I have worked for some of the larger well known companies of my area (Polaroid, Wang, Getronics, BBN, & HP) and managed employee pc's and also held financial management positions.
You don't indicate whether you are dealing with LCD or CRT monitors and there is a world of difference to the 8 hour user who toils with spreadsheets. Give the users 19" LCD's. In the long run they are much easier to manage when moving people around, which companies seem to do endlessly. They are much easier on desktop realestate of which there is never enough.
It is political suicide to tell people they are going from a larger to a smaller monitor, you won't win any friends, support or good will from your employees. Trying to tell them the smaller units are better quality, etc. does not work.
In the computer pc market everyone always wants a larger monitor, more RAM, larger and faster hard drive and smaller cpu unit. Just look at the tv market..... what are the sellers: larger, flat, and smaller footprint for the processor. Pc's and tv's go the same way.