I might have been one of the first TR members to post a message (5 or 6+ years ago) refusing to answer a password question, openly speculating that such questions might have malicious motives. I even suggested to other TR members that such questions might be best left unanswered.
Since then, and especially lately (or so it seems), the regular TR members have pretty much formed an unwritten rule amongst themselves that no one would (or should) ask or answer any questions about passwords. The reason, of course, is that many such inquiries have (or could have) malicious intent; but in all honesty, there?s really no way of knowing. I?ll even admit to forgetting a password that I set myself on an NT Server years ago, and I had to scour the Internet looking for a way around it.
You?ll be given any number of reasons, and the answers will make any number of claims ? one of which is that it?s against TR policy to post information about getting around/resetting passwords. I?d bet a dollar to dirt, however, that there is no such written TR policy prohibiting such a thing, so whoever made that claim was grossly mistaken.
I would say, however, that most of the questions asking about how to get around passwords are dripping with suspicion, such as those from a brand new member and it was the first thing ever posted by them; or it?s asked in such a way that it sounds more like a teenager trying to get around a parent?s password than it does an IT pro with a legitimate reason. As such, none of us would answer those suspicious sounding inquiries, and probably, rightfully so.
But against TR policy? I think not. If anyone can post a link to the official policy and/or a legitimate TechRepublic representative saying as much, I?ll both stand corrected and pay them the buck I offered.
Actually, from my observations, some TR members have become down-right rude to people asking about ways by which passwords might be circumvented. One recent instance was both humorous and sad when a TR member actually defamed an original TR founder and TR editor who posted a blog piece on resetting passwords. (Defamation, by the way, IS against TR policy, and this particular member did indeed defame the writer.)
http://blogs.techrepublic.com.com/window-on-windows/?p=639
http://www.cnetnetworks.com/editorial/terms.html?tag=tr.ft.co
It appears to me that you may have been blind-sided by an overzealous, albeit well intentioned, TR member who misspoke, and was rude about it in the process. But against TR policy? At best, that?s nothing more than factopinguess.