There are a lot of answers to your question depending on what you ultimately want to do as an IT professional. My suggestion would be to attend some IT professional events. In my area there is one a month in Princeton NJ that is free and you can meet and talk to IT people in different areas of IT. You can also go to a lot of the professional websites to see what they think is important for their members to have.
Another point is to look at the job boards to see what are on the "Required Skills" for IT positions advertised. Now becareful with this, you don't want consulting and placement firms. You want to find the real companies as well. Another thing is you can do informational interviews with businesses to find out what they look for in their IT people, i.e. business to technology knowledge ratio, specific skills, certs, degress, etc. You can find out why they look at such items, etc.
Personally, I think you need to participate as an IT person even if it is volunteer work and also take some courses till you know what you want to be doing. I have spent 20 years in IT and I never stop taking classes, training seminars, birds of a feather seminars, professional meetings, etc. Just to keep up at the very bare minimum.
Read, read, read, and practice what you read.