Question Locked

User settings/files backup when refreshing/replacing PCs

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We have for some years used xxxxxxxx to transfer users from old PCs to their new one.
Not only stray documents outside OneDrive but also user preferences, shortcuts, browser favorites from Chrome, Edge and Firefox etc.

Since MS released the new edition of Windows backup we have looked into using it in a similar way but it really doesn't do much of what we need?
Files outside the users profile isn't found and no option for Windows backup to search, no shortcuts, no App settings (eeg. IMAP mail accounts), Firefox, Chrome (not even Edge) favorites does not transfer over. Actually it seems only settings for Microsoft "Modern UI Apps is transferred.

Is this really what to expect from Microsoft Backup?

Product name and manufacturer removed by moderator.

9 replies

by kees_b

What new version of Windows backup exactly?

by campomario

"new Windows Backup for Organizations in windows 11"

Which turns out to be just as much half-bake as so many MS software s of late...

by kees_b edited

You mean this: https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/blog/windows-itpro-blog/announcing-windows-backup-for-organizations/4416659 ?
That's a limited preview, only for users of Microsoft Entra. Did you test it?

I don't think it can be expected that Microsoft makes software makes a backup of, say, settings in other browsers than Edge. Or of files that you choose to store somewhere else than in your Documents folder and the company's OneDrive. Moreover, files on a company owned fileserver (my socalled p:-drive) don't need backup on the users PC.
The general idea of company PC's/laptops is that the user is responsible for everything (data and programs) he puts on it himself, so to transfer it himself to his new PC. You can't expect the company to do that for him.

Yes, it seems indeed you need a custom solution for your custom requirements.

by rproffitt edited

Microsoft Backup in every version has proven to be unreliable.

We're talking decades here. Are you new to this world?

by campomario

Kinda old actually

Also kinda used to MS, and even more as of late, producing half-baked products.

The fact that Microsoft Backup is a joke isn't news, you're right about that.
But when MS then goes out with the bold statement "new Windows Backup for Organizations in windows 11", I of course check it out.

Crazy thing here is that now that MS has gotten rid of (nearly) all the Steve Balmer Mordern UI Crap, they could just pick up on their all time best tool User State Migration Tool, also being the center of the, also long gone Easy Migration tool.

Luckily another old-timer has single-handedly carried USMT through, all the way to Windows 11, including backward compatibility, including third party browsers, and even the new Edge.
And made it so easy for our supporters to use and even remote, over LAN. We just pray he stays at it as User Profile Central really is unique part of our toolbox.

by enterpriselaplink

Yes, that’s normal. The new Windows Backup only copies basic files and settings, mostly from Microsoft apps. It doesn’t include things like files stored outside your user folders, shortcuts, or browser favorites. It’s really more of a basic backup tool than a full migration option.

If you want to move everything your files, apps, profiles, and even browser favorites from Chrome, Edge, or Firefox you’ll need a dedicated migration tool. Laplink PCmover does that automatically and makes the whole transfer process much easier.

by rproffitt edited

Checking again I found Microsoft Backup to still be unreliable.

PCMover is an oldy but did the trick for single user setups.

by nullsbrawlapp1

Thanks for sharing this! You're right—Microsoft's new Windows Backup seems pretty limited. It focuses more on modern apps and OneDrive content, but doesn't really leave a mark on deep user settings and non-Microsoft browser data.

by gracemiller8477 edited

Yes, that’s essentially what to expect from the current Microsoft Backup—it’s primarily designed to protect files within user profiles and settings for Microsoft apps, especially modern UWP apps. It **does not capture stray files outside standard folders, shortcuts, traditional app settings, or browser favorites from Chrome, Firefox, or even Edge**. For full user migrations—including mail accounts, non-profile files, and cross-browser data—you’ll still need specialized migration tools that explicitly handle these elements, as Microsoft Backup is not intended as a complete PC-to-PC migration solution.

This discussion is closed to new replies.