Discussion Locked

Vista, is it all it's cracked up tp be?

0 helpful
24 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Just saw this in a community forum on another site, in a discussion about what os people use

[pre]
posted:26 Sep 2007 16:27
We have a Vista Computer in the company and no body use it.

I use it a few days and I never touch it again, I think it will be formated.
So we can install in a XP OS
[/pre]

They have a poll running in that thread:
[pre]
Poll :: What is your Primary Operating System.
Pre XP Windows 5% [ 13 ]
Windows XP 67% [ 156 ]
Windows Vista 7% [ 18 ]
Pre OS X 0% [ 0 ]
MAC OS X 14% [ 34 ]
Linux 4% [ 10 ]
Other 0% [ 1 ]
Total Votes : 232
[/pre]

Consider that this is a 3D graphics community site, it is amazing that anyone actually picked linux :D

24 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

We are employing Vista on a limited basis within the IS department on my campus. It is proving to be a minor nightmare.

Hopefully, as the nightmare ensues over the course of the next couple of semesters, we will start offering some Linux (pick a flavor - but likely Ubuntu) classes. I figure to start pushing that idea at mid-term!

by jaqui

A better option, and it supplies the course materials, Linux From Scratch.

The LFS book is meant as a teaching tool, to improve knowledge about the internals of linux.

if just linux workstations, go with pclos, better hardware support and more secure than the *buntu distros.
[ *buntu butchered security by completely disabling the root account ]

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I know about the butchered security in Ubuntu, but am thinking in terms of what the Chair will want to deal with if the suggestion is taken. The easiest to install and use straight out of the box is what will more than likely be required and to date the consensus appears to be Ubuntu.

However the fact that there are course materials available for Linux From Scratch is a strikingly good thing, as is the 'from scratch' notion.

Didn't know there were any course materials for any Linux flavors out there! Gotta be looking into that, for sure. I'd give a big thumbs up if this were the Questions forum!

by w2ktechman

PLLinuxOS is my favorite right now. Easy to configure and use, wireless was a breeze on my HP notebook. Plus, you can download a live version to try first.

SUSE is another choice, but more bloated. It has more in it though, and seems to be a bit more stable.

by faradhi

I am just on the good side of Linux stupid. However, since I am good at step by step, (I am also pretty good with my letters as well but that is another story.) I was able to install LFS in a short period of time.

I like it because I know exactly what is on the box and what I need to track for patches and security flaws. However, I am using it for an internal web server.

I also learned more about Linux in two days than I was able to learn in two semesters in college. (Considering I forgot almost all of it that is not saying much.)

When I do build my workstation it will be with LFS. More opportunity to learn.

by the scummy one

There are still too many issues to overcome with Vista. Mainly with user training and compatibility with older SW which works fine in XP. Many companies are not willing to or do not have the resources to re-write a lot of apps to get it functional in Vista yet.
This will also be a deterrent for Linux/Mac as well.

At the company that I am at right now, Vista was scheduled to roll out in April '07, but due to compatibility problems it is now scheduled beyond March '08. The deadline has been pushed back several times, and finally they scheduled it out far enough to really work on the issues. However, who knows what will need to be done after SP1 (and how far the new deadlines will be pushed out).

You mention that this poll is from a 3D graphics community, in this case I am surprised that MACs dont make up for 25-30% of the systems.

by jaqui

The primary app they use is buggy on Macs, worse than the windows version, so windows gets the nod for the app.

I actually posted a comment in that poll:

If they want me to be spending money for their products, they will support my operating system, linux. no linux support, no cash.

]:)

editing to add:

The company that runs that site is a content provider for the app of choice as well as thay have bought 3 different 3D graphics apps, they make money supplying the content, and none off me since they don't support linux.

by david

I recently got two new computers that came with vista home premium. Yuck, looks fancy and has some nice effects.
If you do more than check your email and visit a few webpages, vista is not for you. Maybe after service pack 2 comes out they can work out all the crap.
Here is a classic example;
My system came with 2048mb ram. Performance was not impressive. So I order another 2048. It works alot better. Problem is you can't ever do windows updates if you have more than 2048. Some glitch they have not fixed. So every couple weeks I have to pull two sticks of ram just so I can install updates. WHAT A PAIN.
I put windows xp on the other computer and no problems what so ever.

by tony hopkinson

Business edition

2 Gig + aero.

A few driver issues initially, couple of bit's of software that weren't compatible and the company av (macrappee) had a few issues.

But I can run delphi 2005, Visual Studio, Acrobat Professional with a SQL 2005 on top of all the usual MS drivel with no real problems at all.

Personally I think MS could have spent their resources on stuff that would have had more of an impact on my productivity, but once the company bought me a compatible pc, no significant loss or boon over XP.

Now you could say XP on my current hardware would have run like hot snot, but my old one was only inplace for a year, so they wouldn't have spent anyway.

The decision to move me onto Vista was so I could do vista compatible development as our customers would be getting it whether we thought it was a good idea or not.

by sleepin'dawg

As you move up the food chain it gets marginally, and I mean only marginally, better. I think it will be SP2 at the minimum before it's ready for any business environment more complex than a one box SOHO. We'll eventually get around to using it but not until or unless we absolutely are required to do so. Thankfully we are only reliant on Windoze in a peripheral capacity. We're pretty much a Unix/Linux shop.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by shellbot

have ya tried running SQL 2000? Curious as some say it won't run, others say it will...

by jaqui

available for linux, but LFS and it's offshoot DIY are actually meant to be teaching distros, not end user click and go distros.
big difference.

linuxfromscratch.org
diy-linux.org

I find that LFS is a better choice for the teaching aspect, it is more comprehensive.
DIY is a scripted install process, LFS is mainly a type the commands out process.
LFs has a livecd which includes the sources and book, so one cd has everything to get a cli only linux system running with full networking support.
BLFS is adding the xserver, desktop, graphical apps etc.
HLFS is secured LFS
ALFS is a scripted install, it creates the scripts from the book itself on the fly.
CLFS is for cross compiling, like from cygwin to linux, or from 32bit to 64 bit, or osx to linux.
The entire LFS website is comprised of these books.

The LFS project is actually based in Alberta Canada if I remember correctly. :)

recently version 6.3 of the book was released, currently the livecd project is working hard to get the last bugs out of the cd to be able to have a stable livecd for the 6.3 book. [ I should know, I've been actively testing the cd for it. :D ]

by boxfiddler Hot topic

as to how long you think it would take to work through LFS for students who are not particularly computer literate and/or lack any programming skills and/or lack a level of flexibility in imagination that effectively cements them to Windows?

The class would have to be completed in 16 weeks, and if we offered it in summer we'd have only 8 weeks.

What would you consider to be a necessary prereq for LFS, if anything?

Am cruising LFS and getting a tad excited! Fedora might bite it sooner than I anticipated...

EDIT TO NOTE: LFS is looking great, but I'm betting that it will be turned down. It appears that some knowledge of Unix is a real pre-req, and we can't keep Unix classes alive at the moment. Students who might otherwise be interested in Linux options wouldn't have a chance...
Other suggestions for a good distro to use in Intro to Linux classes (for the generally OS illiterate)?

by jaqui

a single one hour session on basic cli commands, such as ls, mkdir, chown, cp, mv and ln is really all they need.

the livecd does come with xorg and xfce as well as the book and sources.

a complete lfs build on reasonably new systems should only take a week at most.
adding blfs is about another week.

The benefits to the lfs, besides the materials already created for the course, is the much bettr understanding of how any os has to function, the core of networking technologies and the massive amount that will be learned in short order.

start them with a pclos cd, it's a live cd with Mandriva's live installer as part of it, so the livecd is the install cd. they can see how sweet linux is to work with, then learn what effort it takes to create that. ]:)
[ which will make them apprciate the distros like pclos even more. ]

by neon samurai

liveCD or full install versions available for free. Good selection of graphic admin tools in the drakconf set. urpmi means an RPM based distrobution but with a package manager that works (unless "rpm" package manager has had some serious work done). I rebuilt my mail server last night for fun and to better understand how the various mail programs work together; two and a bit hours though the install was only an hour including package additions after first boot and updating everything including the newest kernel version.

That's just me though, you'd realy have to download four or more liveCD distrobutions to see how they all work.

by tony hopkinson

Expected it to be more of a disaster than it was, but our IS types and deep pockets isolated me from most of the problems.

Converting our product suite to be Vista compatible was interesting, still getting a few teething problems particularly on the upgrade to 2005 Express from MSDE.

by tony hopkinson

run it under an XP VM if I need to do any work with it.

I understand there might be some strange kludge to get it in, but that's useless to me in terms of investigating and replicating issues.

by shellbot

ya,point taken about investigating and replicating.

Thats what I've done (XP VM)..sadly having to use the VM for a good few things..shame that bugger all is compatible..but i guess things will catch up eventually :)

by charliespencer

Since we don't have any users with apps that require Vista, we have no plans to deploy it. We will continue as long as possible to buy new hardware that comes with XP drivers, and to load XP until we have a business reason to load Vista. Until that happens, Vista will continue to exist only in the lab and on select IT department desktops. Nothing against it, we just don't have a reason to load it (or Linux, OS X, Unix, CP/M, VMS, etc.).

by jaqui

something to add to the linux benefits.
Ralink chipsets have native linux drivers.
[ wireless networking ]

Ralink actually made their drivers an open source project, not the roms though, only the os kernel modules.
The Ralink chipset is used by a lot of different companies for wireless cards, pci, pcmcia and usb networking cards.

Fedora doesn't recognise them.
Suse does, but can't use them
*buntu is a battle to use them.
PCLOS out of box use.
Mandriva, copy freely available roms to /lib/firmware and it's running.
LFS livecd, out of box it drives the devices, but it does not try to configure the wireless ssid parameters so you have to manually configure them.

I bought a wireless pcmcia card for an old dell laptop, it uses the Ralink chipset.
[ fwiw, the linux drivers actually work better than Ralink's xp drivers, I tested them :D ]

by jaqui

exactly what PCLOS uses. :p

and PCLOS uses Mandrivas live installer to install from the livecd :)

I've always liked the graphic admin tools Mandriva has, over the Graphic admin tools of RH or Suse products.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

one of the networking lab employees is playing in Mandriva these days. When I have the time - not often, but... - I go into the lab and play myself. I like the interface - it's crisp and clean and easy on the eyes, the KDE desktop is ok. All in all at this point I prefer it to Fedora. But that may be Gnome vs. KDE, or my clunky old hardware vs. the net labs new stuff, blah, blah, blah.

This discussion is closed to new replies.