned, TR member who misspoke, and was rude about it in the process. But against TR policy? At best, that?s nothing more than factopinguess.

by dawgit

And still write a good post. A Hallo to you from Germany, and a Happy Easter to you as well. I hadn't seen that second link before, I have it now, Thanks. You take care of your-self. -d

by scifilover

[/i]But against TR policy? I think not. If anyone can post a link to the official policy [b]and/or a [u]legitimate TechRepublic representative[/u] saying as much,[/b] I?ll both stand corrected and pay them the buck I offered.[/i]

Will this do?

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=101&threadID=254717&messageID=2431958

Beth is the forum moderator. I would like to bring your attention to this statement: [b]"Here at TR, we DO NOT ANSWER ANY PASSWORD RECOVERY QUESTIONS. Period. No need to reason or argue. [u]That's the boundary.[/u]"[/b]

But that's OK! You can donate the buck to Cancer Research. :D ;)

]:)

by maxwell edison

That is, to specifically speak for herself AND TechRepublic as establishing written TR policy.

In the post to which you linked, she said, [i]?The people who've been a part of the community for longer than you, and who've made it what it is today, are telling you that what you did was out of bounds. Here at TR.....?[/i] (as spoken by the people who've been a part of the community)[i], ".....we DO NOT ANSWER ANY PASSWORD RECOVERY QUESTIONS. Period. No need to reason or argue. That's the boundary.?[/i]

In other words, she was simply reiterating what [i]?The people who've been a part of the community?[/i] have established as unwritten policy, not stating specific and written TR policy.

Beth, please correct me if I?m wrong. What is the official TechRepublic policy? (And please provide a link to the written policy.)

If I am wrong, I will indeed stand corrected AND send sifilover the well-earned dollar - or donate TWENTY to the favorite charity of his/her choice, cancer research, apparently. (And just so we don't put Beth in the position of potentially denying a donation, I'll donate the twenty if she just replies, one way or the other.)

By the way, the initial message in the discussion to which you linked:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=101&threadID=254717&messageID=2430566

.....was one of those that I described as extremely suspicious, and by all appearances, it was posted by a teenager trying to circumvent a parent's password. The TR members, in all their wisdom, were correct in not providing any answers.

by tig2

He already has. Donated the buck to cancer, I mean.

But until Beth made that point to CallPete, it had mostly
been an unwritten rule that passed from peer to peer.

There have been a number of discussions about this. A
recent one- the one Max mentioned- drew out that there
are legitimate tools out there that we SHOULD be able to
discuss, even though those tools could be used to reset a
password.

by inky960

I hope Beth Blakely won't mind my copy/pasting these excerpted lines from an email she sent me, just after I foolishly answered the foolish question and was flame-broiled by [****]. Maybe there's no policy against answering the password question (I really don't know), but TR clearly doesn't tolerate it now:

Dear [Inky]

I'm sorry you've had a rough start at TechRepublic.

[****] is a great member at TechRepublic, even if she was a bit
overzealous in her response to you as a new member. // I am the one who deleted your post.

> Sincerely,
>
> Beth Blakely
> Product Lead
> TechRepublic/CNET Networks

by scifilover

But, that is not what you asked. :D You said "and/or a legitimate TechRepublic representative [u]saying as much[/u]". ;) That's all I was trying to point out. And, to get your buck, of course! ]:)

After all, you have to admit that if someone new to TR (or a person who's native language is not English) were to pull up Beth's post and saw that it came from a TR "representative", they [i]could[/i] interpret it to mean "them's the TR rules, now live by them", even though WE know she was trying to say the "TR Community" and not the "TR Policy".

And, isn't that what Inky was trying to say in the original post? At least I interpreted it to mean there seems to be two standards here at TR. (1) What we see and (2) what we SAY is OK to see. ]:)

by inky960

Scifilover wrote: "And, isn't that what Inky was trying to say in the original post? At least I interpreted it to mean there seems to be two standards here at TR. (1) What we see and (2) what we SAY is OK to see."

==============
Exactly.

Hipocrisy: Noun. Insincerity by virtue of pretending to have beliefs that you do not really have. Lip service.

by hal 9000

Is present all through everything that we do. It's that simple if you don't like it get out and live in Ga Ga Land where things never happen in a manner that you don't like.

Would you Inky be happy if I cane to your house and took a Dump on your Kitchen Table. I could quite rightly argue that there is [b]No Law[/b] against doing this and there isn't but if I ignored your feelings and did as I please in your house who would be the one put out?

I'm betting that you wouldn't leave home and continue paying the bills just because you didn't like what I did in your home. So wouldn't that make you a hypocrite?

Col

by w2ktechman

There is NO written policy against answering these questions.

And you are correct that a number of members try to dissuade this behaviour. And to add that Beth does back us up and will remove posts with links to cracking tools or written cracks if they are marked as spam.

However, the official policy does not state that this is not allowed. So until Beth shows up to answer for herself, I have to say that your post is correct.

by beth blakely

I've been up all night with a sick kid and am out of the office today. Just stopping in to check on stuff.

Yes, I back you guys and your policy about not helping cracker/hackers, and that's what I meant in the statement copied above. I also back TR's editorial policy to publish anything they see fit, so long as it's a legitimate tool/solution.

And, as I said before, (or maybe I just thought it) there's a huge difference between someone who's going to find the info anyway via Google, and someone who's trollin' by asking the questions in the forums.

by hal 9000

Discussing Cracking Tools but I just will not answer a question referring to the same tools.

Col

by cmiller5400

http://blogs.techrepublic.com.com/security/?p=228

We NEED an answer from Beth or someone who either states, YES or NO that those questions can be answered. Just the other day, someone posted a blog about how to reset a windows password. Why bother telling the poster no can do if TechRepublic is posting blogs on how to do it; and providing links to backdoor passwords?

Respectfully waiting for an answer... :)

by jdclyde

To my knowledge, there isn't a TR policy, it was just an accepted standard in the community that brought on a life of it's own.

Maybe we all owe ol' Pete an appology, huh?

by jdclyde

We "corrected" him on what is and what is not acceptable when it turns out to just be what is acceptable to [b]US[/b], and he was NOT out of line with his answer in the first place.

While we were VERY polite in trying to explain WHY we didn't THINK it was appropreate, we were still the ones that were wrong. And yeah, he was a dick after that....

by tig2

The ads that appear in "Sponsored Links" are a feed that
someone other than TR defines the content for. That is
what I meant by no control. The feed is supposed to base
itself on keywords that appear in the post (or possibly the
tags). When I do the yearly breast cancer thread, you'll
see links to the 3 Day and the Susan G Komen.

As I post this, the served content is various online
learning institutions. Why? I haven't got a clue!

by inky960

So, it's like ZDNet (and/or TR) turns over control of what will be advertised on their websites to Google-like people who couldn't care less that their ads are dumb little soldiers in Hypocrite's Army, and ZDNet (and/or TR) knows this, but can make more money more easily if they choose not to care either. // Really, I *do* understand that businesses have to make profits and that compromise is inevitable. I don't mean to sound like Ralph Nader, honest. I'm just trying to get it clear in my often-foggy head. I'm on your side, I swear.

by the scummy one

"I'm just trying to get it clear in my often-foggy head"

things appear to start to make some sense, and then suddenly Whoa!!! and the confusion starts again.

Is this what 'fuzzy logic' is all about??

by inky960

My "Oh" response did come off sounding really snotty, and I apologize. I have no excuses, but I'll try to do better from now on. : ) Sorry.

by inky960

In my infamous first post (or second?) here at TR, I suggested to PasswordBoy that he search Google for a particular tool that would do that job for him. This tool is extremely well known, and if it isn't legitimate, I can't imagine one that is. And this is the only tip I gave the guy. // I'd love to mention the name of the "tool" so we could discuss its legitimacy (or illegitimacy). The version I have cost me about $25. Every tech I know has a copy. // Anyway, I agree: there are legitimate tools. What puzzles me, now that I've had time to ponder the issue, is why do these people join a forum like TR, just to bust a password, when Google is 100 times quicker?

Hey-ho.

by tig2

My personal belief is that people who post here for
cracking tools don't know what to Google FOR. Otherwise,
you're right- a discussion of the tools that help us to do
our jobs shouldn't be prohibited.

The door that you are running into is that the community
does not write or dictate editorial decisions. The
community is a by-product and not the stated "goal"
necessarily for the site. As a community, we set the
ethics the way we think that they should be set. But that
doesn't mean that we will drive editorial content.

As a blogger here, I write that which gets me paid and my
direction is set by my editors. As a peer, I can open any
discussion I care to without worrying about my editors.
As a blogger, my goal is to write interesting and helpful
articles that you want to read and that help you to do
some element of your job. As a peer, I want to comment
helpfully and share knowledge. Oh- and fit well with the
rest of y'all.

I agree with Col- there are good discussions to be had
about a lot of tools that we can use to facilitate our work.
But those tools can be used for nefarious purpose. So it
comes to being careful about how we discuss them.

by the scummy one

Beth did what she normally does, and we all did the norm and tried explaining it to him.
who was right? We have the backing of the TR site moderator for answering questions. Plus we are doing the morale good (to some degree at least).
Just because articles are running about this is not really a good reason to question our tactics. If they can search google for an answer, they can search TR for an answer (less likely), or just look back at their question and check the links at the bottom of the page. However, if they cannot search, then they would not find the articles on TR, so they will not get an answer. They are 2 separate items and I do think that we are handling it right (my opinion, I do not hold everyone to this opinion).

However Pete got snotty with Beth, so why should we apologize for it, we did nothing wrong!

by jdclyde

it was what we were trying to explain in the first place that was the problem. It wasn't and isn't a TR policy, it was OUR addopted policy, and he had no oblication to have to follow it, so he was correct all along.

That he turned into a WATB after the fact is besides the point. I didn't mean that he should not have gotten slapped for being a cryass and getting snippy with Beth, because at that point, he WAS wrong when he took "that tone" with the Mistress of Mayhem... :x

by the scummy one

looking at the letter of the law rather than the accepted policy (non-written) that WAS written to him by Beth in support of our action/comments.

Since he could not get by the fact that the written policy on the site did not specifically mention not to answer these questions, he became an ass.

Were we wrong? not in my opinion. We informed him to edit his post and remove links and explained why. Beth edited his post and he got pissed.

Even though it is not specifically detailed in the policy, it IS an accepted policy in the forums. So, we are not wrong if we do not slam someone right away about it. The accepted policy HAS been endorsed by Beth, the moderator of the site, which means that the accepted policy is NOT wrong.

by hal 9000

If you had visitors over and one of them took a [b]Dump[/b] on your Coffee Table in the Living Room I'd bet that you wouldn't leave it at that because there isn't a [b]LAW[/b] against taking a Dump on others Coffee Tables in the living Room.

In the case mentioned above the person in question had to get up tight and insist that they had done nothing wrong and ignore those who where attempting to help him join in. When you go anywhere there are more than Laws or Rules to consider you have to see how those that you visit are prepared to behave. So if you go to a High Class Restraint it wouldn't be acceptable to open a Beer on the Edge of the Table and throw the empty over your shoulder into others behind you. This may be acceptable in other places but most reasonable people act differently depending on where they are. The ones that don't are the ones shown the Door and told not to return.

So why do some people think that they are entitled to do as they please and ignore what others have to say on the matter?

Col

by inky960

jdclyde writes: "it was what we were trying to explain in the first place that was the problem. It wasn't and isn't a TR policy, it was OUR addopted policy, and he had no oblication to have to follow it, so he was correct all along.

That he turned into a WATB after the fact is besides the point."
=====================
And I think, jd, that your point is very well made. I don't think I was even here then, but that doesn't matter either! Logic is logic - if some TR member(s) told "Pete" he was violating TR "policy," and there was no such policy...you're right. Not many people can look back and admit that a jerk was actually right, at least initially, and deserves an apology. Kudos.

by tig2

No apology required! :D

I get why you're confused. See post below for as close an
explanation as I could come up with.

You have to really work at offending me. But I have been
known to be pretty harsh when that line gets crossed. I'll
bet that you would have never guessed that about me,
would you?
;)

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Didn't you know that it's not you or me but [i]them[/i]? :D

"So why do some people think that they are entitled to do as they please and ignore what others have to say on the matter?"

by jdclyde

What I TRIED to say is it was OUR rule that was pushed off as THE rule. [i]( A rule I agree with, as you know) [/i] Being it was not an official TR rule, since when do we shut down people just because we don't agree with them?

That was the only point I was trying to make about pete.

From the Point it went from US talking to him to BETH talking to him, he should have STFU and walked away. His getting booted was well justified because you don't piss off the boss, especially if she has a whip. ;\

by jdclyde

your thinking about dumping on peoples tables an awful lot lately.... anything you need to get off your chest? :p

by hal 9000

But I can remember saying that the Peers of TR Don't answer Password Cracking Questions to Pete.

Instead of sitting up and taking notice of the otters and me who had very genitally informed him of what was acceptable here he chose to want to start a fight and he thought that he should be allowed to do as he pleased.

It was at that point where things went downhill dramatically.

But being [b]Acceptable & Willing to Fit In[/b] is the real issue here as this person didn't want to fit in and wanted to change the place to what he wanted not what he had joined.

OH BTW did my reference to Taking a Dump translate?

Col

by hal 9000

At least JD but Cr@pping on a table in front of someone in their dwelling is a very good way to make a point isn't it? :D

Not Illegal and I don't even think that there are any rules written anywhere about doing that but [b]Common Sense[/b] would tell anyone but a complete eejit that it was not only unacceptable but would lead to a reaction that would involve then cleaning up their mess before leaving. :D

Col

by jdclyde

"Indecent exposer" and at worst the spilling of a bio hazard?

With all the AIDS hysteria, it is assult to just spit on someone.

Cleveland Steamer? :0

by the scummy one

Ok, JD, YOU ARE WRONG!!! I guess since I did not state it plainly enough, it did not sink through...

So, Pete posted a crack, several of us asked him to remove the link, and informed him of what TR members do, and how we felt he should respond. Now HOW IS THAT getting out of line? Were we too harsh in stating this? Should we have said nothing until Beth took over? We have done this many times, and I personally view it as informing newcomers of what we consider acceptable/unacceptable behavior. So to this part of it, please state where we were wrong and why we should apologize?

Continuing on now -- He took it as a thrashing on him even though nobody got nast at that point. He started getting nasty with others, and then started taking a very light beating over it (very light). Mostly though, we were trying to explain in more detail our previous position, however he was very argumentative. Please explain again, from this point Why were we wrong, and why do we need to apologize??

From there, his post was reported as SPAM and Beth got involved. She did not kill his account, just emailed him and posted so that he could find the position that was acceptable. He in turn got even snottier about everything, and when Beth called him on it He deleted HIS OWN posts, all of them. Beth had not deleted his account, he deleted all of his posts because Beth told him to calm down and not be an ass (or something like that).

CallPete had an ego problem that he could not deal with. Since he wasnt allowed to be an ass all over the place and do as he pleased, he had a 2 yr. olds hissy fit.

I personally do not feel that an apology is warranted, and I do think that someone needs to tell him to grow the F*** up a bit.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

[i]...that's what they say when we're together...'[/i]

Sung to the tune of 'Children Behave'.

;)

edit the usual

by the scummy one

I will behave. Sorry, I really didnt mean to be bad and scummy. I was just trying to better myself at arguing, so I decided to argue with JD as a 'good starting point' :^0

See JD, ya feel special now?? :^0 :^0

by hal 9000

For Indecent Exposure while inside a House where they either live or visit? My guess is not many as that would leave the way open for everyone to be arrested for this every time they go # 1 & 2's or have a bath/shower/whatever or for that matter get dressed for work/undressed and changed for bed and so on. Ideal if that is what you like but on the whole completely unworkable isn't it? :0

The only items where some form of Criminal Charges have been instigated against people that I can remember is where someone fits a Camera and films the Victim Unawares in a situation like this so when it's all said and done Taking a Dump on the Living Room Table is less likely to get you widespread exposure than well you know what. :D

Yep I agree it's not acceptable to anyone but then again why is it acceptable to anyone that they think they have a right to walk in and start making changes without being asked? After all there are enough complaints about Site Changes here brought about by the Owners let alone having to drop everything and change it to someone's else desired landscape every time one of these people drop by and start demanding that we all change to suit them. :^0

OH I nearly forgot [b]Bloody Deamoncrats[/b] it's their fault. :0

Col ]:)

by inky960

Col, I don't understand all that you're saying here, but to the extent that I do understand, I don't care.

by hal 9000

You Don't Care

So how many of my friends do you want me to bring over to Cr@p all through your house/residence or whatever it is where you live?

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.