Discussion Locked

Vista, is it really worth it?

0 helpful
306 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

306 replies

by mjwx

I have a small quibble with something you?ve said:
[i]I feel that the mac is just more simple to use than XP[/i]

I think the problem I have is semantics. The difference between simple and easy is much the same as the difference between stupid and dumb. You can be dumb but not stupid and you can be stupid but not dumb. While related they are drastically different

So to say that OS X is simple is not to say it is easy. I consider Linux to be very simple to use but it is incredibly complex at the same time. in Linux I find the CLI to be more powerful and more ergonomic I have only 4 to 8 windows open all the time as opposed to 20 opening and closing all the time but I have to memorise the commands (and conf files).

So I would submit to you that OS X while simple is not easy and easy has always won the desktop market. a simple task such as creating a roaming profile or using a profile on another server is difficult to configure on a Mac. Joining a domain is not as easy as it is in windows (network settings and directory access vs. computer name). Most OS X users I have met didn?t even know about the terminal or even what the utilities folder was for. Simple vs. easy.

by apotheon

With Linux, sure, we'll have some serious eye candy interface issues . . . except that with Linux you avoid these issues by just not installing the eye candy crap in the first place. It'll probably be another ten years before a Linux kernel is developed that can't run on an old Intel 386.

No worries about drowning in eye candy on Linux. Just don't jump in the eye candy pool, and you'll be fine. I like to go wading in the two inches of eye candy called WindowMaker, and avoid the fat, bloated desktop environments like KDE and GNOME (both of which are feather-light in comparison to the Windows Explorer desktop for Windows XP).

by craig

Being a graphic designer by trade , I am guilty of enjoying the odd bit of eye candy... I used to support MS systems in Advocates chambers but have recently completed the Novell clp certification and have been blown away by how powerful linux is , so much so I have not even booted my MS machine since completing the course, by all accounts I'm still a newbie in the world of Linux but so far I'm extremely impressed .

I really do not see the attraction for a pretty looking gui anymore if the performance does not justify it being there.At least with Linux you can do away with the frills , if you eliminate the frills in Vista what do you have?... yup you have a resource intensive win2K.

by gdanzig

This is the beginning of the end. Hanging the box builders for the Christmas season, throwing ball bearings on the dance floor of "gotta have it" MS-bonded software market is going to break the strangle hold. Even the dumbest most ignorant management type can see it fianlly - Bush is a liar and Microsoft is too little for too much too late.

by apotheon

Didn't you hear? Vista is chock full of new security features!

Of course, security features on Windows are just band-aids over the stumps of missing limbs. Until Microsoft addresses the architectural failings you mentioned, the security "features" are just so much marketing hype.

by jccarp

I don't think I'm particularly radical. I actually have enjoyed my Win2K machine. Never had problems, I am a grandmother, but did figure out that it ain't rocket science to learn how to maintain some sensible security. It does require some dedication and regular attention though, and I do find the time needed for updating to be more and more annoying (not to mention keeping an eye on the third-party security apps).

My biggest problem with Microsoft products has as much to do with attitude as anything. I'll probably keep my Win2K around for a long time. But, I have been making a concerted effort during this last year to learn new software and to minimize my MS dependence.

I believe the future is heading away from such Microsoftish things as lock-in, propriatary MS-only formats, and "bundling everything under the sun" into the OS. I think even us ordinary folks are seeing the wisdom of not putting all our eggs in one basket, much less letting Microsoft be in charge of the basket.

I also believe that DRM in the hands of Microsoft will be a major headache to us all...

...and people are actually starting to read EULAs. I don't intend to "agree by clicking" to anymore of those one-sided, non-consumer-friendly, subject to change without notice licenses than absolutely necessary.

Having billions of advertising and marketing dollars handy to make the Microsoft Way look friendly and cute, may help keep them going in the short term. But when the real face of MS begins to show through to even the little old ladies of the world, there's definiotely a problem. One that can't be glossed over forever, and that is going to become more and more obvious in the long term. It's a downhill slide for them.

I think the final straw that solidified my determination to permanently minimize my MS software investment was when Mr Gates publically made fun of the MIT One Laptop per Child project, last week, in such a snide, illinformed, ill-mannered, disrespectful, patronizing way.

I have no desire to continue adding my hard earned dollars to Bill Gates' fortune. He obviously doesn't understand his customers, and doesn't appreciate their value. I'm thinkin' he'll be learning all about it soon.

So, to answer your question...no. No Vista for me. I said the same for XP, and meant it. I mean it now too. I hope that by this ime next year my little company will be running Red Hat, or SuSE, with windows installed only as dual-boot, or on a single computer that has very restricted outside access. Windows is perfectly safe, after all, if it's not exposed to the outside world. Even little old ladies know that much :o)

jcar

by mjwx

I said it earlier but I'd like to say it again.

OSS is the future but unfortunately the future isn?t here yet :|. So we have to live with MS for a little while longer now. 5 to 10 years in my estimation.

MS will pressure PC vendors like Dell or HP to start bundling Vista with new PC's. MS will do this, its their way. If Vista and more importantly DRM begins ends up restricting the normal every-user, mother of invention will force an alternative (I hope it is not Mac OS X) faster than expected.

OS X will never be widely used as long as it is bundled with hardware but if they rewrite it for any hardware it will have a whole bunch of support issues with the lesser known hardware vendors. I think we will replace the currrent MS with a MS like apple. Lets all hope for a open source (Linux based :) ) solution.

by apotheon

Why do you say "the future isn't here yet"? You can have that future as much as you like. You just have to make a decision to use the technologies you see as being "the future".

I don't currently have a single Windows machine, out of six computers in my possession. If open source operating systems are the future, I'm living in the future. Why are you living in the past?

by apotheon

You're a smart one, I see. It's pretty rare that I run across people aware of what's in their EULAs.

It's because of changes in the EULA that I'll never willingly employ Windows later than Win2k SP2 for anything other than a test platform with no saved data. When the EULA grants the vendor more legal privileges on my machine than I have, I can no longer trust that machine. I wouldn't even want such a machine running without connecting it to a network, because if Microsoft comes knocking at my door there's no legal recourse for an individual person with an individual person's budget to keep the Microsoft lawyers from getting full access to any data I store on the machine.

It's a new era in untrustworthy computing.

by sir_cheats_alot

that was a very well thought out reply...and it was actually relevent; unlike 90% of what has been posted earlier.

I was beginning to think i was the only one who reads EULAs. Most don't even bother because they know if they don't click agree that the OS,or application won't even be installed. i've seen the test version of Vista, and wasn't impressed. Microsoft needs to lay off the "eye-candy" and focus on stability, and compatbility other-wise Vista will be just another Windows ME. I'm not sure where but in the EULA(i think its about 2/3 of the way down) reads something like this: Microsoft in no way guarantees that this software will even work! i'm not sure, it's been a few years since i looked at it. i saw it on microsuck.com, and had to see it myself, and sure enough there it was.
as stated earlier this means that there is no legal recourse against MS for the user if something were to go wrong(ie:install fails half way through). As far as security goes most people know if something goes wrong it's usually the users fault. For example; clicking on a email attachment that norton reads as safe opening it instead of downloading and then scanning it with your own,or different AV program. Norton tends to catch only about half of all viruses...when it works that is. If you can't already tell; i've had nothing but bad experiances with it, and therefore don't trust it anymore. most all computer viruses don't cause damage until the executable or whatever it might be hidden in, is ran.
as many have said before the only truly secure OS is the one that has no internet access(but what fun is that without games?).

Before the flamers start i dual boot Fedora Core 4,and Windows. i don't favor either OS over the other. i have windows for games and that is it. i use FC(fedora core linux) for everything else now.

this discussion has nothing to do with which OS is better. i'm tired of reading through the forums and seeing people argue over something so trivial. Which OS is better is nothing more than OPINION, and has no relevence here.

that being said; I won't be going to Windows Vista either.

by dennis.rhine

My standard answer is that I won't use anything from MS until they have come out with at least one service pack.

Also, even with all the discussion about security, as long and MS tries to keep tying extraneous programs into Windows (like IE, etc.), they will not be able to secure it. Too many avenues to close up and too many people who want to crack it.

by scribe6

I know there isn't a lot of software written to take advantage of dual core processors, but that should change with Vista. Development to take advantage of dual cores is already working its way into the video game community. My guess is Adobe and Video editing software companies aren't that far behind them.

64 bit handling will also help alleviate this, as programs are rewritten for it. Again, some game developers have already done this (Valve and Crytek), and I'm guessing the video editing suites and other processor intensive type companies will be doing this as well. I know that SQL 2005 has both a 32 bit and 64 bit code set, based upon the software I received when I bought it for my company.

No matter what the OS has been, there have always been increased hardware requirements when upgrading. The idea is that the newest version of [Insert OS Name Here] will take advantage of [Insert Great new Piece of Hardware here] better. You see this with OS X as much as you do with the Windows versions. Based upon what I've seen, the OS X for Intel Chips is not really compatible with the original OS X for the PowerPC chips. Part of this is the fact that the x86 architecture is completely different than the PowerPC architecture, but its also to take advantage of the features in the new processors from Intel.

PC Hardware development is moving in other directions as well. We saw that with the introduction of 3-d Video cards, and we've continued to see that as RAID, USB and Firewire have come into the consumer market. There's companies introducing special "physics" cards, much in the vein of the original 3D cards. PCIe has increased throughput across the motherboard, and DDR2 is making memory even faster and more accessible. Amd's memory controller helped bring this about, and its new socket should help keep processors cooler while new manufacturing methors are dropping power requirements across the board.

A PC isn't about crunching numbers anymore, like it was with 3.1 and MSDOS. Its about digitally developing pictures, sending email to family or chatting with friends while adventuring through [insert popular internet based game name here].

Its also a question of trade offs. Am I willing to pay $1500-2000 US for a new close to top of the line system so I can see all the really cool graphics in Vista, or will my current PC handle Vista well enough for what I need it to do?

As for me, I was looking at getting a new PC in November/December, with Vista on it. It just means that I'm going to postpone my purchase for a couple of months. I'm also moving back to an "out of the box" solution from one of the Game Performance builders, to clear some of my headaches from building my own boxes.

by deadly ernest

I got a 64 bit CPU, motherboard and Win XP Pro 64 bit edition in January and it has been a hell of a problem. Five brand new applications will NOT run on it, many devices do not run properly - the manufacturer's drivers are removed and generic MS drivers with half the capabilities used no matter what I do. The applictaions and games that do work do not appear to be working any better or faster.

I am waiting to get a hold of Fedora Core 5 and see how that goes as FC 4 works better on my 32 bit systems than Win XP Pro. And I just love Cedega for the Windows based games - brilliant, even plays the older W95 and W98 games.

by nikhil_rattan2003

Guys i don't want to waste my time. If i will waste i will waste on the bugs of win 2003 server.

That can be usefull for anybody in the word.

by blu_vg9

"sata only hard drives"

Where on earth do you get the idea that Vista only runs on SATA drives? And "huge graphics cards" aren't a requirement, either, unless you want to run Aero Glass (and even then, you certainly don't need a "huge" graphics card by any modern standard).

"vanilla hardware that has half the specs and loaded with Mac X or Linux."

OS X does NOT run on "vanilla hardware." Not legally, anyhow.

"...how many corporate environments want the staff to utilse a lot of media and gaming capabilities? I would bet that some, but not all, could be turned off and that it will take a lot of effort to turn them off and elave them off."

Group Policy--fantastic management tool, with nothing that compares well in the Linux world. Or script a custom install.

There's too much to discuss here--check out channel9.msdn.com for great insight into why Vista is a compelling upgrade, at least for some. And XP SP 2 is still a fantastic OS.

by apotheon

It's a terrible problem that you need to use group policies to manage user capabilities in the first place on a Windows system. On a Linux system, you don't need to set a group policy to prevent someone from wasting all his time in the office organizing playlists because on a Linux system all you have to do is [b]not install the crap in the first place[/b]. Try equalling that level of control on Windows some time. You'll fail.

In addition, you're apparently not familiar with user group privileges management, file permissions creation masks, and so on, if you think there's "nothing that compares well in the Linux world". In fact, I suspect you're not even familiar with Linux, making clearly and egregiously untrue statements like that.

Next, you'll be saying there's no such thing as access control lists outside of Windows, despite the fact that there have been ACLs on unixlike OSes for a very long time.

by markdmac

This is not an issue of Vista or IE code being safe or ready. It has to do with a legal decision that requires Microsoft to change the way ActiveX is handled. Users will in some cases need to do a few extra clicks after installing the required patch to bring MS into compliance. The point I was trying to make is that Microsoft is shipping the new code for existing systems long before the release of Vista and therefore it will not be an issue with shipping Vista.

by cr

that was actually what i was trying to convey in my message, that it is a dreadful desktop. I love linux, i love it to bits. however it was my main operating system for a grand total of 3months... then what happend? same thing that happens to most people who try linux, couldn't get some damn peice of software working that i wanted. so i came back to windows. I love the stability of linux, and the tabbed desktops, and all the little features that make linux linux, but without the fancy apps that do things THE WAY I WANT THEM TO BE DONE, it just aint good enough. there may be a different app that is made for linux to do a task, but if it dosn't handle as nice as the windows alternative then im going to choose windows anyday.

by a_fairb

Poor old Bill is riding a runaway train which needs huge cash injections at regular intervals. Trouble is 90% or more of the apps users actually need/use worked fine on 95, 98, 2k... The driver as always will be Office. The main reason our NT4 clients are being replaced is that they can't run better than office 2000. Some users have bought Office XP or 2k3 and now we have to upgrade for compatibility. If we all just got off the train quietly and stuck to Office 2000 or OpenOffice, we would save a fortune and MS would have to find another way to part us from our cash.

by golf24_7

I love windows I have run every version since 3.11 and been pretty happy with them all except the Windows Millennium fiasco. They have improved and utilized the technology of the time in each release, requiring newer better hardware. I personal would like them to drop some of their backwards compatibility because it hamstrings what they can do on current hardware. The people running a machine that just meets the minimum requirements are probably not going to do an OS upgrade anyway trust me I support a lot of them. For those of us that are always tinkering/upgrading our hardware there is a good chance that we will want to upgrades the OS and more then likely will have no problem meeting the required specs.
That said I still work with old equipment and generally speaking I load Win98 release 2 or Win 2000 on anything less then a P3 800mhz PC. Anything less then that is to slow for XP in my opinion and Vista will probably set that bar much higher.
As for Vista so far I love the new interface. I will have all the eye candy turned on in high-end systems because it is cool. I like many of the default settings for security because they improve the security of the average uninitiated user. So far I have only spent a little time with the beta but each new drop seems to get better. They fixed several of the bugs I entered in the latest drop.
Next, I agree that Linux has its place but it is not on the average users desktop. I work in Linux a lot for work and I even have a couple of Linux boxes at home for playing with running different flavors of Linux. I personally don?t find the GUI interfaces to be all that great and even if they were I can?t load a lot of software on them especially my games which is important to me.
Finally, Not that I use a Mac very often but it has similar problems that Linux has with running lots of software, unless you run a windows emulator, which seems obtuse to me. Additionally, I don?t like their stranglehold on the hardware. I have to admit I do find it amusing that with each new Mac OS they seem to require better hardware to and what is worse a lot of the times that means a whole new system. As for security both Linux and Mac have wholes to that just aren?t exploited as much since worse case scenario you hurt maybe 5% of the internet users.

sorry for the long rant

by apotheon

Yes, it's a matter related to ensuring ActiveX is handled legally. You're right. Thus, [b]some code needs to be altered to handle it differently[/b]. What, you think the legal department just sets something down in writing and no programmers have to do anything to change the way software handles ActiveX controls? Is that it? It works by magic?

by craig

Is there such a thing as a final service pack... MS is like a fancy British sports car , looks goods but needs heavy and constant maintenance

by kf6akz

Certainly there's a final SP; there are no more patches or upgrades being offered for DOS 6 or Windows 3.11, are there?

Most places I've worked don't install any MS products for 2 - 5 years anyway. The last place I left in 2005 was just getting around to upgrading the workstations to Win2k, and NOBODY had XP. This seems to me to be typical in the larger corporate environments.

by apotheon

That sounds like a great idea except for one small problem.

Actually, it's a huge problem. It's even a bigger problem than security issues from an unpatched system.

The problem is the EULAs. Ever since Win2k SP3, there has not been a Windows EULA that I'd trust on a computer that will hold any data of any importance whatsoever. You can always protect an unpatched system with firewalls, third-party security, and so on -- even just take it off the Internet and use it as an isolated system to protect against security crackers, if need be. What you can't protect against is representatives of Microsoft coming to your door pressing their legal privileges to control what's on your computer if you have a Windows version any newer than Win2k SP2.

I find Windows to be technically inferior, personally aggravating to use, and odious to my sensibilities because of the corporate practices of Microsoft, but I still occasionally find myself needing to use Windows. When I have to use Windows, though, I stick with Win2k SP2, because I don't want the legal hassle that comes with any later versions. That's just too much risk for me.

I'm amazed so many people don't share my reticence.

by craig

Who ever called you cheap and lazy has never been in charge of a budget and has too much time on their hands to sit around contemplating upgrades... have you ever considered an open source solution?.

Linux offers much cheaper and much , much more stable solutions.Even if you stick to windows OS and upgrade to Open Office .

It all boils down to the "if it's not broken , don't fix it" philosophy.

by markdmac

Had to reply to this message instead fo the one below because max message level was reached.

I know MS Legal does not have a magic wand to instantly change code. The point you are just not getting from this is that as stated above you said that you thought MS pushed back the release of Vista because of this one issue. That is rubbish. Microsoft has already notified Premier Support customers that they will get the required ActiveX update code on patch Tuesday of next month. It is already written. Do you really think the developers were told to wait to figure this out until the court decided on the case? No way.

Back to the original argument, MS has delayed Vista to ensure the code is rock solid. compared to all of the other problems beta testers are currently reporting there is still a lot of work to do before this code will be ready for the public. The latest beta is looking considerably more stable and almost there, but after closely looking at where they were with all the important features the tough decision was made to push back the release.

by apotheon

It seems that you are having trouble holding more than one thought in your head at a time. I will remind you again of the fact that there is a difference between an IE patch and the Vista OS, and ActiveX functionality in Vista might require work beyond what is done in IE (especially since IE doesn't even implement ActiveX, it only allows it to pass through).

by craig

Just means that the vendor's bottom is alot more sore than it was before he placed the add on his box

by craig

where've you been?... Of course MAC is network ready and has been for a while... they have the Xserv as a MAC server , all of which run on a unix platform now.

Yes the cost is an issue but not because it cannot be done .You are not at the mercy of MS anymore , you have options LINUX being a very viable one , just a bit of research and bobs your uncle , this lie down and die mentality is why MS can dictate the terms.

by mjwx

Mac's will under no circumstances will talk to a PC running SMB signing thus making an entire network vulnerable to man in the middle attacks.

Ever tried to use an exchange calendar on a Mac.

All I can say is that virtual PC for Mac?s is a good thing. Now i have solved all my NW problems by running an XP virtual machine on a Mac.

by apotheon

You're out of touch. MacOS X runs on the Darwin kernel, incorporating Mach and BSD kernel code, so you can run Samba on MacOS X just as you can on Linux or *BSD. You can also run NIS, NFS, and a slew of other networking technologies that MS Windows can't touch.

Back to the textbooks for you. You have some homework to do.

by craig

Dude do some research , linux has native apps that can replace those that run on windows... unless it's gaming you're after , then go and buy a playstation , computers are for adults that can think for themselves , MS takes away that function and has us rely on what they want us to do with a product that we paid for , it's like Toyota dictating the terms in which you drive one of their vehicles even though you've paid for the thing.

by cr

dude wut are u on, linux does not have native apps to replace ALL those on windows, would you like some examples? photoshop, flash, dreamweaver, adobe prmeier, office (ok so maybe there is an alternative but its not as nice as office), sure some of these can be emulated, but not all, and i know in my experience of running linux as a desktop, there was always a time i'd come across an app i wanted to run that wuldn't run on linux.

Also, i do play games, but even without wanting to play games i still wouldn't goto linux due to the other apps i like to enjoy using, i think perhaps you need to open your eyes alittle wider and look at what other people use their computers for and not just what you do, which is probably nothing.

by craig

It's called research... how do you keep a job with that mentality , you're lazy . Why the hell would you chose an obscure app , clearly you'd make sure that the app is a viable solution beforee implementing it . Don't get me wrong I'm not for or against any OS they all have their pros and cons , your attitude and work ethic needs adjusting , there is more Linux support than you could ever hope for , YET AGAIN... RESEARCH!

by cr

there is plenty of linux support, but alot more apps are made for windows which could make you be forced to rely on an obscure app, also with alot of apps out there, theres a high chance that they will stop developing their app, this seems to be the nature of linux and a community that thrives on people living in their basements coding.

I think this is due to one thing and one thing only, if ur developing an app are you going to write it for the majority or the minority? and alot of people would think that there is no need to port their apps to linux thus we are left with a windows biast market.

by apotheon

When was the last time you got stuck with a copy of a highly functional, suddenly unsupported open source office suite, operating system, or development environment? Answer: never, because even if the original maintainer gives up on it others can pick up the slack, and the community at large is always willing to help out for free.

When was the last time you got stuck with a copy of a highly functional, suddenly unsupported closed source proprietary office suite, operating system, or development environment? Answer: every time the vendor comes out with an expensive new version, or gets bought out by a rival, or is split up because of an antitrust case, or files for bankruptcy, or any of a myriad of other reasons.

What kind of support is your Office 97 getting these days?

by craig

Got to hand it to Bill , the fact that we are all discussing Vista on this forum means that we are aware of it and are indirectly making other people aware of it , good press or bad press Bill is getting a great deal of Advertising through forums like these... was it planned to delay the release of Vista or have just not enough people discussed it yet.Bill might know as much as my Jack Russel about IT itself , but the bugger sure is a heck of a businessman .

To be quite honest I think Vista will be the turning point for MS , they have alot to live up to when comparing to other OS's (visual effects aside), if this is as shaky as XP was on first release we might find larger corprations switching to Linux or Linux type OS's , Could Vista be MS's monkey on the back .I think so.

by craig

Mr. Richards_Unsubscribe , I'm right behind on the Vista and Hardware retailer "I'll scratch your back if you scratch mine setup".

As for manufacturers that offer Linux on boxes , HP is a good example of one such company , they found that by shipping pc's with a free operating system (NovellSuse to be exact)they can bring the machine price down per unit thus selling more pc's . HP is and has been involved with Linux for some time as are IBM and slowly slowly Dell are becoming part of the Linux family , Linux is not that far from becoming the main contender in the desktop enviroment aswell especially in the business world ,we know that they dominate the server and webserver side already...with HP , IBM , and almost Dell behind the Open Source cause it won't be too much longer now... patience .

All giants fall over at some time... IBM was an example.Bill is starting to trip up , and has to fall at some time... Vista will be his biggest trip wire so far.

by craig

Stop talking about added security , it's windows the file system does not allow for the OS to be secure , it will always be vulnerable to something... it may be more secure than XP but by all accounts never secure , compare it to any other OS, MS is not a secure solution ,if you need security go and download Linux or if you have the money go and buy a MAC... but dear LORD do not Brag about MS and it's Security... that's like mice bragging about being the biggest mammals on earth.

Rather go on about it's good points... like it looks pretty good , okay so that's it it looks good...ooops not much after that.

by craig

If you believe that you'd believe in god aswell , Nice try buck... funny that after any new feature makes an appearnace on any other OS then all of a sudden as if by some magic fairy it appears on Windows , THEY DO COPY OTHER OS's.Ms may have thousands of developers but all other OS's have twice or many times the number that MS have , but yet they still manage to keep their costs way below that of MS and still produce a better quality product.

Why would you say with pride they've spent hundreds of millions of dollars on the product, that's shamefull... as of yet they have not released a stable and secure system but yet every time the promise they will , it's called marketing that's where the money goes, sell first fix later . that's the bottom line... Dollars and profit not product quality

by blu_vg9

Here is a distinction to clarify. First, I will say that I've used Linux, as well as Unix (mainly Solaris), Novell, Windows, and MacOS--all in a production environment, although only MacOS and Windows on end-user production workstations (precisely because that is their strength). But when you're talking about stripping down the workstation installs, at some point you have to decide: are you looking for a "desktop"-style workstation, or are you really going for more of an "embedded" solution. In some scenarios, a stripped-down, embedded-style workstation makes sense--and these solutions exist in the Windows world as well. In my scenarios--and I think most scenarios--the workstation needs a broad range of functionality, including the ability to play media files and the like. And yes, people may want to play a CD on their computer sometime.

What Group Policy does so well, though, is that it provides a universal, easy-to-understand, one-stop-shop mechanism by which you can *control* (not just remove/deny) the functionality available to end users--across all applications on the platform that store settings in the registry--applied over your system directory. The settings can be very specific--for example, if I want to allow browsing/playing Solitaire from noon to 1 for one group, and only allow it after hours for different group, I can easily accomplish that in 5 minutes for the entire organization through Group Policy. And at the same time, I could roll out a requested change to disable "automatic capitalization of the first word in a sentence" in Word for administrative assistants. And, I'll remove the Auto-update notification in Adobe Reader for all users while I'm at it. It comes with Windows, it's supported by a wide-range of applications (and you can create your own .adm file if you want), there is broad 3rd-party support for the tools, and it works.

The closest thing I've seen on Linux is ZENworks... but take a look at the documentation: http://www.novell.com/documentation/zenworks7/index.html
You'll quickly see that, while it aims to accomplish the same type of functionality on Linux as Group Policy does on Windows, it is nowhere near as granular or powerful (the "text file policy" looks like an especially fun time!).

by apotheon

Micromanaging much? Whoever's paying you to spend hours every day fiddling settings in that minute a manner is getting ripped off.

by blu_vg9

It does sound that way, but trust me, this is the type of thing I'm asked to do--it's not a mandate coming down from IT. I get these requests from HR, from people who do training, from all over within the business. There are some settings that are sort of policing-type measures, but most are geared around settings that make our applications fit our environment better. It does make a difference.

I gave examples of some very finely-detailed settings that you can adjust, but that doesn't mean that it comes at the expense of other, broader settings. I just used them as examples of how powerful and flexibile Group Policy is and to differentiate it from the management tools for Linux, which aren't nearly as powerful. You can set application-specific settings for just about any application, and for each individual setting, you can either set it as a user-adjustable default (and do it based on Active Directory group, if you like), or you can choose to enforce it (again by user and/or group). The best part is it certainly does *not* take "hours every day"--it takes only a few minutes to change those settings, and then it's done. I have yet to see anything similar on the Linux platform... or any platform, for that matter, of which I'm aware.

by golf24_7

In some respects I agree with what you say but it is not reality.
I have spent most of my career in Quality Assurance and time and again I watch code ship with bugs and some cases known critical flaws. Why, reasons very from nobody will find it, it will never happen, the users should not do that to we have a deadline and we will meet it. The fact of the mater is I can not recall a single time that I have ever seen software delivered that has more then about 10 users actually delivered bug free.

Additionally, I don?t care what OS you are running exposing it directly to the internet without proper patching and monitoring is absurd yet most people I know do this. They get high-speed internet plug their PC in to the modem and leave it on all the time not to mention they don?t run an Anti-Virus and if they do rarely keep it up to date nor do they deploy patches when they are released.

Computers still need regular maintenance regardless of OS.

On final note, we complain that Microsoft can?t protect our computers, that are all different and they don?t directly control, from possible millions of attacker?s everyday yet I bet most of us can?t even adequately secure our own homes.

By the way you are correct that Microsoft has excellent marketing skills on that note so do most cigarette manufactures, car manufactures, Big businesses (ENRON) the point is we hear what we want which is rarely the whole truth.

by jdclyde

not complacency.

If an auto maker ships a known defect, they are looking at major law suits where there are damages and even loss of life due to the defect.

If a software developer sends a known defect, it is just part of the game and we scrug our shoulders and hope we have a good backup.

We should be able to hold any and all software deveolopers accountable for any damage or loss due to a defect in their product, including down time.

If MS sits on an exploit for six months and the exploit is discovered and used, MS should be held accountable for anyone with a properly patched system that was exploited.

Expect more or you will never get more.

by golf24_7

I don't know about your car but mine has had a couple of recalls and I did not get paid for them. You may also not realize that recalls generally only occur after numerous people have found/complained about a given problem. Furthermore any car that does not get a perfect score in a crash test should be considered defective but odly enough it isn't. Why all these things drive up costs and delay delivery.
Do I think they should be more proactive sure so should everyone else. I am not aware of very many other vendors that support their product for as long or as well as Microsoft does. When is the last time you went to a vendor with a problem in a product that you purchased over a year ago let alone seven years ago and got satisfaction.

By the way I am not sure what you do for a living but imagine trying to do your job in a way that it will please millions of different users with diffearent needs tring to do different things.

Also, I have noticed that most products do not have built in functionality to let you know there is a problem with a solution. If your lucky you get something in the mail assuming you registered properly and you have not moved.

Get real.

by astromusicman

As the IT coordinator for a public school district, we mainly have Windows 2000 machines for use throughout our district. Very few have XP (maybe 5%) and about the same amount are still running 98.

Win2K is just fine for the day to day word processing/ internet searching that is needed. Unfortunately, we don't do much higher end stuff with the kids, as that might change what OS we would be leaning towards. XP just has a lot more fancy bells and whistles compared to 2000 and I don't see a big difference between them (at least not big enough to want me to rush out and buy licenses to upgrade all of the 2000 to XP.

I figure Vista will be the same for us. I can't see running out and frantically looking to put Vista on any new machines. It may be at least 2 years before I even consider putting it on. I'll let everyone else do all of the troubleshooting and patching before I'll even consider getting a machine with Vista installed. If what we currently use works fine and you don't need more, why even think about bringing in another operating system you would need to troubleshoot.

by markdmac

Arguing on the Internet is like running in the special olympics. Sure you can do it but you are still a retard.

I have personally seen the messages sent to Premier Support Customers and know that this has already been fixed and is not a factor in the delay of shipping Vista.

by itperformance

I have been running the latest build for Vista from MSDN. So far I am not impressed at all. I am running this on a an athlon xp 2800 processor clocked at 2.2 ghz, 3 gigs of ram and 300 gb SATA drive with a 256mb nvidia card. So far I am very discouraged. I remember running the bet a version of xp and it was a much better performer than this release of vista. The operating system looks pretty but functionally it is terrible. It is extremely slow does not interface well with or at all with most applications, which means you'll have to wait for patches and or next versions of all of your applications. The hardware drivers are getting better from previous builds but still not there either. There are way to many clicks involved for simple tasks. Their are duplicative icons in control panel. The only positive so far is no BSODs. The security features are more of a nuisance then a sense of a security. It it is microsoft be sure that every hacker will be after it. I'm staying with XP it is solid does what it needs too, if you have good sense when using your pc and have firewalls hardware and software security should not be an issue. Of course there is always linux.

by apotheon

Your faith in the honesty of Microsoft's public relations flacks is truly inspiring.

by dave the computer guy

I?d have to agree with the other posts. What advantage is there in this OS vs Win 2K or XP? I see you mentioned installs imaging. Most large scale corporations already have an imaging solution, such as Norton Ghost, so why would you pay for a new OS just to get something you already have? It?s the same with the new AV and Spyware stuff. We already run a corporate version of AV, Spyware removal, and Firewall. How do you justify budgeting for a new OS when you already have all these solutions in place and they work just fine.

by cwoody382

Since Microsoft have security flaws in most products at this time including the current XP operating system, Office 2003 etc, it will be some time before I will update to Vista. Sorry to be synical,perhaps I will think about it when they release Vista2009 Second edition. As for firewall, AV and spyware I have three tools that work fine. If Microsoft spent more time and effort into building robust operating systems then they would be no need for AV/Anti Spyware and firewalls that exploit Windows vunerabilities and these products would be cheaper. Thinking about Vista from a corperate point of view, I will not be long before Microsoft pull the plug on XP support forcing bussinesses to upgrade whether they can afford to or not. I think perhaps this is another marketing ploy to confuse the majority of users to by a new product.
In conclusion I aggree with Dave the Computer Guy

by comp1systems

Frankly, I have always been a believer that too much hype
on anything can often lead to disappointment. Is this the
case with Windows Vista? It's been talked about so long, it
doesn't seem to be worth the wait any more.

And with everything I have read so far I was left with this
one question, "how well will it perform in a home and
business environment?" And if we are going to need that
big of a video card just to use the special and new windows
effect, does this mean that newer computer systems will
equipped with Vista automatically come with the 256 meg
card installed, otherwise this means that anyone using an
older card in a new or old system will find themselves
running out spending money on a new card just to have full
use of the features.

And with regard to new security features, until they create
something that cannot be hacked into, Microsoft will never
be as secured as they would like to believe it is, and this is
with respect to the next 100 operating systems they
develop after Vista.

It took me a long time to get around to using Windows XP
because I just wasn't sold on the new features reviews
claimed it had. And when I got around to using it and
upgrading my computers to it, the only thing I found
different was the overall look which could be changed to
classic for those who were old-fashioned to heart. They
attempted to beef up their security features in XP, but later
on with updates there were so many bugs in it that alot of
the updates that had been downloaded had to be ultimately
replaced. This is why I have my doubts about Vista.

And now that the Intel chip is now running in Mac making it
possible to run on a Windows platform, I am curious to see
how the new Macs perform over the next year and hear the
testamonies from consumers who bought the new Macs.

Don't get me wrong, I am a long time fan of Microsoft
products, I just do not see them doing anything that
fantastic in the security department. And until we can see
just how well the new operating system runs, I am not
getting my hopes up until I can actually put my hands on it
and try it out for myself.

So as far as I am concerned with Vista...it is a wait and
see...

by apotheon

There's at minimum one highly functional equivalent professional grade alternative for each type of application you mentioned. I have listed here the application type, the application example you gave, one application example each that runs on Linux and is open source, and a URL for getting that open source Linux-compatible alternative.

high functionality image editor
Photoshop: The Gimp
http://www.gimp.org

Shockwave Flash development environment
Flash: FlashDevelop
http://osflash.org/flashdevelop

WYSIWYG web authoring system
Dreamweaver: NVU
http://www.nvu.com/

nonlinear video editor
Premiere: Cinelerra
http://heroinewarrior.com/cinelerra.php3

office suite
MS Office: OpenOffice.org
http://www.openoffice.org

Games work just fine on Linux. In fact, with the use of Cedega (which costs significantly less than Windows), games often work [b]better[/b] on Linux with faster frame rates than you'd get on, for instance, Windows XP.

The moral of the story:
Don't open your mouth if all you're going to do is stick your foot in it. Clearly, you have no idea what you're talking about.

by cr

My point of the original post was that there may be replacement apps but they are inferior. also that 'flashdevelop' dosn't even seem to be a replacement to flash... but u can prove me wrong if u want.

also cedega also reiterates my point as it dosn't play things that have just been released, for example Oblivion, which fails to run on cedega (i have used winex in its pervious forms and that was always the case then as is the case now).

gimp is the only app there that may even have a chance of standing up against its counterpart, and these are all mainstream applications in windows, applications that almost everyone here knows of.

by jmgarvin

Oblivian will work now with the patch that doesn't force the game to use pixel shader 2.0.

Hell, tons of Windows boxes *STILL* can't run the game either, so I fail to see your point.

As for Cedega not working: You are full of it. The 1.10 patch for WoW (a big patch) was EASY to deal with. The folks at transgaming are on top of MAKING GAMES WORK ON A PLATFORM THEY WERE NEVER MEANT TO WORK ON.

Please also answer why you think the apps are inferior? What functionality is missing?

by apotheon

"[i]management tools for Linux, which aren't nearly as powerful[/i]"

Bollocks.

Snort. Nmap. Webmin. UnionFS. Synaptic. YaST. SELinux. Nagios. Secpolicy. Nessus. Netsaint. Gradm. Acidbase. Samba. NFS. AFBackup. Perl (and if Perl doesn't sound like a management tool to you, you haven't been working with Linux enough).

Hell, even the basic, run of the mill user account stuff puts the Windows alternatives to shame.

I think the problem is that you expect to find One Big Application That Does Everything. In the Linux world (and the Unix world in general), people make small utilities that each do one job and do it well. If you want to do a lot of things, you have a lot of utilities. If you want them to work in concert with each other, there are glue-code scripts that tie them together that you can use and, failing that, you can write your own very simply and easily.

In Windows, you have five or six gigantic monolithic monstrosities that each try to do a significant percentage of Everything, and end up doing all those things to some barely acceptible, mediocre standard. Scriptability is lacking. Mixing and matching functionality doesn't happen. Et cetera. The clicky interface soothes a lot of people, though, so they're welcome to it.

by blu_vg9

You're comparing snort and nmap to Group Policy? What on earth are you talking about? That is not the same type of management application AT ALL. Nagios? I've met Ethan Galstad personally, incidentally... and Nagios has absolutely nothing to do with the type of management I'm talking about. There are plenty of products for Windows out there that serve the same function as the products you mention--including many of those you mention (and that includes Nagios).

Again, you're failing to address the point. There is nothing that is COMPARABLE to Group Policy on the Linux side. Don't tell me about system monitoring tools, or network sniffers, or the like. Heck yeah, I can script all sorts of things on the Windows side using Perl, too... but why would I when Group Policy does the job so well? Criticizing Group Policy by comparing it to snort and nmap... now there's the nonsense. They don't even *attempt* to serve the same function.

Please, if you're going to respond, make it relevant to Group Policy. If there is something that comes close to it on the Linux side, I'd love to know about it.

by emil7055010015

for me it doesn't really matter, something's worth if it is cost effective. it can be linux, mac os or windows. there is no such thing as 100% secure until the end of time, unless otherwise you kill all the people who always find fault of something there will always be vulnerability.

by apotheon

Is that just a typo, or is u an abbreviation of a corporation's name? I'm not sure what you're trying to say.

by zlitocook

I might need to support three or four versions of another Microsoft product! It is bad now with XP and it's SP's and company programs that only run on SP1 but not on SP2! But now we may have to support three or four versions of an MS system and have a help desk relearn all thier work. And MS is not done; there could be more to learn and what about updates! Will there be updates for one and a different update for the other?
Linux is looking real good about now!
We have problems with XP PRO on most workstations because we still use older applications and the venders we use are trying to upgrade. But we need to keep using the older apps until we can upgrade.
But MS keeps going and not seeing what it is doing to the companies that can not keep up.
Is this a way to say upgrade or drop out?
Well Free is looking great for alot of companies now. Linux and others are being talked about in most staff meetings now.

by mjwx

By "the future isn't here yet" I mean that the large-scale adoption of Linux as a desktop OS is not [b]currently[/b] a viable option for businesses (or average consumers. while you and I (I only use windows for games) can happily use Linux as a everyday operating system most people cant. It?s just not as easy to use as winblows.

Apo, I'm not having a go at you but you need to put yourself in the average consumer?s perspective. Linux is a great step into the unknown for a system admin who has never used Linux. Although I sincerely doubt any one who has taken that step has looked back but average people don?t have a chance with Linux as it is. Take a hairdresser, as common as sysadmins but knows nothing about computers. As I was having a haircut this morning and talking as you do, to the hair dresser trying as hard as I could to convince her not to get a Mac. But when I bought up the topic of vista she replied "what?s Vista?". My point in short is that most people are not tech savvy.

I think we will have to have to wait out vista's life cycle to see Linux desktops in all their glory. But hey if vista's crap it will have a short life span.

by apotheon

Many businesses find large-scale Linux adoption quite viable. So do an increasing number of government agencies, to include the mass-migration of all municipal systems in Munich, Germany.

If you think Linux isn't viable yet for business, I recommend you have a nice sit-down chat with Sterling Ball, the CEO of Ernie Ball, probably the best-known guitar string vendor in the world. His company made the migration from Windows to Linux. In fact, they found it not only viable but highly preferable, way back in 2000. The whole migration happened in six months. Read all about it:
http://news.com.com/2008-1082_3-5065859.html

Sterling Ball was not some technical know-all guru. He was a business manager. He managed to make the migration, and it saved the company huge gobs of money.

I run across examples every day of the canonical eighty year old grandmother making the switch and suddenly realizing that life doesn't have to be as difficult as MS Windows makes it. It's not nearly as difficult as you make it sound.

Why were you trying to talk the hairdresser out of getting a Mac anyway? MacOS X is a better OS than Windows any day of the week.

by mjwx

"large scale adoption as a [b]desktop[/b] os"

The company I work for at the moment has heavily invested in MS at the moment. Now this may change in the future. Many small to medium businesses are in this position. Believe it or not but Linux has only recently became viable as a server for businesses and as I understand it many companies (mostly large ones that can afford to have a pool of Linux guru?s on staff) have adopted it.

I like Linux. I wish I could use Linux on a more regular basis. I have also suggested that when we upgrade our file server we should use Linux as it would be an easy way for management to gain confidence with the use of Linux servers and it is not difficult to set up in a Windows domain.

?Why were you trying to talk the hairdresser out of getting a Mac anyway??
Because she was a nice girl and I have been asked too many times ?how do I get this program to work on my Mac? only to say that it can?t.

by jmgarvin

If you are so into GPOs and various group policy boondoogles, well have fun. All you are talking about is simple scheduling.

I can create the exact same functionality via groups, umasks/file permissions, a handful of simple scripts and cron. What's the difference?

As a matter of fact...bag the scripts, I'll do it all in cron.

by jmgarvin

A glib remark and an appeal to authority...doesn't get any more classic than that...

Is this a usenet feed?

by blu_vg9

Doing what Group Policy does with cron--now that is hilarious! It's like using a toothpick holder to build a house.

Again, please (!) make your replies to this relevant to Group Policy functionality. If you think you can accomplish the same thing via simple file permissions twiddling (which is easily done on Windows as well, incidentally), you simply don't get it. Look at the ZENworks documentation link I provided earlier--it's clear that not only is the Linux OS support very limited, the Linux application support is horribly, horribly limited. ZENworks is a very sophisticated, powerful product, and Novell has bet the farm on Linux... yet ZENworks can't accomplish anywhere near the same thing on Linux as it *itself* can on Windows.

by majorflash

I must say I'm not sure I understand what your point is. Let's take a look at simple vs. easy. When I think of the term 'easy' in terms of managing a pc, I think of starting it up, doing whatever it is I need to do, and shutting it down.

I just don't think that windows allows users to use the pc in this manner the way that a mac does. For instance, to keep a windows pc running, the user has to make sure that their anti-virus definitions are current, the firewall is up, and their anti-spyware tool(s) are all up to date. The user has to manage the security of their pc proactively or suffer the consequences.

On the mac, this type of periodic, preventive, maintenance us either unnecessary or handled by the OS without the user having to worry about it. Easy.

I also realize that this does not mean that OS X is better or more secure than windows and that is largely due to the fact that hackers target the largest OS for their attacks, etc, etc. But as a user, I don't care. As a software developer, I want to use the pc the same way a carpenter uses a hammer (as a tool to get a job done).

There are things about OS X I don't like (such as the floating windows you've mentioned), but at the same time, I've learned, as I'm sure many other mac users have, to become comfortable and effective in working in that environment.

Yourself being a LAN administrator, I can see how windows boxes would be easier to manage on a network, but most users are not managing corporate networks, or trying to create roaming profiles. The simplicity of the tasks you're mentioning, along with the fact that everything in windows is so tightly integrated to the core of the os is precisely why hackers find it relatively easy to wreak havoc on a windows pc.

As for simple, add hardware to a windows pc, and then try to add hardware to a mac. I don't care if I have to pay a little more for apple's hardware if when I go to use it, it works, every time. There is no finding the 'right' drivers, no add/remove harware in the control panel, no hassles. It just works. Simple.

My point is that for those of use who know where the utilities folder is, and who know how to work in the OS X enviromnent, it just works, and that's something you can't always say about windows.

No OS is perfect, and OS X is far from perfect, but in my experience with working on both every single day, I still find the mac more simple and more easy to use.

Sorry if I freaked out. I know I probably sound like one of those dudes with an apple t-shirt on, listening to my iPod, but I'm really not.

I just look at Microsoft as the AOL of operating systems. It's everywhere, and it's comforatable, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's the best.

It's a matter of taste, and each individual user has to make a choice depending on what they are using the pc for.

by mjwx

Periodic Maintenance is not carried out if the machine is not shut down (Cron stops running). Mac?s don?t get shut down around here, that?s how I know.

So far on 2 G5?s running 10.4(.4 I think) Office has broken twice, indesign has broken on both Mac?s, and a complete reinstall just brings back the same problem (this leads me to believe that the OS is at fault). All of that is just in the last month.

On a PC, if set up correctly antivirus and firewall programs (we use both corporate antivirus (CA) and a corporate firewall (ISA)) will update automatically with no input from the user.

I have seen OS X security used against the user, effectively blocking him out of his own files. OSX GUI said that he had access to the files but it still wouldn?t let him access them (a few photoshop and indesign files). I had to go into the terminal (something an average Mac user doesn?t know how to do) and set the permission to 777 (different on a Mac R+ I think from memory or it could X+ or XR I don?t remember).

As for hardware, I like the ability to pick and choose. I can more easily customise a PC into a media box, number crunching box, gaming box, graphic design box and so on. If that makes it a little more complex then so be it. Besides this is something the average user wont be doing (this also creates work for me).

The average Mac user doesn?t know where the utilities folder is let alone what it does (same as the average PC user). Personally I?d rather do everything in the command line, like in Linux.

I?d love to rip out all our windows servers and replace them with Linux. Someday we may just do that, but I?m not the guy who makes the decisions (yet) I?m just the guy who does the work. My main gripe with Mac?s are in a corporate environment. These little white nightmare?s can ruin a perfectly good day faster that windows can crash.

by apotheon

That schmuck hasn't even looked at the applications in question, most likely, and thus won't have any clue what functionality is or is not missing. He also keeps using this mysterious "u" word. I can't find it in any dictionaries indicating something that fits the context of his message -- not even the incredibly bloated and "liberal" Oxford English Dictionary. Do you know what "u" means?

by apotheon

1. I wasn't comparing group policy management in Windows to Snort (et cetera). I was responding to your ridiculous statement that I quoted at the beginning of my post. Please try to maintain context when responding to my statements.

2. The point jmgarvin and I are trying to get across to you is that Windows group policy management is bloat. It can all be done with simpler, smaller tools. See my previous commentary about how the unix world does things with do-one-thing-well utilities rather than monolithic do-everything-poorly tightly integrated vendor stacks.

by apotheon

The so-called 64-bit OS that MS is peddling hamstrings 64-bit applications, among other issues with the dearth of 64-bit applications that run on Microsoft platforms.

by markdmac

I think your observations on the life cycle are good. You are correct about XP too. Microsoft policy is N-1 for patches. So Windows XP is already dead from that perspective. All new patches require a minimum of SP1 at this point. When SP3 comes out, SP1 support will go away too.

I don't think it fair to to cite this as unfair on Microsoft's part however. After all, the service packs are FREE. It only makes sense for Microsoft to have to draw the line somewhere to be able to effectively provide patches and updates etc. Furthermore any other item you buy will have a warranty cut off and point where parts just are not provided anymore. Why should software be any different? It is difficult and costly to keep software engineers skilled in older technologies.

Your point about trustworthy computing is misguided. The concept behind trustworthy computing is not to keep non-microsoft programs from your computer, it is to ensure that the programs you do purchase from Microsoft meet with customers expectations that they can be trusted to be secure and well engineered.

by blu_vg9

1) Desktop management and monitoring tools, etc. are very different things. The context was Group Policy and desktop management--you're the one who is expanding the context. Those other tools are a whole different set of topics, so bringing it into this discussion is hardly relevant.

2) "Bloat"--for one, define "bloat." That's a trite FUD word, often used carelessly. It's hardly bloat--it works very efficiently from a systems perspective. But more importantly, it saves administrators a huge amount of fiddling. It is NOT a one-stop shop for EVERYTHING systems admin-related, but it IS a place where you can manage a great deal of desktop settings.

But even if it WAS all things system-admin related, what is your point? If you have a single interface that puts at your fingertips the collective power of all your scripts, utilities, etc., is that bloat too? If you're going to make the point that a host of decentralized utilities does a better job than a centralized place that groups these functions--perhaps also made up of several utilities itself--you're going to have to give definitive examples of why you claim that, not just a vague, speculative notion. Furthermore, you're going to have to prove that this approach is better when the use of a centralized management tool such as Group Policy hardly precludes the supplemental use of those very same stand-alone utilities.

If something like Group Policy existed for Linux, you'd be touting the power of that as "yet another advantage over Windows." But the fact remains, there is nothing comparable. Will you please address directly how you can accomplish the same thing on Linux? Again, for the love of Pete, you simply CANNOT do the same thing via fiddling with file permissions.

by markdmac

Well said James.

You hear a lot about IE problems, but the fact is there were more critical issues that required patching in Firefox than in IE in 2004. I don't think 2005 numbers have been published yet for comparrison.

by apotheon

Your statement needs editing. You said:

"[i]there were more critical issues that required patching in Firefox than in IE in 2004[/i]"

What you should have said is this:

"[i]there were more critical issues, according to one standard of measure, that were reported publicly by the Mozilla Foundation for Firefox than were reported publicly by Microsoft for IE in 2004[/i]"

Of course, considering Microsoft's tendencies in vulnerability reporting, that means essentially zero.

by tony hopkinson

those statistics, the numbers change depend on where you are sat. They aren't wrong but different things are being reported. For instance MS's report doesn't include the ones reported in previous years that aren't fixed yet. You might want to look at turn around times for all issues fixed, you'll get a better picture, otherwise you are down to 9/10 housewives say so.

by markdmac

Dude, you have some serious hostility issues. Switch to decaf and get your facts straight on the number of security warnings for the two technologies.

http://blogs.msdn.com/michael_howard/archive/2004/10/15/242966.aspx

You clearly just like to hate all things Microsoft. So don't use Microsoft technologies and live a quiet peaceful life in your own private utopia. Now go play nice nice in your corner and let the grown ups have a nice dicussion.

by jdclyde

do not most products have a warrenty on them?

Your expectations are too low based on what you have been conditioned to accept, and not consistant with expectations for other products.

by apotheon

You said (direct quote):
"[i]the management tools for Linux, which aren't nearly as powerful[/i]"

It wasn't me that expanded the context beyond Windows group policy management. That was you.

You also said (direct quote):
"[i]It's hardly bloat--it works very efficiently from a systems perspective.[/i]"

That's BS. Windows has more than 50M lines of code in it. [b]That[/b] is bloat.

More direct quote:
"[i]If you're going to make the point that a host of decentralized utilities does a better job than a centralized place that groups these functions--perhaps also made up of several utilities itself[/i]"

You don't read so well. I specifically mentioned that separate utilities are often tied together with glue code and unified interfaces to provide more complex and centralized management on unixlike systems. There's nothing wrong with providing such unified access: the problem is in doing it by making your mail transfer agent an indivisible part of your text editor. Why include the same friggin' functionality on your system thirty times over as redundantly repetitive reimplementation? There's only one reason: insufficiently modularized functionality. In other words, The Windows Way.

"[i]If something like Group Policy existed for Linux, you'd be touting the power of that as 'yet another advantage over Windows.'[/i]"

Actually, I wouldn't be using it, just like I don't use KDE. It's a bloated monstrosity (even though it's orders of magnitude slimmer than the user environment of Windows). The advantage to a Group Policy work-alike for Linux is that it doesn't have to be installed in the first place, and neither do any of its supporting libraries.

"[i]for the love of Pete, you simply CANNOT do the same thing via fiddling with file permissions.[/i]"

Prove it.

by apotheon

Do ad hominem fallacies make you happy? Are you unable to make salient points without devolving into insults?

Do you lack the ability to present unbiased evidence? There's no point in even click on an MSDN blog link to see your supporting evidence. Propaganda isn't going to help your case with me.

I'm not angry. I don't hate all things Microsoft. As a matter of fact, I'm Microsoft certified and my all-time favorite pointing device is a Microsoft five-button optical trackball.

You're the one throwing a tantrum, using "bad words", and failing to play nice with others. Perhaps it is you that needs anger management. You certainly need some reading comprehension instruction if you thought you saw anger in my previous post, and you definitely need to take a course or two in formal logic if you think this post of yours constitutes logical discourse.

by the_fixer

I use both Windows and Red Hat Linux and both have their pros and cons. I think that MS gets hit with a bad reputation for security and it has been deserved in the past. I do think they are doing a better job of it lately and if you check the US CERT web site (See link below) you will find that there are more security vulnerabilities listed for Linux in last weeks bulletin. My concern (and this only my perception) if you have an OS kernel that everyone has open access to, wouldn't there be a greater chance that someone could find and exploit a security hole? JMHO.

http://www.us-cert.gov/cas/bulletins/SB06-082.html

by michael_orton9

Just downloaded copy of IE-7 beta. I believe this will be shipped with VISTA.
Initial impression.
The worst browser I have ever used.
Prefer Opera (win and Linux), Firefox (win & Linux).
Both Firefox and Opera were very easy to learn.
I gave up on IE-7. Even Spry Mosaic was easier to learn.
Suppose I will have to get used to it, just to sort out other peoples' PCs.
Thats the only rreason I will try it again!
Its a Creative, Realistic, Artistic Product, pity it is so hard to learn.

by michael l hereid sr

If your computer runs Windows XP it will run Vista. I have it (latest build 32bit/64bit)running on this pc.
MSI K8M NEO-v
512 DDR PC 2700
AMD Athlon X64 2800+
WD800JB 80 gig hd
MicroAdvantage DVD RW/CD RW
Haupauge WinTV Go FM
Ultra 400 watt Power Supply
GeForce FX5200 128meg ddr(cost$35)
Only thing I need to change is the old tech tv card.

by michael l hereid sr

I tested Windows XP on a AMD 6-2 400mhz and it ran very nicely on 198meg PC133 memory and 20 gig harddrive. I ran this for about 2 years before I upgraded and I was never disappointed.

by mjwx

Two IT staff have 50+ workstations and 15 servers (all running winblows) to take care of BEFORE mac's.

Besides life is so much easier with only one crappy OS to deal with.

by jmgarvin

"2) "Bloat"--for one, define "bloat." That's a trite FUD word, often used carelessly. It's hardly bloat--it works very efficiently from a systems perspective."

No, it does not. The system resources it consumes are huge (50Mish). Further, it adds to the boot up time, which can be critical during a server failure. Finally, it adds NOTHING that cannot be done in various other ways.

"But more importantly, it saves administrators a huge amount of fiddling. It is NOT a one-stop shop for EVERYTHING systems admin-related, but it IS a place where you can manage a great deal of desktop settings."

How about a default security level that doesn't let the users do stupid things? Oh, wait, *nix does that. Groups can also be setup quite well in *nix, plus you setup various umasks and file permissions....What's the problem?

"But even if it WAS all things system-admin related, what is your point? If you have a single interface that puts at your fingertips the collective power of all your scripts, utilities, etc., is that bloat too?"

The point is you can either use the decentralized tools or the integrated tool(s).

"If you're going to make the point that a host of decentralized utilities does a better job than a centralized place that groups these functions--perhaps also made up of several utilities itself--you're going to have to give definitive examples of why you claim that, not just a vague, speculative notion."

That wasn't the point...you missed it.

"Furthermore, you're going to have to prove that this approach is better when the use of a centralized management tool such as Group Policy hardly precludes the supplemental use of those very same stand-alone utilities."

Already done. Please re-read the posts.

"If something like Group Policy existed for Linux, you'd be touting the power of that as "yet another advantage over Windows." But the fact remains, there is nothing comparable."

Yes there is. The only point you have brought up that Group Policy can do is that it can schedule when user can or cannot use applications. I suggested you use cron. What else can GP do that *nix just can't do?

"Will you please address directly how you can accomplish the same thing on Linux?"

How about what can GP do that *nix can't? Gimme a list and I'll tell you how to do it in Linux with disparate tools and integrated tool sets.

"Again, for the love of Pete, you simply CANNOT do the same thing via fiddling with file permissions"

WRONG. You can...please give me a concrete example where GP will do something more than file permssions (other than scheduling)

by apotheon

You said "desktop". I was referring to desktops as well as servers. Munich isn't just using Linux for servers: it's also using Linux for workstations. Ernie Ball isn't just using Linux for servers: it's also using Linux for workstations. In fact, Sterling Ball made the decision before the migration that his company wouldn't use [b]anything[/b] from Microsoft, which even means not using Macs since Microsoft owns a substantial percentage of Apple's stock.

Do you think I was referring to 80 year old grandmothers using Linux for servers? I was definitely referring to desktops in that case, as well as the others.

by cr

saying did i read the list of apps is stupid, if u read and knew the apps in that list you would have noticed that flashdevelop is actually a windows utility not a linux one... and also is not a replacement to flash at all.

quote: "FlashDevelop is a .NET open source script editor designed mostly for Actionscript 2 development. FlashDevelop is very quick to setup and easy to use as an external editor for the Flash IDE or as a complete open source development environment."

so common, dont be such idiots about things when clearly you havn't read into things yourself.

by dodgeviper

vista to me is just a nice to have, newer toy to have on a machine. it looks nice, has new features that you can use and it "boasts" bigger and better things then the version behind it, but it is just another new thing that is available for those who have the money and time to fool around with new toys

by golf24_7

Most products come with what 90 days maybe a year. You want a longer warranty no problem but it will cost you extra. Not to mention that most require you to ship the product to them generally at your cost. Don?t get me wrong I want more, but the usually means it costs more and yes I know you can get Linux for free but does it function as well is Windows I think not. Do I really want to retrain my entire household on how to use Linux and even if I did why don?t you explain to a six year old and two year old hoe Linux is better but they can?t play their games on it? I guess my problem is I see the PC as more then just a tool I use it for entertainment as well.
In my house I support 5 desktop users and one laptop all of whom currently run XP and most of whom will probably go to Vista when it ships. I may have to up a few graphics cards most notably my two year olds computer because he has an integrated graphics card. Otherwise I suspect Vista will run fine. On top of those I have a machine with the Vista Beta, Win98 virtual machine, one Mandrake box to Sun boxes with Solaris a Win2k server a win2003 server and a server with the longhorn core that I am playing with. Not to mention the friends and family I support. By in large the XP boxes take care of themselves I do spend a bit of time reloading Win98 boxes due to kids trying to load stuff that will never run on the old hardware namely games and the occasional virus. I also have to admit that the Linux and Solaris boxes run fine to however the require a lot more work to get up and running and I manually patch those.
In principle I agree with you about Quality that is why I work in QA. That said I also realize that there has to be a balance and I personally think Microsoft does a far better job then most. Especially when it comes to support after the code is released. I see software go out with known defects everyday and the developers are more then happy to go back and fix those problems for a price. Microsoft?s way of doing it is every couple of years they release a new version and they charge you a couple hundred dollars per copy to use their software and have it supported. Do I like shelling out all that money no but I like the improvements and the support so I do just like I do for every application I like and use.
By the way I will update my home to Vista first and then upgrade the computers for my company 3 to 6 months later unless I need new computers sooner. As far as I am concerned until a company can give me a better OS that does everything I want to do for about the same price or less I will stick with Microsoft.

by apotheon

jmgarvin: "Lemur" you say? Frink! Frink ptang!
http://www.faqs.org/faqs/lemur-faq/part1/

cr: Apparently, you're not paying very bloody much attention. You don't seem to be aware of the existence of Mono -- an open source implementation of the .NET framework for operating systems other than Windows.

by apotheon

another dull knife in the drawer

"[i]I know you can get Linux for free but does it function as well is Windows[/i]"
I'm going to guess you meant "as Windows". The answer is "No, it functions [b]better[/b] than Windows."

"[i]I think not.[/i]"
That's obvious.

"[i]explain to a six year old and two year old hoe Linux is better but they can?t play their games on it?[/i]"
Why would I want to lie to the kid? You can play games on Linux just fine.

"[i]the developers are more then happy to go back and fix those problems for a price.[/i]"
Wow, exciting. You can pay people money to fix their own mistakes. I need to get in on that racket: I'll create stuff with defects, then get people to pay me to fix them. I could even have the fixes ready before people call! I'll intentionally go back and add defects so that I already have the fixes on hand for solving the problem, then when someone wants to pay me to fix the defects I won't have to do any actual work!

Meanwhile, I'll keep using open source software, which gets fixed for free and far more quickly than any proprietary software I've seen.

Oh, yeah, and one more thing: linebreaks. Learn 'em, love 'em. Huge blocks of text without nice linebreaks are very, very difficult to read online.