Discussion Locked

What really makes IT people tick? What is your motivation?

0 helpful
53 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Somtimes I wish I could take all of the insightful and interesting comments from these threads and show them to upper management and corporate america! (if they would even care to listen)

Why? Because I think it would teach them a thing or two about how to truly motivate people and how to find out what people really care about. It is usually not the money, as I have found in reading everyone's comments. Most people look even deeper than money to be truly satisfied with their job.

I for one, like this little thing called appreciation and not being told how indispensable I am. (no matter how true that might be)

How about you? What really makes IT people tick? What are your motivations? Does your employer make you feel dispensable? What do we really want from our employers???

Just curious......

53 replies

by m_a_r_k

Why do so many people here at TR think that IT is any different than any other white collar job? Motivations, job satisfaction, career advancement, etc are all things that every white collar worker deals with. Take a survey of 100 white collar job types and you'll probably find at least five things in every one's list of top 10 job concerns.

by fshelpdesk

I think IT is different, it is treated differently by most companies, we are considered a necessary evil, does anybody think customer service reps or accounting or HR is a necessary evil? Nobody gets the bad rap that we do.

But I do agree that all careers have the same motivations, I guess I wasn't trying to limit it to just IT.

by m_a_r_k

Yeah, you're right. All career fields do have some things specific to them. I typed my first response before I thought it out. I don't know that IT gets worse rap than some other disciplines. I suppose it depends on the company's line of business and on how well both IT is managed and how well the overall company is manged. People have a natural tendency to think that they are personally getting screwed over. Go ask anyone in accounting or customer service or production about the hassles and headaches of their jobs. They'll probably have a lot of gripes and will think they're getting sh|t on as well.

by wayne m.

I have also noticed how everyone is on pins and needles waiting for the latest sexual harassment briefing or proper interview technique seminar from HR. While getting coffee this morning, I overheard another conversation about how useful it is to fill out a timecard with multiple charge codes each day as required by Accounting. I almost forgot about the joy in people's eyes when I ask them to fill our a purchase requisition for Purchasing.

Why, oh why can't people treat IT with the respect they give to financial auditors?

by jdmercha

Money motivates me to find another job, or maybe to stay put. It does not motivate me to do a better job.

What motivates me to do a better job is respect. Respect the fact that you hired me to do a job, and let me do it. Trust me to do what needs to be done. Listen to me when I identify a problem that needs attention from above. Don't give me the typical runaround. Keep me informed of how the business runs and how my efforts contribute.

by tink!

Respect definitely gives the motivation to continue to do well and strive to do better. When you know you are appreciated for what you do and for what you can do, you're more willing to do it...because then it's enjoyable.
Tink

by jkameleon

You are expected to do a predictable, repeateble job. That's the trend, ever since the 80s.

New ideas, productivity, innovation, quality, you say? Take a tip from me, sugar: if you can't sell it, sit on it.

by wayne m.

My approach has always to assume that people can, will, and should bring their own motivation to their jobs. It is my responsiblity to make sure I do not destroy that motivation.

Money is nice, but the truth is that I always try to do my best. Additional money will not make me perform better, though insufficient money will cause me to leave.

Pats on the back are nice, but nothing is as troubling as feeling that no one cares about what you do or, worse, feels you are not able to do it. The truth is, in IT (and many other fields as well) it is almost impossible to do a superior job. In most cases, one can only do an adequate job and hope not to screw up. In fact, if someone came in saying "Thank goodness the server is up right now", I would be fearing for the worst.

Probably the best way to avoid burn out is not to look for appreciation, but rather to give it out. Don't wait for someone else to come give you an "atta-boy," you have no control over that. Instead go out and tell someone else that he is doing a good job. Don't set you standards for "good job" too high and base it on the experience of the person. If someone struggles though a task for the first time, tell him how you appreciate the effort and he did a good job (however, do not sabotage the effort by giving any recommendations on improvement).

If you take the time to give just one person one word of appreciation each day, then you will find you will not have time to dwell on your own worries.

by fshelpdesk

I think that is good advice....especially the part about not sabotaging the good advice with the bad.....

by tony hopkinson

Any sort of global strive harder campaign from management usually ends up making everybody feeling they've failed. There's nothing more soul destroying than working your ass off and achieving something worth while and then being told you need to do better. Especially when it comes from some HR prick who doesn't understand what you did in the first place.

by w2ktechman

Thank You, that was well stated. I feel very much the same way. But unfortunately my current position may be being faded out due to IT cost cutting, and software/hardware, no matter how bad its needed, isnt coming in. (Its great whil trying to setup new hires and not having a system for them for 3 weeks).
In my current situation, I feel mostly useless because of this, and the waiting to hear if I indeed will have a job in 6 months is the worst.

by ivy clark

yea, definitely agree on the showing appreciation bit... we might get some in return.

I'm based in Singapore... and to be honest, i thought this problem was isolated to where I am... until I came across this thread.

I also think that most of us IT folks don't market ourselves well enough. E.g. when a big project launches... we don't make a big deal. As compared to when profits are made, you see the sales and accounting people yelling about it.

The biggest problem is not only the payoff (in monetary terms) but also the lack of respect, and appreciation shown to people in IT. We have a lot of respect for ourselves and our peers, cuz we know what it's like to support our users 24x7, to work countless days of overtime, to tuck ourselves in bed with our latest techbooks and magazines, only to have to wake up in a few hours later to get back into the office. We pat our own backs and say to each other... well done! Wow... you got that certification? Cool!... and then what's next?

We need to make the world realise that IT is not a necessary evil, but its the skeleton on which the successes their businesses will depend on. I'm tired of that "IT department is a cost centre" attitude. How are we a cost centre when it is our applications, systems and infrastructures that are making the money? Without us, there won't be any internet banking, online payment systems, shopping carts, online fund management systems, b2b systems, the list goes on! Tell me none of these systems make money for the companies that own them? Perhaps they do know we're not a cost centre, but are choosing to ignore it, in the hope that we'll carry on slogging in our little corners, and not ask for more?

The fact that we're not allowed to go away on department retreats during the work week is proof that we are crucial to the company. All i can say now is I'm going to carry on shouting about my department's achievements, to the rest of the company, until they stop labelling us as a cost centre. We are their revenue engine. I believe we'll get our payoff, respect and recognition eventually.

by fshelpdesk

I think you are right, we are all getting screwed in some way or another. There is no perfect job out there and no perfect circumstances. It just seems that the IT world is suffering so much, and from everyone's comments in the threads I have been reading over the last year, everyone is suffering from burnout, or low pay or problems with finding a job due to age.....
In the end though, I love IT and technology, I don't know what else I would do for work.

by beads

Here is the ultimate list of things that motivate people. Don't bother everyone has tried to make a fifth or so column... and failed.

Power: Money, position, fast cars, etc.

Respect: Self-respect, job well done, peers, etc.

Recognition: Awards, pats on the back

Aproval: What your Mommy says when you bring her flowers.

Yep! Anything you can list really does fall into one of those catagories. Learn to recognize these four traits and half your management job is complete.

- beads

by jdh9

I should be a animal doctor, but love them too much, hate their owners.
I fell for electronix as a brain extension. Found true Love in Angie my soulmade, misstress, friend, wife, motivating me every day not to divorce the "old Lady Electronix" beating, rewarding, beating me again with happy 80% and 20% disgruntelled clients since 1970

Just keep in mind:
High school never ends. 60% do not know who they are, what they do, just Dilberts beloved managers. 20% are the Ratberts trying to keep the Dilberts under rap not to wittness what they are up to using the other 60%.

So the other motivation for real crazy people in Geekland is to live all the colors of the life rainbow, we make little kids contact, are Dr.
Doolittles never growing up propeller heads!!!

This is the fith column, the oldest one, from the first wheel turned, sling shot to the latest cyberyarn we spin.
The Heckymeister

by jmgarvin

The new tech toys...you can't beat those.

Education...Man, in any way shape or form I love to learn.

R-E-S-P-E-C-T...Find out what it means to me. If you show me respect, you'll see that not only am I more motivated, but I'll be more loyal too.

The other nice thing is that, where there is some, durning down time we can get in a game or two of Counter Strike or play a little WoW.

I think management is typically learning more about IT, but still don't quite understand it.

by charliespencer

I earn a living doing something I would be doing on my own time anyway. Every couple of years (at the most!) some new piece of technology comes, whether it's hardware, software, etc, and I don't have to pay for it out of my pocket. I still get a kick out of firing up some new toy and seeing what it will do. What could be better?

What do I want from my employer? Acknowledgement that I'm a specialist in a technical field that changes every 3.24 minutes, and that I can probably do a better job of keeping up with those changes than the kid at Best Buy.

by too old for it

Just pay me what you used to pay the spikey-hair hot shot back in the dot-com days. And the sign on bonus. Oh yeah, gimme his keys to the company Porsche too.

See, this isn't hard.

by jardinier

between other white collar jobs and IT.

I have worked in two white collar areas -- journalism and public service (clerical).

I cannot speak for IT management because I have had no contact with it (I have worked only for myself). Quite possibly top management in IT is as brain-dead and unimaginative as top management in the media and public service.

The really BIG difference is that in IT there is always something new to learn. All a journalist can do is improve his/her interviewing and writing skills. All a public servant can do is patiently wait for the next step up the ladder.

The only thing that has changed in these two professions in the past 40 years is that typewriters have been replaced by computers. The work is still the same. In the case of journalism the work is quite interesting because one is dealing with new people and situations each day, but there is no change in the basic skills required.

Incidentally in journalism (or call that the media if you wish, although I have only had experience in the print media) the primary way of gaining a salary increase it to move to a different publication.

IT is VERY DIFFERENT because the technology is always changing and there are always new things to learn.

I would say that I have been drawn to computers because of the ever-present challenge of learning new things.

Incidentally my IT mentor, Patrick Li, who has owned a small computer business in my suburb for 12 years, is DEFINITELY in the game for the challenge. When I was learning about computers, I had an innate ability to create problems that he had never previously encountered. He would start to suffer withdrawals if I did not come up with a new problem at once a fortnight.

Further proof that it is the challenge that appeals to him is that he rarely builds new computers for sale, and his business now is predominantly repairs and upgrades.

by tony hopkinson

I need me to do a better job. I've even been known to work on producing an even shinier turd. Even when constraints force me not to do something as well as it could be, I still put effort in to approach closer to the ideal. I can't see any point at all in spending 30% of my entire life span treading water. If others would be more comfortable with me doing that, that says more about them than it does me.

by choppit

What really motivates me is to look back at the past few years, realising exactly how much I've learnt and then looking forward to everything I'll be looking back on in a few years time.

by jdgretz

That's what I enjoy - probably one of the reasons my company targets the SMB sector. When I was with the Fortune 100 crowd I could go weeks and not know if what I was doing made any difference in the grand scheme of things. Now, when I walk out of a client's office after having gotten them back in operation, put in their first network so they can better share information in their company which will allow them to grow their business, or improved something that helps stabilize their network, I have the satisfaction of knowing I have made a positive difference in their life.

I get genuine thank-yous, and many of my clients are now good friends as well.

by dave.claridge

I was fortunate enough to have the challenge of managing a reasonable size service delivery team a number of years ago and I learnt what works and what doesnt. In essence.

Always look to recognise good and unacceptable performance and deal with them equally. For good performance say "really well done thank you" and not by email face to face. For unacceptable performance speak to the individual face to face without delay and explain why this is unacceptable and help the person to improve on this.

2. Make sure everyone knows what you expect from them and that there is no doubt. Sit down with each of your staff and map out some personalised key objectives that mean something to the individual in terms of how this will help
the business.

3. Always look for opportunities to recognise good perfomance in the eyes of the business by making them aware of special efforts being made and the business benefit.

4. Reward exceptional performance e.g someone working all weekend to fix and IT problem by thanking them and saying "take the wife/partner to dinner and send in the expenses" I had this tool at my disposal and used well its effective

5. Above all else be seen around taking an interest in what the tech staff are doing, speak to them informally.

by bob gately

The book "First, Break All the Rules, what the world's greatest managers do differently", by Marcus Buckingham and Curt Coffman of the Gallup Organization, does an excellent job of explaining why talent is necessary. We call it job matching while Jim Collins in "Good to Great" calls it "getting the right people on the bus." The secret for job success, other than competence, is to have a talent for the job.

The authors' recommendations are based on Gallup's interviews of over 80,000 managers in over 400 companies across numerous industries. The authors' definition of "a talent", see page 71, is "... a recurring pattern of thought, feeling, or behavior that can be productively applied ... The emphasis here is on the word 'recurring.' Great managers say 'Your talents are the behaviors you find yourself doing often.'"

If our talents match the demands of our job, we are much more likely to find job satisfaction because we'll be successful and we'll enjoy it.

by jdmercha

1. Very few managers can recognize talent.
2. Those with more talent than the job requires will never be satisfied.

by bob gately

Hello JD:

>1. Very few managers can recognize talent.<

That is very true. Most managesr think talent is the same as skills and abilities. In other words, The stronger the resume the more talent the person has.

>2. Those with more talent than the job requires will never be satisfied.<

It appears that we are not using the same definition of talent since it is impossible to have more talent than the job requires. We can have different talents but we cannot have more talent than the job requires.

by jardinier

There is a well known maxim which I can't quote precisely but it goes something like this:

A person is promoted in their job/profession, level by level, until they reach a level at which they are not fully competent, and that is where they will stay.

Perhaps someone can come up with the precise wording of the maxim.

by ralphy123

Money
Ideology
Conscience
Ego

95-99% will follow this and fall into @ least one of the categories. Consider the 2 outside (Money & Ego) as the dark side of motivation. For most in our office, we fall into the I-C categories. We're given a task and we try to do the best we can.

by jdmercha

We may be hung up of definitions but it seems to me that a manager that is managing one person, yet has the tlaent to manage 100 people has more talent than the job requires.

by bob gately

>a manager that is managing one person, yet has the talent to manage 100 people has more talent than the job requires.<

We use a percentage scale when measuring talent so an employee cannot have more talent than a job requires. Of course, an employee can be well-suited to manage 1 person or 100 or both. The secret is to know which employees are best suited to manage 1 or 100 and make job assignments accordingly.

by wayne m.

I don't want this to turn into a TR language quibble, but I usually define Management as what I do for the people above me and Leadership as what I do for the people below me.

Management is about bring a task to a successful conclusion. The "talent" to do this has multiple measurement critera, including the size of the project, the riskiness of the project, the short-term benefit from the project, and the long-term benefit of the project. A small project for a new customer may require more talent than a large inhouse project (say a corporate e-mail upgrade).

Likewise, Leadership needs vary. Leadership "talent" required is usually dependent upon the familiarity with the task. For run of the mill tasks, little leadership is often required. For a new task, or with people who are new to the task, more leadership is required to let them succeed.

There are no simple measures here, and certainly number of bodies is rarely a good identification of management or leadership talent.

by jdmercha

If you can't have more talent than the job requires, then you either have talent or you do not. You can't use a percentage scale to measure it. It's either 0% or 100%.

by bob gately

The quote you are looking for comes from the book "The Peter Principle: why things always go wrong" by Dr. Laurence J. Peter and Raymond Hull
William Morrow & Company, Inc. New York
1969, 179 pages in paperback.

"The Peter Principle: In a hierarchy every employee tends to rise to his level of incompetence"

The author provides an insightful analysis of why so many positions in so many organizations seem to be populated by employees who exhibit signs of incompetence which is a most disturbing since we all tend to all rise to our own level of incompetence. This concept is likely to be ignored by most senior managers and consultants since to admit it is to admit that we may also be at our own level incompetence. Ignorance is bliss?

by bob gately

Managers are seldom equipped psychologically to talk to their people on a personal level. One reason is that many people are managers because of their technical ability not because of their managerial or people skills. We should reward technical experts with higher salaries but not with promotions to management. We would be far better off if we promoted to management the people who have good managerial and people skills and poor technical skills -- which will solve two problems:

1 - Improve overall technical competence
2 - Improve managerial effectiveness

As long as executives do not know how to identify future effective managers, management will be stuck with The Peter Principle:

"In a hierarchy, every employee tends to
rise to his level of incompetence."

When managers are asked to list the Top Ten Motivators for their employees the list looks like:

1 - Salary
2 - Bonuses
3 - Vacation
4 - Retirement
5 - Other Benefits & Perks
----- the money line -----
6 - Interesting work
7 - Involved in decisions
8 - Feedback
9 - Training
10 - Respect

Note:

Managers rank money items as their employees' Top Five Motivators. When employees are asked to rank their own Top Ten Motivators the list looks like:

1 - Interesting work
2 - Involved in decisions
3 - Feedback
4 - Training
5 - Respect
----- the money line -----
6 - Salary
7 - Bonuses
8 - Vacation
9 - Retirement
10 - Other Benefits & Perks

Employees rank items that are equivalent to money as their bottom five motivators.

The managers' top five motivators are the employees' bottom five motivators. The managers' top five motivators are more related to the need of the managers to avoid personal contact with employees than the desires or motivational needs of their employees.

Managers pick the top five motivators because these are the things that managers can "give" their employees without ever having to ask what the employees want or need, i.e., no involvement on a personal level is needed and all decisions can be made behind closed doors--all the while avoiding personal contact even to the detriment of the organization.

Note:

Managers give the same sequence as employees when asked to rank their own motivators which is very interesting and revealing.

by wayne m.

It is quite easy to demotivate. It actually takes effort to not demotivate.

It is quite easy to get caught up in being a "Manager" generating an endless stream of important reports and be flippant when responding to your staff. It takes effort to stop writing up that end of month report that was due yesterday and listen to a convoluted explanation from someone who works for you. You will never see a report on the "motivational value" of listening to someone's recent cub scout camp-out or family problem. Do not, however, underestimate the amount of demotivation that would occur if you cut this person off mid-sentence.

As a project manager, I usually do not have control over doing a lot of major things to reward employees. In fact, I probably have more ability to provide recognition to people on other projects, working in different departments, or even other companies. What I can do is listen to what is important to my staff members, cheer the positive, and commiserate on the low points.

by bob gately

Hello Tony:

>Motivation is free... far from sure about that.<

That is ok since nothing that is said about people applies to all of them unless we are talking about death.

>Does de-motivationn cost nothjing as well then?<

De-motivationn is free and given how many employers de-motivate their employees you would think there is no cost associated with de-motivated employees.

by wayne m.

Does anyone just want to do work that he is fully competent to do?

The flaw in the Peter Principle is that it does not recognize that promotion requires two actions. One must give work that someone is not competent to do, and one must also provide support so that the assignee can succeed.

It is a boss's responsibility to help subordinates advance and succeed. Look for reasons to give someone work that they are not competent for, and then make them competent to complete the work.

by bob gately

Hello Wayne:

>Does anyone just want to do work that he is fully competent to do?<

There are more than you think, perhaps.

>One must give work that someone is not competent to do, and one must also provide support so that the assignee can succeed.<

I wanted to be an engineer but I wasn't hired to do engineering until after I received my degree in engineering. Employers want to hire people who are already competent yet they are too willing to make people managers who are not competent in management. It is wiser to make sure an employee is competent before they are promotod-which should help avoid the peter principle.

>Its a boss's responsibility to help subordinates advance and succeed.<

That is so true.

>Look for reasons to give someone work that they are not competent for, and then make them competent to complete the work.<

Does the boss help them to become competent before or after they do the work?

by wayne m.

Bob Gately asked "Does the boss help them to become competent before or after they do the work?"

I find the most pragmatic answer is to help while the work is being done. I don't have the budget nor the foresight to train someone for future tasks that may or may not materialize. I don't believe in make-work, however, so I also cannot let someone fail as a "learning experience." It is difficult to find the right balance between helping and letting someone do the task himself, and the balance changes from person to person. One also has to learn to accept "good enough." Don't accept less than adequate work, but when someone completes a new task adequately, tell him he did a good job, then focus on the next task. There are some cases where you misjudge the situation and you may need to reassign the task. Do it as quickly and quietly as possible, but do it.

I prefer a roller coaster to a ferris wheel. I want to keep my staff on the edge of their seats, with hills to climb, and plunges into the unknown with control there but hidden.

by helloparminder

yes the last 2 words on ur blog...
"Just curious...... "

dats in my case . me jus curious to apply my lil bit of IT expertise in my domain (m not a IT worker), but make sure dat it qualifies on my quality assurance wrk. motivation is to stay updated on technology. & its not what I want 4m my employers but what I'd want 4m myself. my need to satiate my IT hunger ;)

by absolutely

"Go ask anyone in accounting or customer service or production about the hassles and headaches of their jobs. They'll probably have a lot of gripes and will think they're getting sh|t on as well."

But in those departments, the bicth session will be answered by total anonymity. There is no M_a_r_k in those departments (usually), nobody making ANY effort to be objective, just myopic bicthing.

by bob gately

Hello JD:

Qualified to be hired job applicants who have less than a 70% job suitability don't become successful emnployees. Qualified to be hired job applicants who have 85% or higher job suitability become successful emnployees. The secret is to hire as many as you can above 85% and none lower than 70% and be very careful between 85% and 70%.

by tony hopkinson

worry about spending extra money to avoid de-motivating their people. So worried in fact they chose doing so instead of spending a little cash. Must have been a sensible business decision that a propeller head like me can't understand, otherwise I'd have to think they had a collective IQ in the low twenties.

by bob gately

Hello Tony:

Managers de-motivate employees by their words and actions which may or may not include spending money.

by tony hopkinson

Some one decided to save money by not reviewing a mailing list. So they sent **** off if you want to letters to every employee in the business. Most of the ones who stayed they could have done without, a lot of the ones they could least afford to lose were insulted and bogged off.
So they annoyed their best employees to save a ?500, sound business thinking.

by lando56

My original educational background was engineering, so I do have a little variety, amongst a few others, and call me 'restless', but IT is a challenge. How many other careers are there that literally change on a daily basis?
Basically I'm talking about my area of interest (security) where there is a new threat
everyday ... a chance to match your wits with others. Also, in regards to, say Disaster Recovery,(e.g.) you are at least minimally involved with every department in the company. You have to be if you are the lead in DR and BCP.

Engineering bored me to tears! I find this direction at least interesting and know can be a critical part of an organization. Maybe 5 years down the road I'll get tired of IT :) but for now, it's 'good stuff Maynard!' ( Tagline of an old TV commercial.)
Lando

This discussion is closed to new replies.