Discussion Locked

What project management tool is best?

0 helpful
20 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm interested learning more about the project management tools that consultants use.

While Microsoft Project continues to lead in marketshare, there are many other products out there.

What project management tools do you use, and why?

I'llgive the TechPoints to the person with the best answer, and we'll publish the best answers in a future article.

Bob Artner
VP for Content
TechRepublic

20 replies

by mom2michael

I agree that there are many project tools out there; however, it has been my experience that MS Project is the best at covering a project overall from start to finish. Very few other tools will actually let you customize your own project. With MS Project, you can format the way your project appears, make it HTML, even break down the cost of your resources to the penny per hour. I have found it to be a very powerful tool in all aspects of running and managing projects regardless of how big orhow small.

by mom2michael

I agree that there are many project tools out there; however, it has been my experience that MS Project is the best at covering a project overall from start to finish. Very few other tools will actually let you customize your own project. With MS Project, you can format the way your project appears, make it HTML, even break down the cost of your resources to the penny per hour. I have found it to be a very powerful tool in all aspects of running and managing projects regardless of how big orhow small.

by ejtucker

Bob,

The best tool for project management is the brain.

Sounds like a trite answer, however, too many people attempt to manage a project using tool X rather than understanding how to manage a project first and then apply a tool to help with the heavy lifting.

MS Project is certainly my favourite PM tool (especially in ms-centric organizations so that it can tie into office, exchange server, etc). But I have in the past really botched projects I didn't know the theory that the tool wasbased on in the first place.

Elton Tucker
elton.tucker@writeproject.com
www.writeproject.com

by tgross

It depends:
* Get a estimating tool if estimates are important. MS project doesn't help too much with making good estimates.

* Do you have remote projects that need teamware? Virtual team members require virtual team management.

* What does the client need or feel comfortable with? There are a number of tools in the marketplace because of client preferences.

* What about a Project Management tool that integrates with other project tool, like: schedulers, config management, testing, etc.
My favorite is RUP from Rationale.

by bobelino

MS Project is really the only way to go. While I'm not a MS-phile, Project is solidly integrated with Microsoft Office. It is quick and easy to use on small projects, even when all you need are charts to show the client. It really shines on largeproject when you use Team Manager and Outlook. Correctly implemented (and enforced), the project manager can assign tasks to team leaders who break them down and assign them to team members. These tasks appear in Outlook and team members can log time against the task and register completion status. All of this detail information will roll up to the project plan automatically! It is a gargantuan savings in time and effort AND keeps the project status current. Absolutely indispensable on medium to large projects. But beware, enforcement can be difficult.

by plantogo2000

This is not an answer of what software is best. It is what process is best. Visibility is the most effective technique.
The two best rules are to define the program in terms of program deliverables (Master Plan) as defined in the contract and enable the people that are doing the work to do the planning related to program deliverables.
To micro manage the project is an effort in futility. At the most define the master plan deliverables in terms of intermediate schedules for the major functional heads of the business (approved by the program manager) and concentrate on developing a status reporting system that deals with solving problems and saving money.
Status at an individual contributor level is worthless as s/he already has a manager whose milestones you should be on top of. You must help and eliminate roadblocks and concentrate on the important few. While everyone is dong a forward pass you should be doing a backward pass. Before you know it people will be asking you for help.

by ravine12

I have used the product "TimeLines" by Symantics. I think it is a more Intuitive, and is easier to learn. I tought myself how to use it one Saturday in about 10 hours, you can't do that with MS Project. At least I couldn't.

Good luck in finding a product that works best for you!

by realgem

I'm not a consultant, but I'm a project manager. I see a lot of consultants using MSP because of the market share thing. If most potential clients are using MSP, this makes it easier to work with your client.

This is a good reason to use MSP, and my company may switch over soon, but we're currently using ABT's Project Workbench v 4. It's a more powerful tool that MSP98, but it lacks the "pretty" stuff that MSP offers. This is why I also make extensive use of Word and Excel.

We chose PMW because it is a good planning tool. In my opinion, it falls down as a project tracking tool, but that was a second criteria when the evaluation was done.

by lauthier

Project Monitor is a french tool for project management that I know well. The software is published by the company Virage Group. English is supported by this software very well. More information on http://www.viragegroup.com.
This is a complete solution to manage projects by milestone, workpackages, tasks, budgets allowed, ressource activities, from reporting to consolidated information of sets of projects

This discussion is closed to new replies.