Question Locked

Two schools of thought on DHCP.

0 helpful
2 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am setting up a new network for a client with a DC and file server. All users are allowed internet access.
What is the opinion regarding using the router to perform DHCP vs using a Win2003 DC?
If you use the router then workstations are connected more or less directly to the gateway router. But if you use the DC you must access the DC to access the internet.
Is there a big performance hit if the DC has to perform DHCP and manage internet connections?

2 replies

by p.j.hutchison

I do not recommend using a router for DHCP when using Windows domains as clients must resolve names via Windows DNS so that can access the domain and windows resources.

If you used a Router DHCP it will use itself as DNS and gateway bypassing any Windows server and clients will not be able to access the domain.

If you use Windows DHCP you can control the gateway, IP address range(s), DNS entries for your Windows DC.

You would set up DNS on the DC and set up Forward addresses to the router for any internet access, clients will not know the difference and there will little if no performance hit.

This discussion is closed to new replies.