Discussion Locked

VPN vs. Frame Relay WAN connections

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

My company has some new office opening that will need high speed, reliable data links between them.
Some of our existing offices are using frame-relay, and some have T1/internet lines using VPN connections.
What are some of the pros and cons of each scenario and which method is best?
Any information will be appreciated.
Thanks.

5 replies

by stillatit

There is no global "best" -- it depends on your individual needs.

Frame:
Typically more expensive than internet T1's.
If your vendor is not oversubscribing the Frame cloud (most are not), usually very good throughput up to whatever port speed you bought.
No access to internet unless you route at some site. (Good or bad, depending on your viewpoint.)
In some cases, you buy T1 (1.544mbps), but max out at 1.1mbps due to overhead.
The vendor is responsible for end-to-end transport of your packets. There is nobody for them to point a finger at.

T1/VPN
There is some hardware cost for the vpn hardware (unless your router happens to include it).
Speeds can vary minute to minute since your traffic is travelling over the internet. You can minimize this by having all your circuits with one vendor with a national backbone. If the internet gets hit with a massive DoS attack, your traffic will probably slow down.
You have internet access as well as access to your other sites.
Depending on your vpn hardware/software, any internet dial-up user with the appropriate hardware/software and passwords can access your network. Good if you have travelling users, but a potential security hole.

Good luck.

by Member 26122104

VPNs offer a good alternative to traditional WNA circuits.

1) you can have Internet access at all sites and not use your WAN bandwidth to provide Internet from a central location.

2) You can use your site-to-site VPN solution for remote users as well.

3) You can use any Internet access that is available (ISDN, DSL, Fractional T1, Cable, wireless, etc.)

Here is a white paper that is more benfit focused (not very technical).

http://pages.sbcglobal.net/mckenzies/shawn/whitepapers/changingoftheguard.pdf

This discussion is closed to new replies.