Question Locked

Why can't my Vista machine see my XP shares?

0 helpful
68 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I've read so many posts about this and tried so many different things but none has solved my issue. I have 7 computers all networked together. My "Main" computer is named "C210" and is running Windows XP. Four others are also running XP, 1 running Ubuntu, and then the last one is running Vista 64. They all have shared folders. C210 has the largest share and all of the printers attached. All computers can read/write files with each other and all can access the C210 printers without a problem ... except when it comes to the Vista machine. Vista can read and write to all of the other machines except for C210. It can see C210 on the network but trying to view it's shares always asks for a login. None of the other computers ask for a login, only C210. And of course, the login is never correct. The same usernames and passwords exist, simple file sharing enabled or disabled doesn't make difference, guest account enabled/disabled makes no difference, it is the same workgroup name across all computers. I've uninstalled Norton on C210 to see if that was the problem, no difference. I can ping C210 from Vista with no problem so it is being seen. Trying to do "net view \\C210" returns "System error 5 has occured. Access is denied." but trying a different machine name works just fine and shows all of the shares on that machine.

What is stopping only the Vista machine from accessing only the C210 XP computer? After I removed and subsequently reinstalled Norton, I made sure to give "Full Trust" to all of the computers again, including Vista.

Please help!

68 replies

by peconet tietokoneet

Too often it times out, meaning you will have to wait a minute. The best way is to reboot your Vista machine and see if you can input your Username and password again.
Make sure ALL of your computers are up todate and try again.
Make sure your XP machines have "LLTD" on them,
LLTD here:
http://www.microsoft.com/downloads/en/details.aspx?FamilyID=4f01a31d-ee46-481e-ba11-37f485fa34ea

More information that might help you here:
http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/bb727037.aspx

by bryanmohr

It does not time out. It immediately returns with the invalid login popup. //i have tried rebooting, many many times now.

All computers are completely up to date. None of the XP machines have LLTD on them because they all have SP3 installed which does not allow LLTD to be installed. But again, only C210 (1 of 5 of the XP machines) is having this problem. So I do not believe that it's a problem with SP3, or the absence of the separate LLTD installation.

by bryanmohr

Nope. That's not it. I went through the instructions and everything went just like you said it would, even after installing the responder. But the same thing still happens on the Vista machine. It is STILL asking for a username and password.

by Member 22220486

You will need to downgrade security settings of your vista machine to NTLM v1 or upgrade other systems to use NTLM v2. The solution is to force Windows Vista to use the older encryption methods. To do that, follow these steps:

Users of Windows Vista Home Basic and Home Premium

Click start
Type: regedit
Press enter
In the left, expand these folders: HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Control\
In the left, click on the folder named: Lsa
In the right, double-click "LmCompatibilityLevel"
Type the number 1 and press enter
Restart your computer

Users of Windows Vista Business, Enterprise, and Ultimate

Click Start
Click Control Panel
Click System and Maintenance
Click Administrative Tools
Double-Click Local Security Policy
In the left pane, click the triangle next to Local Policy
In the left pane, click Security Options
In the right pane near the bottom, double-click "Network security: LAN manager authentication level"
Click the drop-down box, and click "Send LM & NTLM - use NTLMv2 session security if negotiated"
Click OK

by bryanmohr

Still not the problem. This was done long ago but I thought I'd check it again just to make sure. It is still set at 1. Besides that ... it's not the Vista machine that really has the problem since it can access the other XP SP3 machines just fine.

by peconet tietokoneet

So, if you know about the XP machines Username and Password, why not put it in?
You might need to check to see that you are inputting the correct username and password. Try and change the Username and password on your XP machine and go from there. Make sure ALL machines are on the same WORKGROUP.

by bryanmohr

I do enter the username and password but it always returns "Logon Unsuccessful". All machines are using the same username and password (I'm not worried about security since I am the only one with physical access to the computers). And yes, they are all on the same workgroup except for the Ubuntu machine, but that's not an issue anyway. I tried changing the username and password temporarily on the XP machine but still got invalid login, so I just changed it back so I wouldn't introduce new problems to all the other computers.

by Member 22220486

what i have seen with systems in workgroup, sometimes we need to explicitly pass user name and password to access them. I used to map a drive using a batch file with net command:

You may want to try this if you have not tried it already.

PS: i tried to put full command line here but that was not displayed correctly. use "net use /?" to get help and try mapping a drive of target system share.

by bryanmohr

C:\Users\Bryan>net use \\C210\Documents
System error 53 has occurred.

The network path was not found.

Yes, Documents is the share name on C210. All other computers can read and write to it just fine. No login necessary even.

by Member 22220486

you get error 53 occurs if you don't pass user name and password. use "user" option to pass user name of target machine. You can use following command.

Replace (DriveLetter) with the drive letter you want to map e.g. Z
Replace (BS) with backslash
Replace (IP) with ip address of target machine
Replace (ShareName) with the name you have given to shared path
Replace (UserName) with the user name (created at target machine) user name must be provided along with IP address in case if you are in workgroup.
Replace (Password) with the password you have for above user. Password must be given. If you have a user without a password, create a password for it.

net use (DriveLetter): (BS)(BS)(IP)(BS)(ShareName) /user:(IP)(BS)(UserName) (Password)

by Member 22220486

you get error 53 occurs if you don't pass user name and password. use "user" option to pass user name of target machine. You can use following command.

Replace IP and share name.

Replace User Name (TestUser in this case) with the user name (created at target machine) user name must be provided along with IP address in case if you are in workgroup.

Replace password (Password123 in this case) with the password you have for above user. Password must be there. If you have a user without a password, create a password for it.

net use Z: \\192.168.20.100\MyShare /user:192.168.20.100\TestUser Password123

by bryanmohr

It looks like Bonjour is only written up to XP. Since C210 is running XP (the machine that cannot connect is Vista 64), and all of the printers are connected to C210, there were no network printers found. I did install it on both Vista and XP but they both show "No Bonjour Printers Found".

I uninstalled Norton (again), and didn't even install AVG, and didn't even enable the Windows FireWall. But still have the exact same results.

So no, still at square 1.

by bryanmohr

I just tried running C210 in Safe Mode with Networking and still have the exact same error.

by bryanmohr

Still no. I have no problem seeing that the computer is there, and when I try to add a network printer it shows up in the found printers, but when I try to connect to the printer or to the shared directory, I get the errors. For the printer it just says that it doesn't exist and to make sure I spelled the name right (which of course it's right since I double-clicked the name directly from the found printers dialog), for the directories it tells me to enter a username and password. I've entered the username and password, upper, lower and mixed case with preceding machine names (both) and without but it always says invalid login.

And still my other XP machines (some with Norton, others with MS Security Essentials) have no problem reading or writing the Vista machine and the Vista machine has no problem reading or writing to them. But my main computer (C210) is the one with the largest hard drive and all of the printers attached.

by jasonjb1222

First things first. To use NET USE, you need to specify a drive letter.
You wrote above: net use \\C210\Documents -> Which gave you error 53.

Try instead, NET USE P: \\C210\C$ (adding dollar ($) at the end will initiate an administrative share/logon to the machine) try that. P: can be replaced by any other letter not in use on your system.

by bryanmohr

ahhh ... I had high hopes for this! But alas, no. Here's the output:
------
C:\Users\Bryan>net use p: \\C210\c$
Enter the user name for 'C210': Bryan
Enter the password for C210:
System error 86 has occurred.

The specified network password is not correct.
------
And the password is definitely correct since I just changed it to a single space for now.

by peconet tietokoneet

Inbound connections limit in Windows XP pro, XP Home Edition and Vista.
Windows XP Professional, the maximum number of other computers that are permitted to simultaneously connect over the network is ten.
This limit includes all transports and resource sharing protocols combined. For Windows XP Home Edition, the maximum number of other computers that are permitted to simultaneously connect over the network is five. This limit is the number of simultaneous sessions from other computers the system is permitted to host.
http://support.microsoft.com/kb/314882

Try this out and see:
Open "cmd" as Administrator
type "net config server" and check for "Maximum Logged On users" number. That is max. inbound connections.

by bryanmohr

Ok, it does say 10. So I shut down all computers except for C210 and Vista. Still won't connect. Same exact error.

by freginold

You've definitely got yourself a good problem here. Not sure why you can't access the XP shares, but as far as the printers are concerned, have you tried adding them as local printers to the Vista machine? It sounds weird but it works when Vista won't connect to an XP-shared printer. You can find full instructions here:

http://www.helium.com/items/1667507-how-to-add-xp-printer-in-vista

Also, I'm sure you've tried this, but have to ask, have you tried removing the password completely from the XP computer and connecting through the Vista PC?

by bryanmohr

I have made sure that one of the printers can be accessed from Vista by connecting directly to it. That works fine. And yeah, I have removed the passwords and tried without.

by bryanmohr

I'll play around with the firewall settings a bit more. But first want to give you guys all a little more info. I installed WireShark on both of the machines. When connecting to any other XP machine, Vista goes through the normal sequence of requesting the tree, giving authorization, etc... Quite a bit of network traffic. When trying to connect to C210, not a single byte of traffic is exchanged before the login dialog pops up! But when retrieving the network name list of attached computers and devices, it shows everything.

by peconet tietokoneet

Ok, my brain is hot on this issue :).
Do you have a router for your network or just a switch?
If you have just a router and have this locked down with a Username and Password then you could just use (try to use) the Username from the XP machine and password from the router.
Another way is to delete ALL shares from the XP machine, reboot BOTH machines and try again with a new share and then try and connect with your Vista machine. Do not worry about your other machines because if this works between these two machines then the others will connect with no problem though you would have to add a new share to others.
Post back if all goes well or not.
I am going to have another cup of tea and see if i can come up with anything else to help you with your issue.

by Former member

I have always had what seems like the same problem, using a printer on Win7 from the xp machine. It will only work if the Win7 machine is switched on/rebooted after the Xp system. (OR vice versa, I forget which). Also had the same situation from the xp to a vista machine with the printer... it depends on the boot order. The printer was attached to a vista home premium and is now attached to a 64bit win7 homepremium. Usually when on the xp machine, there is never even a chance to input the login or password. If they are booted in the correct order. no probs at all. Other win7 (32bit ultimate) machine has no problems with the win7 printer HP machine ever, and all are fully up together as describedby original poster. Usually all are permanently on, so I live with the problem until there is a good reason to reboot. Usually I share the xp file with win7 ultimate pc, then print to the shared printer on 64bit HP from the win7Ultimate. If this boot order helps anyone to find a correct method so any order works, do tell.

by bryanmohr

Yeah, I thought about that too. But the C210 shares are always ready before any of the other machines are even turned on usually. But I did do a full shutdown on all of them again just to make sure. No change.

by peconet tietokoneet

It has nothing to do with the BOOT order, except that the machine for which others access the share from must be up and running for the share to work. As to which machine boots first does not matter.

by bryanmohr

I take it back about the WireShark results. It actually does send a name query to C210, and it receives a valid response. Then the login dialog box comes up. No other further network traffic after that.

Just for fun, I also changed my XP computer name. No change, so I changed it back.

by peconet tietokoneet

Did you reboot?
Any change to the system (or systems) you will need to reboot to keep the changes.
If you did not reboot then it would be a waste of time because you will be back to square one. Always reboot if you make any changes.

by peconet tietokoneet

NetBIOS over TCP/IP or add NetBEUI on all your workstations.
I would try and change the name for C210 to either bill or bob But make sure your computer name is ALL upper case (Capitals). Sometimes when there are two "C's" , example, you have drive "c" and you name the share or computer name that starts with a "C" then it might confuse your system(s). No harm in trying it out.

by daveaaa3

I think you have something here. This might not be enabled.

by Member 22220486

you get error 53 occurs if you don't pass user name and password. use "user" option to pass user name of target machine. You can use following command.

Replace IP and share name.

Replace User Name (TestUser in this case) with the user name (created at target machine) user name must be provided along with IP address in case if you are in workgroup.

Replace password (Password123 in this case) with the password you have for above user. Password must be there. If you have a user without a password, create a password for it.

net use Z: \\192.168.20.100\MyShare /user:192.168.20.100\TestUser Password123

by Former member

Following the definite answer above, I just did the experiment. Started with both on, and another win7 machine can use the win7 printer on "Bella". The xp machine cannot access the Bella machine but knows it exists. Printing instruction from xp gives a pop up about ~~server cannot perform the requested operation~~. could not copy and paste the exact words. Reboot the xp machine, same result. Reboot the win7 "Bella" machine which has the printer, xp can immediately see it and the shared files and the printer without logging on or anything. This was even before the user had logged onto the Bella. So for my original poster, please try booting your xp machine with the shares, last.

by daveaaa3

Shot in the dark here, but Start, Run, gpedit.msc to open local policy. Drill down, Computer Configuration, Windows Settings, Security Settings, Local Policies, Security Options. Check Network Access: Sharing and security model for local accounts. Make sure it is Classic. Is Netbios over TCP enabled also?

by bryanmohr

It was set to "Guest" so I changed it to "Classic". No change. And of course, I rebooted both machines after doing the change.

NetBios over TCP was set to "Default" so I forced it on. Still no change. And now for a new twist ....

by bryanmohr

That accesses C210 perfectly! No problems at all. No login required, nothing. But, that machine has to go back to a customer.

by rotimi.amzat

For your vista to see Xp you must first enable the guest account from the control panel by turning it on. then create passwords for all account on your system including the guest. then restart . this should fix the issue

by bryanmohr

Nope. Tried again just to verify for about the 50th time. But still no luck accessing the shares on C210 from this one Vista machine. The other Vista machine is still connected and still connects and accesses C210 without any problem.

by Former member

Since all the software has been tried 10 times, perhaps a small cable fault. Initiallly I was thinking the network controller, but have you tried swopping the cables. OR trying with wireless although I rarely use wireless as you can expect wireless problems to add to the list of maybe issues.

by bryanmohr

I thought that as well and so I did change the ethernet cable as well as change the port that the main Vista machine was connecting to on the switch (to one that works fine when an XP machine was connected to it), but still the same results. I then tried to connect wirelessly and although connecting was no problem, I still could not access (I've been saying "see" but I can see they exist from Vista so "access" is a better word) the shares on C210.

by graic

first you have to find out eh version of windows your using, home edition, or proffessional.
well with proffessional make sure the computer group is the same and enable sharing. or put the machines in the same domain, or same ip scheme. you will have access to your shared folders of filez,

by bryanmohr

Thanks for the suggestions, but if you go back and read the history you'll see that all of this has been done over and over again with many variations along the same lines.

by bryanmohr

From now on, the main XP machine will be called (and named) "XPS210" and the main Vista machine will be called "PAV9720". A couple of the other XP machines are named "BKTOWER" and "TECRAM3" and the guest Vista machine is called "EMACHINES".

XPS210, BKTOWER, TECRAM3, and EMACHINES can all read from, write to and use shared devices to and from each other without any problems. No logins required, nothing out of the ordinary.

PAV9720 can read from, write to and use shared devices on all of the above except XPS210. When accessing XPS210, it can see the computer name, but it cannot see the actual share names. When I click on the computer name, it asks for the login which it does not recognize when entered.

XPS210, BKTOWER, TECRAM3, and EMACHINES can all read from, write to and use shared devices to and from PAV9720 without any problems. No logins required, nothing out of the ordinary.

All machines are on the same workgroup "NYK". Currently Guest account is disabled on all machines but even when it was enabled it made no difference. They all have the same username "Bryan" with the same password. And that username has Admin access on all machines. Yes, I even temporarily changed the username and workgroup on EMACHINES which is a client computer and only here for a short time.

All of the above machines are connected to a SMC 16-port switch, which is then connected to a NetGear router, and out to a Comcast broadband modem.

by jay.sanders

1. Check that the time + date is set the same on all machines.
2. Check the amount of time you have wasted trying to fix this, backup the PC and reinstall windows etc.
3. On both machines reinstall the TCP/IP
http://www.mydigitallife.info/2007/06/19/reinstall-and-reset-tcpip-internet-protocol-in-windows-vista-2003-and-xp/

Again though - I would be asking myself how much time I really want to spend on this as a reinstall would have other benifits and would narrow your troubleshooting down considerably.

by bryanmohr

Well considering that reinstalling Windows on the Vista machine, then reinstalling all of my software would require the better part of a few days, I don't think I'll be doing that.

Why would I want to reinstall XP on XPS210 when EVERY other computer (XP and Vista based) connect to it flawlessly? Only 1 of 2 Vista machines cannot access XPS210.

And yes, the time and date are set the same on all machines.

by bryanmohr

Nope. No change. But, I made what could be a BIG mistake! I was wrong in saying that it could see the sharenames! It can see that computer is on the network (so it sees XPS210 listed when I click "Network" in Explorer), but selecting XPS210 asks for the login. I never do see the shares. Sorry about the misinformation.

by jgwinner

I've seen a smilar problem with Vista to XP, but I've upgraded machines since then.

I hate it when people say to reinstall the O/S. A good many times I see the same problem come back. And if it fixes something, how do you know what was fixed? Our ASP does thsi all the time with email performance problems and it "Fixes" it for that day, but then the next day the performance problem comes back. Fix the real problem.

Anyway, with my Vista machine I changed from sharing with the name to sharing with IP address and it worked. I opened up a bug on technet but of course got no real response. I also tried all the tricks above or most of them - now I'm on Win7 on all machines so I can't verify.

Try the IP address trick and see if that works.

== John ==

by bgcr

when the vista machine asks for the login details input the log in details for the vista pc. it is a common mistake to think that you input the login details of the pc you are trying to access.

by bryanmohr

Well, since it's the same username and password on both machines, it really doesn't matter.

by daveaaa3

I wonder if forcing it to use the username in the context of the computer issuing the challenge will allow access. I have to do this when I try to map a drive via VPN to my work computer which is XP from my home computer which is Vista.

by bryanmohr

Nope. That's what I do normally but tried it again just now .. just for fun. Still does not recognize the username or password.

by bryanmohr

Well, that didn't fix the issue ... but at least I got to change the Organization Name! So there was an upside to that test. :)

Here's another new thing to consider. I installed VirtualBox on the Vista machine with XP running on that. Set the Network Adapter to "Bridged" inside VB and that XP connects to every other machine just fine.

So it seems to me that there are no hardware issues involved here. There's just something on this Vista installation that isn't allowing it to connect to 1 out of 6 XP installations.

by jgwinner

I had a similar problem once with a Vista machine to an XP share. My setup was slightly more complicated, but I found if I used the IP address instead of the symbolic name it would work every time. Oddly, the XP machine could setup a share to the Vista machine symbolically so I usually just copied the other way around.

I later upgraded to Win7 on both machines and it all worked.

I feel for you - there's a bug floating around here. The O/S should say something. I assume you checked the security logs in the event viewer for clues?

== John ==

by bryanmohr

Well, I could have sworn I tried the net use ip address method before and failed, but .... drumroll please .... It worked!! I did "net use v: //192.168.0.4/Sharename" and it connected no problem! Tried connecting through explorer after that but still couldn't get that to work. I checked the event logs and there is absolutely nothing in any category (security or anything else) showing any kind of error when trying to connect to XPS210 through Explorer.

So, at least I can access files. Now does anyone know how I can access the shared printer?

by bryanmohr

Update: I got the printer added too! Thank you everyone for all the thought and time you all spent on this! Peconet hung in there from the start! Thanks again! I'll live with the sharing this way. John, I agree that there is a bug in here somewhere.

by bryanmohr

It looks like this only works intermittently. And it can allow or stop access at any time for any reason, or no reason. I was copying a directory from XP to Vista, it got about halfway through the copying and then suddenly popped up and asked me to login. Of course the login didn't work and doing Net Share didn't work. Rebooted, still nothing, tried to do a print to the printer on XP about an hour later and that worked. Then I finished copying the directory over. Strange stuff!

by jgwinner

Ouch :(

Did you post a bug on the Microsoft site?

Do you have any Win7 machines? I think mine mysteriously started working after an upgrade or Windows security patch, but I also upgraded one of the PC's a while back, so I can't test now.

But - back to the error, when you got the login popup, what does the security event log say? If it doesn't say anything, you'd need to turn auditing on of course.

== John ==

by tnelsonp

I know it has been a while... I am wondering if you were able to resolve this issue. I am in a similar situation where I have an existing workgroup network of several XP machines, one of which is XP Pro and an existing Vista machine. My printer is on the XP Pro and everyone can access the device. I added a new Vista machine and cannot access the shares or the printer. Like you, I keep getting prompted for a user / password when I attempt to access the XP Pro shares or printer from the new Vista machine. Also, like you, I have Virtualbox installed on the Vista machine. The Vista machine has no problem accessing the XP Home machines, only the XP Pro.

Thanks.

by adam_12345

Hi,

I dealt with the same problem and I couldn't access any resources from Vista Ultimate OS. The solution that worked for me was a change of the LAN authentication method to "Send LM & NTLM - use NTLMv2 session security if negotiated". But before I did that I had uninstalled Link-Layer Topology Discovery Responder. And I installed it again.

This discussion is closed to new replies.