Discussion Locked

Trojan source traced - what next?

0 helpful
50 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I found a Trojan installed where I least expected it.

It came as part of a LEGITIMATE software. That software has won several awards, including a 5 stars award from CNET.com

None of the antivirus I tried ever found it, but I was tipped off by an anti-spyware report (only after most recent signature update).

After trying various tools, one eventually reported this.
I am currently investigating further the exact installation process, but the source is final.

To stop speculations introduced in some answers, I add a few things in the main post:

-1) The source has already been verified, as I already mentionned above.

-2) This is a known trojan, listed in security databases, together with the author's alias and a sizeable list of other malwares known to come from the same author.

-3) I am not interested in speculations on what I checked or not, I have enough background to be past that. I am only interested in the legal aspect versus surprise effect (If the author is traceable to that company, but I contact them first (or somebody else does), he/she will have the time and opportunity to clear his/her tracks.)

What should be my next step?

1) Contacting the editor?

OR

2) Contacting the relevant law enforcement agency?

50 replies

by husp1

Have you double checked your sources claims? Rest asured that your opening yourself to a liabilaty issue by contacting the athoritys first. check with the editor first. If his or her answers don't supply the satisfaction you then should contact the proper law enforcement agency.

by oz_media

AVG antivirus will indicate SUN's Java as being a trojan in Firefox, an obvious false positive.

Spyware and trojan detection is up to the discretion of the spyware programmers. They often consider completely fine programs as being trojans or spyware, probably why nothing showed up before.

When you get the scan report it usually lists the citical factor of the trojan too, in most cases it will notify you of a piece of software that has an autoupdater etc., but list it as being harmless.

It's more of a heads up if you will, in most cases such spyware or trojan is simply misreported and is completely harmless or may even be a small reportig plugin from FREE software or a piece of advertising code for FREE software. Writers have to make money somehow, no software is REALLY FREE.

by _christian_

No, the trojan is genuine RAT, I had already verified.

It is listed in a reputable security datase, with extracts of its own distribution file, and author alias and list of known other malwares.

I am now checking if the latest version of the software it came with still contains it...

by jdclyde

A virus gets slipped in and you get it installed using nothing but the original disk. Ask Microsoft about that one.

Contact the vendor and let them explain themselves.

by oz_media

This may even be related to a CNET or other trial download and perhaps not even a CD version.

Many updaters are said to be trojans because they try and connect to the internet and collect/send version info.

It's all just speculation I suppose unless the software and source are provided by the original poster.

by bfilmfan

I recall getting a copy of Cheyenne Backup that had Monkey B on the floppy direct from the vendor.

It's rare to get a virus from a vendor, but I will totally agree that it happens.

by oz_media

"RAT is an acronym for Remote Access Trojan. A RAT might have a functional use, but it is typically used to describe malicious code..."
http://netsecurity.about.com/od/hackertools/p/aapr092004.htm

I would say that in YOUR case, this particular RAT software is not malicious but used as expected to update or even validate it's licence on boot.

Not all RAT's are malicious, but they are all identified.

I would hazard a guess that the software vendor you purchased the software from is adding this for a speciic reason other than to hack your machine.

by _christian_

Please, do not assume that I do not know what I am talking about.

I have been in IT a long time, I know EXACTLY what a RAT is, and I have actually been involved in computer security a few times, in the past.

Furthermore, your comments are irrelevant to my question...

by oz_media

Nobody is ASSUMING anything, I am merely responding to your evasive opening post.

While I did think perhaps you were genuinely wondering what it was, though unmentioned, and wondered what to do, I have no information to think differently.

Therefore, I tried to be helpful by explaining what this trojan may or may not be and offered a link for more information.

People come here with similar issue quite often, if you KNEW more information than you provided, in a computer world you should know that you need to provide all of this to begin with.

You should have just said,

"I bought XYZ software and it comes packaged with a RAT right on the CD that's being picked up by my antivirus software,

I know a lot about computers and don't want any help, infomation or support. Please submit your specific replies to the two following questions, without further comment... "

I know you posted someting vaguely similar but you still failed to mention details as to what you were dealing with.

But in my foolish case, I assumed that you were unsure about this, and that's merely due to a lack of information provided, but again MY fault of course.

I then took some time to provide information that may help you decide whether this is an issue you feel worthy of persuing or not, blasphemous bugger that I am.

I bow to you faithfully.

by synthetic

Wow, since you know what's going on, why ask? If you expect others to have some concern for your issues, have some concern for them, and their replies. One of the greatest aspects of TR, is that many people will answer, at the level they are familiar with, and with the information they feel best suits their understanding of the issue. This will not always be at the technical level your working at. One issue that seems prevalent with those who have been working IT" for a long time" is that they get so arrogant, and removed from their humble beginning, they forget that the simple answers, and answers provided from varied points of view, actually help quite a bit, as the most perplexing issues can often be solved from a simple issue that was assumed as a non-variable. As for "going straight to a legal authority" which one exactly are you planning to go to, with what illegal complaint or activity. Since you case, and belief is so strong, and you honestly believe this a beneficial route, then run with it. Then, you can come back, and let us "ignorant assuming" how to tackle this problem your having.

by afoshee

Just because you know what RAT and MOUSE and MOOSE are doesn't mean the next worthy person to come along does. Since this is a public forum it could be a near-relevant posting is the genuine piece of gold that'll help someone who's searching for answers.

I for one stopped by because the topic sounded interesting, and had no clue what you were posting. I found the explanation provided by others to be both informative and enlightening.

Rather than pouncing like a CAT on a RAT, perhaps you should pounce on a chill-pill and just appreciate the fact that folks are willing to help, even if that help isn't exactly what you need. All jumping around like that does is make you appear far less like the nice guy I'm sure you are.

Then again, this is just my opinion and I could be way off - you could be as big a horses backside as I am. ;-)

by _christian_

Your comment suggests that either:

a) You do not have a clue about actual security work (first rule is "do not give advance warning", which would be breached if I posted the info you ask for)

or

b) You actually are on the cracker side, and want to warn whoever is involved.

by oz_media

Your simply overparanoid as many security techs are, which is fine, and again I apologize for trying to offer any helpful information. I should have guessed your level of IT intelligence and your profession before trying to help.

by _christian_

Why do you think that security techs are paranoid, in the first place?

And one bit of advice: If you do not want people to throw sticks at you, do not give them the sticks in the first place...

As for help, help would be answering the question, not mucking around...

by deepsand

Then, you need to be open to debate on all aspects of the issue.

If you're merely going to say that "Party A" committed "Crime B" by engaging in "Act C" with and/or against "Party D," thereby causing "Loss E" to "Party F," and ask for advice, you're SOL.

by oz_media

Sorry that was really hard to type with a stright face. ANY suit brought upon this company would be open to full discovery long before it hit a courtroom anyway.

"a) You do not have a clue about actual security work (first rule is "do not give advance warning", which would be breached if I posted the info you ask for)"

You gotta just smile at some people's comments I suppose. First rule " Do not give advance warning" wonder what rule book he found THAT crap in? The Girl Guide's rule book for playing 20 questions?

Corporate law doesn't work that way, sneak attacks are not gonna work sorry. And THAT was form someone who claims he's too clever and security paranoid (pardon me SAVVY) to accept anything but the specifically requested help.

I have had people call me and ask how to wipe out and reformat thier harddrive. I usually try and find out WHY and, in most cases, it's due to frustration over some virus or trojan.

Asking some simple questions or offering som ebasic advice, usually results in a worthwhile answer that happily stops the person reformatting.

by _christian_

If you are genuine, then you are incompetent on the security side...

And my question was very specific from the start, with options 1 and 2, while you diverted straight to answer z...

Or maybe you did not take the time to read it properly before starting to answer?

by oz_media

You are right, I have no interest at all in security, at all whatsoever. Leave that to the IT department, not my problem. I'll just make sure they have the tools and work efficiently enough to resolve issues for thier respective employers.

by jdclyde

belong to lawyers and such.

From your postings we see that you have already decided this was a problem.

If you are really worried about this, do nothing.

If you just want people to see how grand you are, keep doing nothing.

If you want this activity to stop you have to decide WHAT this trojan is doing as you are so good at the security side, is it really a threat? Was it intentional by the vendor or did someone slip it in their software?

If you have determined this is intentional call the law enforcement. You can NOT get in trouble for reporting a possible crime to the authorities. If you report it to the press and you are wrong THEN you get grilled over the open fire with a big apple in your mouth.

But you already know all this, don't you?

by _christian_

Well, this is the tricky question.

The editor had NO legitimate reason to include that piece of software, which is explicitely designed as malevolent, according to the report I have seen.

The company is legitimate, so it could not be intentional from the company, BUT it could have been (and probably was) from one of their employees.

At any rate, I was continuing my investigation in the intervening time, and found that it has been republished, same version, but clean.

So it has been found and my question is moot for this software.

The company however failed to inform their registered customers, and would therefore be liable...

This said, the question itself is not obsolete, since this is an issue which can reoccur, and actually already has, on another piece of software. That on being a technical tool published , if I remember correctly, as a freeware, from a legitimate company editing recovery tools...
I am checking back on that.
In this second case, I suspect, from the way it looks in the distribution, that a genuine clean distribution has been hacked into and modified on the server.
In my view, the company is not behind it and is only guilty of not checking their files periodically.

So basically I am more looking for a general answer, what to decide in this type of situation, still the same options 1 and 2, and still with any challenge to findings being irrelevant ;-)

by synthetic

....does not mean that the issue of the software being reported as malevolent actually is. Back Web, a component of CABC's digital distribution is reported by a number of spyware databases as malware. Because their is a tracking and reporting component. It is bundled with a number of product, and has very legitimate rights in a systems installation. What one calls spyware, another sees as critical software.

by synthetic

....does not mean that the issue of the software being reported as malevolent actually is. Back Web, a component of CABC's digital distribution is reported by a number of spyware databases as malware. Because their is a tracking and reporting component. It is bundled with a number of product, and has very legitimate rights in a systems installation. What one calls spyware, another sees as critical software.

by radiic

I would report it to the vendor. Give them the chance to clear the matter. If it truley is a "rat" that was put in by an employee, I would say the company will take care of both.

With that said - I see you are a new member.

I also saw the way you replied to Oz_Media who was trying to help you. First of all, if you did not want any opionions you should have posted this in the technical Q&A. Second Blasting someone that is trying to help you is RUDE>!
Third, maybe you should not come back here. We do not need members that are as arrogant as you.

by _christian_

My opinion is that when I asked an advice between option 1 and 2, I am not interested in somebody tryng to drive the matter to option z.
THAT is rude in my view, and the forum equivalent to spam.

As for being a new member, not quite.
I had another registration before, but I lost access to it following a redundancy, my position have being terminated (company cuts), and the company not willing to let me access the system (I was the domain admin) when they informed me on my return from vacation. Nice people, isn't it?

Anyway, I was too busy to be really active here at the time.

So I simply restarted a new registration as soon as I had again a practical Internet access.

by husp1

that you have already formed your answer and are looking for conformation. But on the otherhand after folling this posts responses I think that your being a bit too stiff and should lighten up a bit. your original posting did not request that people should decide between 2 answers only. As to what OZ posted early in the topic some RATS have a purpose. you failed to give us all the spacfics needed to make a more informative answer. As to paranoia, if your in security you should be mildly paranoid. (I think it helps!)

by just_chilin

Software usually come with ways of validating and registering your license key.
If that is the case with yours, you don't stand a chance in any court of law.

by _christian_

But I had already asserted that this was not the case for that one, and stated so.
That should have been enough to close that matter.

I quote myself:

"No, the trojan is genuine RAT, I had already verified.

It is listed in a reputable security datase, with extracts of its own distribution file, and author alias and list of known other malwares.
"

(first answer to OZ)

by synthetic

Since you want a very narrow, and rigid answer, to two options posted, why don't you do both. Contact the authorities (whoever you think that might be that would help you, I've been in this business a while as well, and I've yet to see a governing body with any legal authority you could report a Possibly errant trjoan to that would give you any satisfaction. Why not also contact the author/editor, whom ever. Most legitimate companies do not tolerate this kind of issue, will not allow some random coder to cover his tracks, and will have the ability to take the appropriate action. No serious business will let this go, as being know for sending viruses packaged with ones software is a sure way to kill a reputation. Just like being rude and arrogant to people trying to help will ensure less willingness on the part of other to help you in the future.
Now, your two options have been covered, and as you want pure rigidity of issue, it will be interesting to see if you take things to Z, and make a hypocrite of yourself.

by jbaker

...and one that many of us need to take to heart.
It is so easy to become so ingrained in what we do on a day to day basis that we forget the basics, and we sometimes need to be either reminded of them, or knocked down a notch or two.

by oz_media

He asked you to answer questions directly, not offer an opinion on what he already knows, he has been in IT for years and even in the security field.

Smarten up and lean how to read the question, don't assume that he doesn't already know what you are about to offer okay?

by synthetic

Your assumptions that _Christian_ is unaware of this is just ignorant, and that you should offer such an observation is
1. Completely rude, selfish, and shows poor moral character.

2. Leads on to believe that you do not have the many years, and expertise that _Christian_ has, and the Rolodex of knowledge your just waiting to flash before us. Next time, stay on track, there are two questions to be answered. No opinions, or observations have been asked for, and how ignorant to think, that in a open, friendly, non-formulaic site should one generate such opinionated garbage. What were you thinking bflin_flam? Hehehehehehehe, makes it to easy. Opps, I think that was an unwarranted observation that had nothing to do with the two possible questions.

by radiic

Cant you see _Christian_ doesnt care about what you have to say. All he wants is 1 or 2. Why should anyone ask and try to understand his problem so we could be a little more helpful. Cant you see he already knows everything>!

Jeez, you would think everyone here has Attention Deficit Disorder or something. Take some mind altering drugs first so that you can answer the question the way Christian wants you too>! X-(

by oz_media

Sounds like you've been taking lessons from Bush.

"non-formulaic"

I understand exactly what the meaning is, but is it REALLY a word??? IF so, who the hell used THAT one!? (other than you of course) ;)

by deepsand

Why, Doctor, how can you even consider that my diagnosis might be in error.

Remember the adage that "in matters of law, he who represents himself has an idiot for a client, and a scoundrel for an attorney."

by bhunsinger

Where did the program/virus come from: i.e. download or original disk?
What is the most effective way to get it cleaned up/protect others?
What is the reputation of the company with these issues?
Given these issues, here are some non issues
1)In the United States Legal liability: Anyone has a privlidege to call a cop when they think a crime is being commited. The only way you get in trouble is by lying. Handing over the documentation and saying this is suspicious, is not actionable.
2) Going public- if all you say is this is what I found in my disc/download- and it is there- truth is an absolute defense to libel/slander.
3) and if you add, In my opinion it is a trojan based on this this and this, everyone is entitled to an opinion.
CD copy: call the company- the evidence is not going anywhere.

Downlaod: I'm in the FBI office because to document such an issue, they need to preseve the chain of evidence. Let them handle the isuue. They get to deterine when and where the file was altered.

I have a relationship with the company and I know who will jump on this and that they will call int the cops, then I give them a break and tell them to meet me in the office.
If, as some of your posing suggest, this particular issue has been solved, check wth the local FBI office and ask them what to do in the future. If not in US, then call the national investigative branch concerned with this issue. Say you saw this issue on a site, and that's why you want to know.

by davoud

O.K I read all the messages and I agree that answering in a bad way to somebody who wants to help, is out of Charachter. But I guess _Christian_ already noticed this himself.

Anyways, why don't you (_Christian_) give us name of the Trojan and a guidance on how to be carefull not to purchase the software that you have purchased?

I am just a user and not an "IT PRO" like you.

by synthetic

Instead of asking general questions, and generally being negative to those trying to help, or otherwise taking, try giving. What software, what Trojan? Nice call davoud!

by jdclyde

by telling him what the had already decided and did not need us for in the first place.

Not much of a discussion, when you tell everyone how stupid they are for not just posting 1 or 2.

But as we are NOT the onces to have downloaded the trojan, who is the stupid one?

by oz_media

Wow, after reading about IT_Lobo's issue and then reading the bashing I go there, I really had to read my comments several times.

I honsetly don't think I did anything other than offer some sources of information, I didn't realize I was trouncing on the guys ability, or lack thereof.

Nice to see it WASN'T just me this time. Gaaaawd, what's wrong with all these overly sensitive people these days, did someone just unwrap another box of fragile IT members or something? They should place a warning on these posts:

WARNING: This comment came from a VEY sensitive person who is VERY insecure about his knowledge of IT. Please do not suggest you are helping them, just pretend they can be YOUR big helper, just like a 5 year old when it comes to lacing up shoes.

by oz_media

"a) You do not have a clue about actual security work (first rule is "do not give advance warning", which would be breached if I posted the info you ask for)"

The secret Coprorate Lawsuit :D.

Rule #1, you will need to air ALL of this information LONG before you ever see a courtroom or even come close to filing a suit.

by jdclyde

And this time it was ACTUALLY YOU that was attacted! Imagine that!

No, offering additional information is not out of line in a DISCUSSION which everything posted here IS.

He just wanted to have everyone see how clever he was for finding and identifing this unidentified Trojan verified by an unidentified source.

Sounds like the first cold fission experiment a few years back. Was a big deal till they couldn't support ANY of their claims.

He needs to find a non-tech site if he thinks this will get anyone to "oh" and "ah" his grand findings. Maybe his highschool classmates would be impressed?

Surely not the posting of a security professional or he would know that ANY security professional that isn't paranoid will be out of work real quick. It is a job requirement to keep you always looking for the next exploit.

by oz_media

Judging by the TITLE "...- What's next?"

And the comments: "a) You do not have a clue about actual security work (first rule is "do not give advance warning", which would be breached if I posted the info you ask for)"
LOL,I still find that rather amusing :)

I would have offered a detailed resolution to the issue at hand BUT....the first rule is "do not give advance info", which would be breached if I had actually offered any advice on the issue at all.

So which is it?

WHAT'S NEXT?
I ALREADY KNOW!
I HAVE A SECRET.
or
I NEED OPINIONS.

Maybe you should finger that one out before asking for advice next time, or simply POST IN THE CORREECT FORUM TO BEGIN WITH!

You don't want opinions, DON'T POST IN A DISCUSSOIN THREAD.

But now that I've told you that, I have probably breached he first rule of TR. "DON'T TRY TO OFFER ANY HELP TO PEOPLE WHO THINK THEY KNOW BETTER!"

What a putz!

by jdclyde

better do it again, unless you really did want to "finger that one".

I like to finger this one and that one and this one over there and this one over here and ....

by oz_media

He wouldn't wnt to hear the TEACHINGS of Christ.

Just
1) Did he live?
2) Can I take him to court if it's all a lie?

by deepsand

It's possible that, because Zone Alarm had'nt been trained to allow the possibly legit "RAT" in question to access the 'net, that, when it 1st tried to do so, and ZA presented its pop-up asking whether or not to allow the attempted action, our Christian assumed that it must be malware, otherwise ZA would have simply allowed it to do as it wished.

by thomasmac

I would not goto the editor but somebody
higher in the company as you say
Quote"It came as part of a LEGITIMATE software. That software has won several awards, including a 5 stars award from CNET.com"
So the higher the better Present your
findings and leave it with the CIO or CEO of the
company, Ask them to get back to you !As they have
cleaned up the newer version then Why were you not
informed about the possible Invasion of company
privcy???
TAM

This discussion is closed to new replies.