Discussion Locked

Which Cable/DSL router is the best?

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I have a home network, a NetGear 10/100 Switch, 3COM Cable Modem. I have five IP addresses allocated to me through DHCP from my ISP. I host five domains with DNS, Web, FTP, Telnet services for them. I need a Cable/DSL router/firewall that will dosome sort of logging/reporting and also do NAT & PAT, DHCP client (to ISP) and server (for internal). I need it to be able to be multi-homed for the outside so I can use those five addresses and NAT/PAT them as needed (I think this is the real kicker here, I haven't seen one that can be multi-homed AND be a DHCP client) I've already looked at NetGear and SMC, but I'm not sure if their routers meet all the requirements. The reviews at CNET and ZDNET weren't that helpful either.

19 replies

by sixfourtykilo

SMC is great but the logging isn't very good - however, Asante is the OEM of that router. Netgear has a better NAT and logging capabilities. With a couple firmware upgrades, it is one of the better routers out, but very complicated. If you're looking to save money, stay in this area, however you may want to look into lines like Cisco as they will offer more functionality.

You may want to check out http://www.practicallynetworked.com/

Good Luck!
640k

by sixfourtykilo

I myself run the SMC Barricade 700br router. Its great for home use and is very easy to administrate - however I would not recommend it for a professional environment, etc. My personal fav about it is the print server that comes with it. I have it hooked up to a similar situation as yours, netgear 10/100 switch, 3com cable modem and I manage speeds in excess of 300k/sec.

by sixfourtykilo

kgosnell@aculink.net brings up a good point. If you REALLY want to go this route... your cable internet provider will generally supply you up to an additional 5 IP addresses at an extra cost. What you could do is, purchase those 5 IPs, uplink them to a switch and hook up 5 routers to the switch, each with its own IP. Then, daisy chain the routers to each other (cross-over cables) and then uplinked to another switch (seperate) and then POOF! It is rather redundant, but if you don't want to shell out the $$$ for a quality router, that seems to be your only option.

by sixfourtykilo

Quick observation: You may want to set each of the external IPs up as a virtual LAN. Any cable router will come equipped with DHCP and you can create each range in its own subnet. This should eliminate issues with internet and network traffic andcollisions.

by ann777

The very basic Cable/DSL routers will not work for you. SMC, NetGear, LinkSys and Dlink (there are probably others out there are well) all do NAT but only one-to-one. Which 5 ip addresses, you will need to look at a real router... Cisco 1700's series would probably be a better fit.

http://www.cisco.com/warp/public/44/jump/routers.shtml

(Please remove any embedded spaces from the above link)

by mckaytech

I don't think you're going to find an off-the-shelf DSL/Cable Modem router that will act as a DHCP client for five IP addresses.

I work alot with routers built using Linux Router Project software (leaf.sourceforge.net) and I think it is conceptually possible to do what you want to do but the configuration would be quite hairy. It would be easiest if you could use an individual NIC for each IP address but there are difficulties in getting five going in the same box because of IRQ limitations. However, if you could dig up a 486DX motherboard with six ISA slots and 20meg of RAM and populate it with six NE2000 clone NICs (or possibly some mix of ISA and PCI interface cards), I'll bet it could be done.

Alternately, you could try and bind multiple IP addresses to fewer NICs, but I have this sense that ARP problems would bite you.

But I'm also guessing that your proposed hosting arrangement will fall outside the Terms of Use for your ISP anyway so perhaps the most proactive approach would be to find an ISP that will supply five static IP addresses and specifically permit the kind of hosting that you would like to do. Otherwise you risk getting the plug pulled just about the time you get everything working right.

paul

by jetstream

just on my hand I think this can solve your question. Specifications are:
SMC Barricade 7004BR
- Internet Sharing Methods:
- Static IP,Dynamic Ip,PPPoE,PPTP, Dial up Networking
- Data Rate
- 10/100 Mbps switch (full duplex)
- Max Clients - 253 PC?s
- Network Interface
- LAN: 4 port 10/100 Mbps (RJ 45)
- WAN: 1 broardband uplink (RJ-45) for Cable/DSL
1 RS 232 port for dial-up and ISDN
- Features
- DHCP Server, VPN, NAT Firewall Protection
- Print Server
- Supports Win 95/98/NT/2000/UNIX LPR
- Standards
- IEEE 802.3
IEEE 802.3u

That?s it, hope it helps

by ebob

Yes: Cisco.

It sounds like you're trying toi support some REAL environments, so it's time to put away the other gear and get a REAL router.

(I myself use an Asante for my home network and love it. But it's NOT for a commercial environment.)

by kgosnell

You are looking in all the wrong places, contact your ISP and simply ask which are supported best. The Local ISP's are not all created equal, and are a homogenous mix of what has worked for their setup over a period of time. Likely they will have several types , and simply choose which best serves your needs , now , and the near future, that will dictate the price. The field is composed of those types that best meet your needs, price ,budget and future plans. Don't fall into the trap of not allowing for future needs, as the next low cost budget device combined with the one you are thinking on, will surpass a quality type which can give smooth service throughout the transition period, also there is down time, and service instalation to consider, as you have better things to do with your time, don't you think?
Have a great day, and as they say in Star Trek, "PROSPER"
Kyle Gosnell
Steps Tech

This discussion is closed to new replies.