Discussion Locked

User perception of IT staff as irrelevant or slackers

0 helpful
59 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

OK, here's the issue...

Our department has come under fire for our perceived "slackness" This is mainly fuelled by people seeing us coming and going at non-standard hours (not knowing the real hours put in) and the fact that we all refuse to get stressed / angry when they are having problems. We are the normal bunch of guys who happen to love and enjoy our jobs, who get along well and even management conceed we are doing a great job.

The problem is how to fix the public PERCEPTION that we are not worth our pay etc. etc.

Any ideas???

59 replies

by nicknielsen

Invite some of the loudest complainers to accompany you through your "slacker" day. Just the invite causes many people to take a second look. The rest have second thoughts when you tell them that "shadow day" will start at 0600 because you have to verify back-ups!

Seriously, though, see if your management is amenable to job shadows. It's amazing how fast eyes can open when they take a walk in the "slack" shoes.

by fred123456

I don't really see the need to change the PERCEPTION. If management sees your department as a well organized, efficient team, then thats all that matters.

If their are fellow employees in other departments who think you are "slackers". It may be impossible to prove to them you are not.

Management should be looking at the people and departments who are complaining the most. My guess is those departments have either to much time on their hands or the employee's are unhappy about their work load.

I.T. is always an easy scapegoat when the users is ticked about to much work.

by sgt_shultz

who knows what strange ideas folks have about IT. Unless I get feedback directly from management, I just let it roll off back. Taking stuff personally bears too high a price for me usually...

by four-eyes_z

If you are consistently meeting your key performance indicators then you should have nothing to be worried about.

Why dont you email that unhappy bunch of people a copy of the powerpoint slide that gets presented to management during meetings? That should show all of them that you are meeting your KPI's.

You have nothing to be worried about... You can never please everybody anyway...

by kscheer

I agree, this isn't a big problem if your management appreciates you. It is your management's job to help change those perceptions. I would go to your manager or Director and talk about how you feel. They can help with changing this perception. Most people have a hard time understanding what we do but if you get more involve in the business process it can help. The key to this is to talk to the user so they can understand what you are saying don't try to use too many technical terms.

by gerberb58

You're doing your job? You are happy? The organization is fond of the work?

Disable all their accts and TELL THE BOZO's TO TAKE A HIKE!

Or better yet, Complain about THEIR SLACKERS, disable all their accts, tell them to call someone who gives a s**t, and tell'em to go play in the street.

by fred123456

Ok gerberb thats a litte extreme, but perhaps a simple logon script popup that displays a message like...

We are currently workng to make your computers more efficient. Please wait...

Let the script pause the logon process for a duration of your choosing.

Then dispaly a "Thank You" from the IT team for you patience.

by w2ktechman

a system hang randomly throughout the day for 30 seconds to 1 minute.
It should run at least every 3 hours.

by sgt_shultz

that was funny. and somewhat tempting.
hey gerber, i grew up in rochester michigan. where do you work? maybe they will can YOUR ass and I can get your job...

by gerberb58

And apparently, much toooooooo long. I've heard them all. I know just what he is talking about. The last end user that questioned my "work ethic" never used his PC again at that company. I turned is cyber days into vaporware. He was canned a week later.

by w2ktechman

First, is the job getting done?
How does management feel about the IT dept?
Do you have to do research, upgrades, etc.?
If those are going well, there should be little concern for your appearance to others. But there are things that can be done to increase the IT appearance.
Work with different department, poll them to see what can/may be made better for them to work more efficiently. This does not have to be constant (like you are bored), but an ongoing thing where departments can add feedback that can help them.
But dont stop there, look into their needs and address them, even if the answer is ultimately a "no". They can/will feel more appreciated by IT, and will know that you are at least looking into their problems/needs.

by fred123456

Nice.. So now your just proving to us that your work ethic is vindictive and childish.

I'll bet you admin password is GOD isn't it..

by gerberb58

I wish my name was Gerber, that way I wouldn't have to work in IT, just make food and collect millions...LOL.

by sgt_shultz

man, it always keeps coming back to that.
i spend most of my first 6 months at a new job developing, cultivating.
listening. following up. writing up instructions. do it their way etc etc
hey, where did this soapbox come from?
(sound of me pushing it back under bench)
sorry

by fred123456

To quote your name sake...
I see nothing, I know nothing!

Schultz! Close the gates! The War is back on!

by dr dij

alot of good points came up, such as who cares, etc.

But it can't hurt to do a few small things.

Always carry a notebook.
Look worried.
Be friendly but professional; keep to minimum the watercooler chat during working hours (ok at lunch or after work), even if she's really cute :).

If any of those users stop you for questions, be nice to them but unless work related act like you're in a hurry, ask them to put their question thru the proper channels. Support request, etc unless you can do it in 15 seconds and have time right then.

Carry a cup of coffee in with you when you enter the building later than normal starting time. Mutter within their hearing about having to stay late (or traveling to other offices, etc), but not complaining, instead that you're HAPPY to be doing this, and wish you could leave when they left.

This is regardless of when you actually stay till. My preference is to stay late only if a real emergency. Otherwise I'm working smart, not hard as House MD says. (OK, my gf likes him, don't know why).

If things don't get done and you were working all day, isn't your fault and they need to hire extra help. Leave on time or close to it. But if you're on a roll and can finish something up quickly, stay and do it.

by absolutely

If they don't notice you've gone, they're right. If they do notice, and wish you were not gone, you have won.

by w2ktechman

the best response yet! I have actually suggested a 'day off' for the whole dept. a few times, and rotate it throughout all of the various IT departments. See how much people get done if say, a router goes down....

by leee

I agree with the vacation -- it's safer than losing your job and everyone finding out the hard way!

At the last place I worked, our IT-department-within-a-department had that same reputation. So they eliminated our jobs. It was a university, so they were not permitted to refill jobs they'd eliminated. Since then, I understand, the department has more or less collapsed upon itself. (They don't call it infrastructure for nothing!)

by neon samurai

Blank the screen and draw one of those old time cartoon bands with the five guys and instruments all squished together. Have it march across the screen playing "yankee doodle" or whatever. Add a banner waving above in the breeze if you like. For the final flare, have it march off the other side of the screen and on too the next screen along the office.

or

Start with a single pixel in reverse colour that buzzes about a little then stops. As it buzzes about more, it get's bigger until; fwap!, and a giant fly lands on the "other side" of the screen. Make the buzzing about and "getting closer" bit as long as you like.

I never did write either one but thinking about it still makes me giggle a little. I don't know that it would help the IT departments image but it might be fun.

by w2ktechman

Back in the Win 95 days (and not at work) I had found a program from an antivirus company, that simulated a virus deleting all of your files. It first took a snapshot of your directory structure so it looked pretty real.
Anyway, an explorer window opens and the prompt to delete all of your files came up, it would not let you press no, and soon it continued while if you did not know what it was it was horrendous site to see.
After it was done it simulated a shutdown, then it pops up with a big sign THANK GOD THIS IS ONLY A GAME then the av company logo appears.
This was a fun one to run in someones startup group. I wish I had a digital camera back then....
I did this to one person who kept powering the system off and then rebooting. After several times this person finally just let it go through the motions, but wanted to kill me afterwards......It was fun though.

Also a good one, an old teacher had setup a netware server while in school. He 'allowed' me to obtain his PW, so I logged in as him and created a logon script to log him off. This was funny as heck. But I did give myself 2 admin accounts as well, so I could get back in....

The devious are truly blessed.

by fred123456

Back in Win95 days there were some great gags called the runaways.
They were mostly mouse related, where the mouse would just not do what it was told.

But one of the best was the one that made the windows you had open runaway from your mouse. Go anywhere near the Title bar with your mouse, any button up their and the window would just sort of slide away before you could touch it.

I loaded that on a buddies PC at work and it was hilarious. For a moment he thought it was possessed

by dumphrey

I remember that one. My current favorite atm is BSOD screen saver from systernals. It Simulates a blue screen and a lot of verbal print garbage. Pretty fun really.

by martinaaa2

you know its really true - and you think you've got all us customers fooled just because you can talk geek!

by highlander718

in all honesty in some of my previous jobs, I had the same impression about the other departments (what on earth can they be doing the whole day, how come they go for a smoke every half an hour, chat next the water cooler every hour, and having a vague idea about their work just couldn't imagine how can they fill in more than 3-4 hours a day).
No if I look at my part, there are/were days and days ... I had the ones where I was cleaning up the server room just out of bore, than the normal ones when I was running around, really working for 4-5-6 maybe 7 hours out of 8, and then there were the crisis or special project ones when I was there up to 20 hours (maybe 2-3 times a year) and some calls in the middle of the night to spice it up (at one point these were happening almost weeky).

So ....

we used to have interdepartamental presentations, discussing diferent projects, trying to get an understanding on what others are doing.

Right now, I'm at the point when I want to give my best service, the fastest possible way, I want to have everything as organised as possible, I do not care what other colleagues are doing and how long they work as long as it doesn't affect my work and as long as I get their attention when I need it. I also do not care what they think of my work schedule or how I look in their eyes as long as I stick to teh above mentioned principles :-)

by glennhughes

You need to articulate to them 2 things.
1 - That you understand to some degree their business and what is important to them.
2 - Where IT is adding value and making the IT services better.
For example have you identified the root cause to a recurring system problem ... every month end the finance system slowed down due to all the accounting bods running month end reports so IT added additional capacity to improve performance (either permanently or when demand peaks). This shows you fixed something AND you know when the system is most important to them. Make sure it is in plain English not techie babble.
This assumes you are actually doing something productive, if you are not then you deserve to be fired anyway.

by sartrains

When was the last time that your department went to the groups that you support? Your department has the role of providing the Infrastructure that allows them to do their roles, so go and see what it that they want and not just at a managerial level, see what the guys/gals on the floor need, there may be things that are being missed that could help out your colleuges that would really help them out and increase your inter-departmental reputation

by efranko

Long time reader, first time poster. I have been in the IT world for about 15 years now, mostly on the consulting side. I do agree it is important that you must have the powers at be on your side and happy but users or employees are more important.

In today's world IT is the clue that holds companies together. ALL Employees need to be able to do their jobs to keep the company going. It is the function of IT to make that happen as smooth and easy as possible, 24x7x365 if need be. If you are not willing to do that then you need a new career path Like it or not it's not 9 to 5.

If you are finding your users are not happy with the IT department then get out and find out why. I have found over the years it is crucial to talk with everyone in the company not just management. Users are more important because they are doing the lions share of the work. They know the ever day process and what it takes to do them. What better way to find out about things that are not working correctly then going to the source.

My advice after 15 years is to talk with the users. Be response to more then just problems or emergencies. Be proactive. They have a wealth of information to give. It really works.

by swardco

Wow I have read the statements here and I think that everyone is missing the big picture here. Perception is everything (think Beta vs VHS) and if you are not managing perceptions that your "customers" have about you then you are probably exactly what your customers are complaining about. While it is true, most customers have no idea what exactly is needed to keep a network up and running it is also true that sometimes all they need is a few minutes of your time to be reassured that their concerns are being at least evaluated. Also don't confuse their ignorance about computers as if they are stupid; after all you can't do brain surgery but some people who can't boot their computers can.

by highlander718

While I used to think the same when I was a beginner in the field, now I find it sad to say that "Perception is everything". You end up caring more about perception than the actual job to be done.

My personal opinion is that the focus is the job, and if it's done properly, perception comes automatically. Or else there are users who will not care, or will have something bad to saywhatever you do.

Sorry, but your "Perception is everything" sounds more like lip service to me. Again, sorry if I didn't understand, nothing personal, unfortunately we don't have the space here for a detailed debate :-)

by samuellthomasjr

It has been my experience that end-users, our customer, don't have much opportunity or reason to know who we are and what we do. If we seize the moment, and make an opportunity, to address a customer's issue in a timely manner, rapidly & thoroughly resolve their problem and do it with a happy & positive attitude, everyone wins. Seize the moment and frequently visit with your customers. They may need help with something very simple, that can be addressed as a "drive-by". It does not help ticket resolution count, but it changes the customer's perspective and surely adjusts their perception.

by charles.williams

Your message is very important! The manner that we use to handle our internal customers does make a difference. I work in a large Community College. Since I am assigned to a fixed building with many users, I have found that by making about 3 rounds a day through my building I can be proactive with my end users. Through some brief conversation (even if it is to say Hi! ) My internal customers have gotten to know me better and items that are little problems can be solved right there while I am talking to them. This prevents the customer from waiting until it is a big problem and everyone is stressed. You mentioned the help tickets, what I do is file a ticket on their behalf for the service work that I do during my rounds. This way everyone wins! I also carry a small pocket sized spiral book to make notes with, where each service is recorded.
My Customers always look forward to see me because I don't put them down and I use humor to defuse the situation. How many of you get a call and you get to the customer's location and the customer says "It's working fine know, I don't know what happened." I always tell them that like people Computers always feel better when the Doctor walks in. I offer to make a cardboard cut out of me to scare the dickens out of the machines.
Another thing is don't be afraid to to say I don't know. then follow it with: I am going to consult with my department's experts to see if we can solve the mystery.
I always follow up and I never promise more than I can deliver.
So if you want the users to rave about your help, get to know them.
Remember, other people are our mirrors. THey mirror back to us , what we are giving them. Think positive, be positive and the smile is best way to melt the worst grouch. Always talk to the good side. Be friendly and always helpful. and finally: the solution: All computers do that when you jiggle them. Will bring a smile to most faces when you are trying to figure out a problem. I always teach how to avoid the problem or the new method for a customer to use to get the answer they expect. Don't use jargon unless it is funny and it will help them to remember what you taught them. For example, I was installing Vista and a customer was asking me about the differences they might expect to see. We were talking about software activation ( I used the example of ET ... Software phone home. I told him we have a server that handles this every 180 days. I called it the EULA server. EULA phones for us and she is efficient. HE asked me what a EULA was so I explained it to him, he thought is was funny we having to let our server phone home so 'Uncle Bill' wouldn't worry about it.
HAve a GREAT week!

by jedmundson

SBWA: Support By Walking Around.
I agree wholeheartedly. I work at a small chemical manufacturing plant. I support, not only this site, but two others more than 200 miles away.

I make it a point to walk the local site every day and just check in at every office that has a computer.

Every week, I make "telephone rounds" of my two other sites (I support their databases remotely), just to check in.

I not only find that many of my users don't like to deal over the phone and just wait for me to come around.

You get to know everyone by name eventually, and they know you.

Now my problem is "How do I keep them from trying to have cannonized?"

by nicknielsen

I do the same, but my territory is almost 250 long (and pretty much the width of the Interstate :D ). I make weekly or bi-monthly visits to all my stores and also make a point of asking if there are any problems.

My customer service mentor always attributed the "It's working fine now, I don't know what happened" syndrome to "technician effect." His explanation had to do with that noise your car makes until you take it to the shop.

You know you're doing well when the customers who used to seriously ask "What do YOU want?" now ask the same question to tease.

Edit: punctuation

by w2ktechman

I had a bunch of them.
Not long ago I was going through old cd's, and found a bunch. Loaded them onto my 98 box for the memories...

by techmail2

I've been in an odd-hour job (24/7 tech support for a major telecom) and had people working elsewhere in the same building complain about our group not keeping standard hours.
It required having a manager a couple of levels up on the complainants' side to tell them "No, they don't work 8 to 5. They often work much longer days than that. You can work the same hours if you want, but with no increase in pay for the extra hours."
The complaints stopped.

by rfrias

It is always a problem with techies since people do not know what the hell they were doing. I felt the same problem when I was still an ordinary engineer and how did I solve it? I started documenting what I am doing and created a report that I submit to all departmental managers. Eventually I became a manager and rose up the ranks and reporting and documentation has been one of my strongest assets. I even maintain a daily activty log as well as my daily log-ins and log-outs.

by kaburu

... I don't mean that your department are a bunch of slackers, Steve, but rather that the user perception could masking a genuine service issue. For example...

I've worked in a couple of companies where users tend to be early starters - in at 7:30 and gone by 4 or 4:30. IT departments are notoriously late starters (often precisely because they were in until midnight last night fixing yesterday's problem or forestalling tomorrow's.) But all these users see is people rocking up a couple of hours late by their perceptions.

And if one of these early bird users finds a worm or other bug in their PC at 7:30 and can't get a response from their Help Desk, who are still asleep at home, then they may even have a genuine grievance.

I don't know whether this is or something like it could apply in your situation. Is it worth researching? Maybe ask the other managers. Or if you really want to find out, ask your team what they've learned from the non-management users at the coffee machine/pub/gym/whatever. Scuttlebutt can be very useful - managers don't always understand their team's problems.

The more you understand the problem, the better your chance of finding the right solution. For the rest - I think user perception's always going to be an IT problem!

by wayne m.

Has anyone verified the users' perceptions and underlying reasons? One needs to take care not to assume why the users feel they way they do.

Though coming and going at unusual times might explain the "slacker" comment, I am not sure it addresses the "irrelevant" comment. Why do users not feel the department is helpful?

Try to have some informal discussions with the users. A series of 5 minute discussions over coffee can reveal a lot more information than a month's worth of "survey monkey" style requests. Also, realize that the department may need to change what it is doing to better meet the expectaions of the users.

by charles.williams

Surveys, the bias goes in before the name goes on. The more informal the talk the greater the accuracy. Sometimes an informal donut and coffee talk can find the true path. But you first have to be trustworthy, someone who has earned their trust not someone who parrots the stock answers.

by siobserver

Having read some of the responses to your post I totally disagree that "retaliation" of any sort is advised. That in fact would prompt me to terminate your employment (thus solving the problem for you) were I in a position to do so.

Having said that, I presume you do have a supervisor who I also presume would report to the CIO of your company.

This situation should be brought to the attention of the CIO. Problems of the nature you describe ARE solvable by management. They are not within the purview of "worker bees".

I do though wonder why it is that management "conceded" you are doing a good job. If management has been made aware of the problem as it appears from their "concession" what has management done to resolve the problem?

by charles.williams

I too have multiple locations. I let my users know when I will be out and how to reach me in a hurry. They know I carry a blackberry with a Nextel push-button. Should there be a problem I can call in back up to cover for me. When walking around I may not always be able to respond while working on emergencies or high priority jobs. I always am honest with them and I let them know what I am doing. I will call them during any break in the action to talk with them further. If at any time they appear to have a problem that does require an immediate responce I will call in backup support.
WE have a small, close knit group, and we help each other out as needed, there is no "its not my area" conversations.
In the business areas the we support they always invite us to their group meetings and they rave about our work.
To be the best you must raise the bar every day. to be appreciated you must first appreciate others jobs.

by clark1

I also take at least 2 "walk-arounds" a day just to see if anybody has any issues. Usually as soon as I get in and check my email I go up to communications (I work in a sheriff's office) where our 911 consoles are and make sure there are no issues in house and I also ask about our units (we have laptops in all of our cruisers) to see if anybody had any issues overnight. I come in an hour before everybody else for the express reason of taking care of any laptop issues before the next shift if possible.

Some days I do very little when everything is running good, other days I have to wait till I get home for my butt to catch up with me because I was busy putting out fires all over the place, be it desktop issues, laptop issues, print issues, whatever it may be.

The key IS to walk around, talk to people, ask them directly if everything is working ok. When you do that, the end users are more comfortable telling you about the smaller issues that you can fix quickly instead of waiting until they become large issues that require a more intensive fix.

by charles.williams

I know exactly what you are saying, on those days where we are Working like crazy and the users see you in action and they appreciate what you do that much more!

by w2ktechman

I had it running on my NT4 system for years, and tech's would come by and tell me I needed to fix my system often. Lol, sometimes I had to tell the same person 4-5 times efore they got the clue that my system Was not really BSOD'd. And for a few, all I had to do was move the mouse before they believed me.

by gsg

In the past I've had people comment about me coming in late, leaving early, or not working on Thursday and Friday. I don't ignore the problem, but let them know that I drove in at 11pm, let them know it was an hour drive, and that I've been there 15 straight hours, and already have 60 hours and it's only Wednesday, and I have to come back at 3am tomorrow. Then I ask them if they want to trade jobs. Of course I'm cranky, all the makeup has warn off, and I look like Charles Manson on a bad day, so I'm not sure what made them stop.

by absolutely

I'd tell them I have more important skills, I earned my knowledge by hard work, the work that I do is worth all their lifetimes' productivity, and I can automate a pole to shove up their rectum if they want to keep whining at me about work they aren't paying me to do. Impertinent little wastes of skin.

by martin.swart

I conly put that comment in to see what reaction I would get. Talking to people outside your company about IT and finding out what they know and think should be part of everyones job description.

by dean.owen

Publish stats of the work you do. . . helpdesk calls, projects, emails, etc. We used to send each department head a monthly statement listing the service tickets: who in their department made the call, description of the call, who from IT was working on the call and what the status was. The volume of work we were faced with surprised a lot of people...and the fact that we completed a high percentage of requests within an acceptable (KPI) timeframe satisfied most folks. It pays to advertise . . .

Dean

by absolutely

"...and even management conceed we are doing a great job.

The problem is how to fix the public PERCEPTION that we are not worth our pay etc. etc."

Who signs your pay checks? Whose PERCEPTION counts?

by gerberb58

Shultz, you can have this contract, micromanaged POS position anytime you can choke it. I have already accepted a position in S. Florda to start in June. A REAL job. So move back to MI, watch your home value go down the tubes, keep watching as this Bit*h of a gov. raises every tax known to man as people bail out of this state faster than 4 internet t1's. Soon to be "Michtucky" SEEEYAAAA...

by eddie n

Yes, yes, I know: "perception is reality" and all that, but...who has the perception? If it is users, well, quite honestly, that is their problem. You guys in the IT department may do your at odd hours, but YOU DO YOUR JOBS -- if you didn't, I can assure you, management would ensure that you no longer have jobs!

As long as you know that you are doing your jobs, and as long as you can prove that to management -- you know, the guys who pay your salaries? -- then I really wouldn't bother about what "mere users" think. Personally, I think they're just jealous of the fact that guys in IT get to wear jeans and T-shirts to work while they have to always be in suits :)

This discussion is closed to new replies.