Question Locked

What more can Windows 7 homegroups do?

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In response to the discussion post https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=319284&messageID=3183851 I think it is more appropriate to continue from here.

I am not too sure what the homegroups can do while the usual workgroups can''t. In this case the computers on the network had already been communicating part-way copying files from XPs to Windows 7. All of a sudden messages came up and said to the effect that the Windows 7 had run of storage space while it still had plenty. It didn't actually say network was lost only when I tried to access from the XP sides I realized that the Windows 7 was not accessible. I don't remember I had such problem before since I always had mixed operating systems on the network. However I always waited until service pack started to come in before I had the new operating system installed. Perahps this is just a teething problem.

I do have 1 W7, 1 XP Home and 1 XP Pro on the network exactly like yours. I was copying files 13.5 gigs from the XP Home wirelessly and 13.5 gigs from the XP Pro wiredly to the W7 simultaneously. About 20 to 30 minutes down the track, messages came up on both XP systems. It was not they didn't work at all, just it didn't keep up a sustained effort.

18 replies

by older mycroft

And that only the XP Home installation is wireless.

Now, if as you say, you were copying 2 x 13.5GB files SIMULTANEOUSLY (one wired one wireless), then the wireless router would have had its work cut out, and your mapping into the Windows 7 PC might also have had a bit of a struggle. Your wireless file transaction would've HAD to be running at around a quarter of the speed of the wired connection.

Were you copying the same amount of data for some basis of comparison? How many hard drives are fitted into the W7 machine? Were both 13.5GB amounts being copied to the same HDD?

I'd have transferred that amount of data one lot at a time.

by healer

I did realize there was a lot of data transfer at one time. I was trying to have both processes started and then walk away to do something else, in other words I left them unattended. I was expecting it would take very long time to finish. I didn't expect I would have such error. I believe it could be technically done though it might not be that efficient. There was only one hard drive on the Windows 7. Both copy processes transferred files from two different computers to one computer but two separate partitions. Anyway, I got it done eventually successfully after I initiated the two processes on the Windows 7 computer simultaneously. I thought I would have distributed the workload if I started the processes on separate computers. The processes were not for any test or comparision. It was just a coincident. One was for images files and the other was data files etc.

How would the router cause the problem? Please take note no problem happened when I copied at the Windows 7. What mapping of Windows 7 PC are you referring to?

by older mycroft

[i]"I thought I would have distributed the workload if I started the processes on separate computers."[/i]

Not if the entire copy process from both PCs terminated in two different partitions on a single HDD that's only got ONE write head. You were asking the one single write head to copy equally large amounts of data to two different places while one data stream arrived at a quarter the speed of the other.

That's why I inquired how many hard drives you had - if there were two HDDs, each HDD would've had its own WRITE HEAD and wouldn't have been unduly influenced by the speed of the other data stream.

Similarly, the ROUTER was having to cope with two data streams going to the same place at the same time, but at grossly differing transmission speeds. One stream of which also had packet loss due to being wireless, thereby requiring re-sending of dropped packets which would interrupt the flow even more.

Just my opinion mind you. ;)

by older mycroft

As I originally posted over on the Discussions thread - Homegroup will only run within a Windows 7 ONLY network.

Whatever your present file transfer problems are, it [u]DOES NOT[/u] involve Homegroup. ;)

Edit for typo

by healer

what you are getting at. What do you mean by using homegroup? Having read some technical notes I understand homegroups technically consist of only Windows 7 computers. I have not been up to speed with the implication of homegroup. What are the advantages and disadvantages, pros and cons of having homegroup? Like previous versions of Windows systems I always felt computer systems using the same operating systems would work more seamllessly together. It did not matter whether they have an unique name for the group or not.

Incidentally, I did put the Windows 7 system in a homegoup during the process of setting up the computer. It was by itself. At this stage there was no other Windows 7 on the network though I was planning to add one or two more after getting more rams. Neverthless I still expected the Windows 7 would still operate as usual with other computers in the same workgroup regardless unless you tell me otherwise. I have not read anything to the contrary.

by older mycroft

Until I've got the full-blown RTM installed on my systems, I'm p|$$ing into the wind.

Tomorrow is 22nd Oct 2009 - I'll see how confident I am to comment after that date.

by healer

With proper handshaking as long as it didn't panic and took one step at a time I still believed the systems should be able to handle it though it might be slow. I thank you for your opinion. I still learn something though.

by healer

for your recommendation, but the blog dosn't tell me anything about Windows 7 homegroup.

by healer

Please find out what a so-called homegroup can do that a usual workgroup can't.

by rob miners

HomeGroup takes the headache out of sharing files and printers on a home network. Connect two or more PCs running Windows 7, and HomeGroup makes it easy to automatically start sharing your music, picture, video, and document libraries with other people in your home.

Concerned about privacy? So are we. That?s why HomeGroup is password-protected and puts you in total control. You decide what gets shared?and what stays private. You can also make your files "read only," so other people can look at?but not touch?your stuff.

You can join a homegroup in any edition of Windows 7, but you can only create one in Home Premium, Professional, Ultimate, or Enterprise.

http://windows.microsoft.com/en-AU/windows7/products/features/homegroup

by older mycroft

Didn't expect it to arrive [b]ON[/b] the 22nd October but it did.

According to the courier sticker on the package, it was despatched on the 19th October, so it was clearly intended to be delivered on the day of release to market.

I'll be installing the 64-bit later today.

By buying it Pre-Order back in early August I saved 126GBP on the current pricing for the full Windows 7 Professional pack, so I 'invested' in 8GB of Crucial matched RAM with cash still to spare.

[i][b]Just waiting for the lightning strike now coz it's all going too smoothly for my liking![/i][/b] :^0

by rob miners

your luck changed. But you shouldn't even mention lightning.

If you are using a drive that has been previously used, Nuke it first. Don't activate Windows 7 until you are really sure that it is running OK. You will then have a chance to sort out the problems, if any. Good Luck with the install and let us know how you get on.

by healer

You have a 64bit computer. I understand not many third party softwares support 64-bit yet. I am looking forward to your joing the rank and hearing from you interesting stories about Windows 7.

As to me I have not installed any extra stuff but the barebone Windows 7 Ultimate which I downloaded from Microsoft. I am waiting for next month I suppose for more bandwidth available.

by healer

I wiped the whole hard disk but I forgot your advice. I was too excited to see the features and couldn't wait. I hope I wouldn't have copped any residual problems left behind.

By the way you have told me this before but I can't find the info now. Is there any other way by software to hide all other partitions or even any other hard disks in the same computer so that Windows installations can't see it and unhide the only one I need later on. I have supposed diskpart will do it but it doesn't seem to be that way.

by rob miners

but it should work in W7.

Follow these steps:

Start, Run and type in Regedt32 and press Enter.
Navigate to HKEY_CURRENT_USER\Software\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Policies\Explorer.
Right click on Explorer, and select New, DWORD value.
Name the value NoDrives.
Right click and select modify to the Edit DWORD Value.
Using the list below, type a number that corresponds to the drive you want to hide in the Value Data text box, and click OK.

Example:
A: = 1
B: = 2
C: = 4
D: = 8
E: = 16
F: = 32

Close the Registry Editor.

You must restart the PC or log out of Windows XP for the changes to register.

You can hide other drive letters that by doubling the number for each successive drive. For example, drive G: would have a value of 64.

To hide consecutive or multiple drives add the values of the drives together. To hide drives D: and E: Add their value which equals 24 as the DWORD Value.

Backup your Registry before making any changes.

Log on with an Admin account make the necessary changes to the Registry until you get to the Right click on Explorer, and select New, DWORD value.
Name the value NoDrives.

Right click on Explorer and select Export. Save the file to your Desktop as opendrv.reg

Right click and select modify to the Edit DWORD Value.
Using the list below, type a number that corresponds to the drive you want to hide in the Value Data text box, and click OK.

When you have selected the Drives that you want to hide add it to the DWORD value.

Right click on Explorer and select Export. Save the file to your Desktop as closedrv.reg

You must restart the PC or log out of Windows XP for the changes to register.

From now on when you logon to your PC if you want to access the Drives double click on opendrv.reg and merge it with the Registry. The same applys when you want to hide the Drive.

You must restart the PC or log out of Windows XP for the changes to register.

by healer

Thanks for your kindness and patience. If one hides the drive on XP, it is most likely the effect only applies when XP is run. The reason I want to hide the drive because I want to install next Windows system without seeing the currently installed operating system so that all all the system files and boot files will be in the same drive. In other words, I would need to be able to unhide the drive that I want after installation. Is it possible? AT present when I install more than one system on the same drive but different partition the boot files will go to the first partition instead of the partition where the system files are and multi-boot will be automatically created. I want the files stay together because as you say it would be easier for me to delete any individual system which is on one partition only.

This discussion is closed to new replies.