a Dilbert Full Year Calendar which was in color. Even though it's 3 years old, I just print out blank calendar sheets from outlook and replace the existing 2003 monthly calendars in it (paperclip over top of the pages, don't want to ruin it).
Dilbert is hilarious and every month a different dilbert toon just seems to hit so close to home you think Scott Adams worked at my office or something.
I haven't received anything for system admins before or after that but I was remembered one year and it was unexpected which was pretty nice. I think that's why I still hold on to the calendar, it helps me remember some of the good times in my life.
My office/whse network users are regularly appreciative of me: they're all a great bunch of people and I appreciate working with them - I guess that's my reward. Things could be worse and people should be thankful for what they have: I'm thankful (although I may not always say it) that I have a job, I have a beautiful wife and 2 beautiful trouble making kids, I have my health, good friends & family in my life.
When I win the lottery I'll be thankful for the millions of dollars in my bank account, I just have to start buying those lottery tickets now....
If I had to ask for something, a free lunch on that day would be nice, nothing extravagant: mcd's is around the corner so a dbl qtr pounder w/cheese, fries and large diet coke would be nice - just in case one of you yahoo's is listening, your smart a$$ "IT Guy" (lovely title, get's used alot around my work) gets hungry at lunch!