Discussion Locked

vlans

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
In a switch network (a school setting)37 class rooms with a switch in each, should a router be in each IDF (9) or a switch, and just create vlans to connect to the severs(8)in a sever farm or what is the best way to design such a network? thanks in advance.

8 replies

by ebob

I would just keep it nice anc clean. No VLANs, nothing. Just switches right back to the servers. In your case it sounds like:
a switch in each classroom --> to "IDF" switch, then each of the 9? IDF switches back to a central switch. The servers should hang directly off of this central switch, with either 1Gbps or 100Mbps Ethernet, and the backbone to the IDF and classroom switches should be 1Gbps or 100 Mbps. In the classroom, you can use either 100Mbps or 10Mbps if you can get away with it.
The WAN and/or Internet router(s)/Firewall also hang off of this central switch at 100Mbps.

Unless there is something special going on, there is likely no need to use VLANs. The switches themselves will handle the traffic nicely all by themselves.

by pacomtrad

I for got to say that the Instructor is attached to each class room swith and I need to create a V-lan for them (instructors) and give access to two (2) severs and the internet and deny students access to the admin and tfp severs and internet pleasere spont.

by kevin anderson

I agree with eBob.

Skip the vlans, and you'll save yourself a weekend or so of configuration, as well as simplifing maintenance later on.

Kev.

by some guy in seattle

Assuming you can trust the instructors not to have hacking wars between classrooms, I would leave the system open, with no VLANs.

Modify the permissions/accounts on the servers to only accept logins from authorized users (the instructors). I imagine some kind of router/firewall is in place. Implement user authentication on those for the instructors as well.

Hope that helps,

This discussion is closed to new replies.