Discussion Locked

What does white paper mean to you?

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

So I'm pretty sure when I signed up I did not check the checkbox saying to send me white papers. But maybe I had a brain fart, and I just don't remember that.

Anyway, this morning I get an email touting the following:

TechRepublic White Papers
Read About the ROI of Wide-Area Data Services

We know how it is: The heat you're under to improve systems and application performance is rising while your IT budget shrinks, so you have to make do with the infrastructure you already have to meet the escalating demands.

Wide-area data services (WDS) can help. WDS improves WAN performance while reducing your server and bandwidth needs. Other benefits include fewer replicated databases, less storage and less power consumption. To read more about the positive ROI of WDS, check out today's featured offering from the TechRepublic White Papers Library.

---
Now, I don't know about you, but I read that to be "this is a TechRepublic white paper". I mean, wouldn't that be what you would get from the TechRepublic White Papers Library?

I don't mind advertisements that are clearly advertisements. I'd read a Riverbed white paper, but this said it was a TechRepublic white paper. I really wanted to read that.

I do mind statements that lie. And this email did precisely that.

So I went to figure out how to send my thoughts on this to the management. Well, good luck with that.

11 replies

by charliespencer

You can control the messages you receive by clicking on 'My Newsletters' in the upper right. Check or uncheck what you want to receive. The important part is to go to the bottom and click the 'Update my account' button. That's the part many people miss when they try to alter their subscriptions.

by techrepublic

I know how to unsubscribe.

I'm talking about the disingenuous language in the promotional email. It purports to offer a TechRepublic white paper. Nothing about the URL suggests otherwise. But click on it and it leads directly to a vendor's white paper.

It's dishonest.

Like I said, I'd still have clicked if it was clearly marked as the vendor's material. It's the being lied to that I object to.

by charliespencer

but I'm guessing all of them from TR are described as a 'TechRepublic white paper', regardless of the source vendor.

by Tammy.Cavadias

that it is sponsored by: Riverbed

For the HTML version this is stated in the right hand column. For the text version it states: Extreme Savings: Cutting Costs with Wide-Area Data Services
(Sponsored by Riverbed)

We often sponsor White Papers within our library from Vendors along with our own White Papers.

This particular offering was from "News and Special Offerings" - not a White Paper only newsletter. This particular newsletter offers a variety of items - whitepapers, products, webcasts, etc... This particular newsletter send was labeled as TechRepublic Whitepaper - as that is what it was - a whitepaper that is available in the TechRepublic Library. Had it been a featured Webcast - it would had been labeled TechRepublic Webcasts.

I don't believe this to be misleading in any form, no more than we offer software downloads from other companies outside of those created by CNet. As this allows us to offer extensive content that covers a wide variety of items of interest than we may have available.

I do apologize if you have found this to be confusing and misleading but we do try to always convey upfront when we feature a Vendors Whitepaper, Webcast, or other content.

-Tammy

by techrepublic

for example, on the web site you see "Sponsored" or "Sponsored links" everywhere there's vendor-sponsored material.

In the email, that applied to the links *after* the supposed TechRepublic white paper.

Had it noted that the link was sponsored, no big deal. But some person chose to flog advertising as technical matter. That's deceptive, and a very poor business practice.

Another poor business practice is providing no direct method to contact the publisher or ombudsperson.

by seanferd

As they are meant to outline a problem and a solution.

Since commercial entities have adopted the white paper as a marketing method, it is misleading, because it is actually marketing, even if the vendor does in fact, offer a solution.

Be that as it may, nearly all tech industry white papers are marketing, so what TR offers is not misleading.

Just check the landing page, wide right column:

Most Whitepapers in Enterprise Apps

Microsoft   * 1469
Oracle   * 1245
IBM   * 759
SAP   * 709

TechRepublic features a vast library of resources from the world's leading technology companies.

This discussion is closed to new replies.