Discussion Locked

VOICE YOUR ENTERPRISE VIRUS SCAN OPINION

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello everyone -
We are preparing to implement an enterprise Virus solution on our NT Network. (Our exchange server is currently running ScanMail)We are interested in looking at all of the products on the market, but only interested in the best solution. If you have any suggestions ... please post.

Thanks,
Paul Schubitzke MCP, MCSE+I

11 replies

by sfo farmer

Here is my two cents... Stick with ScanMail on the exchange server; It is the state of the art (using avapi).
Enterprise wide for clients and servers: Norton AntiVirus Corp Edition 7.5 (just released a few weeks ago- 7.5 adds some nice features like virus defintion rollback..)
Why I picked NAV: 1- Cost price being the same for client or server (other companies charge $$$ for the server software) 2- AV defintion updates to clients from parent server 3- Security- users can be completely locked out from doing updates/disabling the service/whats scanned and when. 4- Management- One MMC management point to start a virus sweep by group. 5- Outlook aware client (gee, how many viruses have we seen enter by e-mail lately?) to scan attachments before it's previewed.

I have used McAffee and InnoculateIT, the products were not bad, but not as easy to use and manage as NAV CE. Usually you can download evals from them and test yourself...

G'Luck! SFO

by kares

hi,
we use inoculateIT for online virus scanning on servers at the moment but there are different problems with this product and the support is bad. we are going to use sophos antivirus on workstations and servers.this product seems to be really good in scanning,handling and management.
www.sophos.com

for microsoft exchange there there is a fine
product from sybari.www.sybari.com
i heard this should be the best virus scanner for microsoft exchange at the moment.

sven kares

by tallpaul

I have several clients where I've installed Trend OfficeScan. It has a centralized, web-based console for monitoring the status of client workstations and scheduled (daily, weekly, etc.) updates of the definition files via the web. It runs best onNT with IIS and is accessed via a URL on the server. It can also be accessed from outside the LAN if the URL is reachable. Great for RAS or dialin users. Plus you can configure the rights that the users have so they can't unload or uninstall the client application.

by dlw6

First, I concur with SFO Farmer.

But, if you can't afford NAV Corporate Edition, I recommend you consider a site license for Norton Antivirus 5.0.

Its default install is decent, the updates are supported by the Symantec Antivirus Research Center which is usually one of the first to get updates out for new viruses, and it installs (and de-installs) reliably.

Best of all, with a couple of minor configurations of the Scheduler and Scanner (scan all files, scheduled scans, scheduled Liveupdates), you can set it up to run and update itself without any user interaction. If the PC is off when something was supposed to happen those events can be set to automatically occur (run missed events) when the PC is turned on again, without the need for user interaction.

My experience with MacAfee is that it sometimes corrupts itself on install, can't de-install completely, and lacks some of the automated features of NAV.

I have no experience with any other current AV products.

Good fortune,
Don

by pherbst

We currently use Network Associates (McAfee) Virus Defense Suite, which includes McAfee Antivirus for servsers and workstations as well as Groupshield for Exchange. In the past we were quite happy with this solution, but are now becoming increasingly frustrated. McAfee releases product updates that have significant issues and support is not what it once was. We now have to send an e-mail support request- my last one took 5 business days to get a reponse, or we can now pay for a contract to be able to talk to a real person! There is not even a 'per incident' option. Finally, the alerts that automatically come from Network Associates when a new virus is detected are usually slow in arriving and their server is very difficult to reach for thepatch.
Anyway, a consultant whose opinion I have learned to value highly has recommended Trend Micro's Scanmail for our Exchange Server and I am hearing from the reseller channel that Symantec's NACE is outselling other products by far. We are currently evaluating that product. So far version 7.5 looks like a very complete package.
This is an extremely important issue and we are prepared to drop McAfee like a bomb if that's what it takes to get it right.

This discussion is closed to new replies.