Discussion Locked

Unix flavor for new server being researched

0 helpful
29 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We are currently looking to purchase a new server which has the following requirements.
1). Host some web/java applications which have MYsql back end data base's.
2). Be a backup server for Crystal reports which were are currently deployed on a Microsoft Server.
* Research is occurring to change these over to native database drivers so they can function on different Os's.
3). Most likely, the CVS repositories I put in place will end up here.
4). There are some future java development occurring that will most likely find it's home on this server.
5). This server will be on an internal LAN, and not open to the world.

What they are trying to decide on is what flavor OS to run. The person that is doing this in charge of the purchase does not want to go with Microsoft. This is not because he is a Microsoft bash er, his requirements is to find an OS that does not have support and upgrade costs. He feels that a UNIX flavor can provide this and also be more reliable then MS.
Also, he is looking for an Unix OS that has a good GUI with low overhead because of the various daemons that he wishes to run on this server. I seriously doubt I'm going to be here forever, so there will be nobody with command line experience like I do(And I'm not even that bloody good). He is looking for the GUI that is straight forward in helping him maintain the OS and installed daemons(Apache, ssh, ssl, java, MySQL, ...).
Now, my personal preference is to use FreeBSD, but I can not in all honesty present an argument for using this as the OS. I have never dealt with FreeBSD in a production environment that maintained the types of applications that he wants to support. Truthfully, I think it could do it with out issue but I am unsure that his simplicity factor would be met. I've only ever done command line with this OS, and truthfull thats all I want to do.
I have used AIX before, but I believe the cost factor rules this out based on this person's specifications. He has looked at Suse, and was happy with everything but the support costs. Do you have to purchase Suse? I didn't think you did now that I think about it. Do you need a license for various patch's and upgrades to your port/rpm/??? packages? I didn't think it was a requirement for this either, unless you wanted technical support hot line assistance.
Any suggestions here? What ever is suggested I'm going to use to go do some followup research on.

29 replies

by jaqui

nope opensuse is available free of charge.

Red Hat's Fedora Core is the free version of RHEL

Mandriva 200x Free is their free of cost version.

all three have full easy to use gui tools for running the software.
Mandriva's are a bit more idiot friendly ;)

all linux distros have full gui tools, but the large "commercial" distros have a more polished set of tools. The drawback, the large "commercial" distros are also the least standards compliant.

for ease of use from a gui, stick with a kde based gui, so no Red Hat, no Debian [ majority of distros ] They default to G.N.O.M.E., which is designed to look and feel like Macos < 10 (X).
K.D.E. is designed to look and feel like windows, so it would be less stress for a from windows user to work with.

Suse requires that you have a large /opt partition, they decided that things like the gui, webserver, cvs server go there, instead of the standard /usr area. [ majorly stupid on their part ]
Mandriva changed the location of the GUI menu files, so that software for them doesn't install properly on another distro and visa versa.

Red Hat is GNOME based, so it's a completely different look and feel for a MS admin to get used to.

since this is for internal lan, going with the security of the bsd options isn't really needed, though open bsd is probably a good choice otherwise.

You might want to use samba as well, since a samba enabled server box will improve windows client connectivity for most areas.

Mandriva's DrakX Wizards will configure every server for you if you want, so the wierd file locations aren't a problem if you pick them.

I would concider postgresql for enterprise use, it has better security than mysql, with very little performance difference. Also, with postgresql being under the bsd license, it can be used as you want with no issues.

by dawgit

...If this is truely a comericial use (business) they may 'have' to 'purchase' a licence (and soft-ware). Very touchy area in some locations in the world. In that case, Then SuSE or Red HAT would be the prefered way to go. (also depending on location as to which one) -d

by jaqui

the majority of Mandriva is GNU-GPL, which doesn't allow for commercialisation of the software, but does allow for corporate use of the software.
[ v2 of gpl at least, v3 may be different. ]
Mandriva's own tools they created are all released under the GNU-GPL.

the "Boxed Sets" that you can buy have commercially licensed software, where you are right, licensing does come into play.
this is why the free versions are usually recommended for a single box, which will be minimally used as desktop, the commercial software is all desktop stuff, like Star Office, Crossover Office [ commercial version of wine ].

by danlm

Jaqui, I should have posted this question in the QA area so I could have reward points up. Sorry about that. I appreciate the in-site though.

I have been doing some reading on Mandriva(cnet, some it business reviews, Mandriva's web site) and everything I read and have forwarded to the purchasing person looks like this is what will work. I had a concern about hardware, because this individual was looking to purchase a 4 to 8 processor server and I seen in my reading that mandriva only supports up to 2 processors
(http://news.com.com/Mandrivas+new+server+Linux+does+virtualization+treble/2100-7344_3-6116959.html)
, but this does not seem to be an issue because the actual hardware purchase has not been done yet. And he was looking to future requirements for multithreading purposes. Right now, I don't think the have the overhead to require that so a dual processor would be sufficient.

I have also went through some of the documentation on the madriva web site, and it looks like it is fairly straight forward to install. Considering I just might end up being the person, I appreciate that. I have never done anything with mandrake or mandriva, and my only Unix installs have been FreeBSD.

Because I am under contract, and I do not know how long this will last. I don't feel comfortable suggesting BSD as the operating system even if what I have read it is a more secure operating system. I don't want to leave these people high and dry when my contract runs out with regard to who can support the new server.

I think my biggest question is, do you feel they need to go with the Corporate Server? I would think not if the Lite(?) version can handle the db/applications that need to run. Which from what I read, I think it can. And they purchase hardware to support what they for see as their current and future needs. Enough guts under the hood type of deal.

Hmmm, and I wonder at the complexity of upgrading to Corporate if they need to at a later time.

Thanks again Jaqui, your help has been very much appreciated. As always, youve laid out a number of options which is what I was looking for.

Dan

by jaqui

Mandriva has the server, Desktop, Community and clic as well as a live cd versions.

The server version is a single cd no gui install I beleive, the Desktop has full gui but no server software.
the Community [ Free ] version has both available.
the clic is a clustered version of Mandriva.

Purchase wise, I would say buy the Desktop version and add the servers you need from online repositories, or go with the free version.

Mandriva, was bleeding edge for most of their history, they found themselves in a bit of a financial bind and reversed that well enough to merge with another distro.
[ Mandrake Linux Sa + Connectiva Linux to Mandriva ]
The ability to get out of the financial straights within 2 years shows a company with reasonably responsive management. :)

Migrating from one version to another is a simple matter of copying the config files for most of the software to cd then back onto new version.
[ from regular workstation / server to clustered ]

the biggest changes for the cluster is in the kernel area not in the user software area.

by rem

I realize that Linux appears to be a good solution.
Have you considered Mac OS X. It is the largest distribution of UNIX and their are many people who support it. It meats the criteria of being easy to maintain and in expensive. An unlimited user licence version comes with Apples xServe and Apples xRaid is one of the most cost efficient way of adding storage to your system.

by danlm

This is the first time I have worked with Mac, and I have acquired a lot of respect for it. The box that we are currently using is a proof of concept machine only though. And doesn't have enough under the hood to suite the person that requested it. Plus, he feels that the overhead of Mac is a waist for what he wants from the server.

There really are two reasons he doesn't want to go with Mac, and stability is not one of them. But, they are the cost factor of Mac, and he feels that the overhead of the Gui which is tied into the OS(FreeBSD) is too high.

He doesn't want it, and I am not in a position to argue.

Good idea though, I'm impressed with what little experience I have with it. That's for sure.

Dan

by vlondini

4 Suggestions

I like the simplified Web-based administrative interfaces offered by the first three:

1) Nitix - www.nitix.com
Nitix is only 25MB. It bascially installs itself. Lots of cool features including auto-managed VPN.

2) ClarkConnect - www.clarkconnect.com
CC 4.0 includes a full groupware solution built on Kolab, Horde, and the Toltec connector - the price is excellent.

3) Collax Business Server - www.collax.com
A former CEO of SuSE and a former CTO of SuSE are now both with Collax. They just opened North American offices in Boston last month.

4) Xandros Server - www.xandros.com
A very Windows-like GUI - at half the cost. Xandros offers a Desktop OS, Server OS, and Management tools. Xandros picked up the Corel Linux team and assets a few years ago and is doing a great job with it, imho.

V

by justin james

I am working on a review of Collax now, actually. It is free, but only partially so. Much of its functionality needs to be purchased.

by vlondini

These four are not free, though most supply a limited "home" edition for free.

ClarkConnect is the least expensive of the four.

Collax actually comes close to Microsoft's cost when you include the OpenExchange server. But, if I read Collax's Web site correctly, phone support is included with the purchase. Try $245 a call for Microsoft.

Nitix and Xandros almost are priced almost identically.

There's some really cool technology in this workgroup-server-that-brings-Linux-to-the-masses market space.

by hbates1

I was going to also recommend Solaris, or what about Ubuntu? Sure, the server version lacks a GUI, but a quick "apt-get kdesktop" should solve that for you :) Also, you can make excellent servers from Fedora Core :)

by justin james

"Also, you can make excellent servers from Fedora Core"

first of all, Fedora Core is no longer being produced by Red Hat. More disturbingly, Fedora Core *is not production quality*! Yes, most of the code in FC is of a very high quality, but FC is quite clearly a development-quality release, and always has been. Anyone considering using FC on a producing server is someone considering losing their job...

J.Ja

by jmgarvin

Fedora is a great test platform, but I wouldn't put it in production. I also have some issues with the development of the various crap they put in.

If you want a Linux server check out Red Hat Enterprise, Novell SuSe, or IBM

by justin james

FreeBSD is an excellent choice for a server. BSD has a longer history of being used in production server environments than Linux and even Solaris.

That being said, if they want or "need" a GUI for their *Nix server, THEY HAVE NO BUSINESS HAVING A *NIX SERVER. If their level of comptence in *Nix is so low that they want/need a GUI and/or can't handle the CLI, they will end up spending a ton of money on *Nix support contracts. And that amount of money is high enough (compare a year of RHEL support to the purchase price of Windows 2003, if you do not beleive me), that if they do not need a support contract with Windows, and all other costs are equal (in other words, if they are using the same hardware, not hiring any people either way, etc.), the *Nix route is actually more expensive.

So yes, either they get real comfy with *Nix, learn the CLI, and leave Windows, or they go with Windows and no support contract. Anyone who puts a GUI on their *Nix server is just begging for problems.

J.Ja

* Minor edit for clarity, 9/28/2006

by danlm

I just don't like it, I think one of the strengths of a Nix server is that it only runs what is required. And all that processing power is used for the applications/daemons that you use the server for. Which is what you want, which is why you bought the server.

Going with a GUI just waist's valuable resources in my opinion. Also, I don't like not knowing what is going on. Doing command line makes me feel much more comfortable with regards to doing stuff. I know I am not that best Nix person, and I don't pretend to be. But I do know where I feel most comfortable, and a Nix gui isn't one of those places.

And there are others in this shop that don't want the Nix box, they want to go with Windows because that is what their Crystal reports are currently running from. And they have a say in things like this. I guess it is going to come down to who ever can justify their the position the best, which is the way it should be anyway.

Dan

by gsg

We have a couple of Unix machines that we've found are more expensive to maintain than our others. It could be because we have a lower level of competence with these than we do the others, but since the hardware is significantly higher, I don't think that's the whole issue, just a contributing factor. The plus side is that we have longer uptimes with them.

by cmelebeck

You could look into these two possible solutions:

Ubuntu (Linux) at www.ubuntu.com and also the free version of Solaris 10 at www.sun.com.

I found Ubunto very easy to install and they plann on supporting the current version for up to 5 years. The web site has quite a bit of information.

by max_bogomips

If you want to have binary compatibility and all the "goodies" of a full Red Hat Enterprise Linux install you might want to check out CentOS http://www.centos.org/

This way if you need outside support from a vender, you can just look to one who knows RHEL.

by ibanezoo

There are no support or upgrade costs other than perhaps consulting from a third party. I havn't found anything it won't do, yet. We use it as a core for our email systems, database servers (mysql), webservers, monitoring servers, and a few other things.

by tstone3

You always end up needing a command line eventually even on Microsoft systems.

Just adding and removing users is pretty simple GUI stuff on almost any OS made today. However, if you are looking at ssh, apache, java, MySQL, etc., a command line will be needed at some point. None of that stuff works without some technical expertise.

As for Suse support costs, it is pretty cheap compared to Windows or AIX. Don't forget about continued upgrade costs, too.

by justin james

tmstone -

Yes, you are right, many/most sys admin functions in *Nix do have GUI alternatives. But the use of CLI on *Nix is not only preferred, but mandatory for many more tasks on *Nix than Windows.

More to the point, X (and the desktop managers built on top of it) is incredibly resource intensive, tends to be unstable with less-than-mainstream hardware, and is in general quite a pig. I would never in a million years run X on a server unless it was an X farm type setup, which is pretty rare now. I have never once found a valid need to install X on a *Nix server.

If the client demands a GUI because they do not feel comfortable with a CLI, they have no business touching a *Nix server. It also makes me wonder how they are managing their routers & switches...

J.Ja

by danlm

Cell/land line company that also had a publishing company breaks into two companies. Prior to the breakup, the methodology for their LAN and stuff was set that a central/corporate office maintained the LAN/switch's and mainframe. Where the local offices mostly take care of desk top. The publishing company had a few servers on site they maintained, but these small servers were the only things they had to worry about.

After the split of these companies, the publishing part of this is trying to get more control over their own IT destiny. Support basically sucks from the local/corporate office. Hard drive failures on support/development servers which ended up causing over a week of down time for these specific functions. The primary db servers are also controlled from this office. The publishing company is trying to get more control over this. They can't necessarily change what already is in place, but anything new they are trying to control. this server is specific to the publishing arm of the company. They don't want it controlled by people that haven't a clue what this arm's business requirements really are.

Basically, cutting out everything I just said above. It's politics. Publishing wants more control, and this is the only way they will get it.

If I knew for certain I was going to be here for good. I would push the BSD/command line nix, because I think I could maintain it. Specially with the requirements that I see now and into the future.

Dan

by pgm554

You can go free SuSE,but if you want support,I would go with the Novell/OES stuff.

You get all of the tools and apps you are looking for(Apache,MySQL)plus Novell makes sure the kernal and security patches are up to date.

Built in clustering,along with robust management tools(YAST and iManager)along with the best directory service(Edir) available,makes a very strong case for Novell.

Novell is a "no brainer".

You can download a 90 day eval.
And if it is to your liking,just buy a license file.
You don't have to reinstall anything.

by bill_w

More to the point, why not FreeBSD with a tool like Webmin? We maintain (not that they need a lot...) our half-dozen FreeBSD servers via Webmin, which is a web-based graphical admin tool for FreeBSD. No real overhead on the server, at least compared to X or some GUI.

It could be argued that servers should be in a server room and not normally be accessed by the local keyboard and monitor anyway.

And if we do need command-line access, there's SSH.

However, Dan, it really looks like your issues there are political, not technical....

Good luck.

by danlm

I never knew about the Winmin though. I am going to research this out.

These people seem to always want to be at the machine when they do things, where I always ssh in and su up. That is something I definitely want to change here if I possibly can. There is no reason for it. After an initial install of the OS, there really isn't a reason to ever sit at a machine again physically if it is set up right. Least, in my experience this has been the case.

dan

by justin james

I have servers here without video cards! If it happens, it is SSH or nothing. :) If the server is down hard, I can rip a video card out of a desktop temporarily to get the machine up and running.

If I can run a "full boat" FreeBSD server solely thorugh SSH, anyone can.

J.Ja

by danlm

Seriously, my home BSD system sits under a table with a table cloth on it. I do all installs, everything from ssh. The issue really isn't if I can run the machine straight from ssh. Shoot, I've been doing most of the installs on their Mac server like that. The problem is if I'm not there, can they? And the answer in my mind is no. This guy can figure it out, I don't doubt that. But, he ummmmmm scares me sometimes with what he does.

Let me put it this way, if I can work them into FreeBSD(no cost for OS or upgrades) which I know there are many forums to use for help(minimal support costs) by using winmant because he gets his pretty gui that he can click and install. I know that I provided them with a solid operating system that there are lots of help forums they can run to. Because, they are going to need the help. Shoot, I use the forums constantly. At least if I get him to use that winmant(web/perl), I stopped him from doing everything at the machine. God, that bugs me.

Hell, I need to teach these people about security. I would never, ever, ever have left someone that came in as a pl/sql coder(me) installing and setting up security on a server. Just the thought makes me shudder.

What I'm going to do is install winmant on my home machine from ports, get it working... Then show him from work what it looks and feels like.

Dan

ps. sorry, I got off topic there

by danlm

I've done some reading, and some testing on my home machine. I learned along time ago to never go in with just one proposal. So, I going to present two options to him. Actually, I already have but I'll do it in a formal manner.

Option 1. FreeBSD with the webmin port installed.
Thanks bill_w, much appreciated. I didn't know about this port.
I am a FreeBSD fan from get go and know my way around it. I've tested the port to a certain extent on my own machine and pretty much like it. As long as the ports are kept up to date, this should meet his requirements of installs. And there is a lot of system functions that can be performed from this. I was putzen with my sendmail from the pages, and I hate sendmail. It was actually helpful to me, I have always been scared of sendmail just because of the possibilities of being used as a relay.
Also like that it has ssl log in. Even if it is on a LAN, I like that a lot. I still prefer command line, but that's the way I learned(the old main frame programmer in me). But, he should be able to get by. Also, there is a huge amount of online forums and tech area's for support issues if needed with FreeBSD. Free, this he should like.

Option 2. Mandriva.
Did a bit of reading on this, liked what I seen. Thanks Jaque, much appreciated your input. Your right, I was reading how they turned that company around. How Mandriva is becoming a large server OS in Latin America and Europe. The support options are flexible, and the GUI from what I seen via various web sites looks pretty idiot proof. Probably more so then the FreeBSD - webmin. Another established OS with a lot of following, should be a good amount of forums and how to online area's for assistance.

Again, I wanted to thank everyone and let you know what I was going to propose.

Dan

This discussion is closed to new replies.