Discussion Locked

Tracking Employees

0 helpful
37 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Our Network Administrator recently decided to disable everyones interntet connection, which management quickly said was not acceptable. Now he is tracking everyones internet usage with software, then making it to where they can only go to certain sites. On top of this he has installed a keylogger on all the systems. I think my company's Network Administrator is pushing it too far. What do you think? Is it against any privacy laws?

37 replies

by dc_guy

This is a very emotionally charged topic and it already has a thread of about 250 postings. You asked two questions:

1. What do I think? Yes, I think your network admin is pushing it too far. Most of us spend a greater number of our waking hours in our offices than any other one place. The office in effect IS our home. If they want us to be productive, they've got to make us enjoy being here, or at least not hate it.

Face it, a lot of us are not terribly social people. The time people in other occupations spend gabbing, we'd rather play Minesweeper or google for writeups on ideas we've read about. We need our down time just like any other knowledge worker. Up to a rather generous limit, every minute we spend playing will probably be repaid with five minutes worth of output when we're more relaxed and centered.

2. Is it against any privacy laws? No, not here in the USA. It's company time and company property. Period. They can make any rules they want to limit your ability to use their resources for personal or frivolous purposes. Just because it's a stupid thing for them to do, doesn't make it illegal.

by services

Sorry if you've heard it already. I'm fairly new to tech republic and didn't find anything already going. Thanks for the insight.

by craig herberg

While it is probably legal for the company to track internet usage, it sounds as if this particular person is out of control. Perhaps he is capturing passwords for future nefarious deeds? Run, do not walk, to your management to express your concerns.

Good luck.

Craig Herberg

by deepsand

It is a well established legal prinicipal that, when using your employer's facilities, there is no reasonable expectation of privacy.

This holds for the use of company phones, copiers, fax machines, computers, Internet connections, vehicles, etc..

It would be in the beast interest of the company if its rules & practice were promulgated to all existing employees, as well as being presented to new & prospective hires, so that mis-understandings are minimized.

by tony hopkinson

not so much in that your admin is exerting what in my opinion is a stupid excess of control, but that any private transactions (such as checking you balance online!) are no longer private. Let's hope the fella is an honest monmaniac. I can see the URL tracking, but the keylogger is extremely iffy in my opinion.

by dafe2

Internet usage is usually allways tracked, just like phone faxes etc...The reports however, are usually only requested, generated & reviewed by HR or a Manager if and when deemed necessary by a supervisor or other responsible person.

You have no REASONABLE expectation of privacy at work.

A keylogger on all systems?????
He/She has crossed the line IMO.

Not against any laws that I know of......but I think your Admins nuts. You should advise Management of the presence of a KEYLOGGER ASAP.

Let them make the call. If they accept the presence of a keylogger, find a real place to work.

by deepsand

What we here don't know is what lead the Network Admin. to these undertake said measures.

It is entirely possible that employee activity is compromising the integrity and/or perfomance of their network, and that the employees are either uncooperative or too uninformed so as to be able to assist with regards to remediation of the problem(s).

by dafe2

There are much more, shall we say, ethical ways of going about things.

IMO, if there's admin out there using a keyloger, network users would be better served by cafeteria staff.

Other tools are much less 'suspicious' and much more 'informative'.

Not a fan of sleezy tools is all I guess.

by maecuff

Is the network administrator implementing these restrictions? I'd have a real problem if one of my employees took it upon him/herself to impose these limitations. And if I, as a director, decided to implement a policy like this without approvel from the VP I report to, he'd have a problem with it.

by dafe2

My point.............further, I believe if any of the Executive found someone implementing a keyloger the implementor would be fired on the spot.

Sure, they're are all kinds of reasons for shutting down, auditing and other 'investigations'. I just can't think of ANY sound reasoning for implementing something as juvenile & dangerous (for morale & trust) as a 'keylogger'.

by dr dij

My GF works for a company that has eliminated internet browsing for employees. They are a very small company, distributor and may not be able to afford the extra work involved and problems it is likely to bring - extra admin work, extra software for threats etc.

Since employees would reasonably be expected to be working most of the time, it shouldn't be too much of a loss to them tho it is a convenience. My point is it is easily abused. It's easier than having HR monitor a surfcontrol report to eliminate the need and time and cost to do that.

I don't know the exact situation at her company but since internet access is not a GOD (Giver Of Data) given right at work, even tho many expect it either for personal use or to do their jobs, I don't have any problems with this.

And due to the severity of internet based threats it may make more sense than most realize.

by deepsand

We know nothing of the nature of the problem that the Net Admin. is seeking to resolve, his responsibilities, his authority, the approval(s) that he may have received from higher authorities for any of his alleged actions, the level of co-operation that he has received from the users, etc..

Absent such salient information, to remain neutral is the only logical & equitable response.

by kevaburg

But to say he is paranoid to the point of needing serious medical help might be a little mre accurate!

What could his users be doing that makes him believe such strong measures (keystrokelogging being the most serious) are necessary? And are management also being monitored in such a provocative manner?

And what measures has he taken to inform his users of his actions and assure them that the gleaned information will not be misused?

This admin I think has become perhaps his own worst security issue because somewhere, more than likely in clear-text and held in a single flat file, are an entire companies passwords in a single list and confidential communications that he or anyone else that has access to the file can read.

And lastly, we all know that not all admins read all the logs that are generated simply because there are too many of them. We stick to the ones that mean something to us and to our organisation. At which point in his busy, proactive day is he going to read the keystroke generated log and analyse that which needs to be acted on and that which does not.

And of all the given input, who exactly has the right to say what is important and what is not?

by deepsand

services@... has give us NO BACKGROUND on this matter.

For all we know, the Net Admin. may have tried any number of approaches, without success.

The fact that he tried to quarantine the network, by denying i-net access, could indicate a very serious problem that REQUIRES draconian measures.

by cuteelf

Just for the heck of it..

Let's say that IT has noticed a break-in into a heavily guarded server..one with a lot of good info in it.

Now, the log points to a LAN addy, and some where within 1 hour begin/end of work hours.

What other tools to use/point/figure out who all's doing this? Besides a keylogger?

And, from the users point of view, if I had a suspicion that a kl was on my ws, I'd go to my boss, and ask wtf is going on. Then, I'd make sure I was only on G-rated webbies and no financial/email/personal stuff...ever. I'd point out to the boss that a kl can catch anything..and that his bank number may be in someone's hand...

Then, I'd start sniffing around for other jobs.

CuteElf who's still broke and blue :(

by jamesrl

There is a time and place for such tools.

At the 65,000 employee firm I worked at, any use of any such tools had to be approved in writing by the CIO. There were strict limits placed onuse of such tools -only IT security could use.Anyone caught using a sniffer, keylogger, war dialler or any other tools which could be used to compromise security, if they didn't have written permission from the CIO, was subject to immediate termination.

This meant in effect you had to have a pretty good case to bother the CIO with.

James

by bfilmfan

I would ask why wasn't the server being audited for usage. It should show which account was used for access and exactly when, where and what the account was accessing.

With the new HIPAA and SOX laws on the books, woe be to any upper management that isn't monitoring servers properly.

And on a personal note, I think we've all been financially broke and blue at one time. 20 years from now when you are a financially secure and successfult consultant, you can have a glass of bubbly somewhere in honor of all your friends that believed you could make it.

by jamesrl

I've been where you are....

In the late 80s, I made a rule to myself that if a small business I was a part of ever failed to make the payroll, I would walk. I had to walk twice, but both times ended up with better companies. The one time I stayed longer than I should have, I've come to regret. The writing is usually on the wall, you just have to want to see it.

I've had some properous times too. Some of those came to a screeching halt 2 years ago when I was laid off. But I learned from the experience, and bonded with my kids so I can't say it was totally miserable. I now appreciate having a job more.

If you were closer, I'd buy you a beer. I could offer to review your resume....

James

by dafe2

playing devils advocate, because I've read your stuff ellswhere..... :-)

(IMO) No ethical admin would stoop to using kiddie toys no matter what they're faced with.

by deepsand

If he was charged with the responsibility for such, and was unable to faithfully discharge said responsibility by any others means, then he would be negligent of his duties not to do so.

I.e., ethical considerations may clash with one's contractual obligations.

Under such conditions, his only options would be to take any & all measures to faithfully execute his responsibilities, or to breach such and accept the consequences.

Since the original postor has failed to provide us with sufficient information, we are still not able to render a fully informed opinion is this particular instance.

by tomsal

I'm only going by what you posted of course, so I don't know any underlying details. However, based on what you said I'm surprised management hasn't slammed this guy hard. Keylogging everyone? It sounds like he took it upon himself to essentially say who can go to what website.

Sounds like this guy is suffering from disease that is rarely found in non-executive level positions, called "Egomaximus".

by dafe2

The only know cure:

A size 12 boot in the pants....all the way out the lobby entrance.

"A good talking to" usually does little good.

by deepsand

There is no reason to yet believe that the postor's scanty description of events represents an accurate portrayal of the whole picture.

by dafe2

I'd have to dissagree with you.

The only discharge I'd do is showing the Admin the door.

An admin should know ennough about the OS to realise there are other alternatives.

IMO, using a tool like a keylogger has the potential to damage the employee / employer relashionship.

As far as contracts in my world:

----> Ethics win over contracts everytime <----

It's easier to update my resume than it is to shave with my eyes closed.

by deepsand

I am not taking a personal position here; rather, I am withholding judgement of another for lack of knowledge.

Until we know all the facts, including the full impact of his not taking the measures here alleged, we cannot make a fully informed judgement.

I find it interesting that the original postor has yet to come forth with anything more than his obvious dislike for the Net Admin's actions.

by bhunsinger

The first response to his post was to complain that this topic was done to death- maybe he doesn't know that were are wwatching.
The Admin is out of control IMHO. That does'nt mean there isn't a reason for his overreaction. But shutting down internet access WITHOUT management buy in signals that this guy is a fan of my mother's school of investigative technique- punish everyone until the culprit comes forward: Then doulbe up becuase everyone else had to suffer. My kid brother (now 45) STILL claims he has no idea how the lipstick got in his hair. We set a record of standing in the hall that night 6 hours.
Why not punish those who abuse privledges? Why is that such a hard thing to grasp?

by jdclyde

Some people just forget why they have a job in the first place. They also get a huge ego.

Keystroke logger. Has he officially notified everyone about it? If not, he can have issues with that one. Companies CAN monitor, but they have to let you know that they MIGHT be.

*****
I would add in your signature on your e-mails a note that due to "MR. X" loading spying software on all company systems, there is no expectation of privacy. Any yes, list him by name for doing this and make SURE this is on EVERY e-mail that you send.

The other thing to do is on a regular basis, open your work processor and set a book on your keyboard and walk away. Log that keystroke.

Don't write anything that is inappropreate or could be used against you. Just stay with the facts and the truth will set you free.

by deepsand

As I've covered in more detail elsewhere, we simply don't have all the facts; and, the postor is apparently not going to provide them.

I fail to understand why so many here nonetheless feel compelled to judge the Net Admin..

by tony hopkinson

internet capability all together. Don't care about URL blocking and monitoring. Global keylogging if it's in place is decidedly iffy though.
The only reason I can think of using it is if they are using software that leaves no audit trail at all, or their system is so open that anyone can hack the audit trail. In his shoes I'd get that/those issues out of the way before I looked at who was providing the necessary impetus for such a measure in the first place.

by dafe2

Can't speak for others.....but as you've probably gathered by now, my blood pressure went up at the use of the keylogger. LOL

by alece

As others have said on this thread, you do not have any rights to expect privacy on your company computers. Make sure that you do not communicate anything that you would not want plastered on the front page of the nation's newspapers.

I would make an inquiry to management regarding the activities of this software and how the use of a keylogger helps productivity. The 'bean counters' only care that the Internet browsing wastes company time and company resources. How does a keylogger benefit the company in the profits department? Who takes all the time to review volumes of information looking for that all important tidbit of information that might lead someone to suspect that there is something suspicious going on? If this same person is also in charge of auditing the data found on the workstations, that is a problem for an auditor. The information logged at everyone's keyboard needs to be properly disposed of and that activity monitored and audited for proper compliance with established standards. There are a number of security questions that arise when this approach is taken by any company. How much of this has been discussed with company management? I would think that if these issues are raised to management, the use of the keylogger would be seriously considered.

by deepsand

Simply put, we've heard nothing more than the allegations of a disgruntled (presumed) user.

Why the rush to judgement?

by dr dij

While I think there could be remote circumstances for keyloggers, sounds like this idiot just is trying to do what web site loggers do.

No, I meant I felt it was justified to deny internet access to all or most if a company felt the problems outweighed the benefits.

I'd suggest that only standard use for keylogger would be if company started an investigation into criminal activity on companies net, not just to 'see what employees are doing'.

You don't have a god given right to use the internet at work and for small companies, idiot users bringing in spyware and trojans from screen savers, stealth install websites, etc. could bring the company to its knees or cost more than if they didn't allow this, and if it isn't work related why should they pay any more for it?

It's up to company to determine that many employees, such as a production line person or may have little or no need for internet.

by dafe2

Can't think of any impetus that would push the use of a keylogger though.

by dafe2

I understand where your argument is comming from, but you can't (really) believe there's any use for a keylogger in a business environment?

Regardless of the circumstances, the logical & equitable response - Do not use a keylogger.

As far as shutting down the internet (or) auditing it's use -> THAT is a known good & 'expected' response to threats (or) violations of AUP's.

In this posts example I dissagree with the degree of response, but as I say, IMO it is an 'acceptable' one in SOME cases. (That's stretching it) The 'response' to internet use/abuse vary according to Admins ego of course. :-)

The only 'issue' I have with the scenario, as defined by a non-responsive poster, is the use of a keylogger.

by deepsand

My "gut" response is much the same.

However, I long ago learned that:
1) To achieve anything of long term value, man must learn how and when to subjugate his emotions; and,
2) Making judgements about others is an endeavor best engaged in with great care.

So, while my eyebrows are raised by the mention of a keystroke logger, I recognize that, knowing nothing of the circumstances, any judgement in this particular case, at this point in time, would be mere speculation.

This discussion is closed to new replies.