Discussion Locked

Whats the best Network Attached Storage?

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Basically, want to store roaming profiles and some file sharing for 10-30 people. Any good advice or have you seen any good, current reviews of products? I have heard good and bad on Quantum and Maxtor. I want cheap, but reliable(20+ gb). Thanks!

13 replies

by ann777

Western Digital or Maxtor. Within the last year I've purchased one of each, one was 60 GB the other 80. Both are working flawlessly.

by legj1

I think you are only talking about Hard drives? WD doesnt make a NAS or am I unaware of the product?

by timthetoolman

Hi,

Yep, I use Western Digital and they've been flawless for me too.

I would however consider using a raid 0 configuration for this. You can get IDE raid controllers cheaply now. Some roaming profiles can get quite large (they store the temporary internet files and these can be many MB!) and all the speed you can get to decrease boot time would be good.

Ideally, I'd suggest SCSI but that'll push the cost right out.

Also use a 100Mbit network if you're not already.

Roaming profiles are a good concept, but be careful with them!

Cheers,
Tim.

by legj1

I have researched and cannot find where Western Digital makes Network attached storage. Can you verify this? You may only be referring to HD's. However, I was hoping to find out about NAS..like Quantum SnapServer or Maxtor MaxAttach or DellPowervaults... Thanks though

by legj1

I think you read my question wrong. I am trying to find out about NAS...not HD's. I know seagate and WD are good. But thanks!

by legj1

I think some may have read the question wrong. NAS not HD's. Thanks though!

by timthetoolman

Hi

re: Us reading the question wrong... ...you're right. I guess we were assuming you were putting in place a file server.

As far a network storage goes here are a few links to look at - although I'm sure you've already hunted around...

http://www.networkstorageforum.com/

http://www.snapappliances.com/solutions/medium_large.asp

(remove spaces in the above URLs)

...but... You want to use a Network Attached Storage solution for 10-30 people?
And you're talking about 20+ Gb ?
My experience with fileservers (I've never used NAS) is that users will fill them to capacity very quickly! And if you're offering it as a filesharing solution, then <1Gb each doesn't go very far!

Looking at the snap server range (Quantum) frommy link above, the prices are very competative for the 40Gb range (at $500) and 80Gb (at $800) but start to rise at the 160Gb range and these lower capacities still dont offer any redundancy (like raid)

In fact its not until you get to the 240Gb range that redundancy starts being built in. And the price tag is around $3000.

(continued...)

by timthetoolman

For that amount of money, you could buy a server PC (no screen) with built in raid and tons of disk. Of course the cheapy raid solution for you would be raid 1 (mirrored) which is much slower than raid 3 or 5.

For that you need to move to a promise UltraTrak100 TX8 - which has a significant price tag attached at $1600 but includes the case and everything.

By the time you add the disks (and a PC to run it, it'll be more expensive that the $3000 for the NAS solution... but... you will get more Gb !

Do the sums on price/Gb to work out your best solution...

It really depends on how much emphasis you place on the "reliable" vs. "cheap"

Sorry, I dont have actual experience with these products, but Quantum (and WD for that matter) are well respected brands and I'm sure they would deliver close to what they claim.

One final word, though. Dont underestimate your user's use of the space for filesharing! They'll use heaps!

Hope this helped - a little at least,
Cheers,
Tim.

This discussion is closed to new replies.