Discussion Locked

Web Based Office Operations - no way, not by anyone with any sense.

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I know Google and many others are busy developing web based applications to allow you to do all your business over the web - but anyone who uses this type of set up is asking for big trouble. Sure this would be good for the home user who may need a particular type of office software for a short period - say you need to prepare a presentation, hire it over the web for a few days for a few bucks. But not for everyday use.

Here's a few problems with this for a work system.

1. Laws on privacy and data protection - hard to manage when sending them back and forth over the web.

2. Security of the data itself, don't want the opposition to sneak a look at your bids etc.

3. Ready access to the data - hey the ISP link's down, so is the whole business.

4. Cost of maintenance - what if the host service decides to double their charges, hard to shift it all.

5. Are the hosts going to provide ALL your productivity software via the net? Who will see it's maintained at the level you require.

6. What if the host wants to upgrade to a new version and it's not compatible with some of your old records or data - just try opening Word 6 documents in Word 2003 or Word 2007 and you'll see what I mean.

-------

Sure, I can see an advantage to the IT department of a major business in having a web based applications system set up IN YOUR OWN INTRANET off your internal web server. One update ensures everyone is updated, also ensures all data is stored on the controlled and managed servers. This is perfect for the business, as long as the applications and servers are in-house systems, not out on the Internet. But this isn't what's being offered or touted.

OK people, what are YOUR thoughts on these apsects and others?

4 replies

by richardh9935

Here's a few SOLUTIONS.
1. Laws on privacy and data protection - easy to standardise across a large organisation. Use ISO or open standards. Specify in contract.

2. Security of the data itself, - easy to set in a contract with the vendor. Easy to comply with national and international standards because the vendor must satisfy those rules as well as the customer's policies. Use ISO or open standards.

3. Ready access to the data - hey the ISP link's down, so use the DR plan's alternative link or go next door and use theirs. Benefit of using ISO or open standards.
3a Corollary - Plane smashes into building, so go to another building and retrieve all your data, and keep trading. ie use the internet for its core benefits.

4. Cost of service (or maintenance) - contract with the vendor. If vendor super-inflates price, benchmark & change vendors (but see #6 first).

5. Vendors can provide ALL software via the net. That's the way the net was designed. Suits spy agencies too, because operatives don't hold any data. No data risk in the field.

6. Vendors can upgrade software because we and they follow open document standards (preferably ISO or open standards such as PDF/A, OASIS)

by deadly ernest

it matters not what you specify in any contract, the moment the control of the system goes out of your hands, they can do anything they want, and often without you knowing it.

The point I was making about the legislation is the laws place responsibilities on those who COLLECT and USE the information, not those who store it. In the situation of my business having information on private individuals, I place that on a contracted storage service. Regardless of the contract I have with them, if they get broken into and any of that information is accessed improperly, it's my business that wears the huge fines, it's my business that loses the government contracts, and it's my posterior that ends up sitting around in a prison cell if it's that bad. Sure a good contract may allow my solicitor to sue the posterior off the service provider, but it won't get me out of prison, or put him in it.

The people designing these systems are setting their own standards for the software they're using, and you have to accept what they have, and the contract will be sure to give them full control over what they provide and how they provide it.

Regarding the link down, it's a bit hard to go next door when the trunk cable to the area is torn apart in an accident and the whole area has no Internet access for two or three days, what are your staff going to do. At least with it all on your in-house server, you can still operate. and yes, I've seen the above problem occur, not everyone has multiple major trunks to their area.

-------------

Just an idea about how good this concept is; picture outsourcing your country's military services. Sign a contract to hire air force, army, and navy services from Canada. The USA does this and Mexico attacks, Canada sends the troops in as per contract, very good. OK, what about when Canada decides they want to take over the USA -- Oh sorry, the troops are busy invading you at the moment, we'll happily pay the contract forfeiture payments when this is finished.

----------

This is exactly what this Internet based office services is offering.

Another point, will they offer net based versions of all specialised productivity software, if not, you still need all the local systems to handle that anyway.

by delsby

I have been doing a little research for a client of mine that has a software selection project underway. There is a heated debate between IT and some others... IT is insisting that the solution be web based. They have no interest in Citrix or Terminal Services for application delivery to the end user. I think when they say web based, they mean brower based more specifically. My thinking is that when they have large numbers of users doing "heads down" data entry, a Citrix or Terminal Service solution will be better for that cluster of users. There are a number of remoted contracted service providers (non-employees) that need to input data and I can understand them thinking browser based via the internet would be a simpler solution with only a browser required for these remote users. What are your thoughts regarding this debate, and do you know any specific place I might rummage around out here to find more information?

by deadly ernest

the first thing that management has to do is decide which is more important

security and integrity of the data OR ease of access to it OR cost of maintenance of the system.

The biggest problem with web based or browser based systems is the fact it is SO EASY to access over the Internet, and most of them work by you subscribing to the supplier's arrangements - and that usually puts the data on servers outside of your control. Many big dangers involved there.

I don't know of any specific resources that have addressed this issue on a comparison basis, but a Google on thin client services and web based services will give you enough information to sink a major cruise liner.

If you have a lot of remote users, then a browser based system would be easier for their access. The down side being you'll have to incorporate a lot of very strong security measures to ensure data safety - access via vpn and https etc with lots of checking system. One I've heard of is a special ID cookie that's installed on each remote machine and works only on that machine, once the vpn is up, this is used with the user ID and password to verify identity is an approved person coming from an approved system.

Thin client means it's a great deal more difficult to access the system from outside. It's possible to set up thin client for remote access, and that is harder to do than set up a browser access system.

The key points are to retain control and security of what ever system you use. This will mean, for a browser access system, you have to BUY the whole shebang from the supplier, all the software needed to set up complete servers within your server room. Many of the web based solutions are not available for setting up on your own servers, they're only available for leasing access on their systems at their site.

------------

I suggest you ask IT to demonstrate that they can purchase all the software to set it up at headquarters (citing security of data and accessibility to the majority during communications down times as your reasons), and that they can set up high security remote access. Then cost out the full cost of doing both that and Citrix etc - make sure to do the costings over several years and including maintenance costs.

I think you'll find the IT people have been looking only at what's easiest for them to set up, and have been looking at externally supplied and managed services, not internally managed. Once they're forced to accept that whatever system is used, they have to set it up at HQ and look after it, they may view things differently.

This discussion is closed to new replies.