Discussion Locked

What are your thoughts on this password issue?

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm taking an online class where we have an open forum going on the following:

You have been sent to a local sales office for your company. You discover that all users have the same username and password. The justification for this is that "it is easier to remember."

What arguments would you give to convince the office that this is not a good practice?

My initial opinion was as follows:

The first argument I would give is that this is a good set-up for a social engineering attack. This non-technical approach can be as simple as someone calling the office and asking for the password. I'm sure that in this kind of environment with such a lack of a security policy in place that the users are very complacent and would easily give out the information without a second thought. Also, it only takes one disgruntled employee to get fired and get back at the company by making that info public knowledge. Another point to consider is that any employee with highly sensitive information in this office has opened themselves up to leaking this info.

One of my classmates replied with:

This company and its members are considered loyal and upstanding. The office staff here at the local sales office have been working together to make the success of the company a priority. Having the same username and password allows the team to confide in each other and share the network and information openly. This ideology works for us as it allows for all to collaborate in a much more fluid manner without need for restrictions. The point of view of the sales office staff is that we should consider each other as trustworthy and by beginning to doubt each other by justifying set restrictions only creates an uncomfortable setting where paranoia breeds conflicts of interests.

I couldn't think of any rebuttal on this if everyone is so trustworty of one another. Does anyone here have any additional insight they'd like to add? Thanks!

4 replies

by charliespencer

'Trustworthy' embezzlers are convicted all the time. I believe a large French financial institution just got taken for several million Euros by a 'trustworthy' employee. Ask any former Enron employee about 'trust'. What about any new, unknown employees? Are they immediately 'trustworthy' by virtue of passing the interview?

None of your classmate's points would be disrupted by each individual having their own unique credentials.

"...it is easier to remember."

It's a single username and password. How is one set of credentials easier to remember than another? Each employee could as easily learn a unique set of creds as a common one.

"Having the same username and password allows the team to confide in each other and share the network and information openly. This ideology works for us as it allows for all to collaborate in a much more fluid manner without need for restrictions."

How would having individual credentials disrupt this? They'll all still be logging on to the same network, with access to the same files as before.

"we should consider each other as trustworthy and by beginning to doubt each other by justifying set restrictions only creates an uncomfortable setting where paranoia breeds conflicts of interests."

How does having individual accounts mark them as untrustworthy? Do they share ATM PINs? How about paystubs; do they swap those around for comparison? Does everybody have a key to each other's cars? "Sure, you can sleep with my spouse tonight; you're 'trustworthy'!"

How do they manage e-mail on a single account? Does everyone access the same account? How do you know if everyone that needs a message has read it? How do you know what to delete and what to keep, have a dept. e-mail meeting every day?

Is there a company policy on this?

by jamesrl

I worked in an environment where most of the employees had undergone gov't clearance to either Secret or Top Secret. Do you think we trusted each other - on a personal level perhaps, but never at a systems level.

Having unique passwords ensures not only security but privacy. I certainly do not want people to see my personnel reviews, or my budgets or salary planning sheets. I do not want anyone, my boss included to see them before I have finished work on them. And I want the confidence to know that no one is going to go in and edit them without my knowledge. If we all share passwords, thats not possible.

Also consider troubleshooting. If I am trying to track down an issue, I need to know who did what, and sharing IDs just makes that so much harder.

I hope your classmate is playing devils advocate, cause that kind of thinking is terribly naive.

James

by jdclyde

their mentality makes it worse than if they didn't even have a password, because they have some assumed security, even if it is shared with their group.

Has no one ever been fired?

Has there never been a disgruntled employee?

Has there never been a NEED to determine WHO did something?

If you have a unique ID and password, then someone else can not doing something wrong with your account, and you get the blame for it. It protects the user.

ANY accounting firm will scream at you over this. There are standard procedures that are required to protect the business. For the same reason the people that enter checks are not the ones that PRINT the checks, and are usually in a different department. A check and balance to avoid fraud.

What you are dealing with are lazy people, not trustworthy people. The problem is, you will never get a stupid lazy person to do what you want if you let them know you realize they are stupid and lazy. You have to find what is in it for THEM, or they don't care.

It protects THEM, the individual user.

by .martin.

When it comes to security it can be a problem, as other people have said, if they fire people and want to keep their 'false' sense of security, and depending on the size of the business it can be troublesome if nobody at the business knows how, it can be annoying for the business, and the tech support, to simply change a password, the circulate it to everyone.

Also with privacy, you don't want everyone to be able to trample around seeing everything, some people wouldn't be happy finding a document named 'who is about to get fired (because they don't know how to do their job (and i don't know how they got it))' and to find their name on it, which would lead to a disgruntled employee...

People also don't need to have complete administration rights. It is a bit like what Microsoft did with Windows 95 (and Apple did with their iPhone and iPod touch?), that is, every program ran(runs) with complete administrative privileges, why give something more privileges than it requires??? it can lead to major problems...
What if you got a new staff member and as they were trying to learn a special sales program, they accidentally ran the procedures to shut the program up for the night??? if that was done at 11:00am and can not be turned on until 9:00am, what do you do???

As for trustworthy, ha! who can ever really be trustworthy??? how do you know that somebody you work with actually works for a crime mob, and is spying on you company with a finally goal to assassinate you??? (I know it probably won't happen, but you never really know...)

This discussion is closed to new replies.