Discussion Locked

USA is going global and losing jobs

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
As a result of going global, America's IT workers have been losing more and more jobs each year to outsourcing. Our President feeds the economy to create more jobs but does not understand the dichotomy of IT - which in itself is designed to be more productive and need less human intervention with each upgrade or enhancement. Going global just makes the process much easier buy combining international resources together to eliminate the need for as many IT workers with each new solution. By working globally we find other resources much cheaper than those found in the USA and the American worker is eliminated. Is there a solution to this problem ?

21 replies

by oz_media

You could always move. The IT industry in Canada is fantstic, I turn down work constantly. The only thing with IT in Canada is that your bst off generalizing in th eindustry instead of being a specialist in a particular field.

by john_wills

Under the theory of comparative advantage, which has lots of history to prove it true, this globalization should result in an improved total utility. The problem is only the temporarily reduced utility of the person who loses his job. The steel workers, for instance, are in cahoots with their employers and their Congressmen to reduce the total utility of the world and of the U.S. for the sake of temporarily maintaining their utility. The correct answer to competition is finding a new niche, perhaps after retraining. This can be very difficult, as I know from long experience of unemployment. I have the extra personal problem of being "overqualified" for many jobs - I was once fired after a few days doing good work because the manager got around to looking at my work history. The social solution to this problem is somehow to persuade hiring managers that overqualification is not a lack. The personal solution is to take an interest in every job I do and to make sure that my managers knowI do so.

by nat18466

Can anything global be done in an Orderly way or does it have to be chaotic? Majority if people in the USA hold information technology positions. After all what is USA market - it is Info Technology. But we seem to have gone global with no plan other than lets throw the sticks up in the air and see where they fall.( Our sticks by the way ). When the sticks fall we won't have most of them any more - someone else will duhhh.
Our global strenght grew but in the process we found ways to eliminate what we discovered was fat. We found somthing leaner. We did not make use of the fat. We wasted and had not made use of the product life cycle. American workers are part of the life cycle of any product that gets outsourced overseas we need to include them in the life cycle of the product.This is the only solution I can offer to the pitfalls of Global expansion. I hope corporate america can think lifecycle not just change or expansion for cost savings.

by road-dog

understood by the administration. From my understanding of thei Administration, it is largely based on a free market approach to the economy. It would be hypocritical to institute government policies prohibiting export of labor while pursuing free trade agreements.

I tend to agree. I too have seen this movement by American companies outsourcing to companies overseas. Although this alarms me, I cannot fault companies protecting shareholder interest and competing using legal means.

IT is restructuring right now, post tech wreck. I suspect that this trend will continue. It really peeves me when I call tech support and need my Delhi decoder ring to understand the response.

What really gets me is these "get your MCSE in 30 days" dealspromising gigabuck careers to rubes who remember the '90's tech boom and don't realize what the current situation is. These folks are ripping people off, cranking out new paper MCSEs to further flood a bad market.

I guess we need an IT equivalentof the "buy American" campaign. If there were any new regulations put in place, every vendor of hardware, software, and services should be forced to post a disclaimer if they outsource overseas. Maybe we could create an "IT America" seal that the product is at least 80 percent coded and supported domestically.

Does anyone else think that would carry weight with American buyers and companies?

by thechas

As it has become easier to transport products and skills to lower labor cost locations, US industries have been moving nearly all activities to foreign locations.

There is no good solution to stop this trend.

The US work-force is going to haveto suffer until our standard of living more closely matches that of the rest of the world.

The jobs that cannot currently be moved off-shore are:
Retail
Construction
Health care
Hospitality
Trucking

Until the global economy grows to the point where all countries have the same costs of doing business, the US (and other high standard of living countries) will continue to loose jobs.

Chas

by djent

You can make your own personal statement in reply. disqualify those companies (HP, Dell, Ford, GM) that have "globalized" our jobs. Bypass the lowest price for better quality and support. As a nation we are on the fast track to becomming hamburger flippers and janitors. Let the global companies sell their products to the employees of their subcontractors. How long does it take to buy a Ford Taurus at $2 per hour or an HP computer at $20 per week? The unemployed from globalized companies are notbuying new cars or computers, they can't on their wages. To the CEOs, when you displace your "overpriced help" you also remove them from the marketplace. You can cost cut yourselves right out of existance.

by john_wills

A certain amount of ignorance of economics has been shown in some of the contributions above. However, I note that Microsoft is hiring for 5000 new R & D positions and is offering high wages to attract people from other firms to Redmond. That means those other firms will have 5000 spare positions unemployed IT people can move into, some directly and some indirectly. The trick is finding those positions: stop moaning about rivals abroad and take advantage of employers' rivalry for you. Also, if Microsoft is expanding R & D, maybe Peoplesoft, Oracle etc. will too. Maybe SAP will, then you can emigrate and prevent Germany completely depopulating. A prime rule of liberal (and distributist) economics is that by sharing wealth we increase it, and that is what is happening when some jobs are exported.

by oz_media

Microsoft is hiring tons of people from the British Columbia INstitute of Technology (BCIT) and Toronto's colleges (that where Bill scooped the Windows idea).
In Vancouver there was a huge job fair last week for IT students and those looking to enter IT as Microsoft was here on a hiring rampage.
So, it is fortunate for those who got hired but unfortunate that all these American jobs are being filled by Canadians.

by djent

You can spout economic principals ad infinitum but unemployed auto workers don't buy new cars, computers or anything but basic sustinance. They also don't qualify for MS R&D positions. Read the unemployment numbers, we are loosing manufacturing jobsto second and third world countries at an alarming rate. Do you think Nike could afford to pay a living wage to children in Maylasia when they sell sneekers at $100+, hell no they would rather pay some jock $90 Mil to hawk their overpriced junk. I am suggesting that to many large corporations need a refresher on ethics and responsibility. Is it fiscally wise to trash 10% of production workers annually that earn $25 per hr and send those jobs offshore for $2 per hr? In the short term maybe, in the long term they shrink the domestic market, convert self sufficient workers into a national social burden, borderline poverty service workers. Tell me thats good economic policy. Maybe we could retrain all those 55 year old punch press operators tobe software developers or high energy physicists while we are at it.

by djent

I notice from your BIO that you are employed a local Gov. in CA.. It is common for local Gov. entities to require residency of their domain, profer hiring advantages to minorities, veterans, handicapped and a host of other social subgroups. It seemsthat you may be enjoying the kind of protection you think the public at large should be denied.

by john_wills

Are they bad people? Should they not be given equal access to work possibilities? And if the best BC informaticians move to Redmond surely some Nyawkers and Angelenos can move to Montreal and Toronto? By the way, I thought it was Apple Bill copied the Windows idea from, though I stand open to correction. If

by oz_media

I dont know what you read into my post but I live ni BC. It was just a statement, people in the states are wondering why jobs are leaving the US for foreign countries, I assume Canada is a foreign country because the jobs are being farned from here.

As for the Apple and Gates thing, to the best of my understanding, Gates scooped the computer model from his buddy (now apple)but DOS and Windows from two techs from Toronto, of course he offered them jobs at MS just to be PC.

by djent

If you bone up on your history you will find that Xerox originated the GUI concept, offered it free of licence fees as a public service. Apple then used the concept and tried to sue MS when they also used it. GUI is a Xerox's IP, not Apple's.

by john_wills

You are spouting the same kinds of arguments that turned the Wall Street Crash into the Great Depression.

by djent

You sound like a politician. Address the salient points. Is it ethical to displace American workers in favor offshore labor for price alone? What is to be done with the displaced labor force? What effect does the shift from high value manufacturing jobs to low value service jobs do to our economy and GDP. How do we offset the trade deficits created by these policies? Then there is the cost to the public at large as a result of large trade deficits. Politicians espouse theoretical platitudes without solutions for the problems they create with their policies.

by john_wills

Is it ethical to save a cent per ton-mile - or whatever it is at the moment - by shipping via rail rather than road? All production is for consumption. The firm aims to maximize added value, which it measures in money. Turn your question round: it is ethical to refuse on grounds of sentiment alone to employ equally good workers more in need of the wages than those you might employ locally?

by nat18466

Do not fret..Since we who have dependants are recieving our checks at $400 per child we are on the road to economic recovery right? NOPE - - wrong. That $400 per child will pay for the next months rent - or bankrupcy lawyers fees - - too bad. But hey why the sour grapes. Do you know a politician who is worried about what happens after the the $400 per child is used up - I dont.
And like the corps that are not ethically grounded the same goes for the decision makers. i fear that like mold that grows and sporns then eventually dies we have to wait for this age of unethical reality to die before we can gain enough strenght to support our families hope for a more stable future - or any future at all.

by djent

There is an interesting artical in Information Week, July 28 issue, titled IBM Backlash, that outlines this subject.

by john_wills

In California it is illegal for a public entity to insist that its employees reside within the entity's boundaries; I actually live in a neighboring county. I belong - not quite the right word - to one of the ethnic groups liable to be disadvantagedby preferences. The least professional questions I was asked at my interview were about intercourse with members of other races, so I told them about my lunching habits at my previous job. But even if I were enjoying advantages I disapprove of, doesthat matter? I don't think mortgage interest should be tax-deductible, but I take the deduction; I don't approve of Dubya's tax cuts, but I am not making contributions to the U.S. Government to offset them; I disapprove of the extra floating holidays I have been given in a complicated deal resulting from the City's fiscal problems, but I intend to take them. I didn't vote or campaign for any of these things.

by djent

Few decisions are based on economic logic alone and neopotism is a time honored practice, correct or not. All entities, Gov. or private, factor some predudice into their decisions. Case in point, USA tarrifs on EU steel imports VS EU ban on geneticly altered AG products. Neither of these items are based on economic logic. They are in fact emotional decisions, pure and simple. Back to my reply to the original post. I suggested that the poster could vote with his feet to reenforce his feelings. Iwas not promoting trade protectionism. I was advocating the option to make a personal, emotional if you like, choice. There are however some gross inequities that the USA suffers as a result of geo-political and geo-economic differences with our trading partners and we do need some mechanism the balance these problems. Many global corporations use this situation for economic advantage reguardless of ethics. We as individuals have the option of endorsing or rejecting their choices VIA or spending habits.

by nat18466

I love the fact that others can benefit from the great American products by using and producing as well. I want those in other countries to continue to do what they are doing. I don't want to take all of what we have and give it to them so I am left with nothing. Somehow I feel ownership in what we as Americans have invented and produce. I believe it is irresponsible to take all and give away. I believe such economics much like human behavior will cause Americans to react accordingly. If we are to keep a boat moving forward we must have balance. If we are to continue with globalization we also must have balance not imbalance.

This discussion is closed to new replies.