Discussion Locked

To negotiate or not negotiate; is it a question any more?

0 helpful
24 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I was recently offered a contract with a government IT solution provider. I agreed with the salary and benefit package they offered me. However, one of the recruiters sent an email to all the successful candidates stating the contingent letter would be mailed out to each candidate. The email exposed all the emails for each candidate and what followed was a thread on how the company "low-balled" everyone's position. Now they want to negotiate a higher base salary - which I feel is a losing cause since it is an accept or reject situation. One of the members sent an email back to the recruiter asking if the director would entertain an increase. My thought is that there is no negotiation; it is an accept or reject offer, the company can find workers that would be willing to work for the said amount. Last I looked, it was an employer's market. What does the majority of the Tech Republic community think?

24 replies

by jrod86

I agree that it is an employer's market, but you still have to ask yourself, "why did they hire me?" If you are a competent IT professional, then maybe an increase would be ok. I was caught in the same situation two years ago. 30 people applied for the job I got so I felt pressured into accepting the offer immediately because I knew the 29 other people would snatch the job in a heartbeat.

Negotiation is always tough in my mind.

by jamesrl

Is preferrably before the offer, or worse case, when you receive the offer. Once you have accepted the offer in writing, it it too late.

If you haven't signed off on the offer, you can try. But you do risk having the offer recinded. But in my personal experience, this doesn't happen - usually they will either counter or re-iterate the original offer.

A lot depends on where you are in your career. I didn't negotiate at my last job because at the time it was definately an employer's market. Its been 18 months and the market has turned around in many areas, but it depends on geography and your particular skillset as to whether or not you are in the "hot" skills group.

James

by edglock21

I had to reject a job offer from a friend - it was hard. I was diplomatic and let him know that I was really looking for a job in my field and was going to stick to that.

Well, I did get a job in IT and have moved up quite nicely since I started. It all depends on your personal situation though.

You can always take that job and continue your search. If something else comes along, tell them that you had interviewed for both jobs around the same time and the other place has now made you a better offer. If you're working out well with the contractor, the may counter-offer to keep you.

by dggraham

James is absolutely correct about the timing. It is especially true when dealing government or public sector entities. I'm currently working for a government agency and have seen the department make a low offer in hopes that it get a good deal. It will negotiate and make a better offer, but only in advance of acceptance. Once you agree on you should stand by the contract.

by quantumetrics

I strongly feel that it is less and less an employers' market; this trend is reversing, as it inevitably does, especially with the latest burst of punctuated equilibrium in technology development. Over the next year, skill set requirements are going to take a big jump upward as new, attractive technology becomes available for platform expansion and re-design that many companies are going to see as mission-critical. Consultants who have already soaked up these new skills will be able to name their price.

by dinotech

Isn't the supply of qualified IT personnell outweigh the demand? The last job I applied for was in 2004 for a Help Desk Specialist. There were over 2000 applicants who applied for that position. At the time, I didn't have my A+, and I would bet top dollar that was one of the reasons why I didn't get an interview. However, I cannot see the number of applicants changing much. Are you saying that IT professionals are being employed in the last quarter where the demand outweighs the supply? If that is the case, then negotiating could be a factor. However, there is still the off-shore outsourcing - recently, I read that there have been some management problems with this type of outsourcing, but it still is a factor nonetheless. So if a company can get cheaper labor for its IT projects, then what good would negotiation be?

by jamesrl

If you are an SAP specialist with a couple of implementations behind you, the demand is pretty high and the supply is low, you can pretty much name your price.

On the other help desk techs are not in high demand due to outsourcing, and supply is high.

James

by tony hopkinson

so much as no tech for a considerable amount of time and a lot of it put in by numbwits on the end of the last boom. The market is turning in the UK though.

by sjohnson175

IMO true developers are born, not taught and the industry is rife with system put in by those not born to the craft.

by rb_itprofessional

Yep, the market is indeed changing. I'm noticing here in NC, that it is increasingly becoming more of an employee market. In fact, I heard my boss the other day discussing with another manager that they are having a really hard time finding and keeping IT Contractors. These days, contractors are getting multiple job offers and can be selective. This wasn't the case a couple of years ago.

by thomastri

Are you willing to do all that is required for this salary? Chances are you willo have to do more than is required, there are swome jobs I will not except for under $25 per Hr.If you qualify and is hungrytake the job and ask is there a chance for advancment and if so how long does it take to get promoted. Talk to people about the work enviroment is it stressful or laid back all this constitutes what is acceptable.

by dinotech

I have accepted the offer from the company. My question was posed as some of the other candidates have started a bidding war with the company expecting to gain a higher salary. I doubt I will be seeing any of them at the start date of the contract, which is in October of this year. It is sad that people don't want to prove themselves but expect to get paid the money because of their time in the industry. My view is that you start at a base level with ANY new company and prove yourself first. Your peformance will speak louder than any pre-employment negotiating ever will.

by itengineerguy

I believe you negotiate upfront before you accept the offer. If they understand your skills going in and what you bring to the table they will consider your offer and pay you what your worth going in.. Meaning get what you can upfront. My experience its harder to get what you deserve later. Especially if finances are tight for the company.

by tony hopkinson

with pimps, you may be right there may be more money of offer, that doesn't mean you are going to get it though. I guarantee the pimps will get theirs plus whatever hike one of you manages to get. Does your prospective employer know about this, if I was them or you for that matter I'd be livid.

by jellimonsta

In the position I recently moved to I imagined there would have been some serious competition as it is a great company.

However, they offered me the position at the top of their salary range which they were unable to negotiate.

In its place I simply negotiated additional vacation time. If you feel you were pretty solid in the position offer, perhaps benefits are something extra you could negotiate?

However, I would not let 'the green eyed monster' ruin the opportunity if it is something worth while. Let the other guys negotiate themselves out of the position. IMHO.

by bfilmfan

You have a decision to make and then 2 courses of action.

If you want the job, email the recruiter requesting a personal meeting. Print out the email chain. When you arrive for the meeting, drop the email chain on the recruiter's desk and say, "My current and only acceptable rate is XYZ $ and that is for a XYZ length no-fire contract, which states that if I am released for any reason, I shall be paid for the entire length of the contract."

Should they not agree, look them in the eye and say, "Sir, you've broken several laws concerning the hiring of federal government contractors in regards to privacy information which could be viewed as as a security risk. As I am sure you aware this could have very negative impacts for the organization and the persons involved as there could be potential civil and criminal penalties for the release of this information." Then shut up till they make you an offer.

Scenario two is that you immediately contact the General Accounting Office, Office of Personnel Management and whichever agency they are performing this work for. Trust me that government agencies do not think that releasing personal information on candidates to anyone but investigation agencies is a laughing matter.

If this is a state agency, I'd check with your local controlling agency, which can vary. Most states take a dim view of this kind of behavior.

Note that if your Soecial Security number was released, they are immediately afoul of the HIPAA law, as your medical data could be exposed. In California, 1798.29 and 1798.82 - 1798.84 all state that you may not release certain information on persons.

Frankly, I would advise you to have no dealings with such an unprofessional organization and move immediately to scenario 2.

by dinotech

I am not seeking any action against the company. It was an honest mistake to expose the email addresses. But that is all that was exposed. The candidates took it upon themselves to create a thread stating the offer was lower than the median salary for that area. No additional data was release, and I was looking for opinions about the art of negotiation and how this particular scenario would be seen by the members of Tech Republic. My opinion is that it is an unprofessional way of dealing with any company. But I do agree that the recruiter needed to think before submitting the email about the exposed addresses. There are ways to hide them and most of them is easy. I know of the Bcc...can anyone share any other ideas of how not to send addresses in a broadcast email?

by jeffersnet

It will depend on your email client and system but sometimes it is possible to use a group instead of bcc that will not show each email address. I think that in some systems a group would show the members but not in all systems.

I really think the market has turned for IT support that has to be on site but I don't think it has turned yet for programmers or others who can work from any location. The market really does change from location to location but not as much as some people think.

by dmambo

I've tried a couple of time to negotiate more vacation time as I started a position. In each case, I just stated that I would want to start with 3 weeks vacation, and each time I was promptly shot down. I'm sure there must be a better way to go about it. As far as salary, I always thought that asking for more would have the same result. Maybe before the offer is made is the right time, but then you have to be careful not to price yourself out of contention.

Thoughts??

by prefbid ii

To effectively negotiate, you must put your desires into 3 categories.
1 - Things I must have before I take this job, otherwise it is not worth it. Normally, this is what you are currently making now.
2 - Things that I would really like, but would be willing to trade for other things.
3 - Things that would be great to get if I can swing it. Make sure that you still feel qualified to do the kind of work this package states. Companies that offer this know that they pay well and are more than willing to accept turnover if they don't get what they think they are paying for.

Preferably, write your list before starting your job search. If you get offered a "less than #1" package or a #1 package, counter with a #2. If you get offered #2, counter with #3. If you get offered #3 -- take the job and don't haunt yourself with scenarios of what you might have been able to get; you probably would not have gotten them and you would have insulted a generous offer.

If on the counter-offer you are still less than #1, stand firm at #1 and don't take the job if they won't give you what you are asking for.

For all other scenarios, assume that anything offered on the 2nd go around is a "best and final" (unless you are negotiating an executive salary).

The key here is to recognize when the company is likely to be insulted and when they are not. A company that knows it is offering average wages and benefits is not going to be insulted if someone asks for some more. They may not be willing to change their offer, but you won't be insulting them. If you are offered an attractive package and you counter, then they will assume you are fishing - will be insulted and may (though not likely) withdraw the original offer.

by dinotech

What I mean by this is the benefits MUST be taken into consideration for the compensation. Most people look at the cash compensation not realizing that the benefits also come with a price to the employer - and sometimes a price to the employee. To look at the cash compensation only is to sell yourself short; the benefits must be competitive. I would take a lower salary with an awesome benefits package. So if my median salary is 47k and I take a job at 37k cash, the benefits must be worth 10k or more to me.

by khadaji

In today's culture of "lean" companies, people are expected to do more for less to companies can increase their profits. The culture is significantly different than what it was "back in the day" where people were often rewarded. In my experience companies are running leaner, and therefore it's harder to get what you're worth after your hired. Especially if you're hired far below your actual worth just to get a job and put meat on the table. Just my $.02!!!

by dinotech

That is the key point here. The interviews lasted a whole 30 minutes and the deciding factor was basically what have you done for the majority of your career. If they were interested in negotiation, the interview would have lasted longer and more information would have been sought. As I said before, this was an accept or decline offer. And I think my point is still being missed here: I have accepted my offer and plan on peforming to the best of my ability. It is the other candidates that have chosen a bidding war with the company. The company has declined any increase in pay.

by marionuke

to wright your own ticket you have to specailize in something in high demand as someone said before help desk just isn't in that high of demand.. kinda sucks to be a help desk tech anyway..

but anyways you have to specailise in something that everyone needs then you'll be in a great position to negotiate

Guess what the number one money maker is...

Data recovery. and Data recovery is pretty easy with the right tools and you can charge company's thousands of dollars just to get there lost data back :)

and those guys are right I've looked into goverment positions and i hate how if you aren't a private contracter for the army or something you get constantly lowballed.. Oh well whatcha gonna do....

This discussion is closed to new replies.