Discussion Locked

Who made the mistake, Microsoft or Acer?

0 helpful
95 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

My neighbor asked me to look at her laptop because it was running VERY slow.

I look at the system, and it is an Acer Aspire 3680, with a Celeron M 1.6GHz, [b]512MB RAM[/b], running Vista home basic.

http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/acer-aspire-3680-2633/4505-3121_7-32481478.html

Microsoft requirements:
http://www.microsoft.com/windows/windows-vista/get/system-requirements.aspx

Lets get real here, 512 MB Ram is entry level for XP to have a functional system that runs more than one application at a time, expesially when you consider third party software such as AV/malware scanners also running. I personally would never send a Vista system out with less than 2 gigs, which is what I will upgrade this to, for $36 thanks to Kingston.

I admit I don't run a lot of Vista systems, but for a working XP system that runs several tasks 1 gig is my starting point. Is there anyone out there that uses or deploys Vista with 512 MB ram?

95 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

It's fairly common knowledge that MS minimum system requirements are so minimal as to leave users with nearly non-functional systems.

by jdclyde

On the MS site I linked to, it just says "Windows Vista recommended system requirements".

And I made sure to link directly to MS so someone that is a VistaZombie can't claim false numbers.

So, WTF is up with that?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

their latest boondoggle...

Still, common knowledge... I still say both their faults.

by michael jay

Microsoft should know with the low price of memory to up their minimum standard, yes Vista will run in 512, but not very well.

Acer for Selling a pc with 512, again as you pointed out the cost of memory is small and not to load up a laptop with at least 2 gig is just asking for an unsatisfied customer.

by jdclyde

this system will only support up to 2 gigs of RAM.

What level of incompetence is involved to limit ANY system to 2 gigs?

If this is an indicator, I don't see Acer ever getting on my list of recommended systems, for home OR work.

by michael jay

familiar with that model, perhaps it is older, celeron processor also a bad choice, guess they were looking at a price point and not a quality laptop.

by thechas

I would say that neither Microsoft or Acer is to blame.

Acer is trying to meet the demands of the market to have a system meet a specific price point.

Microsoft is under similar pressure to define bare minimum system requirements that allow system manufactures to build low end entry level systems. Microsoft also needs to maximize the number of existing systems that a new version of Windows will "run" on.

If you want to blame anyone, blame the purchaser for not being willing to spend what is needed for a decent computer and the required support.

If you want to see slow, you should see the laptop my brother in law had me take a look at. It has Windows XP on it and had an entire 128MB of shared memory. Even at the full 512MB that can be installed, it crawls. But, it is enough for the intended use.

We need to convince both consumers and managers that they will not get the productivity they desire from low end "price-point" systems. Only when people stop purchasing low end systems will the manufactures stop selling them.

Chas

by jdclyde

Joe consumer that knows nothing about computers, just wants to do email, chat, and view a little porn. They go to what they mistake for professionals (big box stores) or even go to the web sites of the vendor.

After all, they wouldn't sell it if it were crap, right? :0

Most people I help barely know how to turn the system on and off. I don't blame them for being sold lemons.

by michael jay

It is up to us to educate them, often times I am asked, Mike what should I buy? I say it is not what you buy but where, to stay away from the chain stores, go to the little shop on the corner where they will actually listen to you and educate you as to just what you are buying.

The small shops have the largest reason to satisfy the customer, the big guys just do not care.

by thechas

Yes, the consumer who buys a low end laptop is often not in the know of what they need or should buy. But, you can make that case about any number of purchasing decisions.

Acer built that laptop because either market research showed that they could:
1. sell "X" number of units at that price
2. bring customers in who would then be sold up to what they really needed.
3. HP, Compaq, Toshiba, Gateway or someone else had a model with the same specifications and Acer needed to compete.

Take a look at the Dell and HP web sites. If you start at the bottom end, you can build up a laptop that is nearly the same specification as this Acer.

I have not checked out the specifications, but it will be interesting to see what the Walmart $300 laptop brings to the rest of the market.

I would say brace yourself for another round of people buying under-powered systems. Likely followed by another wave at Christmas. If we have a $300 laptop for back to school, what will Black Friday bring?

As far as crap and lemons, time will tell as far as how well these price-point systems hold up over time. I would expect low run time batteries at a minimum.

Chas

by jdclyde

If that is all you know about computers, what else is there? They could read the stats, but they don't understand what they read.

The alleged professionals at the big box store told them it would work good.....

Guess we should add the big box stores into the list of villains.

by the scummy one

I thought it was common knowledge not to trust those incompetent salespeople that learned their tech training by installing programs on their parents system and being told they were a 'natural' :^0

by jdclyde

or the big box stores would have gotten out of the business of passing off crap computer systems a long time ago.

by nicknielsen

but not to most others.

They see it in the television ad, so it must be true. "After all, it's against the law to lie in a TV ad."

by jdclyde

The biggest problem, most real techs don't get asked until after the mistake has been made.

by the scummy one

for a recommended model system. However, I tell them that I do not recommend a specific model, there are too many to keep track of. Then I ask what the useage is for, and ask if 3D gaming is planned for use.
I will get some specs for them and than go over a few items online to find something in their price, that is do-able.

by jez47

It sounds good to ask what the customer wants but many of us wrinklies (over 60's) will visit the big box store for fear of being thought dumb. There is a growing market for older generation to buy and use computers for staying in touch with family by email or VOIP. All we want is non-tech jargon and a guarantee it will work with minimum knowledge.

by shellbot

Must have been painful for her to use the dang thing...

I've only got 2 gigs (intended to bump it up another 2..just never got around to it) and sometimes it even annoys me at the speed it is...

by jdclyde

mind you it does have a mild infection, but still.

Time to check on memory. I have been finding it cheap on my systems. Just bought two 2 gig chips for a system last week, for $36 out the door (combined).

by shellbot

Memory not so cheap for me..

I've got a Vaio.

No way I'm cracking this baby open..would have to send it to Sony..and at this stage..I'm loathe to do so..should have got it done at the time of purchase..

but we shall see..it suits my current needs..so what the heck

by the scummy one

What is worse is at the W-place. We have sooooo very many POS apps and checks that happen, on a good, fast, new system with 4GB RAM (after I upgrade it), it crawls along at 6-10 minute bootups.
I keep getting people telling me their systems are slow, so I stockpiled RAM, and went through it like crazy. Our original Vista systems only had 512 :0
all of the XP systems shipped with only 512 :o -- well until about a year ago. Now everything ships with 2GB, but even still, I swap a 1GB chip for a 2GB chip and then let people do their actual work (instead of staring at the computer saying "c'mon -- I know you can do something")

by the scummy one

if so, easy enough to add to -- just remove the keyboard.

I had a system recently that had the RAM partly under the keyboard and partly under the front bezel -- yeah, great friggin design!
especially since the rear bezel needed to be removed to unscrew (yes, unscrew) the friggin keyboard -- AND it only had 1 RAM slot with 512MB chip.
Had to take half the NB apart to replace a RAM chip -- some designers should just be shot dead for their stupidity (or the project manager assigned to it).

by shellbot

I haven't a clue.. ]:)

I'm a software/app techie..RAM is not my forte!

I suppose I could look it up..but can't be bothered at this point in the night.

by nicknielsen

Memory upgrades require only that you unscrew the memory expansion slot cover on the bottom of the laptop.

Edit: I may be wrong about Dells; I can only speak the more recent Latitude models...

by willcomp

Some have internal memory slots including some older Latitudes -- internal slot was a pain to access. Recent Inspiron 1525 notebooks have one on bottom of mobo and one on top (requires removing keyboard only.

by the scummy one

except often 1 slot is under the keyboard.
The ultraportables often have only 1 slot, and it can be in either place.
The one that I worked on was some home model with all of the brand markings with stickers over them -- no idea WTF it was. I just went by the chip itself as to what 'should' work.

by shellbot

I wanted a lightweight pretty laptop :)

I saw her sitting in the shop, a Vaio SZ5..as a demo model..they weren't being released for another week here...and I fell in love with her..had to have her..even though I knew that Sony are proprietary and a pain to do anything with if needs be...
I overlooked her upgrade imperfections :)

I know i should have gotten an extra 2 gig before I brought it home..but I couldn't wait!

by shellbot

(feels so wrong to say that word on a saturday)

My machine is so-so at work..it better than most of the staff have..however, as someone who needs a lot of apps open sometimes..its not the best.. By the time I have outlook, 2 remote desktop sessions, a couple word docs, visual studio and 2 web sessions (website * intranet) I'm pretty mcuh crawling.

by jdclyde

for a production system.

Most crashes are from running out of system resources, so if putting $30 into a machine will stop it from crashing 3 times a week.....

Vista, 2 gig is my starting point.

For the most part, I am hoping to have Vista be as big a part of my life as ME was. Minimal.

by the scummy one

minimal Vista -- but at my W-place -- we are MS bitches.
Even now people are begging for Win 7 :o
XP is phased out on new systems already, and Win 7 is in testing.

by jdclyde

hope to bypass vista and jump right to w7.

I admit to not even looking at w7 yet, so don't know if they got their act together yet or if it is just a repackaged Vista.

by oh smeg

2 GIG for XP and 4 for Vista to make the systems sort of half way decent.

I ran across a Acer a couple of months ago with Vista Business on it with 1 GIG of RAM installed as 1 X 1 Gig Module.

The owner was convinced that i would want to install XP on it and when I asked if he was happy with the system he did have some sarcastic comment about XP but I just suggested adding 4 GIG of RAM to the system. After all it only took 25 Minutes to reboot so it was a real flier [i]I think not![/i]

But anyway when he got it back he was insisting that it was a different computer Luckily I had taken a note of it's Serial Number in front of him and when he checked this against his copy of the Work Sheet he had to agree that it was the same system but I'm not sure that he actually believed that. Anyway as he could now watch a movie on it from DVD he was happy.

So anyone want a stick of No Name 1 GIG SO DDR2 RAM? :D

Col

by jdclyde

we are going to be so screwed because of the current trend in bloated software.

And the lemmings continue to buy more and more bloated systems every year, and that 4 gig limit is looking us square in the face.

I mean, really, how many "features" do you really need in a fricken word processor?

by glennen2

Microsoft make MS products, Acer make Acer products but it is the Marketing and Middle-men(people?)who put these together for a level of sellable items. Acer produced the package with its minimum requirement, someone has bought the package and made a deal between MS and Acer to sell it with Vista installed. Acer and MS would have had nothing to do with it at that level

by jdclyde

first, MS is at blame for publishing fraudulent specs.

Next is Acer, knowing that the specs are fraudulent, but still building based upon them.

by nicknielsen

I' not sure how much RAM was going for back than, but I remember seeing prices of $50/gig the last time I checked laptop memory costs.

by jdclyde

I got a gig for $85 for my dell.

now I have seen (like for this model) 2 gigs for $36. Last week I found 4 gigs for $36.

Got 2 gigs for a desktop for $14. :0

Edit to add: All are Kingston, not crap discount stuff.

by willcomp

Manufacturers know better and shouldn't build marginal systems. Acer is not the only culprit though -- HP and Dell are just as guilty. I recently installed 2GB of RAM in 4 HP notebooks that came with 512MB. Dell and others sold a bunch of consumer PCs with XP and 128MB RAM when XP was young to meet price points (RAM was relatively expensive then).

I can see selling low end Vista PCs with 1GB RAM. Performance is not stellar but acceptable for basic computing tasks. 512MB is just plain inadequate for Vista but not as bad as XP with 128MB. Plus DDR2 RAM is cheap (2 x 1GB SODIMMs are about $25.00)

by jdclyde

it uses more memory than that just to turn the pig on, once you factor in your AV.

by the scummy one

even with Symantec, XP ran slow but could perform with 128MB -- until SP2 that is. After SP2 is when it really dogged XP with low memory.

by the scummy one

purchased through the manufacturer when ordering a unit online. Have you seen the prices for the RAM upgrades? Everytime I see it, I think -- gee, go pickup some RAM from Fry's or somewhere, I'll install it. You will save like $60-$80

by the scummy one

cause I didnt want XP at the time. couldnt find a job easily without XP experience, so I had to get a copy and start using it.

by jdclyde

half 98, half 95.

95 wouldn't run some of the new software, so we upgraded them all to 98.

Only had one 2k system.

The systems slowly got migrated to xp, more for memory management than anything else. of course because I was not involved, no one thought about a site license so they bought them, one at a time......

So glad to be gone from there, they would spend a dollar to save a dime.

by the scummy one

luckily, only for 2 months -- they canned me and told me that I just wasnt working out. I was relieved (until I remembered I had to find a job).
Anyway -- the guy that replaced me had several years exp. vs. my 'right outta school' exp.
2 weeks later I was asked to retake my position -- I said no.
still had nightmares about the place :0

by jdclyde

being home users, most don't know what to expect so again, don't know what they are not getting.

Besides, most people I know sit with the laptop in their laps, with it plugged in. Of course they wonder why the power cord breaks.....

Even worse, MOST people that own laptops would be better served with a desktop, but a laptop is "cool".

by thechas

No argument that the consumer who buys a cheap under powered laptop is getting no more than what they payed for.

And, no argument that the average consumer does not research their needs for many purchases and do not know what they should buy.

Still, the forces that create these low end systems come from market research and you cannot blame the manufacture for building what the consumer and the stores think they want. After all, if Acer did not build it, someone else would have.

Perhaps at least for the US consumer, we need a rating system that compares computer models to car models.

This Acer system might compare to a Ford Aspire. Sure, it will get you from point a to point b. Just not as fast, or as comfortable as a Taurus or an Excursion.

Chas

by nicknielsen

I've seen XP on 128 MB and that was gawdawful slow:

Turn it on, go make a pot of coffee and wait for it to brew...
Log in, take a coffee break and have a cigarette...
Doubleclick email client, take a potty break...
Double-click browser icon, take a shower...

by jdclyde

WTF was someone thinking? :0

I have seen them, went to the person that put the system in place, and asked them it in it's current state, it was something THEY could use to get their email and simple browsing.

When the answer is "no", the follow up question is why they would hinder someone elses work by giving them a defective tool?

It was hard not calling the Tech a defective tool.....

by nicknielsen

but in my own defense, I did it only at the insistence of the owner.

The PC was newer, but the owner had been running WinNT 4.0 Workstation because he liked it. He was just tired of having to search for drivers every time he updated peripherals. I told him he could put XP on it, but would need additional memory and recommended adding at least 512 MB. He insisted he couldn't afford it and told me to go ahead...

You [u]don't[/u] want to know how long the install took! X-(

He called me two weeks later and asked how much memory he could get for $50! :^0

by hal 9000

But that was a 486 with 8 X 16 MEG Modules. I just hate to think how much those 8 Sticks of RAM cost way back then.

But when Windows came about we needed to start shoveling more and more RAM into the systems to get decent performance.

I was looking at a 2 year old NB today and was nearly going MAD it was horribly slow and the owner was just so happy when I ripped out the 2 X 1 GIG Sticks and replaced them with 2 X 2 GIG RAM Modules.

Can't upgrade it anymore though and in a couple of years time it is is still running they will be looking at a new one just to run things. A Dual Core AMD with an over the top RAM load 2 years ago is now just not up to scratch with the same [b]supposedly[/b] software. :D

Col

by jdclyde

especially when there is NOT A SINGLE advantage of the new bloatware over the old one! GRRRRR.

GAwD, My first pc was a 386, must have had 4 megs.

Second was when mom upgraded and I got her old 486 SX32 with 8 megs. Memory did a HUGE drop, and I was able to get another 8 megs for ONLY $120! What a deal! And that system SCREAMED! :D What was it, 500 meg drive? Would you believe, I still have it in the basement? ;\ Should drag it out and see what it is..... :p

by jdclyde

when you let a customer know what is required, but they insist on otherwise.

Moving to win2k would have been a better move for him.

Now, when people have that old of a system but little money, I just recommend a referb. $200 and have a fully running XP system. I only charge a nominal fee to move their data over and setup their printer/email.

by jdclyde

the stuff that comes in a white box with a pouch of powder to mix, that is suppose to be cheese! :D

Funny how different things appeal to others. My fav pie is rhubarb. NOT Strawberry rhubarb, just rhubarb. mmmmmm.

by nicknielsen

Or a new girlfriend?

I've had a couple of either that should have been upgraded before I brought them home! :D

by jdclyde

When out on the prowl, I have had many pet names to account for not caring enough to remember their names, but "laptop" has never been one of them..... :D

by the scummy one

to hit for several years now. Would be nice :D
However, the problem with it for me is I dont want Vista at home. Still undecided bout Win7. want some new games though.

by jdclyde

will also give you the 64 bit experience.

Where is the software though???

I wonder who is working on this more, open source or shrink wrap?

by jdclyde

is that you will NOT get honest, quality care at ANY of the big box stores.

Sure, they won't laugh at you to your face, but as soon as you walk away from the counter with a poor purchase, you are the joke of the day. Feel better?

Go to a computer store.

by hal 9000

What was once way over the top is now just about satisfactory and the 4 GIG limit is getting more and more of an Issue.

The particular system has 4 GIG of RAM and 95 Processes running which is way more that are really required.

I also have a 64 Bit Version of XP and while it is OK it's hard to get enough software to make it usable and just like Vista many 32 Bit bits of Software just don't work with it. Let alone thing like Scanners and printers which at best are the most basic functions.

On the other hand most Linux Distro's which do have 64 Bit Versions call these AMD Versions and optimize them for AMD CPU's not the Intel CPU's.

Col

by jck

There was an old story about how Microsoft changed the level for Vista capable systems to have less memory and CPU horsepower.

If MS would have been realistic and metered things properly, no Vista system would have less than 2GB of RAM and nothing less than a 5400 RPM HD laptops and 7200 RPM HDs for PCs.

Vista is an obvious resource hog. Microsoft downed their spec requirements so that people felt they could keep their older PCs as well as current PCs (at the time) would be able to be Vista capable.

by jck

Microsoft defined an inappropriate standard for their OS.

It is not Acer's duty to define or investigate the validity of such a standard. Only to implement what Microsoft *requires* for their "Vista capable" logo.

by the scummy one

Ok, how would asking about it's useage change that? Especially since I will do a build on a website and print it up for them with the options listed, so that they can order it or look for something very similar.

If they still think it is too much trouble, maybe they deserve to get screwed by the store.

by jck

I don't know why it wouldn't.

Go to Acer's support site, and check out the Acer Aspire 5600/3680 User's Manual. The photo shows the Vista sticker on the palm rest, and page 21 declares the laptop "Windows Vista Capable", but having "Genuine Windows XP Home Edition (Service Pack 2)"

Of course, it could have had Vista installed since MS quit allowing XP-installed machines to be sold quite a while ago.

by notsochiguy

Mistake indicates that it was a 'whoopsy' of some sort. Both parties knew what they were doing. I think a better question would be 'who owns more of the blame for the offense'. ;)

MSFT wants to ram (no pun intended) Vista down the throats of consumers at all costs. Paring back the 'minimum requirements' listed for the OS is one way to do this. Maybe their only real way left, given the rejection in the corporate market.

Acer is just looking at it as a way to get more market share in the low-end PC market and to maximize profit margins. I have no doubt that with their buying power, it would have been pretty easy to get the laptops shipped with 2GB of RAM without moving the price point all that much. However, $3 per unit less profit is still $3 per unit less profit in their eyes.

"Lower quality, more issues, greater down the road costs: Vista and Acer. It may not work well, but it does work, sorta." Marketing gurus should stuff that tagline into their pipes and smoke it!

by jdclyde

It is the underpowered systems that helped give Vista the bad name is has earned.

by notsochiguy

I can't fathom why companies haven't yet come to realize that customer experience matters long term to the financial success of a firm.

This is one area where Apple has really done a good job---getting consumers to look past cost, and focus on the overall experience of their systems.

With Windows-based systems, all the consumer market is being trained to do is look at the cheapest model possible. No brand<-->customer loyalty, pitiful customer service experiences, no real reason for a consumer to continue to purchase one brand as opposed to another.

Is that what they are teaching in marketing classes?? If so, what a shame!

by jck

Vista Capable was retired when Vista was the only OS available?

Who knows. I would never buy an Acer anyways...I dealt with too many Altos boxes that were slow and broke easy. I can't imagine what an Acer laptop would do the first time you set the laptop bag down too hard.

by shellbot

to admit I've 3 boxes of that stuff in my kitchen at this time.
I've said it before..its amazing what you miss when you can't have it.
Can't even get proper macaroni here..

by oh smeg

Some of the scariest [b]Power Users[/b] that I have run across are Retired People who have started to use a Computer for the first time after they retired.

They are the ones that I see at Intel Launches looking and buying the Newest biggest CPU's to do Photo Editing and god only knows what else. These people have such over the top hardware to do what they want that it really is scary. When Intel Released the Pentium Extreme I saw at least 20 of these people order CPU's on the night of the presentation and the system specs where as high as they come. These people are the ones who rush out to the newest Hardware possible and Software as well. Between them they have a lot of knowledge and know exactly what they require.

One Retirement Home that I do work for want the newest and fastest Hardware available for everything. The Little Old Ladies are the ones who insist on showing me the Latest Porn that they have managed to find and it's not the [b]Soft Core[/b] stuff either. Not sure what's worse the actual porn or the womens comments about it. :^0

Col

by oh smeg

What a curse you have there my girl because it looks like something I would like I have to have it. [b]NOW[/b]

Now what do they say about Females and the color of Cars? :^0

I bet the shop assistance loved you too as he was instructed to sell it for a lot less at any cost and you walked in and paid Ticket Price. :0

Col 0:-)

This discussion is closed to new replies.