Discussion Locked

What's more important for you in a laptop: Power or mobility?

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

A new TechRepublic poll asks members what they prefer in a laptop:

- Highly powerful desktop replacement
- Powerful but mobile
- Highly mobile and as small as possible

What do you prefer and why?

18 replies

by stargazerr

I really prefer desktops because I can play around with the hardware and upgrade easily...

But lets not beat around the bush....I prefer a Highly powerful desktop replacement.

by jamesrl

I do travel, but I rarely work on airplanes or sitting in a starbucks. More often I work in hotel rooms or at a visitor's cubicle at some foreign office. So I want power.

James

by jdmercha

I don't use a laptop. I encourage my users to use a desktop unless they absolutely need a laptop. For those who need a laptop I encourage them to buy the most powerful ones. Many still opt for lighter weight less powerful units. I get many more complaints from the users with the smaller laptops that their copmuters are too slow and they can't get their work done.

People seem to be happy with ultra-portables for about one year, portables for about two years, powerful laptops for about three years and desktops for about 4 years.

by nigelfarman9

If you don't have mobility and long battery life, there's no point buying a laptop. Then you should go for a desktop. I have an IBM X40 and am very happy that I can use it all day at university without having to plug in. If I want to ply games I use my desktop.

by jdmercha

But different people have a different definition of mobility. Large laptops are too large for some people. So they sacrifice performance for light-weight.

by nigelfarman9

for word and internet 1.2 GHz is enough. Of course if you want to play games, a desktop is always better

by jdmercha

My users want to manipulate research data with statistical software packages. The large data sets they work with are very processor and RAM intensive.

by rickydoo

I use mine mostly to configure point-to-multipoint radios for the wireless ISP in town, so the performance need is minimal: telnet and a web browser.
But if I'm doing site surveys all day I don't want to drag a heavy laptop and an extension cord up a customer's roof. finding the right spot and direction can be tricky and time-consuming at some of these farmhouses.

by mr. tinker

I need Power, Mobility, AND Battery!
I use my laptop in a multitude of situations.
It has doubled as: a SQL server, a web server, a firewall, a mobile programming/programmer's tool, a network sniffer, and just about everything else in-between, and at times doubling for a DNS/SQL/WEB-PAGE server. Until I could effect repairs and reboot the "real" server. (Usage a stand-in machine.) I doubt that many "real" techs would conceive of such a premise, but I have,... have used, and will continue to utilize any and all of my laptops as a stand-ins when duty calls for it. Think of it as a stand-in with it's own battery backup built in!
The "REAL PROBLEM?"...
It just would be nice if the battery had a usable shelf-life beyond 3 years, or the laptop makers all agree on a design that could allow anyone's battery to operate in anyone's laptop. It would drive current battery costs down, and allow for stores to carry replacements. (universal battery replacement.)Hey, at least get closer to that goal ok guys? You'll sell more laptops because of it.

by maelorin

i suspect there are plenty of 'real' techs who have grabbed a laptop and plugged them in as a short-term fix.

in fact, i can think of a few places where laptops have become *permanent* solutions. on ehas lierally been screwed to a wall in a machine room. it monitors several industrial lathes, and has done so from more than a year.

they're about to replace it because a forklift driver has broken the screen adn they can't get a replacement. but it will be replaced with another laptop.

a vendor suggested a flatscreen + micro case, but there's nowhere sensible to put the box.

by northseeker

I would want both, of course, IF I still had my private professional practice. But for that I would want the smallest footprint possible with exceptional battery life. But now I work with a government agency where the majority of computers are portables, tied into an in-house mainframe network. Powerful large portables are in demand here and battery life is less an issue since most of these portables have access to electricity when used away from our headquarters. But the budget reality of having and replacing such high-end portables dictates the use of many mid-range computers, not the device for using demanding applications such as GIS software. We should really be using more desktop computers, which are, of course, more powerful for the buck. My son-in-law has also used his large, powerful Dell as a SQL-server at times, but his job demands that. Until they can create large powerful portables with very long battery life at the same price as desktops, this question will never be answered. For my current situation, I'd prefer a more powerful desktop computer AND a smaller medium range portable for occassional use. See, there is no real solution!

by maelorin

the answer, my friend, is in the purpose of the device.

the need should shape the product.

like any other part of ict. you establish the requirements, then find the best fit.

by sanrojea

the need should shape the product!! how true.

case in point: we purchased a top of the range ASUS. cost $4000. the thing does everything but whistle dixie. TV tuner and all, and all it gets used for is email traffic, some games and my grandsons internet ramblings. The idea behind the purchase was, when we are travelling, to use in the various accomodation vacilities for DVD, TV viewing but everywhere we go nowadays these facilities exist. (we are retired and travel a bit) So therin is the story. My wife gets a lot of oohs and ars about HER notebook , like -- isnt it absolutely gorgeous!! which it is, BUT
$4000?? Don't get me wrong, it is a magic machine, but did we need it. I think not. Delightful it is and I must admit I get a bit of pride from it as well so, what the hell, we can afford it. 2.2gb, 1gb ram, 80mb hdd, 17" wide screen, beautiful graphics, beautiful case, you name it. But as maelorin said 'The need should shape the product'.

by daniel.muzrall

It depends upon what the intended application of the laptop is for. If you've got your "typical" user (web, productivity suite apps, e-mail, etc.), then I'd tend to lean more towards portability. If I have a power user (processor/memory intensive apps like GIS, graphics, etc.) then I'd definitely go with power.

In my situation (supporting approximately 25 users), the predominant need is for portability since most are field personnel; however, with the anticipated 3-4 year life cycle we're anticipating, power is also a major consideration. I'll find the best combination of power and portability for them...most likely with a slight edge to power. If I'm getting a laptop for myself, it's POWER, POWER, POWER.

I'd also like to echo the need for superior battery capacities and life...the usefulness of a laptop is limited by its battery life in the field.

by ushetgeri

Lets not forget mobility begets its own set of problems..
Risk that the staff may may want to work remotely.. from home, which brings own set of problems
- security of the data on the laptop
- circumventing company policies wrt downloading of unauthorized software that may create ways for virus to getinto the company networks.

There are solutions for each of these but that adds to the TCO.

by jeff.allen

I have both. Work desktop, my own laptop. I use both for work, the desktop has all the official work-related apps I need at work, and when the workload spills over, I take some home and do it on the laptop.
WRT the standard battery suggestion: Manufacturers: Make a standard laptop power supply while you are at it.

by liquidxit2

Alright I, like everyone else, would like both. But Im going to have to side with mobility. Lets face it laptops are meant for mobility not power. Thats why my I have my "rig" at home built for. I use my laptop on the go and even with a 1.3 celeron m (I know) with 512b of ram I can do basic multitaskin i.e vpn to work and run several remote connections.

ALthough Id love to have a 3.2ht chip in my 14in notebook, my current setup will do.

by jdclyde

Because the others are buying this laptop as a status symbol rather than as the tool it is meant to be.

Determine what job you need it to perform.
Get a system that will do that job.
If your NOT mobile, it is better to have two desktops than one laptop, one of work and one for home.

The thing that is disapointing about laptops for techs, is that most don't come with a COM port anymore. So you have to go out and BUY separtately a USB to 232 addapter so you can still work on your many devices in the field.

This discussion is closed to new replies.