A well-rounded education from a reputable institution will take you far, no matter what your discipline, and it doesn't necessarily have to be IT-related.
Yes you might get a good job with those certifications, but that should only be a short-term goal. As the years go by, you will find that it's your peers who do have degrees which are the ones being selected for management positions or given increased responsibility for the overall IT architecture. That's why people who have bachelor's and master's/MBAs are generally considered by employers to have better critical thinking skills, and more able to take a larger perspective in making strategic and tactical decisions.
Bottom line is that it's much easier and quicker to train someone in a specific technical skill that is needed, than it is to give them a well-rounded education. An employer wants reliable, smart, trustworthy employees that they can grow over time to lead their company. If they want specific IT skills, chances are they will use contractors.
Hope this helps!