Some very good ideas, and choices, imvho.
Important to recognize what 'makes' for a good (and, also important, profitable) film, just as what makes for an effective SF franchise. I'm surprised no one's commented on WHY Hellburner, rather than something like, say, Downbelow Station, or Rimrunners, or Heavy Time, was the choice for Cherryh.
I would sweat a great deal, and probably never stop sweating, at what might happen to Honor in the hands of filmmakers (no pun intended...) -- even though if you want a long-term, progressive SF franchise with a strong and complex female lead, that would be on the short list. Not least because being 'attractive' is a point Weber himself is at some pains to deprecate... ;-}
But much of the choosing leads into another point, which I think is critical to the success or failure of many of these projects: length and market.
deepsand noted (with respect to Foundation, I believe):
> How to end it? Where to end it?
> If you are faithful to the books, you'll >get a long, bloated pic with an ending that >offers neither resolution nor even a clear >choice of such.
Assuming you tried to make a typical feature movie out of the whole 'extended trilogy', which imho is what doomed DeLaurentiis' version of Dune before it started. By the time you establish the rules of engagement for verisimilitude in future history, how many minutes have gone down the pipe? And doing it right clearly requires more than a few mattes and a pretentious voiceover
Seems to me we have at least four basic formats, and at least two 'extended models', for 'video' SF formats:
1) Feature film: 140min. practical length, can be extended to about 240min for VERY profitable niches...
2) Feature film with sequels/prequels a la Star Wars... but remember the harsh lesson of Bakshi's Lord of the Rings, and that the 'typical' ways that sequels can suck will have to be carefully, carefully avoided (I am NOT intending something like "Hard Landings Will Not Hereafter Be Permitted" here, either...
3) Miniseries (usually up to three nights, somewhere in 2-hr running time with or without inline commercials depending on media, but can be a BIT longer). Point is that it's a longer format BUT fixed duration;
4) Full series - probably 1hr for adaptations, although I have done extensive treatments for half-hour short-story adaptations (Galouye and Niven being sample authors, and the pieces chosen so that the film can carefully reflect the authors' points and intent, which I think is important). You have a choice between making the episodes separate (a la Outer Limits), separate with a general common theme (Twilight Zone or, a bit stronger, something like the Friday the 13th Series, which had about as much to do with Jason as Halloween III had to do with Michael), a common theme with different 'adventures' each week (Star Trek, of course, or with a different emphasis Time Tunnel/Quantum Leap), or in typical series form containing ongoing and evolving plots, themes, character development, etc. (the 'new' Battlestar Galactica, and Firefly, being two examples)
Note that there are internal timing and dynamics issues for film, particularly television film, that are more akin to Stratemeyer-Syndicate literature (and I'm NOT knockin' it!!!) than typical SF -- some of which, like the need to impress 'readers' when pitching a project, or enticing the audience across commercial or time breaks, can be easily gained from texts on film composition. More importantly, a 'good' film will appeal to multiple quadrants, while still satisfying enough 'core' to guarantee repeat attendance and establishment of the 'franchise'.
I mention this because it might enhance the discussion to have some explicit taxonomy of KINDS of SF adaptation, and the titles and authors best suited to each. To prime the pump, as it were:
Hellburner is an excellent candidate for a movie -- but with a full set of hooks and references to the extended and very rich future history that can be used for the 'franchise'... if made alone, especially by 'typical' Hollywood types out to play up the "military-industrial-conspiracy" aspects of the story, I worry that it might suffer the fate of the script that became "Spacehunter" (1983) -- if you know where to look in the movie you find some extremely good tech details, like the orbital-insertion graphics, or what Chalmers' first name is, but by and large, Who Cared...
MULTIPLE FILM or MINISERIES: The Mote in God's Eye, or any single part of the Ringworld (instructive why it, and not the Smoke Ring, is a better 'vehicle' for film...) You can't do justice to it in one sitting, BUT a book treatment would have a very fixed duration and a reasonably firm conclusion... the 'extension' of the story having all sorts of reasonable format possibilities, including not coincidentally King David's Spaceship...
Honor, I think, would be a movie AND a roughly concomitant follow-on series; you might do 'later' stories as miniseries (or as 'extended episodes') and use the extra time to explore the contrasting elements and contradictions in more depth or detail, but doing that for ESTABLISHMENT of the franchise would I think be too much like Russian roulette... ;-}