Discussion Locked

Whats the best size for a monitor

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi Guys,
I am trying to figure out if a larger monitor size is better for work on spreadsheets. We currently use a 19" Dell Monitor and the company is trying to provide us with 17" Dell monitors as it is cost effective. Will there be a big difference..
Would appreciate you advice please..
Best regards,
Nigel.

11 replies

by thechas

If you are going from 19" CRT monitors to 17" LCD monitors you will see little if any reduction in workspace.

The "effective" area on a CRT monitor is always less than the actual glass size.

Next, you can simulate the smaller display to see and prove how much impact it will have.

Use your monitor control buttons to resize the screen to match the usable width and height of the new monitors.

Can you work with this size screen?

Does it increase eye-strain?

Does it lower your productivity?

If you can view all columns with the 19" monitor, but need to cursor over with the 17" display, it will definitely lower your productivity.

Chas

by opatzg9

Yes size mattersw even in monitors. The more programs help us do our work the more programs I want open at one time viewable, having gone from 9" to 14" to 15" to 17" to 19" CRT's I'm not about to go back now. It's amazing how easy things are to read on larger monitors with finer detail with multiple windows. I'ld love to try a wide screen lcd someday as the new graphics cards support some pretty neat options on for cross section pixel counts. But take a look at how programming has changed over the years. I used to use an editor for 80 columns with 25 lines of code. With Visual BASIC and it's tool bars and headers and other boxes the area of actual coding only displays 12-15 lines and only 40-50 characters across. Larger monoitors allowed us to go from 8 lines to 12, which is still half what we used to look at in DOS basic programming so larger still would be better.

by roger.radda

In today's fast paced environment - and with LCD monitor prices so low - I've found that a minimum of two, and three is better, LCD panels is what is needed. One for email, one for current work, and one for systems performance monitoring is a must for anyone in IT! It's not size, it's performance that counts!

by jdclyde

Some monitors have had a HUGE case around them but the screen isn't really that big.

It is much easier to go from a 17 to a 19 than the other way. Always hard when someone is taking away something you are used to. And if you are zooming in and out or having to scroll then your productivity will drop.

Do you work with big spreed sheets or drawings? If so you will not like this.

If you do word processing and e-mail then it won't matter at all.

by hal 9000

If you can currently fit the full width onto the screen without too much eye strain the new 17" monitors even a CRT one would quite likely do as good a job as they have a far better resolution than the older CRT monitors that we all used to use.

However if you have to rip up the resolution to get it to fit across the screen you will most likely start having eye strain problems but you'll have more room on the desk for your eye drops. If they are going to the LCD. Plasma monitors you'll most likely not notice any difference and you'll have heaps more room on your desks to pile more junk.

It really depends on what you are doing if it is just data entry it will probably be OK but if you are doing numerous other jobs and need several different windows opened at the same time you could start to see some problems. Without a bit more information this is a very hard question to answer and really boils down to the individual who is affected and how they perceive things. Personally I use two monitors and split the screens so I have my main work on one monitor and all the secondary work and normal Desktop on the other monitor which isn't quite as easy to look at because of the different angle but it is only there for a backup rather than the main viewing screen so it really is not that important.

Of course if you find that the 17" is to small you can always opt for the Dual Monitor approach and just spread your work out across both screens that would of course negate any financial benefits that where hoped for by going back to the 17" monitors but in all honesty I personally do not think that the little extra screen area is worth the cost of the 19" monitor.

Col ]:)

by dc_guy

I wear trifocals. I find large monitors annoying because I have to rock my head up and down to keep the appropriate portion of my lens on the portion of the screen I'm looking at. I also don't like the amount of space they take up on my desk. I much prefer my laptop at home to the behemoth in my office.

Most software in which resolution is an issue has a Zoom command anyway.

by angry_white_male

17" CRT or 17" LCD. Big difference. You'll get more bang for the buck and desk space with a 17" LCD - or a 17" LCD vs a 19" CRT. 17" LCD's are getting cheaper and cheaper. $150 USD if you shop around a bit.

I think a 19" LCD is a bit overkill, and exponentially more expensive than a 17" LCD. 19" CRT's are on the bulky/heavy side.

For the average user - a 17" monitor, CRT or LCD will suffice.

by faustus67

It really depends on the resolution. Most reasonably priced TFTs will only give you 1280x1025 resolution. If you are using that already, then a 17" LCD should be fine. If you are using a higher resolution than 1280x1024, then a TFT will not diosplay as much of your spreadsheet.
Personally, I love my 19" CRT running at 1600x1200!

Dave

by craig herberg

Assuming that you work on typical spreadsheets with multiple columns, the most cost effective solution is the largest monitor that will fit in your workspace, unless you work for free. Samsung makes a nice 21" TFT display for about $900. Its resolution is 1600 x 1200, which is quite good for spreadsheets.

On the other hand, if you work for free, the lost productivity caused by a monitor that doesn't fit your work will be more "cost effective."

Good luck.

Craig Herberg

by andros_nic

Actually the size of the spreadsheet is one of the most importnant things that count. Also, as mentioned, what kind of screens you purchase?Am guessing you are talking about TFT screens, the slim ones since cost is a major thing. Would you concider buying CRT since is half the price of the TFT ones? Check with space availability!!
Hope this helps

by gadget-girl

I have worked for some of the larger well known companies of my area (Polaroid, Wang, Getronics, BBN, & HP) and managed employee pc's and also held financial management positions.

You don't indicate whether you are dealing with LCD or CRT monitors and there is a world of difference to the 8 hour user who toils with spreadsheets. Give the users 19" LCD's. In the long run they are much easier to manage when moving people around, which companies seem to do endlessly. They are much easier on desktop realestate of which there is never enough.

It is political suicide to tell people they are going from a larger to a smaller monitor, you won't win any friends, support or good will from your employees. Trying to tell them the smaller units are better quality, etc. does not work.

In the computer pc market everyone always wants a larger monitor, more RAM, larger and faster hard drive and smaller cpu unit. Just look at the tv market..... what are the sellers: larger, flat, and smaller footprint for the processor. Pc's and tv's go the same way.

This discussion is closed to new replies.