Discussion Locked

Why don't Windows users celebrate innovations in Linux?

0 helpful
17 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Competition is what makes companies try harder.

When there is competition in a market, the products have to be better to compete.

When there is competition in a market, there are more innovation and improvements.

When there is competition in a market, prices have to be competitive.

Bottom line, the better Linux gets, the better Windows will have to get and vise-versa. How is that bad for anyone, regardless of which OS you decide to use?

17 replies

by charliespencer

"...the better Linux gets, the better Windows will have to get..."

Until the Windows incorporates the improvements in Linux (or OS X, or any other OS), and until the user upgrades to the version that includes these improvements, there's no reason to celebrate.

Owners of existing sedans don't celebrate when new luxury cars come with factory-installed GPS systems or rear-view cameras. These features aren't in the cars those owners already have, and aren't yet incorporated in the models they would buy (assuming they wanted to buy a new car). What's to celebrate?

by jdclyde

There are always patches and updates to existing software. Both to improve and fix flaws.

Just like American car manufacturers are raising quality to catch up to Toyota and the other imports, the same is true for Windows.

Not to mention, as a windows shop, don't you want the NEXT version to be better than the last? Don't just slap a new GUI on it and end support for the old version to continually make money. Do the job better.

Also, do you think that if wasn't for linux, MS would have made security an issue in both XP and Vista, instead of the "default on" of the NT years?

by charliespencer

Ignorance, either of improvements to Linux or their incorporation into Windows. Hell, many users think the only difference between XP and Vista is a new GUI and a nagging security feature. If they aren't aware of improvements to the OS they already use, why would they be aware of changes to one they don't use?

I'm in the trade but the only recent (last 18 months or so) improvements I'm aware of in Linux is that some distributions now play better with Active Directory. I don't anticipate using Linux so I don't follow it's development.

by jdclyde

the os religion wars, where zelots from one side or the other feel the NEED to attack the other side any chance they get.

How big of an improvement did you see from win2k to xp? win2k was a stable system and used half the resources. I still have it on a few systems at home because it runs much better on older systems than xp does.

The other side of the coin, when there is a problem with linux or windows, people get defensive about it instead of standing up and saying "hey, you're right. that SHOULD get fixed".

You don't think linux had anything to do with security improvements in Windows over the last few years?

by charliespencer

"You don't think linux had anything to do with security improvements in Windows over the last few years?"

Not really, but I'm not aware of the security improvements in Linux so I don't know which ones have been incorporated into Windows.

I don't know why you raised the original topic. You complain about zealots and then start a topic that just throws more gas on the fire. You may not think so, but reverse your original title and see how it sounds:

"Why don't Linux users celebrate innovations in Windows?"

Either way you phrase it, it's bound to rile up the fan boys.

by $$$$$$$$$$

Exploits would have been a relevant advertising metric in
Windows v. Mac, with or without an open-source Unix clone
creeping onto desktops. Maybe *nix security models have
helped some Microsoft coders do things better, but the
market demand for better access control comes from the
market, not from one operating system kernel or
corporation.

by jdclyde

I WANT people to keep using Windows.

It is the only thing that will keep the linux flavors trying harder and harder to get better.

When you are on top, you get lazy, like MS has been for so long.

MS doing good is good for linux and vice versa.

And I didn't say they used advances done by linux, but the pressure to compete is the only thing that changed their focus.

by charliespencer

You haven't like the answers I've offered to your original question. You didn't like 'Linux improvements aren't readily available to Windows users", or "Windows users aren't aware of Linux improvements." (Hell, most of them aren't aware of Linux, period.)

I agree Windows benefits from the existence of competition. (Right now MS's biggest competition is it's own product, XP, not Linux.) I'm trying to answer your question of why Windows users don't care about Linux improvements. By 'Windows users' I assume you mean the average corporate or home desktop user, not those of us in the biz. Apparently you're looking for a particular answer and I haven't hit it yet, so you tell us.

by $$$$$$$$$$

As I said last week
I WANT people to keep using Windows.

It is the only thing that will keep the linux flavors trying harder and harder to get better.

When you are on top, you get lazy, like MS has been for so long.

I thought that when I'm on top, higher performance is expected. No?

MS doing good is good for linux and vice versa.

And I didn't say they used advances done by linux, but the pressure to compete is the only thing that changed their focus.

From what, to what? It could be very interesting to look closely at either side of that: vice, or versa. When has MS "doing good" been good for Linux, or vice versa?

by w2ktechman

you expect us to remember what you said last week??

cr@p, I dont remember what you said yesterday in many posts!!

"As I said last week
I WANT people to keep using Windows."

-- Why?? People will, but why would you want people to?

"It is the only thing that will keep the linux flavors trying harder and harder to get better."
-- I disagree, people flock to free SW, especially when money is an issue and there are so many licensing restrictions on other products.

"When you are on top, you get lazy, like MS has been for so long."
-- Whenever a company gets large, they have expensive failures. these failures usually cause a company to put more measures in place to reduce the risk of this happening. However often good ideas get passed by and bad ideas get through.
There also seems to be a mindset thing when a company sees lots of money coming in -- preserve wealth over all....

"MS doing good is good for linux and vice versa."
-- No arguments

"And I didn't say they used advances done by linux, but the pressure to compete is the only thing that changed their focus."
-- I dont think that Linux has threatened them enough to change the way things are done because of it. However, I do think that corporate pressures were a big reason. Linux/Mac were sidenotes to stack on top.
I am not saying that MS isnt scared of Linux, just that it is doubtful that Linux alone changed the way MS does things.

by $$$$$$$$$$

the os religion wars, where zelots from one side or the other feel the NEED to attack the other side any chance they get.

So now that that's clearer, it's obvious to me that you started this thread on the false assumption that Linux advocate = Microsoft non-user. Back to those OS flame warz, how would I know how much Micro$loth $ux if I only ever played with Tux?

I think good old-fashioned geek cred and competition among independent contractors to establish the best reputation and highest billable rates are more than enough to push improvements in computing for centuries, and the existence of corporate licensing of algorithms is harmful not helpful to IT at large. I'll even say this is true of every industry, just more plainly so in IT due to the amount of productivity that can be realized with a single workstation, and the right programmer.

by $$$$$$$$$$

I assume, based on my own usage, that many Linux
advocate/enthusiast/users are also frequent users of
Windows, even though many of us having very few positive
things to say about Windows ... because it is so often
necessary to use it due to Microsoft's compatibility
minimization strategies, negating the reality of "choice" and
the basis of your [b]free[/b] market assertions.

by jck

In the home market: no doubt. Windows is the vast majority, mainly because of the ignorant home user who just wants to get their Dell, plug it in, and let their kid play World of Warcraft.

Stupid-friendly = $$$$ (in the home user market)

In the server market: Linux has made in-roads now to breaking MS's position in the server market. As where at one point there was a surge for shops to go "Microsoft" for simplicity's sake, that has ceased to be seen as a necessity for performance and cost-efficiency.

Sure, Linux's share is nowhere near a majority. However, Linux's cost-effectiveness both in price, support, and man-power is better for the corporate bottom line.

It's no more hardware cost to run Linux (and usually cheaper in the long-term).

It's no more cost to support Linux (as some MS licensing provides you no support at all without paying either).

Linux admins are generally paid about the same MS admins are.

And, Linux is free.

As for security, Linux being an "out of the box" more secure OS for years did finally make MS look at their defaults and security model. There were even posts on here (i think about 2 years ago about the topic). They knew that if they didn't get on-par at least, they were on a road that could lead to problems.

I think Windows has its place in the world. Mainly with the home market and small business (office work, small publishing, etc.).

However, Microsoft being the behemoth it is puts it at a disadvantage in the majority of the business sector from a server standpoint. Their lack of efficiency makes them the 21st century IBM.

I too, like jdclyde and others, want Linux and MS to compete.

However, I want to see Linux grow to the point that I can choose what platform i want to buy a game or other piece of software for...rather than try to figure out how to get an MS game to run under Cedega...or consider buying an Xbox360.

As for info on cost, here's an article. it's 2 years old, but it's what i found in 30 seconds of googling. lol

http://www.linux-watch.com/news/NS9173276172.html

by $$$$$$$$$$

However, I want to see Linux grow to the point that I can choose what platform i want to buy a game or other piece of software for...rather than try to figure out how to get an MS game to run under Cedega...or consider buying an Xbox360.

Netscape ... OpenDocument format ... standards compliance v. IE compatibility: I don't see Microsoft suddenly deciding that direct competition, for the same software functions among the same user-types, is the way to go after all. Rather, I expect they will fight tooth-and-nail against attempts by competitors to remain autonomous while providing any services too similar to their cash cows. When they cannot throw enough money at the competition, this strategy will be their downfall.

by jck

Microsoft can't buy the GPL.

Therefore, Microsoft would have to buy every programmer in the world by paying them not to write Linux code.

They can't do that. Or maybe they could. Used to be they gave you a free product of Office Academic if you signed a document stating you wouldn't use WordPerfect for 24 months.

Maybe they'll give all programmers free Silverlight lol

Anyways, Microsoft can throw all the money they want at it. Linux will always have more developers, because MS can't hire all the programmers in the world.

And, college students can get Linux free and goof with the source and build anything from the kernel to a driver.

Anyways, I want to play a game on whatever OS is the best for the price. And to me right now, that's Linux. I only use Windows XP Pro now for playing Shadowbane...which is free too lol

by $$$$$$$$$$

I chose it partly for brevity, over something about cooperating with the inevitable. Maybe it was too obvious to mention at all with all their standards non-compliance, and shoving of new "standards" where they don't belong. But I thought my meaning was pretty clear overall. N'est-ce pas?

[i]When they cannot throw enough money at the competition, this strategy will be their downfall.[/i]

This discussion is closed to new replies.