Discussion Locked

Thoughts of an employee

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Thoughts of an employee:

I am writing this in the form of an interview to bring a touch of reality into the subject I want to talk about.

Interviewer:
Ok, our first question is: In your opinion, why should someone have a job?
Employee:
Talking about me, I work because I have passion for accomplishments, but I can live a great life without a job. That doesn?t mean that I should not study or that I can work for no salary, in other words, whether an employee needs the salary or not, everyone should earn what they deserve based on skills, performance, and market value.

Interviewer:
That sounds good, but if you said that during a job interview, it might give the impression that you will be running away as soon as you are not comfortable.
Employee:
Yes, you have a point. Being employed is more of a relationship to me, just like marriage. I will help the organization reach their goals by all means and give it all the reasons needed to make it invest and take care of me. On the other hand, I will bring this relationship to an end in case I was given all reasons needed to make me actually end it so that I can continue to pursue my goals. I am fairly sure that this is a good deal for any organization.
Interviewer:
In a perfect world, yes, but it is really hard to expect everything to go normal as it should without fighting for it.
Employee:
Ok, let us look at it this way, when you get a job, you will sign a contract, right? By definition, a contract has the terms and conditions for a business deal between two or more parties. There is no such thing as a one-sided contract. They have their version and I have mine. I don?t see why I should fight and negotiate for my rights because, to me, negotiation is weakness. We have to satisfy the formula of equality. Employees have objectives just like organizations. We both should support each other to reach our objectives and if one side is stopping the other, the relationship must end.

Interviewer:
Last question, you mentioned objectives, can you tell us about your objective?
Employee:
Ok, my objective is written in my resume. ?To start a relationship, with an organization, that will enable and strengthen both parties to reach their goals and objectives. I should give the organization all the reasons it needs to be interested in investing in me by doing an outstanding job.?

18 replies

by tony hopkinson

Ask me that and you'll be talking to the back of my head as I leave.

Negotiation is a weakness?

You haven't actually said that have you?

If I was interviewing you, that one statement would cross you off the list.

If you were interviewing me and said it, I'd just get up and walk out of the door.

Not being willing to negotiate is a negotiating position.

So is not being willing not to negotiate.

The so called equality of the relationship is a perception, none of the factors can be measured in a meaningful quantitative way.

by mismeshal

I like your reply, that is what I wanted to see.
If you consider what I said as general, you are absolutely right.

Ok, I will tell you my story and then you tell me what do you think.

I worked in my first year after graduation with a company as a level one manager. Then for reasons that dont matter here, I resigned. I applied for one bank, and i got a trainee position because I have less than two years experience as they said. That was a downgrade, however, I had to sacrifice because my new manager is a true gentleman and i'll prove that I deserve that position. By the way, both firms have the same grade scale. I recieved other offers with 20% more salary but not that great managers so I chose the bank over them because I would rather be happy at work than have higher salary and at the same time I can work hard and get the salary I want in the place I want.

Now, this bank has two cycles a year for promotions and raises. I joined the bank a month before the first cycle. So I worked for 7 months and did a extraordinary job. My manger was really happy and he recommended a promotion and a raise without telling me. In the promotion day, I didnt get any. I was very disappointed and I decided that I should not continue the same performance. I couldn't do that, because I either do a perfect job or I just dont. Suddenly, my manager told me that he spoke with management and they told him "We are sorry, we promised you to promote him but HR didn't list his name in the list of candidates because he didn't complete one year, so we forgot him." and he said I will make it up to you next cycle.

The point is:
1- I want to continue the same performance, however, if I didn't get what my manager promised me, I will have to leave because it is not fair at all. In addition, I recieve offers every two months with higher salary BUT not that good managers or environment to work in.

2- If I lowered my performance, I will not feel bad because I didn't perform well at the first place. The problem is, I cannot lower performance because I cannot do anything not well, I just can't, I have to do it very well.

That is the source of the problem I am trying to explain.
One thing to know, my performance is better than people with higher salary and higher positions in the bank as agreed by my manager and many colleages.

Please tell me what do you think? What do you recommend?

Warm Regards,

by jamesrl

In my company, you must complete 2 years to be considered for promotion.

You are young. You must learn patience. Instead of being grateful for having been considered for promotion after a short period, you now sound bitter. If you can't get over that, then leave and start fresh somewhere else.

You are right to consider more than just salary in your considerations. Over the long run you are better off in a place where you can learn and grow, than going for salary in the short term.

Forgive me for being bold, but your statement about being better than those making more, are you really in a position to know that? Do you know their performance as well as their managers do?

In my experience these things correct themselves over time. If you are performing at a high level for your pay scale, you will get better raises and more promotions and things will even out. Seven months is barely out of probation around here, this leveling out takes years. Again if you don't have the patience, leave, but don't expect that everything will be wonderful at your next job either.

James

by boxfiddler Hot topic

The ONLY thing fair in life is that EVERYTHING (emphasis not yelling) that comes into existence goes out of existence. Fairness is an idealogical concept invented by man that has no basis in reality (that which is as opposed to that which ought to be).

edit typo

by tony hopkinson

I've been in continuous employment in IT since 87. I've got a skills list longer than you are tall, shed loads of experience in varied businesses. I've done DBA, admin and web admin, I started computers academically in 1977.

If the experience you are gaining is valuable, then you are right to stay.

I see no benefit to you from leaving after seven months, give it another year. Another year and you have two things, one you've been a substantial investment by the company, two you can write two years experience on your resume.

Two years is way way better than than 6 months. If you are getting sidelined and left with crap tasks, cut and run, otherwise stay. You'll get more out it than they will.

Watch for more broken promises, any company going down that route is serious trouble.

Be the best you can be all the time, it will get noticed by those who have the intellect to recognise it. Those who don't, don't matter, leave them in your wake when you choose your own path. Don't let fools choose it for you.

Careful about the performance bit, at what and when. I've no idea how good you are but only a complete idiot would tell you, you were performing well, when you weren't.
They didn't reward it though, did they, worse still knowing they'd made a mistake they didn't correct it, so may be it doesn't have as much value to them as they would have you believe.
With a mere seven months in the only thing we can say is if you hadn't performed at least adequately you'd be gone.

If I was reading your resume and I saw seven months and then left, that would worry me. If you told me you left because more experienced people were getting paid more for doing less, it would be "don't call us, we'll call you".

That's why you want the other year, otherwise you are effectively starting from scratch again.
Leaving because there was no scope to develop yourself is a very acceptable reason, because you thought you were as good as everyone else, a non-starter.

by zen37

Patience is a virtue that will bring you wisdom and judgment.

I find that expecting a promotion after 7 months is hopelessly optimistic, unless it was stated in your initial contract. You are barely out of college with not even two years experience. Being a manager right out of college is a rarity, not the norm.

Be patient, good things happen to those who wait. Never compromise. Either you do your best or don't bother doing it. I'm kinda that way myself.

Think of it this way, how would you feel if you were working at a company for a number of years and a fresh out of college kid would get a promotion after just 7 months of work?

by mismeshal

Thank you all very much, Mr. Tony, Mr. James, and Mr. Boxfiddler. I really appreciate your comments. I feel much better now, the way you put it is very optimistic and bright. Today, I rejected the job offer number 4 (an offer without interviewing me). What I said was

"Thank you very much for offering me the opportunity to work at XXXX. After thinking it over, I don't see that changing the industry I work in now as a good move because I should at least have a banking background that counts before switching to another industry. In addition, doing this will endanger my career by being considered a job hopper. If I switched now to insurance, I will have one year in marketing, 9 months in banking, and recently insurance all in two years.

Once again, I'd like to express my gratitude for the consideration and my regrets that it could't work out under current circumstances. You have my best wishes in finding someone suitable for your team.

Warm Regards,"

Thanks all for inspiring me and for letting me gain from your experience. What you all said is very true, I should let things even out and if they didn't, I should have enough experience before leaving, that is, get the most out of it.

by drowningnotwaving

[b]Thank you all very much, Mr. Tony, Mr. James, and Mr. Boxfiddler.[/b]

ROTFLMAO - in tears.

Sorry - in no way do I wish to demean the kind message !! Just that sentence was Python-esque and all the more because of the innocence.

Courtesy on TR has reached a new high.

by mismeshal

I am thanking them because I didn't expect such a long honest reply with that much of details. To be fair, I dont care if someone percieved the message "funny" as you did. Even if i turned back in time, I will write the same message.

P.S. you could've LYAO without posting a reply saying that you did with reasons.

by rclark2

This is the same question we all go through every year. We see the Salary Survey results, and we feel our pay doesn't measure up, especially based on our knowledge and quality of work.

Unfortunately, the longer you stay at an organization, the more likely you will be underpaid and taken for granted. Not the other way around.

In my experience, the only large pay increases come as a result of successful rollouts of large projects, c-level management promotions, and job hopping. Rolling out a large project takes years. C-level promotions only happen once or twice a career. So if you don?t change jobs, you probably will fall behind over time.

On the other hand, as an experienced manager, I don't consider anyone who routinely hops from one job to the next every two years as stable. It takes six months to teach a new employee the corporate culture and that doesn't even start on the number of new languages and software they have to learn to support.

So when I look at a resume, I look for longevity at one company. The industry average length of employment in the U.S. is about 18 months in our field, which means there are a lot of job hoppers out there. My boss has 23 years here and I have 17. For a newbie, three to five years is good, middle tier seven to ten, senior management 12 to 15. I like to see steady growth, with increasing responsibility and accomplishments shown in the jobs over time. I like to see teamwork, and I like to see evidence of a three dimensional personality.

As for us here, we have made a choice of trading gold for a little glory (big fish, little pond), a lot of peace, and the opportunity to raise families in a good place. We could have made more money by changing jobs more often or living in the big cities, but then, we wouldn't have had the stability to raise our children in one place. That is worth an awful lot. Our children have homes, not just somewhere to hang their backpack between moves. They have roots and are connected to the community. We masters of change sometimes forget that stability is important to the human mind.

Life isn?t about piling up money. Your intellect and training have given you the means to acquire enough to live comfortably. Your duty now is to have patience and continue to grow, to do what you can to aid your fellow man, and to live your life in such a way that when looking back, you have as few regrets as possible.

by jackofalltech

Perhaps you gentlemen can advise me also. I was hired at a large banking corp. as an in-house consultant at a very nice salary. After two years, they decided they really didn't need my position after all but offered me a job in Production Control at the same salary. Although I have over twenty years of experience in everything from mainframes to unix, Windows servers to desktops, Novell networking and Cisco routers, I'm now pretty much a glorified help-desk operator. I'm under-utilized and bored out of my gourd! Yet... they haven't been stingy with the raises. Should I stay or go?

by tony hopkinson

a third asleep, and the bulk of the rest transitioning between these two states.

So is this money doing you any good?

Course you can afford to have a good look around and find yourself a nice position.

Don't take too long though.

by gpellett

I'd like to address your comments about stability -- particularly about "So when I look at a resume, I look for longevity at one company. The industry average length of employment in the U.S. is about 18 months in our field, which means there are a lot of job hoppers out there. My boss has 23 years here and I have 17. For a newbie, three to five years is good, middle tier seven to ten, senior management 12 to 15."

Many of us stay only an average of 18 months per job because of situations we cannot control. These include:
a) Many more small (and short-lived) companies than large, stable companies.
b) Out-sourcing and lean staffing policies.
c) Companies that don't directly hire but prefer short term contractors.
d) Stereotypes about age vs. ability to keep up with technology and maintain productivity, or pre-conceptions about age vs. acceptable titles and pay.
e) Fewer companies that take care of their employees.

You and your boss are becoming quite rare with your 17 and 23 years at the same company. Many of us would stay longer too but the economy just hasn't let us.

Anyway, I hope that hiring managers don't disqualify good candidates with "job hopping" tendencies without interviewing them first. You should be able to get a feel for their intentions and stability during the interview. You can factor in the locations of all of these jobs -- if they are mostly in the same city or area then he is demonstrating a desire to root into the community just as you value so much.

by delongj

The organization you work for has policies, many policies. You agreed to support those policies. O.K.

Now, lets talk about 'you'. Other organizations are sequestering your knowledge and abilities and you are backing off. Why?

The organization you signed up with let you down. There is an outer structure of an organization and an inner structure. The inner structure corrects the outer structure. You have people beating on your door and the inner structure knows it and will not move to compensate in training or comptime or travel or . . . Don't dance to the music. Move on. The relationship is damaged. If you can afford financially to move on, you can always come back. Don't burn any bridges. They need only to know that you are departing to seek greater advancement. Keep smiling and be the hot shot you know you are!!! jd

by rclark2

A lot depends on how large the company is and if they can afford to have over qualified techs hanging around. It's very challenging when you are so close to the edge that you feel you have to justify your existance every hour of every day. I won't live like that anymore. Been there, done that, and it is a grind. So for me, I will work for companies large enough to afford the best in the industry. I may not be the best, but I generally save the company many times over my salary every year. As long as that continues to be true, I'm not over priced and they can pay up even if I'm not always doing what my job description calls for. Some times they need janitors and if that is what they need, we all grab mops. Sometime they need managers, and I manage. Sometimes they need a systems implementor and then I shine. But I still know how to do all the other things that got me where I am, and I will do what ever they need. They are paying the fiddler, so they can call the tune.

You need to provide value for the salary you recieve. If either side of the equation is out of balance, then you won't have a future in that position.

To combat your boredom in the position, use the time to grow your skill sets. Nobody knows everything, and everyone can learn something. You have a golden opportunity to expand your usefulness to the company. If you are not worth your salary now, perhaps with growth, you will be.

If the situation is too lopsided, and it is bothering you, go to your supervisors and discuss the situation with them. Perhaps they have plans that include you and they are waiting for parameters to align before making changes.

Perhaps they are waiting for you to step up to the plate and ask for more responsibility. Maybe they really need more from you but are unwilling to change your relationship until you show you are willing to shoulder the responsibility.

Or it may be that they are just nice people who hired you and while they realize they made a mistake, they are willing to live up to their responsibilities. If this is the case, at some point you will need to move on. Doing otherwise would be taking advantage of their good nature.

So use the time to grow, start looking around for something that will be a better fit for your skill sets, and by all means, sock away a rainy day fund. You won't always come up smelling like a rose, and your next move may be the opposite of this one. Karma has a way of balancing out.

by midniteone

the courtesy in your reply does you credit - and even if it did come over as a little stylised, it's a shame that we should wind up commenting on something which once upon a time we might have taken for granted. you maybe take the response a little personally - we're all old and cynical, that's what it is.

I'm not going to get into a rant about young people and bad language (etc etc etc) but it is noticeable how terse and abrupt much of our communications have become. it's all info and impact and no time for anything which might be perceived as decoration or irrelevance.

considering how little emails cost to send, it's strange how we're so miserly with the things - you'd think we were paying by the word.

(of course, the time preparing them in a safe and lawsuit-proof way is something else again...(!))

This discussion is closed to new replies.