Discussion Locked

What's my first step in expansion?

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I started working for a small (35 node) company a year ago. We are an NT network running DHCP, Exchange, Proxy (serving our own website). We are moving from a DSL line to a segmented T1.

We have just won the bid on a LARGE project. This requires the company to open a second site about 20 miles away with approximately 20 nodes. Cost is a factor.

I need to figure the most cost effective way to connect these 2 sites. I believe that a dedicated line is too costly. But, I am not sure of anything at this point. I have been given this project and have no idea where to start. If someone could give me a hand or point me in the direction of a good text that can help.

PS - The cost of a consultant makes this service out of the question.

10 replies

by trip

You could consider a frame relay connection. Or business DSL and run VPN/encryption on your routers to provide security. Various vendors, i.e., ilec or clec's would be happy to quote you a cost.

by tjrocco

Sounds to me like you might consider more DSL service for your new office. Use that to connect to a VPN to your main office. This site has some good intoductory articles on the topic. Check out: https://www.techrepublic.com/briefingcenter.jhtml?id=b983. If you are looking for a book that has more details on the topic, take a look at, "WAN Survival Guide, Strategies for VPNs and Multiservice Networks" by Berkowitz.

by stillatit

The system we use for branch offices is to put a server at each office with RRAS and Proxy, with a DSL line for access. We set up a VPN (PPTP out of RRAS) and routes, so that any time someone at the remote site wants to access the central site, RRAS"dials" a VPN connection if it is not already up, and routes the data. If you use a static IP at the remote end you can mirror the connection so that the central site can also establish the connection. We have exchange servers only at central sites.

Go to www.microsoft.com/technet and search for "PPTP" for many articles on VPN technology, deployment, benefits, etc.

The DSL cost is typically about $300 per month for a 384K DSL from a large provider. As a side benefit, the remote sites alsoget internet access. You are going to pay for Proxy on a second server, but you were probably going to buy that anyway.

Note that you can find DSL cheaper, BUT beware of failing vendors and flakey vendors. You can read ratings on www.dslreports.com and www.2wire.com. Many vendors have gone Chapter 11 in the past 90 days.

Good luck.

by Former member

Good answers but I see that no one raised the question of the amount of traffic you'll be expecting between the sites. I mean, if you have an important project, where the remote users will be HEAVILY accessing the home office, you may want to tell your employer that a T1 or better IS cost effective and that your WAN is directly related to productivity!

by mckaytech

With a distance of only 20 miles, the best option will usually be frame-relay. Since you're already going with a fractional T1 at the main office, it would seem most appropriate to go with fractional T1 at the new site. That way, if traffic studies show you need additional bandwidth, it can just be dialed up without investing in new equipment.

You could also do VPN over DSL but at such a short distance, the economy might not offset the annoyance of having bandwidth limitations that are outof your control as the packets traverse the Internet. At 2000 miles, the economic advantages of VPN/DSL over frame-relay are huge because rates for f-r circuits have a distance component.

Q's point is also well taken, depending on how the network is used. If huge files are routinely transferred, a slow connection is penny-wise, pound-foolish. But for routine business purposes, a fractional T1 will easily support 20 users.

paul

This discussion is closed to new replies.