Discussion Locked

What router to use for Internet connecti

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We currently have about 40 users and a Lynux machine acting as a Gateway/NAT/Firewall server to the internet. Our Internet connection to the internet is an always on ASDSL connection to the internet. We have an ISP hosting our Internet Site and Email accounts.
What we plan:
We plan on setting up an Internet server and Email server on site. Since our web site is going to offer legal documents for review by our clients (they will logon with a name and password to the restricted (documents) areaon the web site) Which means that I'll have to open up ports on the firewall for internet users to be able to connect to the webserver.
I dont know how to use a Lynux mahcine the guy who set it up has left me with this machine and I dont know how to use it. However, I can learn how to use it.
One more thing, the one who set up the internet connection thru the Lynux machine has left the company but he might be intrested in getting into our computer system (he is angry with us).
Here is my question:
Should I learn how to use Lynux so I can configure it myself and make sure that I do what I can to block unwanted people?
Or:
Should I rather purchace a Cisco router that has Firewall software with it?
Which one is easier to teach myself Cisco or Lynux?
Which one is more secure? Cisco or Lynux?
Please give answers with experience and/or a resource I can look up.
If the answers will good I will make the point values higher.

7 replies

by garetjax

Newyorker211,

As your question reads like you already have an ADSL router (or bridge), why not purchase a dedicated firewall appliance to replace your Linux box. Sonicwall and Watchguard both make robust (and easily managable) firewalls with embedded OSes (not moving parts). They support ADSL (including PPPoE) and offer NAT for IP address "sharing". Depending on the number of internal hosts, you are looking at an investment of $400-$4000.

Your Cisco suggestion will work but why not letyour router route instead of acting like a firewall.

Hope this helps...

by shmaltz

I never asked about other options, I just wanted to konw if Lynux is better than a Router firewall. By the way Lynux can also act as a router.

by mckaytech

Generally, the security of a firewall is directly dependent on the skill of the people managing it. I current support a number of systems that use various forms of firewalling (Cisco PIX, Linux, firewall appliances)and it is not my opinion that oneis necessarily more secure than another.

On the one hand, I like the wide range of options I have with the Linux box. But keeping on top of the security advisories, patches, limitations, etc. can be challenging when security is not your full-time job. The Linux community is hugely helpful but when it comes to crunch time, you're more or less on your own and you'll be hard-pressed to shift responsibility for any breaches to someone else.

On the other, just mentioning Cisco's PIX unit gains instant credibility, particularly among users with limited knowledge, and you have a single vendor to monitor for updates and patches. For better or worse, people are less likely to singe your feathers if a breach occurs through a recognized commercial product.

As much as I like Linux, and as much as I like to maintain my own firewalls, if I have a site that is particularly sensitive because of legal or financial information, I will tend to use a well-known commercial product and will usually also use an outside consultant to audit the security after I get it set up.

That way, at the very least, I can demonstrate that a subsequent breach wasn't because of arrogance or ignorance on my part.

paul

by wlbowers

We currently have a Cisco Pix 520 im place. The capabilities of the pix for configuration is amazing. The only thing is that they are not cheap. The routers with a firewall are a consideration to. By working with tac in programing you are actually getting training on the device. Their routers and the pix have help files on board.

You can contact cisco direct, describe your system and what you want to do and they will recommend a configuration of equipment and software.

Linux is a good os, but from my experience it defaults to some not so good settings, and if you don't know to change them you leave your self open.

With a firewall router you have a separate device that is dedicated to two things. getting you there. And letting only who you tell it can go, go.

Chek out cisco.com for device and tech specs.

If you go cisco get the service contract. Then TAC will work directly with you on configuration once the product is in place for free. You also will have immediate overnite replacement of defective equipment.

Good Luck Lee

This discussion is closed to new replies.