Time for a gas tax
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by tonythetiger
[i]Your government - and mine and everyone else's - is charged with a lot of high-level duties, such as defence, that you don't seem to object to.[/i]
I don't object to government spending that benefits all equally... defense and infrastructure management. Spending that benefits one citizen above another is against our constitution, and those who misspend it should be criminally prosecuted.
[i]They are also charged with prudent fiscal management and any examination suggests that the US is spending far, far too much on buying in oil and that[/i]
You're confusing the "They" who are (should be) charged with prudent fiscal management, with "the US". One is the government, the other is the citizens, who have the liberty to be as prudent as they desire and can afford.
by tonythetiger
[i]What Honda are you driving that only takes 2 or 3 people?[/i]
It'll seat 4 (uncomfortably) and gets 25 mpg. So it will use more gas on two trips than the navigator will with one. In that example, punishing the navigator owner is disingenuous.
by jamesrl
But any "public" company, that is a company that is owned by shareholders and whose stock is traded at a public exchange has to provide audited figures every year of the make up of their investors.
Between mutual funds,penion funds, insurance companies etc., most public companies are owned by people like you and me, just not directly. They are called institutional investors - people who buy on behalf of someone else.
The number of shares someone owns is less relevant than the percent of the company they own. 500,000 shares out of how many in total?
James
by tonythetiger
[i]sounds like a job for a Gas Tax[/i]
the gas tax is traditionally used to build and maintain roads, and with the increase in alternative fueled vehicles as well as more efficient ones, will leave less revenues. More fair in my opinion is a weight/distance formula.
by jck
The Navigator is a "full-size SUV", and the Civic is a "coupe" or "sedan".
The example I gave you was a Navigator vs. a Honda Pilot.
Both are SUVs.
The Pilot gets better gas mileage, seats more people, and would require the same number of trips with 6 people and use approximately 20% less fuel doing so.
Hence, what justifies using something like a Lincoln Navigator vs a Honda Pilot, when the Honda has distinct mileage, passenger capacity, and price advantages?
That is what I am driving at. There are alternatives that make more sense economically, environmentally, and ergonomically.
Hence why I have issues. Most people buy the Navigator or Hummer or Escalade solely for a vane status symbol. Not as a vehicle to perform the things they need to do in their lives...but singly as a symbol of how much they can spend.
But, that's the gluttony and vanity and self-indulgence that's become so commonplace and often accepted/tolerated in America today.
by jdclyde
wow, you must really have gotten screwed at some point to have your intense hate for companies.
Why is it smart business to give an Exec blocks of stock? They have a vested interest in the company doing well, which is good for EVERYONE in the company, including jealous/angry programmers at the bottom.
Not to mention, stocks are better for signing bonus than cash also because it keeps the money IN the company, another good thing for the company.
Look past your jealousy to the big picture.
by tonythetiger
[i]Someone wants to drive that 9mpg Hummer...let em think of it...while they're paying $350 a tank for gas :)[/i]
They buy more gas than you do, so they pay more. They pay more taxes than you do (including fuel taxes) so they pay even more. But that's not enough... no amount will be enough to suit you. As long as they're a little higher on the hill than you are, you will claw and scratch at them trying to knock them down.
It's clear that the green-eyed monster has a firm grasp on you...
by tonythetiger
is a drop in the bucket.
[i]And, that was in 2004 and about 2% of the total held shares in the corp at that time.[/i]
and the other 98% was ????
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
That's teh most retarded and insanely inaccurate statement to make teh forums on TR. What an absolutely ignorant and unqualified comment.
In essence you have just called most Europeans stupid and that they don't know what's good for them, that they need to government to fix everyything etc. That is SO far off base it's not even partially amusing. Europe as a nation and th epeople of that nation are actually light years ahead of us in Canada or the USA. They make us look so backward its not funny, we are simply a bunch of dullards who can't get our heads around fighting for freedom in order to enjoy the freedom and the world we already have. Americans are ignorant, wasteful, irresposible and living in the dark ages with their heads underground in comparisson to the advanced, energy resourceful nation that Euope has become.
You can only hope to be as astute as them, actually there is no hope you'll never get that far in your wee lifetime.
yoru entire posts reeks of 110% ignorance.
In that exact same sense, Americans are all warmongering retards who invade other countries illegally for their own personal gains.
Nice how blankets can be appied. isn't it?
Don't be so f'kin stupid!
by jck
[i]wow, you must really have gotten screwed at some point to have your intense hate for companies.[/i]
Everyone has been screwed by a company. Just some are used to taking up the bum or maybe like it.
[i]Why is it smart business to give an Exec blocks of stock? They have a vested interest in the company doing well, which is good for EVERYONE in the company, including jealous/angry programmers at the bottom.[/i]
I wasn't a staff programmer at the bottom, I was a hired contractor who wrote the system their TEAM couldn't.
Also, many CEOs don't have a vested interest in the company doing well as a whole. They have a vested interest in meeting their CONTRACTUAL GOALS. Big difference. I can be a CEO and have a goal of meeting a 11% profit increase, but lay off 300 people to meet that goal and short supply my need for manpower.
Is that good for the company? Not if you need to get things done. But, that's how a lot of deals work in the corporate world. Of course, that's the fault of a Board of Directors for setting goals in a manner that is irresponsible.
Cases in point:
Harris Corporation under Phil Farmer: laying off 600+ at Christmas 1994 to meet a goal to get a personal $3M bonus, then later selling off Lanier Office Equipment - their largest profiting arm
Sunbeam corporation under "Chainsaw" Al Dunlap: laying off hundreds,selling off manufacturing arms all to bring in short term income to get large bonuses...but almost killing off the corporate brand as a whole.
[i]Not to mention, stocks are better for signing bonus than cash also because it keeps the money IN the company, another good thing for the company.[/i]
Answer this please, jd:
What happens to the value of a corporation's shares whenever they issue new shares to a corporate officer, or the bottom line when they buy back current shares to give to that corporate officer?
And please, if you can, explain to me how that process benefits the bottom line of a corporation or it's share value when you give an executive large numbers of shares in addition to paying them large salaries, and often cash signing bonuses and guaranteeing them large "golden parachute" retirements?
[i]Look past your jealousy to the big picture.[/i]
I have no jealousy. I am paid quite well.
Look past your piety.
Just because someone is at the top doesn't mean they are worthy of being overlooked by scrutiny.
And just because someone is in IT and doesn't agree with contemporary corporate practices doesn't mean they are a jealous bottom-feeder.
And just remember: It's not "anti-company"...it's "pro-responsibility" ;)
says that - up until the advent of the $4 US gallon, the rich bought the bigger cars. That's the way it's always been in the US and that's the way it's always been here and even at $8 US per gallon, we have plenty of people who seem willing to afford it. Because we have swingeing petrol taxes, I'm less bothered about our gas-guzzlers. There's a lot fewer of them as well AND what makes a gas-guzzler in the UK would probably be a mid-sized in the US.
NOW the sh:t has hit the fan, the US is struggling with a car industry that can't cope with the change - not that it could cope particularly well before.
As far as I can find out your gasoline tax is around 57c per gallon so the majority of the cost of your gas is "real". I reckon that you're f*cked. given that this has been coming straight at us both for the last few years as China and India ramped up, I don't have a lot of sympathy. A gas tax a few years ago would have limited demand and reduced the big car dependency in the US and you'd have a less traumatic time of it than you are having. You are the richest country in the world and they are your "poor" so you sort it. I'm done with suggestions.
:)
by jck
With what I get paid at my new job, I can afford a Hummer...or a Navigator...or an Escalade...or a Mercedes-Benz. Thank you very much.
Fact is, I drive a Kia. Why? It was all I needed to get around, be able to haul things, be safe, etc. Did I need a Navigator? No. So why get one? I didn't.
Most people get things they don't need. People are self-indulgent and pious and stuck on "look at what I got" rather than using some sensibility and not caring a flip about what their neighbor thinks about their car, house, spouse's looks, etc.
It's all about self-indulgence and gratification...rather than responsibility and common sense.
And if you can't see that, then I feel sincerely sorry for you.
by tonythetiger
[i]Hence, what justifies using something like a Lincoln Navigator[/i]
that anyone has to "justify" anything to you.
That's just another part of your entitlement mentality.
Answer the other question: Should you be "allowed" to have more children, since that will also cause more pollution?
by jck
[i]and the other 98% was ???? [/i]
Not the 98.5% total you suggested?
by jck
You assume I have children. I don't.
And again, it's not entitlement or anything else. It's called responsibility. To yourself, your kids, your planet, your neighbor.
As I said, I feel sorry for you. Go drive what you want, drink what you want, and do what you like. It's your planet, and since you wanna spend your money that way go do it...even if it is ruining things for others.
I think I'll forego kids now. I don't want them being brought into a world like this.
by tonythetiger
You need to reduce demand NOW. By all means go and drill anywhere you want. What's Alaska to me? Don't waste it though because when it's gone, it's really gone this time. Forever. And you want to burn it up pushing two tons of steel box around? And, I might add, a box that has the aerodynamic capabilities of a brick.
What you seem to want is to reduce the price by having more US-sourced oil although there's not any guarantee that the price will drop much even if you DO drill more. China and India aren't finished yet.
by jck
that 2-pack box of Cheerios I got at Sam's Club means I am just a heathen. It was heavier than a single pack box, and that wasted fuel. Bad me.
My dining habits and other things are really just a real detriment to the world around you, aren't they?
You're so right. You win. I am scum and you're are social perfection.
I'll go sell my Kia now and get a Hummer and buy a really big boat that burns lots of unclean exhaust and leave all the lights on in my house. I wanna fit in with your idea of acceptibility.
I'm not given over to [i]ad hominem[/i] attacks and this is not one, this is what I really think of your last answer.
You are an idiot.
There are two possible motives for the answer that you gave concerning the responsibility of government in assuring sound fiscal management.
The first is that you really have your head stuffed THAT far up your own arse. I'd like to think that that is impossible.
The second is that you are just arguing for arguments sake. For a laugh. HA HA HA.
If you really consider that your government need do nothing to handle your appalling balance of payments and the current outpouring of US funds other than leave it to the Murrican Way and the Little Man and his Pioneer Spirit then all I can do is to reiterate my comment of a few posts ago. You're f*cked.
I'm done talking to you. Abs was right. Have a nice day.
:)
by jdclyde
sucking money out of the country is bad for our country, period.
If the oil were to be drilled/refined here, then it would be US workers making wages, and US companies generating income and paying taxes.
All things that are good for our country.
I don't believe it is supply causing the prices, so increased supply would not solve that issue. It DOES keep from sending money to countries that are global threats as a bonus.
People should continue to develope alternate fuels that are cleaner and cheaper, which would get people off of oil. If there is a profit to be made, people will develope it.
I hear people talking about global warming will effect us in 100/1000 years, what about NOW?
What will happen when all the batteries start dying in the hybrids?
What IS the life of these batteries?
Is the car junk because the batteries cost to much to replace?
How about disposal of the batteries?
What will the batteries be made of in a few years, and will THAT resource be the next on the list?
by jdclyde
the REAL "gas-guzzlers" are the big cars of 10 to 20 years ago. They are in the price range of the poorer people, so they drive them more.
Newer cars today still get better mileage than many from decades ago because of lighter materials.
My car is 11 years old and I kept track and am getting just over 40 mpg. My last car was a full size Concorde and it got about 33 mpg. Not all of our full size cars get 15 mpg like the pickups do. (heard new ones get about 20).
by jdclyde
People will do their job based upon the goals they are given.
Giving stock instead of cash is an attempt to get the CEO to work in the best interest of the company, and most now have a clause that they can not be sold for X number years to prevent short term increases at the expense of long term health of the company.
No, I have not been screwed over by a company because of "greedy" execs.
And no, not every CEO will make decisions in the best interests of the company.
look at the "little ford boy" that refused to take a wage until the company would turn a profit. Unlike you, I beleive there are more people out there trying to build lasting PROFITABLE companies than those destroying them.
This is the third and last time I will ask for a reasonable answer to this question:
The average size of the engine in a US domestic vehicle is exactly TWICE the average size of a European domestic vehicle. Why?
Neil :)
And, no, you don't drive more than Europeans and you don't carry more stuff than Europeans and you're not any bigger than Europeans (heavier, maybe but not taller).
No need to go to a Prius or an electric car. Just drive something with under 5 litres and under two tons. Could I suggest that 2 litres and 2,500 pounds with a properly engineered chassis (European designer, please, as we have bends in our roads so know what we're doing) would blow any SUV off the road. If even half of you did that, you'd be paying the Arabs and Chavez so much less. If you could get your grannies and your wives into 1.6l or even less, so much the better.
by jck
My first project here where I work now has already secured 3 contracts totally in the mid-six-figures...for one web-based application. And, it's designed to go open-interface to as many customers as want to use it over the internet.
How much money did your sole work bring into your company in your first 90 days there?
Even though I'm not my happiest here, I still do my job and do it DAMN well...thank you very much.
[i]Unlike you, I beleive there are more people out there trying to build lasting PROFITABLE companies than those destroying them.[/i]
I'm sure there are...and a lot of them would do over their own family or friends to do it too.
Oh well...you must be right since it's happening all over. I'm gonna change my mindset and join you and Tony in the self-indulgent lifestyle. I'm sure I'll love it.
by tonythetiger
but I am sure that CEO's and Navigators are not the problem in this country. They are merely the scapegoats.
[i]You assume I have children. I don't.[/i]
If not children, then something else that someone told you you couldn't do because it's affecting something else would get your goat... eventually.
[i]'ll go sell my Kia now and get a Hummer and buy a really big boat that burns lots of unclean exhaust and leave all the lights on in my house. I wanna fit in with your idea of acceptibility.[/i]
You still don't get it... It's not about how much you use...(Actually I think I'd probably be in the lower third of households of the same occupancy (8) in most related categories) ... it's about someone else deciding for you what you can buy, how much you can use, etc., and the fact that more than likely, the ones telling you are using several times that (Al Gore, Oprah, et al). If they can't "practice what they preach", how are we to really believe that what they're preaching is right?
And in reality, it's no different in the so-called Socialist or Communist societies... certain people have more power and influence than others... They just peddle it using units other than monetary ones (it was well known in many of the Soviet bloc countries, for example, that families with an older daughter could get more food and nicer lodgings by applying the "appropriate currency").
by jellimonsta
by jdclyde
the part of LASTING profitable companies?
NOT doing the short term gain and get out.
by jck
but, it still escapes me how...if someone makes money...they are freed from being responsible with it. i have plenty of money now, but does that mean i am free to do things without considering how it impacts others and the world itself?
if so, then i've missed a really important life lesson somewhere along the way about how to live right.
but i don't think you'll ever convince me that money in your bank is a ticket to do whatever you wish with it.
Even though I'm not impoverished, I'll stick to thinking more like a pauper.
I'd rather be humble and conservative with my materialism, than hubristic and superficial.
by jck
Because a CEO can just as easily start chopping up a company, like Chainsaw Al did at Sunbeam from day one, toward the end of his or her contract. Get big bonuses. Stock shoots up. They sell stock. Retire with golden parachute. Corporation feels the effect a year after their gone.
It's happened before. it will happen again.
Not all CEO's are real bungers. Guys like Kelleher at Southwest Airlines have done their corps right and prepared them to last. His management team's foresight of long-term fuel contracts is helping keep them profitable while other airlines are going down the tubes.
But, the majority of corporate execs are products of a system that now values a degree and a handshake and a good speech...over someone who has proven their worth and loyalty to their employer.
And, most of those people have no loyalty base in the company that hires them. They often are brought in from the outside by other execs or board members, and lined up to succeed those who bring them in.
So as I said before, it's really the fault of the Board...and corporate attorneys...to allow such agreements to be written.
But, the CEO who would do such things as people like Dunlap, Farmer, Corpan, Ley, etc., have done. Those people are low. They are the kind who ruin the company and its employees lives to feed their own need for perpetual personal gain at any cost to others.
by tonythetiger
by jck
My Kia is a 2L Inline-4
Aren't you proud of me? :)
by jamesrl
You know JCK, I do see lots of people that drive SUVs that never leave the city. They drive them to work, never have any passengers.
I'm sure many of them bought them for status. And I think they are fools for doing so, and I don't cry for them when they gas up.
On the other hand, I don't want to legislate their behaviour.
As I mentioned when we were talking about the same subject in a previous thread, its not only the vehicle, its the behaviour. Driving a beat up old out of tune full size mid 80s van uses more fuel than a brand new Hummer H3. So do I penalize the person who bought the image, or the person who fails to maintain their vehicle? Or do I just make the price of gas taxes reflect the cost of providing the roads?
I don't even agree with these eco-rebates my country is providing. The Honda Fit missed the rebate by 1 MPG, yet its probably a better choice for many drivers that the 2 passenger smart car(and it costs less). And I don't want my tax dollars subsidizing the people who can afford new cars(I can't afford a new car, why should may tax dollars pay for someone else's).
James
by ic-it
Domestic drilling isn't even necessary to produce millions more gallons per day. There is roughly 500,000 capped wells that are capable of producing that amount. Many were capped due to the depth of the oil and/or hard rock structures that are covering them. With 1/2 the current price of oil, these wells are again profitable. Companies in California and Midland Texas are taking advantage of this and are turning those wells into producers. Then there is also the talk that a lot of domestic capped wells have been capped simply to preserve the price of oil at peak levels (it also resulted into a development cost, thusly a write-off; another way to mask profits).
Gull island is also in the middle of controversy. It was initially drilled and found to be a huge deposit. Some claim the oil companies capped it for future profits; others claim it was the government. The last link will confuse us even more.
Here are a couple of links (many more available). The first also briefly mentions the microwave option.
http://www.carbonrecovery.com/Applications_Capped_Stripper_Oil_Wells.asp
http://rense.com/general82/gull.htm
http://americastops.com/gullisland.htm
http://www.state.ak.us/admin/ogc/orders/co/co300_399/co329add.htm
According to the U.S. Census Bureau, 46% of those defined as being in poverty in the U.S. own their own home (with the average poor person's home having three bedrooms, with one and a half baths, and a garage).
I withdraw my offer of sympathy...
by tonythetiger
[i]What will happen when all the batteries start dying in the hybrids?[/i]
They have to be replaced, and at least for the time being, it's expensive (like two or three thousand).
[i]What IS the life of these batteries?[/i]
In lead-acid days, you could get about 200 deep discharges (to 20%) before the batteries needed replacing. If you didn't discharge as much, you could get more discharges, and if you discharged deeper, not as many (I don't think it's linear. If you discharge to 10%, you might get 50, and if you only discharge to 50%, you might get 1,000). That could translate into a few years in town or a few months of long-distance driving.
Newer technologies probably improve on this significantly but I don't think any of them last forever. Most car makers warranty their batteries for 10 years or 100,000 miles, for example, so they'll probably last quite a bit longer.
[i]Is the car junk because the batteries cost to much to replace?[/i]
Is it junk if the motor blows up? There will probably be wrecked ones in the junk yard you could get used batteries from :)
[i]How about disposal of the batteries?[/i]
Mining new is probably much more expensive than recycling. They will be recycled, just as lead-acid batteries are now.
[i]What will the batteries be made of in a few years, and will THAT resource be the next on the list?[/i]
Who knows? The great thing though is that whatever it is, electricity is electricity, so it will be compatible :)
by jck
Yes, I do. I think we should get as many fuel-wasting, heavier-polluting passenger cars off the roads as possible.
It's never been just about Hummers, et.al for me. I just have a beef with the fact that someone who is poor does not have the choice of being able to buy a Prius (even used).
Someone who is buying a Hummer or Navigator...has the choice of buying something else more efficient and ecofriendly and which would actually give them more money for other things.
But evidently as a lot of people believe on here (unlike me), any money that you earn you have the right to spend it in any way you like so long as you won't get arrested. When it comes to spending, anything goes.
It seems that most think here that their personal right to choose whatever they want to spend their money on overrides everyone else's right to breathe cleaner air, and that it excuses them from any social responsibility to lower their fuel consumption to help lower the demand in this country which is supposedly driving gas prices up.
Why should they care? Right? They have it to spend. Who cares about anyone else?
But yes, I think if someone has (say for instance) a 1979 GMC extended van that runs horrible and gets 8MPG city and they have to fill the tank (say 40 gallons to be round) every 10 days (32 miles a day...reasonable?), then that costs them approx $480 per month in gasoline.
If they were to go buy a used 1995 Plymouth Voyager for about $1200-1500, they get 20 mpg city/ 24 mpg hwy. Say even for age it gets 16 city/ 20 hwy, they still double their mileage and save $240 per month which would more than pay for their car within a year and save them lots of money.
I think there are applications for large vehicle in the world, i.e.- mass transit, cargo transport, trade work operation, etc. But, I will see (and Floridians are REALLY bad about it) a retired couple riding around in a Navigator or Escalade.
You know they have no children living with them (especially when they come out of a 55+ community) to drive back and forth to events, they aren't using it for cargo, etc.
They generally get the thing for taking golf buddies in to the course, or taking friends to dinners, etc., about once a week. It's a status symbol; nothing more.
They could just as easily get a Kia Sorento or Isuzu Trooper or Mitsubishi Montero or Honda Pilot. But because it's a Lincoln, they feel accomplished in having bought something that cost $55,000 to impress their friends.
I say: Woop...tee...doo.
But, I'm in the minority evidently.
by delbertpgh
The fastest way to create more available fuel is to use less in the first place. And, unlike the straw Democrats you want to thrash, I (and most Dems, I bet) favor punching holes in the Alaskan sod and sucking out all the oil we can. But all the oil in the North Slope isn't going to last us for long. The U.S. alone uses 8 billion barrels a year. Might as well burn that caribou oil, but don't pretend it's some kind of permanent fix.
This conservation idea is real. It won't come without pain. Some guys in this forum seem to think that it's government's job to turn every stick into a carrot, that gas should be cheap forever, that we should all buy immense gunboat cars to feel like secret Marlboro men, ranchers who just happen to live temporarily in the suburbs, like we never ought to have to grow up or face the consequences of our choices.
I've got two cars in my family, because one of us works 200 miles away for part of the week. I had to get a bigger minivan than I wanted because of the boys and the dogs on trips, but it still gets twice the miles of a Ford Excursion. We drive the hell out of our Neon, using it whenever we can. I can't get away from cars; I live an American life. Still, we figure out how to sweat down our fuel budget. I never felt the urge to go buy three tons of steel to send my wife to the store in, so we don't have to dig ourselves out of that hole, and I'm sorry for people who are stuck with those monsters, but immense cars are not in the future.
Between 1978 and 1983, U.S. petroleum consumption dropped from 18.8 to 15.3 million barrels per day. The sky-high price that initiated that conservation also started dropping, because oil production soared and usage dropped, both in response to price. We could have, as a nation, acted in the national interest by passing laws and taxes to keep consumption low. Instead, the feel-good Reagan spirit said we should buy bigger and bigger cars and screw conservation. We did, and as of last December we used 20.9 million bbl/day. (www.eia.doe.gov/emeu/mer/petro.html) (Interestingly, it looks like we've cut daily use by about 1 million since then. Guess why.)
We won't get out of this cycle until we create alternatives, and we'll stay in it if we use the next price drop to just burn more gas. No investor will risk money on inventing large-scale alternative supplies unless it can be assured that an oil price collapse won't destroy its business model. We need a means of keeping motor fuel at three bucks a gallon, at least, no matter what comes. That means a tax.
by delbertpgh
"Democrats don't WANT us to be independent with our oil supply. Why would they INTENTIONALLY make us dependent on the Middle East?"
Well, I can't figure out why Democrats would want to make us dependent. No motivation I can see. Sounds like another Limbaugh lie, to help keep the Republican rank and file in their fantasy bubble.
What's true about it? Democrats have taken the lead in protecting the environment. Oil companies have some really careless and enormous mistakes in their history, like spills from the Santa Barbara offshore oil project. Drilling technology has gotten a lot better, and safety has improved, so probably a lot of production can happen today that was impossibly risky years ago. (Still doesn't explain how the Exxon Valdez wasn't trusted to an alcoholic captain, does it?)
What's a lie about it is that if we pumped everything we could find, we would not have enough to be independent. The country uses 8 billion barrels a year, and a hundred billion barrel field is not going to take us long into this century. In fact, since we have private companies selling into a world makret, we'll still see American oil bid up by traders for China, and companies won't drill American oil if they can drill Nigerian oil cheaper. Some of our resources are too expensive too exploit, unless there is confidence that oversupply won't drive the price down. You can't expect an oil company to willingly lose money, out of some patriotic duty. They're international, anyway; there is no such thing as a major "American" oil company now.
We technically don't need to pump or import a drop of oil; we've got huge resources in oil shale, oil that is mixed up in rock that can be surface-mined. We had a pilot refinery project going for a couple years in the 70s and 80s, but we shut it down. It would have cost something like $50 per barrel, in 1980 dollars, and world oil never got to those levels. It would have required a permanent government subsidy to be economical. In fact, it would have put this country at a competitive disadvantage if we had used it, because by 1996 world oil was down to 10 bucks, and if we had laws saying "American producers must use only American oil," then our goods would have been priced out of world markets.
The idea that we could all live on cheap oil drilled within our own borders is a happy fantasy. It would only work if we made it itllegal to export any U.S. oil or have it compete on international markets, and if U.S. industry could be sealed off from international competition.
by delbertpgh
The only immediate solution is to use less, and we're limited in how much we can squeeze down.
Big new oil fields will take ten years to come on line, maybe more. Nobody will develop them if they don't believe the price ten years out will support the cost of production. The ANWR Alaskan field could probably be brought up in less time.
Stuff like oil from algae farms will take years to become economical, and if a success, will still take years more to ramp up to multi-million-barrel-a-day volume. Nuclear power plants and wind or tidal power farms will take decades to displace oil usage. Battery-powered cars are only going to work if you can supply enough electricity (let alone workable batteries) to replace millions of barrels of energy; again, decades of change.
We've had decades to change since 1978. Looks like it would be smart to get started now, since the problem will just get worse. Or maybe some Republicans will get elected by convincing voters that it can be wished away.
by jck
Wind farms could be put up relatively quickly and brought online onto the grid within several weeks once constructed.
Thing is, no one wants a wind farm with 80-120 generation turbines within view of their house.
I'd love to see someone take initiative and put wind farms out in the hills and deserts in CA where all that wind is, as well as in the central plains near the rockies in remote locations where no one would complain.
At least, that'd be a good start to getting alternative power online and reducing fossil fuel use.
by jamesrl
I've been to Southern California and Alberta and they both have massive wind farms.
The ones in So Cal literally run for miles.
One of the objections to wind farms in Ontario isn't the visual, its the sound. These things do make noise and so have to be far from homes.
The regulations in Ontario are such that you can't have a home wind turbine in a city or suburb, mainly because of wind issues. You can buy small turbines for under $1000, but you need to make sure they are hundreds of feet from a house.
There was a recent case in Ontario of a farmer who spent $30,000 on a big wind turbine which provides much of the power his farm needs. Sometimes he needs more from the grid, sometimes he sells power back to the utility.
He was hit with a huge tax increase because he made an improvement to his property raising its value. He fought it, and now the government is working to fix this in regulations so that others won't run into this.
James
by jdclyde
There are plenty of people out there wishing to do that development, and the ONLY reason they are not is because Democrats have obstructed any and all progress of ANY energy independence.
Ted Kennedy opposing the wind farms comes to mind.
What is the SOLUTION, both for short term and long term, that is offered by the Democrats "rock star"? "use less"?
by ic-it
by delbertpgh
Charlie Christ announced he supports drilling for oil off the Florida coast. Guess his voters decided that the definite cost of gasoline was more important than the possible problem of oil spills.
I would bet that, Obama or McCain, you'll see more drilling under the next Pres.
by jck
What Americans call "own" sometimes comes with mortgage or loan involved.
Here, "i own..." usually means "my name is on the title of ..." instead of meaning "i own and have paid fully for...".
I own my car. I have a house. :)
by jamesrl
The target market for the plug in adapter kits that some people are making for Prius and other Hybrids are taregted at those who need to replace their batteries anyway.
http://consumerguideauto.howstuffworks.com/hybrid-batteries-none-the-worse-for-wear-cga.htm
This says Toyota claims no one has replaced the batteries yet due to wear out - some have after crashes. And The Prius was first sold in 2001.
James
by tonythetiger
[i]but, it still escapes me how...if someone makes money...they are freed from being responsible with it.[/i]
that allows people to sit on their asses on the public dole! It's under the equal protection clause. It is a constitutionally protected right to exhibit certain forms of stupidity :)
[i[Even though I'm not impoverished, I'll stick to thinking more like a pauper.[/i]
Liberty allows you that right too.
by jck
lawmakers have to design things for themselves and people on their intellectual level.
Ever wish to have friendly aliens come pick you up and get you off the planet so that in 30 years you won't have to suffer with the rest of the masses?
I have. Damn aliens haven't showed up yet. lol ;)
by jamesrl
One of the reasons government regulation doesn't work is that people find ways around it. Witness the CAFE regulations - they caused the SUV craze because the regs didn't apply to trucks, and even car based minivans and SUVs were classified as trucks and exempt from the CAFE fuel economy standards.
Similarly, since fuel prices went up, our police have done more spot checks and have discovered that truckers are buying diesel from farmers - who are exempt from many fuel taxes. They can tell because the farm tax free diesel is dyed pink.
James
by jck
You might have to switch to English mode, but that's the kind of vehicles I think will make the difference. Inexpensive, efficient, and environmentally friendly.
by jdclyde
by jdclyde
As I said before, I believe it is unethical and our of the scope of what Government is intended to do, to use taxes as a punishment to FORCE people to stop using a product.
None of the global warming hype or the "we will run out of oil" hype will change that.
I have been hearing since before I could drive that we would run out of oil in 10/20 years. 30 years later, we are STILL going to run out of oil in 10/20 years. Heard it all before.
If you and other like minded people wish to lead the way in moving off of oil, that will reduce demand AND provide the alternative. Better get started.
by delbertpgh
Anybody with borrowing power will dump his big egomobile for something that gets 30 mpg or better, whether new or used. Used car lots will fill up with huge SUVs, and the price will get marked down and down. Finally, they will be the only things cheap enough for Beavis and Butthead or Pablo and Miguel to afford... but naturally they won't be replacing tires or repairing brakes, because they'll be pouring every penny into the gas tank.
And to think so many people bought these hulking monsters so that their wives would be safer in them.
by tonythetiger
[i]Damn aliens haven't showed up yet.[/i]
Maybe they have.....
by tonythetiger
[i]but naturally they won't be replacing tires or repairing brakes, because they'll be pouring every penny into the gas tank.[/i]
Maybe they'll live in them...
by jamesrl
You don't have to wait that long....
You can already find lots of SUVs and pickups on craigslist and in used car lots. New pickups are practically being given away - some of them a third off their original MSRP.
James
by jdclyde
it goes right down party lines.
As for Jeb, he HAS to suck up to the wishes of the locals that always say "not in MY back yard", but still want SOMETHING to be done.
China is going to be drilling out there, regardless of if we do or not.
by jdclyde
by jdclyde
A certain political party over here likes to break people into sub groups and talk about groups instead of individuals.
That is why it is always tax cuts for "the rich" that are demonized, while lowlifes turn around and give a tax "rebate" that is MORE than some people paid in the first place.
The bigger the group we can call poor, the more people will go to the group looking for people with their hands out instead of the group that removes obstacles to allow YOU to go out and be successful.
People that Feel instead of THINK.
Directly from Obama's web site that his mindless drones all want.
[i]
Obama will cut income taxes by $1,000 for working families to offset the payroll tax they pay.[/i] Why not cut the payroll tax if it is to high?
He has also said he plans to make a more equal distribution of money..... take from people that work and give to people that don't.
by ic-it
No one in Florida that has supported off-shore drilling has ever been elected there. If he gets the VP nod, he wont have to worry about re-election, but that may swing Florida to the Dems. :-)
McCain seems to forget that by leaving drilling options up to each State, a spill will often affect other coastal States.
NJ Republicans do not want off-shore drilling. Arnie does not want off-shore drilling.
Let's look at the history for a bit;
Congress imposed the drilling moratorium in 1981 and has extended it each year since by prohibiting the Interior Department from spending money on offshore oil or gas leases in virtually all coastal waters outside the western Gulf of Mexico and in some areas off Alaska.
President George H.W. Bush imposed a separate executive drilling ban in 1990, which was extended by President Clinton and then by the current president until 2012.
Hmm, doesn't seem like it was just the Dems.
If you want to point a finger, consider Reagan and the Rep. controlled Congress, relaxing of the CAFE rules in the mid-80's.
And both parties for the lack off encouraging developing alternatives between 1973 and now.
Of course no blame could go to the current administration, the war, and the millions of gallons it cost to carry out the mission. Let alone the favorable opinion and concerns the world has because of our actions. /sarcasm off.
by tonythetiger
[i]The fastest way to create more available fuel is to use less in the first place.[/i]
but our (US) population is increasing by a million every 4 or 5 months!
Some might ask why they should be asked to reduce their demand (by consuming less) when others aren't doing anything to reduce demand (by wearing a condom!). Be careful when preferring one's rights over another's... such are the things that breed resentment and violence.
by tonythetiger
[i]Well, I can't figure out why Democrats would want to make us dependent[/i]
Dependence breeds more dependence. Their hope is that we'll all turn to the elite and wise (that means THEM) for all of our needs, because everybody knows us poor hillbillies just don't have the mental capacity to handle our own affairs. Why, Lyndon Johnson himself sent thousands of welfare workers to the hills to sign us up. Some made it back. Some had accidents and were eaten :)
[i]The idea that we could all live on cheap oil drilled within our own borders is a happy fantasy.[/i]
That's true enough, but the presence of and the willingness to use (and more importantly sell!) our own oil will "encourage" the market to lower it's price.
by tonythetiger
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending