Discussion Locked

To VISTA or NOT to VISTA that is the question.

0 helpful
125 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am a MS professional and I must admit I am confused. When I am confused (after 20 years in the business) I am confident that my clients are as well and they are asking my opinion of VISTA. I have read most of the marketing materials and I have done some testing of the Pre-Release version.

For the record my Company does not install new-new OS's with out extensive testing and experience using them. It's just not good for our reputation to do so, and risk anomalies and client down time. But VISTA has been so long in the making I want to keep an open mind.

The recent PC mag test results and reviews are mixed and not as positive as I would have expected. Apparently MS choose to leave out some capabilities which were in the original design concept, not sure what these are though.

XP works great and runs with reliabialities up in the high 90's and supports everything most business customers need.

I was wondering how the Tech Republic community fees at this time.

125 replies

by tony hopkinson

is to get our software running under vista. So were are currently starting to set up some boxes, see what problems we get both with our products and our development tools to make it.

Know for a fact we'll get some on things like using the registry and system directories (old code base). Then there's no longer using MSDE ....

The only reason we are doing it because we expect at some point our customers to get conned I mean persuaded into buying it at PC World or some such.

Oh and we'll be starting doing this standalone, our IS department won't allow a vista box to be connected into our network at the moment as they can't support it.

Investigate by all means, but if you don't have to implement it yet, don't.

by w2ktechman

on one system. But I try not to use it often, not because it fails, but because I am trying to avoid moving to or using Vista.

But to MS, the system has given me little trouble other than re-learning how to use a computer the way I want to. The drivers for the current system I am using are all workign fine, no issues there. There are issues with many apps that I use, so, like I said, I avoid using this system when I can get away with it, so I go to the XP box.
The main things to point out to people when they ask about it is

You should wait for the service pack release to fix many bugs that may be found
waiting will also allow more SW and Drivers to be developed and tested for the OS
AND
Expect to train employees how to use it. Although most features that they will use are not affected, some are. Also, the IT staff will need some time to review it well and learn how to troubleshoot it properly.

by rpatton1

That has always been my practice, but i thought MS had really teseted the heck out of this one.

by tanimn

An old tried and true mantra with microsoft operating systems: If it's not the second service pack (whether it's SR2, SP1A, etc...), it's not time to upgrade.
Besides giving Microsoft time to fix the bugs in the origional release, and stabilize all the bugs that crop up with the first service pack; it gives the driver and app developers time to get their stuff running right.
How many times have YOU installed Microsoft's latest and greatest, only to find out that your favorite whatever doesn't work right anymore?

by dawgit

Where did you get ahold of a Vista Business in any verison? I haven't seen it at all over here. (They're talking end-of-the-month, maybe) That is the question, will it perform in a business enviorment. It's still a big unkown. (along with the "Why" question.) -d

by w2ktechman

I had to download it to test with from an Intranet site, pre-configured of course.

Didnt I mention in the past several times that the company that I work for are MS bitches???

by sjh_vt

These are very worthwile subscription services that have had Vista RTM available almost as soon as it went Gold. Technet is geared towards support & MSDN is geared towards developers.

by jmgarvin

Non-technial:
I can tell you user training will be a nightmare. Even with the "classic" view Vista will be very different to your average user. Also, your average user will be lost because small things have changes. My Documents is gone and it is replaced with their user name. The start menu interface (in aero glass) shoved shutdown into obscurity and you only put your PC into standby with the "off" button.

Just tons of little things that will add up and make the job of working a helpdesk a real pain.

Technical:
I have noticed issues in getting it to properly connect to AD. Also, the new network stack is faster, but word on the street is there are some interesting holes in the new stack, so expect security issues pretty soon. Also because Vista does both IPv6 and IPv4, expect a LOT of network traffic when you are setting up clients as well as in the morning when everyone fires up. I hope you don't have much in the way of legacy hardware. Drivers in Vista are ok, but it depends on the vendor and the hardware as to how well the driver works. I popped Vista Business (release) on a 2.8ghz, 1gb RAM, 128mb ATI X900 video card and scored a 2.7 out of 5. My machine is pretty beefy, but it is sluggish with Aero Glass. I installed the ATI driver and everything went pear shaped...

As for code base and such. If you are using .Net 1.1, most stuff will have issues. .Net 2.0 does ok, but be prepared for some code changes and the way the APIs work in Vista.

Will Vista be picked up on release? No. I think it will sell like the Zune...average to below average sales with nothing to write home about from the average user. I don't see many businesses picking up Vista before SP1 and I really don't see Vista being an easy migration.

by cg it

Many mfgs will tell you that they aren't going to release Vista drivers until Vista is release. Many of the old equipment that is still in use will either not work or require new drivers that the mfg might or might not create.

I advise my customers to wait.

Going to Vista might require the purchase the new printers, scanners, faxes, modems, that business use which are older if mfgs don't create drivers that will work with Vista.

by rpatton1

Most of my customer are lawyers and like most people they don't like spending money if it's not required.

I had a difficult time getting them off Windows 98 and on to XP, but most spent the money because they ware so frustratedd with 98's problems.

Those were the good days, new machines, faster printers, new server, and all those software upgradess. Hmm... how often can we go to that well?

by rpatton1

After a grueling week of intense Vista RTM testing, I still can't get Vista stable on my primary computer yet even though I've swapped out all the bad memory. This same PC has worked with and continues to work with Windows XP just fine. Even with the good memory in the computer, it locks up every hour or two and forces me to hard shut the system to reboot. Apparently I'm not the only one with stability issues since reader DAC-Tech who's a Systems Engineer with a big company was having issues with his brand new ASUS based motherboard.

I've informed Microsoft almost a week ago of this along with all the other nagging issues I list below and I have not heard back from them. If Microsoft wants to clarify anything in this blog they're always welcome to do so and I'll put their responses on this blog. My other server that I built out of scrap parts laying around is stable but there are still too many issues for me to want to use Vista. The way it stands now, I can't or won't use Vista on any of my computers full time until these serious issues have been fixed. Here is a list of grievances that I tested on my stable Vista system and some of these bugs were pointed out in my RC2 review.

DVD playback in Windows Medial Player or Media Center will only play in interlaced mode making it VERY ugly.
If I replace the MPEG-2 DVD codec with K-Lite Cinepack codec, the interlacing issue goes away but it conflicts with Media Player's translucent controls and delivers low frame rates with slow screen paints that are especially noticeable when the entire screen on the video moves. Windows Media Player Classic will work smoothly though it forces Aero to shut down temporarily and it can only play one file at a time making in impractical for full DVD movie playback. I'm not sure if the slow playback has something to do with the inability of an old codec to paint an Aero 3D screen efficiently or not but I wouldn't have this problem if the built-in Microsoft DVD codec would de-interlace the video properly.
Media Player screws up captured 1080i HDV playback by playing it in a tiny window until you click on the movie to force it to play back at 50% size. While that's not a problem with a mouse, not sure how you would deal with this on an HTPC. Not everyone will know they're suppose to click on the movie to make it play back at 50% size.
1080i full screen playback in general is a problem even with content captured digitally from OTA Over-the-air HDTV broadcasts. The exact same hardware (NVIDIA GeForce 6200 or ATI 9600 Pro with a Pentium 4 2.4 GHz with hyperthreading) that works fine in Windows XP on HD playback at full screen but NOT in Windows Vista. Even though this isn't Microsoft software, it doesn't change the fact that I can't use this server as an HTPC for my living room big screen HDTV.
Media Center crashes when library browsing some folders which is totally unacceptable. This might be caused with a bad interaction with the DivX and XVID CODECs from the K-Lite mega pack, but it doesn't change the fact that I still need to be able to play those videos.
Media Center can't play DVD folder rips on the Hard Disk Drive which makes it worthless for DVD library playback. I can't believe this isn't supported. What's the point of having an online DVD library? [UPDATE 5:21 PM - The explaination I was given was that there are DRM implications in playing back ripped DVDs. I guess this means Media Center is crippled to the point of being useless until I can find a hack to play ripped DVDs. I own the DVDs, I just don't want to have to swap disks. This is like not being able to play ripped MP3s of CDs you own. Last time I checked Zune lets you play MP3s.]
Movie Maker HDV preview is shifted downwards until you toggle widescreen preview. Minor bug but I mentioned something about this in my RC2 review.
Movie Maker only lets you retrieve entire HDV tape, not selections like the old Movie Maker in Windows XP. These last two issues I warned about in my RC2 review and they've not been fixed yet.
The "open with" feature is gone. When I use to right click on a data file, you can click "open with" and choose a new program to open the file or pick something on the list of applications you've used before. That list of recent applications for opening data files is gone which is very frustrating.
Power save settings are hidden in a deep mess. Tweaking the settings don't always stick. Default hybrid sleep mode (explanation here) is very annoying if system crashes because on the next reboot, it takes minutes to reload a gigabyte from hard drive and it stays that way until you shut down properly shut down Vista. I had to struggle with the UI to turn off this feature and change the power button in the start button to off mode and to get my settings to stick. The fact that my main PC is crashing didn't help the situation, but it would be nice if MS could ask if you want to boot normally instead of trying to recover the previous state. For most desktops, going from 150 watts idle to 145 watts in sleep mode just doesn't make any sense. I have yet to find a Desktop PC that can go in to sleep state level 3 which only uses a few watts of power.
Minor changes in hardware will sometimes prevent Vista from booting up. So much for the great driver independent imaging model I'd been hearing about though I haven't tested Vista deployment tools yet. I had read that Vista was suppose to be able to adapt to different hardware but maybe I just haven't found that feature yet.
IE7 embedded Windows Media Video playback won't support anamorphic video and forces the video to play in 4:3 mode as oppose to widescreen 16:9 mode. I had complained about this to Microsoft two months ago under Vista RC2. Example here.
While I've read from Jim Allchin that audio features have improved and Polycom is telling me about the new multiple Mic feature that allows you to pin point voice out of a noisy room, some things seem to be missing that shouldn't be missing. Windows XP allowed you to set separate Audio and Voice input/output preferences. That means voice applications like Skype will use one set of speakers and microphone while games will spit out sound from a different sound card. That feature is now gone and you only get to set one set of record and playback preferences. Maybe this is less confusing for beginner users but it's an unacceptable dumbing down of Vista. [UPDATE 5:21 PM - Vista adds the ability to set sound levels per application. But the ability to have two audio profiles where hardware is defined is gone. I'm trying to clarify if this means that applications in Vista can also have a custom hardware profile or not.]
That's all I can think of now though I'm sure there were other grievances.
[UPDATE 5:21 PM - Forgot to mention that web-based media players like Flash used in YouTube or certain news sites has poor frame rate performance even on really good hardware. If I right click somewhere on the flash box the video will pause for a split second. Any heavy IO activity on the hard drive will also cause the video to skip. Video card is the ATI x800 unlocked to x850.]
Does this mean I don't like Vista? No there are still security features like IE7 Protected Mode and UAC which beats having to log out and back in to do any administrative tasks. I really want to make Vista work but these types of serious bugs simply means that Vista RTM isn't ready yet. At this point in time I'm going to give up on using Vista as my primary operating system and wait for fixes on at least most of these problems to go away.

by tachyon

Why doesn't George?

If you read my post in the 'Trashing Internet Explorer 7...' discussion, I pointed out that there are real IT professionals, and there are lazy posers with letters after their names.

by andymck

We've no plans to move to Vista. I've had a look at the OS and it looks nice. Personally, I'd like to have it running on my desktop.

However, there's no compelling reason for us to leave XP to go to Vista. The performance, according to reviews, is very similar between the two. There's nothing seriously *wrong* with XP that is pushing us away. Add to that the fact that Vista's recommended minimum RAM spec is 512Mb - we've have to upgrade some older PCs - and you find a reason not to.

We'll probably look at it more after SP1 and when we're beginning to replace some of the hardware we currently run but not sooner.

by jaqui

no to vista, I'll not be buying it. ever.

but then, I'm 100% open source operating system.
and only rarely make use of 2 proprietary software apps. I usually use open source apps as well.

by zen37

I've been in the business for more than 12 years and most companies i know, including the one i work for, still uses Windows 2000. We are scheduled to go to XP in 2007. It's always been like that for as long as i can remember.

I'm curious to know who the heck is actually thinking of moving to Vista already? With all due respect to anyone thinking of migrating, i am just puzzled at the idea of going to that OS so fast. Does anyone know of any company actually in the process of preparing for Vista? I read an article that said that sales of Vista was going better than expected, who buys that stuff? Am i clueless or off the track here?

Do any of you have customers actually asking about the OS already?

by cg it

was on a laptop upgrade project for AT&T about a year and a half ago and that was from W2K [some 98s] to XP.

I know most defense contractors and Nasa contractors use CSC for their IT. I also know they are on a 3 year cycle for new stuff [wife works at Boeing]. Yep she gets a new comp every 3 years whether she wants or needs one or not.

by rpatton1

What MS calls house account have professional sals staff that pushes the latest. The DELL's and GATEWAYS buy it to bundle with their PC's, this represents millions of units.

The American public always wants the latest and greatest, weatehr its worth it or not!

There are your big numbers.

Dick

by zen37

....well, they also have a direct line to Microsoft support. If i had a direct line to Microsoft support, and a good financial incentive to switch, i guess i would do it too.

I fully understand that a software company would look at it from the start to deal with compatibility issues. But i was thinking more along the line of the other "big companies that have nothing to do with IT" kind of places. The airlines, the banks, the big auto makers, insurance companies, etc, etc, etc.

by tony hopkinson

If you write software for the windows market and you want to be ahead of the game, then making your software Vista compatible is not a choice, because some of your customers will use it.

Working on that at the moment, one of the things we are trying to discover is do we have to shift our development boxes over to do it efficiently. Not to mention if we do shift them over will that cause problems with customers that don't imitate lemmings.

Been here before haven't we?

by rpatton1

I also have SW apps running at customer locations, as to the affect on them, well I'm not sure. The ones running DOS apps will have a very real problem.

One good thing is that MS has always been sensitive to backward compatability.

Dick

by brianza

New system of computer interface:

Language configuration
Network configuration
Hard drive architecture
High resolution digital image output

All in ONE package,
I'm not marketing for Bill Gates,
I've seen VISTA and she's gonna go to high places !!

by tony hopkinson

but to get to a high place, you start in a low one.

This discussion is should we climb the mountain with it, or wait 'til it reaches the summit and then parachute in with a flask of tea and some butties.

Given the risk of storms, fatigue, cost, mischance and homicidal art collectors, I vote for option two.

by rpatton1

We have been captives of MS windwoes for so long and it is so well marketed is would be impossible to switch clients, even for FREE!

Windows is a part of the "establishment". Way back, I did assy code, which I was told will always be around, Hmm... then along came compilers, and COBOL, So much for JSR, MEM, STO, etc.

Dick

by jaqui

when told to upgrade the systems, switch to a non ms os.
you are "just following orders"
and you get the benefits of software that is written for multiuser environments on every level.

making sure that the report is seen by the decision makers in any company / government office is the best way to get the idea planted that using ms is not the only answer.
[ because of activex, using ms windows is a violation of privacy protection laws, and security of the systems laws ]

by marionx

Great link Jaqui. Appreciate you leaving it. Very interesting read. I wish more of the user communities kept up with things of this nature or perhaps 'big business'. Microsoft has it's place but it shouldn't be the monopoly "norm".

Wonder if businesses have gotten past the (misleading) marketing hype Microsoft put out about costing more to use alternatives..

by tony hopkinson

so, unless you want to run your app as administrator (which of course you shouldn't there are a lot of things you can't do any more that were 'OK' in the good old days.

I'd be the first to admit apps shouldn't write user data to HKLM and rely on files being in windows system, but a lot of legacy apps do.

by cherylr1

Seems to me that changing to Vista now may be another headache like upgrading to SP2 for XP was. I waited forever for all the bugs to be worked out of that one, and still Service Pack 2 for XP crashed my system so badly when I finally installed it that I even had to utilize the services of Microsoft to remove it completely from my computer. I never did reinstall it. This past spring I purchased 2 new computers instead, and went 64 bit. I have NO intention of attempting Vista on my computers. The only way I will add it, is if I buy a new computer that already has it on it, and I don't need to worry about any other hardware, software or networking to go along with it. Microsoft should have made baby steps with this new OS. It has taken them far too many years to have worked the bugs out of Vista, and yet they are still having problems with it. When will they learn?

by rpatton1

It's interesting that you had problems with XP SP2, my experience was good. It whent in, fixed some problems and we have been moving along just fine since then.

As to VISTA i will wait for SP1.

Dick

by robert_ireland

I have been evaluating vista for some time now, and I fully intend to deploy it in a business environment in the near future. I do understand people having reservations, however it seems to bring back memories of "have we not been through this before". Yes we have, it reminds of the same reservations that were voiced when 2000 and when xp were released. So what if you have do a wee bit of work, keeps the old grey matter working. I am an CCNA, CCSP and an MCSE, and I think it's a step in the right direction.

by rpatton1

Hi Robert,

The question is when, and there is lies the crux of this entire discussion. Few have said they will never move to VISTA, most just want it to settle for a bit before jumping in with both feet.

Traditionally, (as an MCSE you know this) MS has worked very hard to produce an OS that is a bug free as possible (recall the 10's of thousands of beta testers for windows 95, loading it from 30 floppies) but there comes a point where they need to hit the streets. We don't want to engineer it to death! So they make the most cost effective and logical decision they can with CM, QA, management and SWE. Yes, even MS has a budget -- Gates said this one cost 8 Billion. So they have tested it with perhaps a 100 machines in a controlled environment and 1000's of users like us. They try to clean up the last bugs and 'go for it'. They do pre-release versions so Vendors can develop drivers and even help them do it! They and we know that there are a virtually unlimited number of possible hardware and software configurations our there and that the OS will fail on some.

That being said, it hits the street and the stuff hits the fan. The only way they can prove it is under fire, just like 95, 98, 2000, XP and now VISTA.

In general large corps and the govt. have relatively well controlled environments and CM is a major thrust. So by designing and testing in these environments they have a great chance of success where the big bucks are.

The public on the other hand loads what ever they want, gets on the internet and down loads Viruses, worms, etc. and then complain about the OS. Not fair, but true!

Okay, is this me saying this Hmm...

MS then gets feed back from customer support and through their automated bug reporting system, from thousands perhaps millions of PC a day and they use some statistical tools to determine what code to evaluate and which vendors to notify about problems. Very effective and after some time they release SP1, Ah Ha now we can trust it!

That's where I Jump on the band wagon. So good luck Robert and I will look forward to hearing all of the war stories.

Dick

by tony hopkinson

Still only a job eh, and if it goes completely nipples up there will be nobody available to give you a bad reference.

by steve-nyeoka

I upgrade my OS with every new PC purchase!

Why else bother? Considering the hardware upgrades needed to realize any of the performance Vista offers.

If the existing software is working fine, I would leave it alone. At this point I really doubt people are shipping software yet that requires Vista as the OS.

The only exception I made to this rule is when one of my office PC's came with what must of been the last copy of Win 95 they had. I upgraded immediately to win 98, was they were already shipping identical PC's with 98 preinstalled (so the hardware was already set-up for 98).

by unhappyuser

We won't be installing Vista on any of our computers in our office. We're happy with 2000 & XP.

Microsoft promised much with this OS but has delivered little. It's Netscape all over again: instead of cleaning up the OS kernel they've added more bells and are trying to drive out the competition.

My next box at home wil be a Linux box or a Mac.

by Former member

I like many of the new features. I see a lot of potential for steps in the direction of next generation computing.

But I just can't stomach that whole product activation thing.

I am sure we will wind up with in in the office in the next couple years, but I am disinclined ot introduce it to my home. I just have a problem with having to 'call' and get permission to run the software I paid for. My first (and to date only experince with that was Half-Life2. A cool game, but if I had to do it over again, I wouldn't buy it, and I am not buying anything else from Valve. I may have to get serious about overcoming my Linux gotchas, and make it my sole OS at home.

by rpatton1

MS is entitled to know who is using their product and is it a real copy. I am sure the activation issue will get resolved very soon and all of your concerns will be addressed.

I will shall wait for service pack1.

by Former member

They may want to know, but I disagree that they are entitled know.

Their product activation only penalizes honest people. There are already hacks to allow dishonest people to bypass the activation. SO I pay for development cost of anti-piracy measures that incovenience me, and invade my privacy, while pirates continue to use the software for free, and without the inconveniences.

by rpatton1

Okay, we have been back and forth on this topic and I can't say I have the answer to my original question. I have learned that many of you are not confident enough to risk your reputation or customer?s data integrity on this new OS just yet.

On the other hand, there is the need to be progressive and up with the technology. Our clients expect nothing less of us.

So I will play in the sand box as follows:

1. I will ghost my current OS (XP SP2) to DVD and wipe the drive.
2. I will install VISTA and play with it, evaluate it in light of my and my customers needs.
3. If it works just fine I will continue to use it until SP1 arrives and this I will test that.
4. If I can work through the issues I will recommend it to my clients.

What do you all think of that?

by tony hopkinson

We've just gone through an exercise with the products we write. After a few niggly issues on the install, it worked fine.

As long as you log in as administrator.....

by rpatton1

That's always been a problem with Windows.

Quite frankly I'd rather stick hot needles in my eyes!

by rpatton1

Windows Vista vs. Windows XP: The duel

With the release of Windows Vista just around the corner, many home computer users are probably wondering if now is the right time to make the jump to Microsoft's latest addition to the Windows family. Some are perhaps concerned about security and stability, while many are probably wondering why they should even switch to Windows Vista, because Microsoft Windows XP seems to be doing the job.
The short answer is that there are several reasons for upgrading. For example, Windows Vista has:
? New features
? Improved security
? Better overall user experience
I'll introduce you to each of these elements, and you can make your own decision.
Discover new features in Windows Vista
Windows Vista offers a considerable number of new and improved features over Windows XP. Some of these great new features include:
? Windows Aero: Windows Vista features a totally different look for its interface?a cleaner, transparent look with impressive graphic quality, not to mention Live Icons and the new Windows Flip 3D feature. Windows Aero requires a higher-end video graphics card; otherwise, Windows Vista is displayed using Windows Basic. Check with your computer manufacturer, or use the Windows Vista Upgrade Advisor to see whether your video card is ready for Windows Aero.
? Windows Sidebar: Windows Vista offers a panel (transparent, if you're using Windows Aero) that displays your selection of Windows gadgets?mini-applications that perform useful functions, such as a clock, a calendar, a Microsoft Office Outlook inbox representation, and currency exchange.
? Microsoft Windows Media Player 11: While you can download it for Windows XP, this latest and greatest version of Windows Media Player is designed for Windows Vista and shouldn't be missed. With its new graphics-oriented interface, Windows Media Player 11 abandons the text-oriented look and field of previous versions. Did I mention that you can also use Windows Media Player 11 to share your media over your private home network?
? Windows Search: One of the most helpful new features in Windows Vista, you can now search for files or applications from almost anywhere. Unlike in Windows XP, with Window Search, you can simply type a few letters of your search request, and the results appear on the fly?a helpful feature when looking for a file or application from the Start menu. For example, type fir, and Windows Firewall entries appear in the Start menu.
These are just a few of the new features that might attract your attention. Of course, there are many more features and improvements for you to explore in Windows Vista.
Enjoy better security
People are concerned about security these days?not only Windows security but also how to protect themselves and their families when using their home computers. Microsoft has addressed both of these issues head on in Windows Vista. Some of the improved security features in the new operating system include:
? Parental Controls: Windows Vista includes Parental Controls that let you as the computer administrator set highly specific boundaries for other users, including separate standard user accounts for family members, especially children. You can set rules such as which sites a certain user can or cannot access and hours during which a particular user can use the computer; you can also curtail access to specific applications and view where other users have been on your computer and on the Web.
? Windows Vista User Account Control (UAC): UAC is a new security feature that lets you operate Windows Vista more as a standard user than as a true administrator, where you have complete access to everything. Features that UAC protects, denoted with a multi-colored shield, require your permission or validation before you can access them.
? Windows Firewall: Windows Vista now features two different firewalls: the standard firewall that was available in Windows XP and Windows Firewall with Advanced Features. The latter offers true firewall protection, including bidirectional filters, meaning that both incoming and outgoing data are scanned.
Other security features, such as BitLocker Drive Encryption, are available in some editions of Windows Vista. All Windows Vista editions feature the latest version of Windows Defender, Microsoft's anti-spyware application.
Top of page
An improved user experience
The overall user experience in Windows Vista goes far beyond what is available in Windows XP. Some of the things that I've found really enjoyable are:
? The new Start menu: The Start menu displays everything within the context of a single menu. Instead of having to scroll through a list of applications (which took up considerable screen real estate in Windows XP), you can now view a single, collapsible Start menu.
? Improved folders: My Documents, My Music, My Videos, and so on are simplified and appear simply as Documents, Music, Videos. These folders are always present when you search folders. For example, if you're in the Documents folder, folder representations of Music, Videos, Searches, and so on, appear on the left side of the Documents folder.
? Live Icons: When you're using Windows Aero, you can hover your mouse over open windows in the task bar and see a live representation of what's running in them. You can get the same preview by using the Windows Flip 3D feature or even by pressing ALT+TAB to toggle windows and folders, which makes navigation much easier.

Searching folders is considerably easier in Windows Vista.
These are just a few of the new features that might attract your attention. Of course, there are many more features and improvements for you to explore in Windows Vista.
Make the jump
There are many more reasons than I've shown why Windows Vista is a more user-friendly operating system than Windows XP. Beyond all that, it's a much faster operating system. The days of waiting several minutes for Windows XP to load are over; Windows Vista loads within 45 seconds and is ready to go almost instantly. If you have to install Windows Vista, you can perform a full installation in about 35 minutes. If you're still on the fence about switching to Windows Vista, visit Windows Vista Get Ready at http://www.microsoft.com/windowsvista/getready.

by tony hopkinson

A few significant omissions.

Price
DRM
Hardware
Drivers
Still have to use IE (as far as I'm aware)
Still no real separation between kernel and user space.
Still a EULA that rapes your ass.

It is very pretty though, the potential for search is good, the potential for the beefed up security is better than XP.

Very, very little software out there as yet that makes use of it though, not even MS's .

Too soon, offers far too little to make the pain and expense of taking it on worthwhile as a user.

As a developer, if it turns out to not to be too flakey and once they fix Visual Studio to work properly under it, I can see mileage in getting ahead of the game.

I'm going to have to seriously beef up my PC though and then shell out for the vista professional super duper ultimate, comes with knickers outside version.

By the time I've saved up enough pennies to do that, there might be some software out there that claims to run under it properly.

by james schroer

After waisting 5 minutes reading over your post I have yet to see a reason to up grade. Who care that the windows are "cooler" a better search? why don't you just get better organized and not have to use the search? All the other "features" are available via 3rd party for small pennies if not free compaired to the price to upgrade software AND hardware to run this thing.

by rpatton1

I am just trying to post everything i can so we all can make an intelligent decision on how to proceed. I think I know what I am going to do at this point. I will try it on my new lap top with is ?VISTA compatible?, Hmm? does that mean it will run or not?

There is nothing that I can see that would make me run out and spend $300.00 for it if I were a user and had to pay for it, however, as an MS partner I get it free so why not give it a shot.

I am very concerned about the whole new security level though, as are many others.

by stan20

Ask yourself if Vista offers any advantage to business users (my customers). Not one of my customers cares what the operating system is. They do care about having the tools to operate their business efficiently.

Most businesses use computers for routine tasks; order entry, inventory control, accounting, word processing, etc.

They need reliability, ease-of-use, speed and security.

The only new feature I see in Vista that has any use at all is improved security, and since my current customers have no problem with the security now in place, thats hardly a compelling reason.

Unknown reliability, training users to use a different system, the cost of upgrading applications to work with a new operating system, and the cost of upgrading or replacing hardware to run a new operating system are a few of the reasons not to upgrade.

Most of the users at my customer's companies run the same small set of programs every day, and have no use for improved search functions. They have shortcuts on the desktop for the applications which they need to do their work.

Vista will run slower on the same hardware, which certainly is not an advantage. Fancier graphics? Who cares? How will that make anyone more productive?

Is there any compelling reason to switch? I haven't heard of any, and neither have my customers.

by rpatton1

Stan,

Thank you for your insight, for most user communities your answer is perfect, until MS stops supporting the product or you are forced to upgrade application software.

It?s really the customer?s option, but I think you have the right idea. Those that want the newest bells and whistles and are willing to pay the premium can get windows VISTA we should oblige them after some stern warnings. At this point as Computer gurus we just have the obligation to offer it, and our opinion on what we truly believe is best for their operation. But also we need to learn much more about this new OS, since soon it will be the only game in town!

by tony hopkinson

writes to the registry say HKLM or to sensitive areas of the directory tree, running as an unpriviliged user will crap on it. Shimming will let it work, but them any changes are effectively sandboxed so you may not be able to use the mechanism to share data between applications.

It's not techically difficult to sort out, but in a legacy product, it could be all over the place and end up have a significant scope and regression testing impact.

by rpatton1

Out there using ye ole version of Sql, or Access or any relational DBMS. stuffing reg keys is a great way to capture, profiles, track access, and so on.

The only good thing is the office 2007 is supposed to run under XP.

Oh! and by the way these is no money in hardware any more so all you get for those neet up grdes is a bloody pain in the neck.

Dick

by maxwell edison

I've been skipping an operating system release ever since the beginning of DOS back in the early to mid 1980s. I don't exactly remember the DOS versions I installed versus the one's I skipped, but as far as the Windows versions, I skipped the first generation of Windows entirely, which really wasn't much more than a GUI for DOS, and which really ran through the Windows 3.x versions.

I went with Windows 95, but not until the "a" version, and settled down with the "b" version.

I skipped Windows 98 entirely, as well as its illegitimate step-child, Windows ME.

I upgraded from Windows 95 to Windows 2000 Professional.

I skipped Windows XP entirely.

I plan to upgrade everything to Windows Vista, but probably not until the end of the year. I'll install it on one machine at the office as soon as I can, and probably another at home, but I'll not upgrade all my Windows 2000 Professional workstations until I have all the bugs figured out, drivers and hardware and software compatibility verified, and so on. (And probably not until Microsoft releases its first Service Pack!)

My Server software, however, is a different story. I'm still considering what to do. It's currently a Windows 2000 Server, and in my environment, it might be just fine. But time will tell.

by rpatton1

I install SBS 2003 on virtually all my servers, and it runs very well. I believe that it?s the best alternative now since MS will soon stop supporting 2000 with Service packs, tech support and upgrades.

VISTA ? I fully concur with your approach!

by tony hopkinson

Has a few issues with XP64, but got over them.
If 2003 64 bit goes as simply, it may be worthwhile to jump the 32 bit anyway if you are going to renew the hardware anyway.

by Former member

I agree that 2003 is a nifty product; stable, friendly... all that good stuff. but I just a thought on windows 2000...
So suppport is going away...
Providing you can protect it, and you don't need to put newer apps on it, and dont' need newer features, why not keep running it?
up-sides: are soon you won't have to play the patch game anymore (since there won't be any more patches), It has lower HW requirements (cheaper servers), and before long, Virii will probably stop targeting it(hey, how many Virii are left that target DOS, or even windows 3.11 for that matter?) ;)

by rpatton1

Keep in mind that each and every one of MS even numbered products have required an up grade, or was it the odd numbers! I can?t remember now, getting old I guess.

You are right though there are some manufacturers who still have a problem with drivers, was that AT_ that said they were making a universal video driver that would read info from the board and then modify the driver on the fly to be compatible with both your system and OS. I think the Nvidia has been the only one that has been successful, and I have never installed an AT_ board that worked right out of the box with out ?please up date your driver? messages. I guess that?s one of the good things about Intel, they do test things, in 98% of the cases it works and if fails they will fix it. Audio, well there is Creative and then everyone else, I guess. Applications, wow I shutter to think what my Adobe production suite will do with VISTA.

And the list goes on and on, I guess that?s why they still need us, chickens in the barn yard!

Dick

by rpatton1

Banking clients still uses 2000 and office 2000 and says they will not move.

The problem is when MS says no more support, that means not service packs, updates, or technical support. That causes some reconsideration, what to you think?

by w2ktechman

If you look closely at each vendor, there is a disclaimer that their systems ARE Vista compatible, but not all features of Vista will work on them. This disclaimer only allows for the basic components of Vista to work to be compatible. This means that using the lowest version of Vista, it should work properly, but you may need to omit some features, or upgrade some components.

by rpatton1

And so i need to guess what does not work correctly as I merrily go on my way, Hmm...

by w2ktechman

that they are talking about Ultimate version mainly, and Aero on top of that.
but look at Dell, HP, Gateway, etc. they all have a disclaimer for the Vista Capable flag in their listings.

by tony hopkinson

well as long as you can read the screen.

It may not exactly point out what the issue is.

Unknown ole error(5) has also been upgraded.

by rpatton1

Most of my clients will keep their servers until they are choking to death and then replace them with the best available. The old server then becomes a workstation.

64 bit is a about 1 or 2 years out at this point.

by rpatton1

A server is a critical part of your business environment and should it crash for some reason you may need support and when you do and are told that ?Microsoft no longer provides support for this product?. Some ones head will roll, hope its not yours, but management is going to want to know, ?how long have you known about this and why didn?t you recommend an up grade??, or ?Our company is on its knees, we have lost our server and perhaps our data, what do you intend to do about this??

?Providing you can protect it, and you don't need to put newer apps on it, and don?t' need newer features, why not keep running it??

Any one in this business can tell you the above statement is impossible to achieve, software vendors are always shipping upgrades, new versions with more features that users and that management want and needs. Bugs creep in and infest your perfectly good server, you run out of space, you more power and performance to support the growing business, etc?

This is not a good decision, I would suggest that you rethink it very carefully and objectively.

by tony hopkinson

decades even.
The two walls you can't dodge, are sourcing compatible hardware at a reasonable cost, and people to maintain the software.

The real reason for keeping fairly up to date on technology, is to spread out the pain of upgrading. Leave it too long and you stagnate, new hardware, OS , applications, people, massive disruption etc.

All those things you get with an upgrade except in a hellacious big lump.

Personally if I had working 2000 and was forseeing no real technological need to upgrade to keep the business progressing, then I would recommend another year or two out of it, not much more than that though.

by rpatton1

Tony,

You can't delay it too long, though because we all know the all these good intension often cost more than an upgrade and as a bonus you get better perfromace.

by Former member

The smiley face was meant to indicate I wasn't really serious.

Though to your point. Bug's don't magically appear in a system. Either they are there (perhaps not discovered) or they're not. Unless you change something, new bugs aren't going to sprout up in your old code. So, if you are doing the exact same thing the exact same way on the exact same server, which has had no changes to it, you are fine.

Of course, if you are doing that, then you are going to go out of business pretty soon...

by brianza

No worrying about new OS ...

Vista is designed to adjust to new system architecture and no body cares ... it's just you and your Vista so make mistakes, change configurations and buy more add ons. But if it doesn't work properly then go back to XP.

Briy

by rpatton1

As I said I will use Ghost to backup my system, then load VISTA and let it fly. If all goes well and all the tests are cool then I'll upgrade my WS and others. Else GOTO restore.

I saw it tonight with office 2007 and it was cool.

I was impressed with the logging ability. You know how when you have a problem and you ask the user "what did you change, load or Download" and they say nothing. Vista will tell you if they lied!

It has some cool features, BUT I am not sure I want to have clients take the plunge NOW! After Service Pack 1, perhaps, mean while I will play with it.

One client is very concerned since his primary applications were written in 16 Bit windows!

by tony hopkinson

We'll suck it and see, guess our way through cause massive disruption to the business and spend a heck of a lot of it's money. If it doesn't work, we'll go back to XP, no harm no foul.

Try and cut down on the drugs mate, they are having a well serious impact on your ability to think.

by tony hopkinson

I mean look at SQL Server 2005, it's 30-40% slower than 2000, unless you go to a wholly stored procedure based design.

Aside from the debit of potential vendor lock, there are a whole raft of issues around that design change.

by Former member

I have been playing with it since betas and I see no reason to even get it?
Whats it do for me?
Make me waste an hour to figure out how to do the same old thing I already know?
MS puts out a bunch of FUD
EEWWHH Vista so secure bla bla bla
There is NOTHING this OS brings to the table
Unless you are one of those asses who like their desktop pretty
Me I like performance and Vista is surely lacking in that area!
REALLY WHAT IS THE IMPROVEMENT?
Looks like all they did was make it look like a MAC and move all the stuff around so you can no longer find it?
I don't get it
Ron

by pj8089

So many forget the problems of XP.. SP1, SP2 and the security updates, the fixes, the many problems with IE7 .... With so many reports of this and that, I don't care what MS says.. Vista is now a PUBLIC Beta !

by rpatton1

But that's the way it has to work, you see if they don't hit the street::

1. They can?t begin to recover their expenses
2. They can?t have millions of people test it free, Ops pay for a copy and test it
3. They will not know what to put in SP1
4. Most important of all they will never make any money from it.

New machines ?should work with it? and the old ones, well it upgrade or die!!!

Please believe me when is say all windows users will all have to accept this eventually.

by intrepi

First, this is a new Windows OS and will require learning, using and paying for whatever goes wrong, no liabilities going to rest with Microsoft. Something to mull over, if Mac and Linux can do whatever Windows does, does one have to upgrade or die ? Obviously the answer is a definitive NO ! Linux of whatever version will run on older machines as well as new ones and do it quite well. Some versions of Linux will actually load Microsoft software and run it straight off the shelf, out of the box. The governments of China, France and others are totally Linux. No boast or MS bashing just a fact. Now since China has moved off to Linux where do you think development is going in the next twenty years. Wait a moment and I'll polish up the crystal ball so you can get a clearer picture. China has the most people in the world, biggest market, biggest user potential of anything you care to dwell on. Is MS concerned, well they'd be short on common sense if they weren't. I'll likely buy Vista but not until I see the fine print as I'm one who upgrades frequently and this business of paying $ 400 a pop for Vista Ultimate and being limited to 2 activations is simply a little too much for me to buy into. So, slow, careful and read your license activation agreement first. If it can't work into your world of business then it's time to learn what the other OS's will do for you. You DON'T have to upgrade and you certainly don't have to DIE. You can keep all your older computers, hardware and carry on with a secure Linux OS in whatever flavour you like. Mac is standing by in case you want to opt for another option with a 3D desktop to boot !

by rpatton1

I like letting some one else do the climbing, carrying their bottle of Oxygen, and once they scale the peak, they can stand resolutely and say ?I am the pioneer? while we look on in admiration and then load service pack 1 and drink a toast to the hero from the comfort of our local pub.

by homeofficeservices

I already installed it on one "Vista Compatible" laptop (Presario V4000) we bought for around the house. We instantly wished we'd bought something with more video performance. That's what you get when rebate shopping, I guess. Vista was noticeably slower, and although very pretty, we just saw no real reason we had to have it instead of XP. After being unable to run a few different apps and having a hard time with a driver or two, I went back to XP and the machine is trouble free again.
The pain is that we need to learn how to use it and how to fix it so we can be prepared when broken Vista machines start showing up at the door. (We're a very small family business doing repairs and such.) Being a small-timer, I can't even follow some of the discussions on things you guys must deal with daily, but my viewpoint may be just a bit closer to that of the average guy wondering if he needs this product. I think most will say absolutely not, given how much my customers love XP. They'll just wait until they're forced to upgrade, and then I'll need to know what I'm talking about when showing them how to use it or attempting to repair it. And guess what, to do that I need to upgrade from a laptop I've had not even close to a year!!! I'm not thrilled about the whole thing, obviously. I guess it could be worthwhile to me and my customers if Vista was very different and had MANY new features and benefits and I could tell people how it was going to change the way they used computers and make their lives better. I have no such selling points.

by tony hopkinson

gets taken up, you'll be able to help us once you figure it out.

In business, especially large ones they tend to bulk buy one model, same hardware same peripherals etc, same av, same .... So we get one variery working, end of story.

Whereas you of course are going to see a different set up every day. You've no real choice but to give it a go again, there are some guys on here who know a lot about it.

All I know is like you, I've got a lot of head aches queueing up to have a go at me.

by robear

Tanimn gives the best advise -- and in a language we can all truly understand!

by intrepi

There is no way I will upgrade to Vista right away as I need to know a few things and only time will give me the answers. I've already asked Microsoft and got no response and I do understand the amount of emails they must get. First, I want to know without any doubts as to the license activation limitations as I upgrade a lot and I'm not laying out $ 400 without the facts on that. I can buy 4 complete, secure, OS's with a lot of software add ons so I do have options. There are not a lot of reasons to rush into Vista as even MS doesn't know who and what's out there to bring it down to another batch of downloading patches. What bother's me is Microsoft is telling us this is a secure system and yet they want to sell us protection for Vista. I'm referring to OneCare which has Defender in the mix. If you read some of the reviews in OneCare's own forum, it would be more than enough to make you ask why would anyone want to buy into that chaotic mess. Let me put it to you this way. If I stood in the middle of a field with a fly swatter and layed to rest everything in sight, would you pay me to protect the United States from killer bees ?
Well, that is not too far from what MS is asking us to do, why ? Well, I'm sure money might have something to do with it. Would it not be cheaper to use Windows OFF LINE for all the software you want to run and use Linux for everything ONLINE ? I've been doing that for quite awhile and needless to say it seems to stay bug, virus, spyware and route kit free. Vista cracks are out there, ask MS and if they deny it, well I'd believe them as I don't think they would be that blatant about saying otherwise. Aside from all of this, there simply isn't enough software / hardware drivers that really warrants upgrading. I won't say I won't buy Vista as it may well be everything MS tells us and a whole lot more but until the dust settles and I know the facts, my money stays where it is. For gamers, there is no software available out there that requires DirectX 10 so running out to buy an 8800 board or Vista may well cost you a lot of money given the time / usage / price drop factors in hardware. The most frightening aspect of Vista is there is no upgrade path from Windows to Vista Ultimate from any NON Vista version. What are the facts regarding license and activation ? When I know that, I'll be able to answer the question as to Vista or Not to Vista.

by rpatton1

I like the way you think and I?m beginning to believe that the user community needs to have a fair go at this to develop a better understanding. I would like to let the dust settle also, however, I believe we need to ?keep up? to get ahead. So the solution is to test and wait for SP 1. I am not familiar with the licensing debacle, how is it different than XP?

by tig2

You will only be permitted to activate the product twice. This is problematic in that there are times when you just have to bite the bullet and rebuild your system. Or upgrade.

Me personally? I will likely encounter the Vista monster. But not at my house. I am investigating Linux in search of something that the less computer literate in my family can use easily. I have chosen the Vista launch as my official entry into the Open Source world. Sorry Microsoft!

by intrepi

The difference is Microsoft has placed limits on the number of times that you can activate Vista. How many ? That's the question. If I upgrade my graphics board and a hardrive, I may not be able to get Vista reinstallation activated as Microsoft is limiting activations.
This said, it means you are left with NO vista and the only way to get another license is to buy another copy. Hope this explains my concern with Vista and activation limits.

by tachyon

Unless you have a pressing business need to use Vista, and/or XP fails to do waht you need it to do, why switch?

Given Microsoft's long histroy of releasing beta quality products to production, why risk your business to it right now. If you look at it, it's really only been since SP2 that XP has become a reasonably useful, reliable product. I expect no less from Vista, expecially given what they had to hack out of it to get it even release worthy.

I look at it this way, just like I wouldn't buy the first year of any manufacturer's car after a remake, I wouldn't buy software that new. All the beta testing in the world can't anticipate the craziness that is the real world.

Tell your customers to wait until XP can't do the job for them, and until Vista does something they need that XP can't do. No need to pay Microsoft to help them finish beta testing their products.

by rpatton1

I agree and basically I think most of us on this forum feel the same as you. Here's the deal though, we bought into XP (reluctantly, but we did buy in) and I really believe we will do the same with VISTA. In this forum we have expressed some major concerns.

But the following seems to come through loud and clear:

1. No one wants to be a MS beta tester with a production release!
2. Most respondents don?t see any value added!
3. Security seems to be a road block rather than an enhancement!
4. Most feel that perhaps when SP 1 is released there may be enough bug fixes to try again!
5. Most believe that there are not enough apps that require/support it at this time!
6. The required hardware upgrades are a deterrent!
7. Finally ? there are those pesky drivers that don?t exist yet!

So for now my conclusion is as I stated before, it?s a sand box to play in and wait while the ?Big boys ?debug it for us, and spend Millions to upgrade hardware!!

So let?s all raise our mugs of grog and say GOOD LUCK BIG BOYS ? See ya in a year!!

Dick

by dstringer

I am "playing" with Vista and I can't seem to get Outlook 2007 to connect to Exchange 2000. Is this a lost cause? Outlook won't even acknowledge that I am online. I have also noticed that web access on outlook doesn't work 100%. Any one have an thoughts or suggestions? Thanks in advance.

by rpatton1

Thank you very much and certainly worth considering. How difficult is the transition from Windows to Linux?

by intrepi

I bought several different distros of Linux, one was SuSe, Xandros Business Edition 3.0, Xandros Professional 4.0 and Ubuntu. They all have graphical interfaces which are different from each other but very similar to XP. If I was going to try another distro, I'd try the newest distro from Mandriva as it's loaded up with more drivers and software. Take a read on Linux reviews, go to Xandros, Mandriva and other Linux websites and take a read to see what you might like to try. Xandros Pro 4 has it's own Office software, free updatable Antivirus, Spyware, File Protection and a lot of other free software. I loaded it up and installed it in about twenty minutes. I use all my hardware including my sony digital camera, printer and it's on a new Asus M2N mother board with 2 BFG 7900 boards. So aside from it not running my Logitech Pro 5000 webcam, it does everything else. Photomanager looks after all the digital photos. But best to download it and try it for free for 30 days and then maybe try Mandriva's OS.

by cyclepro

I feel essentially the same.. Problem that I have (at this time) with Vista is that it is a big resource hog. Moteso than XP. My company is looking to convert to Vista later this year and I am wondering if it is really worth it. So far what I am reading about Vista leaves me with mixed feelings

by rpatton1

Limit two, is unrealistic. Bucause of the work I do, i refresh my machine at least once a year, sometimes more.

by rpatton1

This behavior occurs because the Transmission Control Protocol/Internet Protocol (TCP/IP) stack is initialized incorrectly.

or

This behavior can also be caused if the following registry key is corrupted or missing:
HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Rpc\ClientProtocols

See MS article ID#268575

I suggest that you try the TCP/IP reinstall on you server first!