Discussion Locked

Why I will not be hanging my stocking up THIS year

0 helpful
58 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I posted this last year but, since then, I?ve been checking up more carefully on the facts. As I was once a scientist I have a certain scepticism that has finally convinced me that Santa Claus DOES NOT EXIST. I?m sorry if this comes as a shock to some of you but as you get your presents anyway - stop whining!

Here?s my reasoning.

No known species of reindeer can fly but there are millions of species of living organisms yet to be classified, and while most of these are beetles I cannot completely rule out flying reindeer which only Santa has ever seen.

There are well over two billion children - defined as persons under 18 years - in the world but since Santa doesn?t handle the Muslim, Hindu, Jewish and Buddhist children, that reduces the workload to 15% of the total ? around 400 million. At an average rate of 2 children per household, that's 200 million homes. I?m making the assumption that there?s at least one good child in each household.

Santa has 31 hours of Christmas to work with, thanks to the different time zones and the rotation of the earth, assuming he travels east to west (which seems logical). This works out to 1792 visits per second. This is to say that for each Christian household with good children, Santa has 1/2000th of a second to park, hop out of the sleigh, jump down the chimney, fill the stockings, distribute the remaining presents under the tree, eat whatever snacks have been left, get back up the chimney, get back into the sleigh and move on to the next house. Assuming, for the purpose of simplifying the maths, that each of these 200 million stops are evenly distributed around the earth, we are now talking about a half mile per household with a total trip of 100 million miles, not counting stops to do what most of us must do at least once every 31 hours, plus feeding and etc. This means that Santa's sleigh is moving at a minimum of 900 miles per second, A conventional reindeer can run, tops, 15 miles per hour.

The payload on the sleigh adds another interesting element. Again, to simplify the calculations we?ll assume that each child gets nothing more than a medium-sized Lego set at two pounds weight. The sleigh is therefore carrying 400,000 tons, not counting Santa, who is invariably described as overweight. On land, conventional reindeer can pull no more than 300 pounds. Even granting that "flying reindeer" (see above) could pull TEN TIMES the normal amount, we cannot do the job with eight, or even nine. We need 250,200 reindeer and these are not small! This increases the payload by an additional 34,000tons assuming a weight for a bull reindeer of 300 pounds.

434,000 tons travelling at 900 miles per second creates enormous air resistance - this will heat the reindeer up in the same fashion as spacecrafts re-entering the earth's atmosphere. The lead pair of reindeer will absorb 14.3 x 10^30 joules of energy per second each. In short, they will burst into flame almost instantaneously, exposing the reindeer behind them, and create deafening sonic booms in their wake. The entire reindeer team will be vaporized within 4.26 thousandths of a second leaving a smell of overcooked venison in their wake. Santa, meanwhile, will be subjected to acceleration forces 17,500 times greater than gravity. A 250-pound Santa (which seems ludicrously slim) would be pinned to the back of his sleigh by 4,315,015 pounds of force.

In conclusion - If Santa ever DID deliver presents on Christmas Eve, he's dead now.

58 replies

by jdclyde

As I know what 245 lbs looks like, I can bet that last five pounds will not make that big of a difference! :0

But, as a scientist, you of course forget the special power of MAGIC. Sure, it didn't bring my ex-wifes lover back to her, as much as she tried, it does have it's place.

If the statue of liberty can be made to disappear, then deer that have eaten magic corn can do as they please!

Oh, don't let Mambo read this. It would be so depressing, he would be smiles from ear to ear! B-)

by zlitocook

Never read a book, watched a movie or just thought about some thing you liked, you do not belive!
Santa is not a thing to touch or see it is a feeling, a way of life and how you live your life. Santa is not dead he is just watching the world now, the place is a mess and needs a good cleaning!

by tig2

And your command of scientific facts and figures. However, I must echo JD's sentiment- reindeer hopped up on magic corn can do any darn thing they want!

Furthermore, do we really KNOW what Santa's suit is made of? Could it BE asbestos or better? Just because it doesn't say NASA doesn't mean that Mrs. Claus didn't come by a forgotten bolt of the fabric in red!

And where do you think MGM sourced all the Munchkins for the Wizard of OZ??? That would be Santa's house! A short break from toy making makes for a happier workforce!

Now let's talk weight. As you may know, cookies stored on the top shelf have no calories. Calories are scared of heights and will run away from any food stored on a high shelf. Cookie calories are particularly frightened, so they tend to run more quickly.

Therefore, I submit that Santa doesn't actually "weigh" what he would if he were truly the appropriate size. A bit of plastic surgery (I'm thinking silicone implants here) and you get a modestly weighed Santa for the price of the "full" version.

I don't hang a stocking any more. The magic of Christmas is gone for me. I am an adult and therefore too jaded. But the spirit of Christmas is still alive and well. I have all the best things that life has to offer- and maybe that is why I feel this way.

Did we spend a lot of money on the holiday? Sure. But we enjoy the holiday with our friends and our family. It was a delight to take the time to choose gifts that we believe will delight those we love. It was a wonderful time last year- and I expect this one as well- to wrap those gifts and take the time for the touches that MAKE them special.

Science has no place in a season made of magic.

And for all of your curmudgeonly ways, I wish you and yous the best of the season. May you find the magic of Christmas!

by maecuff

it was the whole 'reindeer' thing that did Santa in for our baby. When he was 4 years old, he said, "Mom, I really don't see how a reindeer can fly. There really isn't a Santa, is there?"

I wasn't going to lie to him, and his logic was sound, so...I agreed. No Santa.

My staff? They STILL give me sh*t about this. They think I'm a horrible mother for not perpetuating the 'Santa' thing. They don't seem to understand that the little one enjoys Christmas and all his gifts as much as the little wankers who still believe in Santa.

by jdclyde

I had this discussion with my boys the other day on when they had stopped believing, and why. Never did get a straight answer about the "when". maybe they were too embarrassed to say "last year"? :D

by uberg33k50

My wife tells me about how when she found out that there was no Santa and confronted her parents they insisted it was true. She was really upset with them for lying to her and never really trusted them again. I think the truth is always better.

by mjd420nova

As a youngster (4 years old) I realized that there could never be a SANTA. But yet each year there were presents under the tree. Then the number of presents from SANTA dwindled to one each member and the rest were from other family members. The question was always who got this gift for who?? SANTA. You see there really is a SANTA. He's in all of us. The delighted smiles and lit up eyes on that special morning when Christ was born.

by nicknielsen

He uses a stasis field that surrounds the reindeer, sleigh, payload and him. This isolates all from any physical consequences.

"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic" - Arthur C. Clarke

by jaqui

Santa isn't human, he is an elf.
[ howthe heck else could the bugger live for centuries? ]

he is only around 1 foot tall.
his magic makes all the toys fit into one sack and only weigh about 5 stone., when he pulls the presents out they grow back to full size as he heads up the express route of the oversize chimney.

by hal 9000

Complete sleigh, presents, Santa & the reindeer.

As this would be an enormous amount of kinetic Energy produced initially to accelerate the massive weight to the speeds involved and as we all know that matter [b]Can Not[/b] be destroyed just converted into energy you have greatly underestimated the effects on the planet.

The size of the Sonic Boom is most likely reason for the decreasing size of the Northern Ice Shelf as it breaks away from the continual assaults of sleighs taking off every year and supposedly returning with less weight. I would assume that there is a Harmonic Effect transmitted through the internal molten core of the planet that has a similar but smaller effect on the Southern Ice Shelf.

So in fact not only have you proved that Santa Claus exists but is responsible for Global Warming and our possible destruction in years to come. As there is now no way known to stop this massive Commercial Juggernaut we are bound to die out through our own greed.

So all I can say is make the most of it while it lasts cause it will not be around all that much longer as everything will be under several hundred feet of water at the absolute least.

I just hope that the Water Chemistry of the Oceans doesn't change too quickly or all the salt water dwelling creatures will die out as they are unable to cope with the rapid changes in the salinity of the oceans.

Now as a concerned Scientist shouldn't you be working on GE the Human race to have gills as an absolute minimum requirement till Santa Claus stops his yearly visits and allows the planet to return to what it considers a normal condition?

Col

by Member 25348569

We all convert to Islam, Judaeism, Hinduism or Atheism and St. Nicholas will avoid us like the plague!

Devil-worship will do it as well. ]:)

I do agree, though, that it's the likely cause of Global Warming as the increase in the number of children has only been really rapid in last century along with the temperature. All that kinetic energy could be recycled as he starts and stops - a [b]big[/b] flywheel, maybe - but as he's more an American myth figure these days, he probably doesn't give a fig pudding about wasting energy.

I reckon that if he [b]does[/b] exist, he's a creature entirely existent only in another dimension. Mass, velocity and time have no measurable effect on his efforts at Christmas. True-to-legend, in his parallel world it is [b]always[/b] Christmas. He has essentially forever to deliver the presents, which he unfolds to our pitifully few dimensions using some kind of device powered by a quasar. He obviously doesn?t live at the North Pole per se, but in an environment on the North Pole of a naked monopole quantum singularity from where he focuses his present-sending. What we call "reindeer" are, I guess, the three-dimensional shadows of 11-dimensional structures that act as transfer nexuses for the vast amounts of energy needed to reintegrate the toys at the "our universe interface" and the "sleigh" is very likely a quantum confinement vessel that absorbs the shock-wave of reintegration when they come down the chimney.

The presents are the residue deposited by the negative entropy created by Santa's faster-than-light communication with the good little children in this universe, thus conserving the second law of thermodynamics.

Yep. I believe that too...

Neil :D

by hal 9000

Santa is just the latest form of mass delusions fostered upon the Western World for the [b]Transdimensional Beings[/b] to see if we've found out what 42 actually means.

Just about every Religion or area of the planet has similar festive times where some mythical beings visit to suit their own needs so this could just be the way that our creators are measuring how we are proceeding on finding the Question to the Ultimate Answer and of course once we do understand what the mystical number 42 actually does mean there will be no further use for us so the Vogans can come through and demolish this planet for a Hyperspace Bypass. Our Creators will by them have no further use for us as their question has been answered. :D

Though I have it on good authority that Ossama has found a solution and the [b]Transdimensional Beings[/b] are currently studding his brain just to make sure that his Question suits their needs before allowing the planet to be disposed of. :p

Kind of makes you feel small when you realise that you are nothing more than disposable livestock to our makers when we are of no further use to them doesn't it? :^0

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Was the Mushrooms that he ate before the trick was performed giving him the delusion that he actually performed Magic rather than just a Trick. :p

Actually while we are on the subject of DM what have you done to scare him away?

Col ]:)

by mjwx

That a reindeer could withstand the G forces experienced whist turning at high velocities Santa has also broken several federal laws in Australia and America.

This Santa character has never filed a flight plan, which according to FAC (Federal Airports Commission (Our FAA)) regulations is illegal in both our countries (I think). If you see a jolly man of heavy build last seen wearing a red and white suit you are to apprehend him at once.

Also on Air safety the "reindeers" have never been inspected by an authorised Aviation safety inspector. Another clear violation of federal law. Also at the estimated speed of travel the sleigh must be breaking the sound barrier over US cities which is illegal.

It appears there will be no presents this year as Santa will need all his money to pay fines for violating FAC/FAA regulations and bringing his sleigh up to code. :(

On another note, this aircraft has never been detected on RADAR nor has it been seen by civilian or military observers so I must assume the sleigh and aforementioned red suit must be composed of a light as well as radar adsorbing material rendering invisible to both electronic and visual detection.

But I too will not be hanging a stocking anywhere this festive season, mainly because it is not an Australian custom. :)

by locolobo

Reindeer kick like a mule. If you attempt to "apprehend" him use caution.
If I do turn him in what's the reward? And how are you going to protect me from the elves? What kind of witness protection is that?

LOL!

by longwayoff

I still retain my copy of the FAA-approved Santa picture AND the message from NORAD reporting detection of a sleigh & reindeer heading south from the North Pole, picked up on the DEW line (for you other old folks).

Lynne

by drowningnotwaving

I want a new bike, a car, house, a cute girlfriend, a lotto ticket with the right f-ing numbers on it, a computer filled with the best porn money can buy, a credit card that f-ing works everywhere and doesn't send me an invoice every f-ing month, a ski holiday to somewhere with snow (not Jindabyne you smartass pr-ck), beer, and a wife who doesn't tell me to put some clothes on when I scratch my left bollock watching the cricket all f-ing day long on my new widescreen telly with surround f-ing sound that you threw in just for laffs.

In fact, gimme a new left bollock too, while you're at it.

Is that too much to ask?

by shellbot

ok, so the question has been answered..(what do guys want for christmas)

great laugh for a monday morning CIBRNP :)

by onbliss

Heard something about 20/20 cricket matches. Does it mean one does not have to watch cricket the whole day? It's a shame it is being reduced to baseball, isn't it? Who started the slippery slope, was it Packer?

by now left tr

May look like 'an old man' but may not BE 'an old man'.

It all could be just a smokescreen!
(Which it is anyway)

by protiusx

I hope you don't mind but I copied this and sent to my friends and relatives. I did site you as the creator. This is fantastic! It is a good thing that I am not at home because my kids (who still believe in SC) can both read and would be devastated to read that Santa is dead.

by Member 25348569

I read an original spoof with some of the calculations over ten years ago and have adapted it for increasing population and corrected a bit of the maths and have posted it somewhere every year since (second year at TR).

I normally aim it at a Kiwi as Santa will burn up somewhere near the International Date Line!

Christmas? Bah! Humbug!

Neil :D

p.s. I will be putting my usual bear traps close to my chimney this year as every other year. Although, as has been said many times in TR threads, "you can't prove something doesn't exist", I only have to catch the bastard once. ]:)

by tonythetiger

hope, and love cannot be proven scientifically either, yet I doubt many would argue their existence...

by Member 25348569

Santa Clause as an athromorphic personification of secular Christmas - and therefore an abstract concept similar to love, hope and faith - is not a problem.

Santa Claus as a jolly fat man who delivers presents to the good children of the world? Well, that's pretty damn concrete and therefore a different matter.

Bah! Humbug!

by hal 9000

Hope certainly can be measured scientifically, Love can be described and actually medicated to prevent as it has all the symptoms of a disease.

Faith on the other hand can be slightly harder to quantify. Do I have faith that the sun will rise tomorrow? Yes! Do I have Faith that I'll need to buy fuel for one of the cars when I take it for a drive? Yes!

Do I have an expectation or faith that every Politician will lie to me? HELL YES!!!

Is there a God? Sorry I can't answer that question but I tend to disbelieve in the Christian beliefs as they don't really stack up when looked at closely, I find Buddhist Teachings to be closer to what I believe in, but then again Chairman Mao may have been correct [b]Religion is the Opium of the Masses[/b] and needs to be stamped out for the protection of the masses. From History it certainly seems than most of the wars and major battles have all resulted from some Religious Belief that both sides had [b]God On Their Side and where Right.[/b] That is quite likely the sign of deranged minds at work to justify their silly beliefs. So maybe some forms of Faith are nothing more than Physiological Problems that Manifest themselves in the deranged who gather followers around them.

One thing that I'm sure of is that if the Christian God was to arrive tomorrow and proclaim his rightful place in the Christian World he/she/it would most likely be locked away to protect society from a disturbed person for both our and their own safety.

Interesting thought isn't it?

Col

by hal 9000

The replies may be very embarrassing. :D

Incidentally I'm looking after a couple of geese for the next few days and they are terrified of me as I keep saying Goose Liver Pattie to them whenever I walk past them. Everyone else including my mother who owns them are scared of them as they have a tendency to bite and attack but when I walk into their area they run away and hide from me. It's really funny to watch particularly when someone who is so totally scared of them watches in total disbelief as I walk in and they run away. :^0

Col ]:)

by shellbot

i need a goo dlaugh :)

geese..growing up on a farm i remember having some of those..nasty buggers they were..used to chase me.

I enjoy eating them..a bit of payback..probably why i love turkey so much as well..was attacked several times by ours!!!!!!

sweet sweet revenge ]:)

by Member 25348569

It may be that jd did a nice job of detective work on my suggestion that Santa Claus is an "anthropomorphic personification". This phrase - which means to give an idea or an inanimate object a human personality, and all the things that go along with it - is used by Terry Pratchett of "Discworld" fame to desribe some of his characters - Death, War, etc.

I once quoted one of my favourite Pratchett sayings, "Erotic is what you do with a feather; kinky is what you do with a chicken". Hence the reference.

I'm so far suitably impressed by jd's reasoning and memory but if that's [b]not[/b] what he is saying then I absolutely no idea what he's blathering about.

:D

by shellbot

i don't know about you guys..but I believe in Santa and he always pulls through..

My husband thinks I'm insane, leaving a list for Santa..dropping hints to him on what he should tell santa i want just in case he was to call. I do this as my parents used to talk to santa on the phone, so surely my husband does as well?

For example, for several years now, i get candy and small bits in my stocking, and i always get at least one or two presents marked from Santa under the tree.

If you do not believe..he will not stop at your house!!

Gosh, the year before he even left me one of the Coca Cola Polar Bears..(in the freezer of course..they like the cold don't ya know)

You will read this and just think I'm a nutcase..but maybe i'm just someone who enjoys the fun and games that this time of year brings. The excuse for a second peice of fruitcake and the 4th glass of wine. I get to wrap up bits and give them to my friends and family, in the hopes they feel good that they recieved a present from someone who loves them..i watch Mickeys Christmas Carol and cry when Mickey is slicing a bean for xmas dinner..then i cry when Scrooge McDuck brings a bag of food and toys..

This year I've been hinting at a laptop..a sony..I put it bottom of the list so santa thinks its not that important..but i don't think i will get though..thats ok though..maybe he'll bring some snow

Peace :)

by gadgetgirl

only [b] four [/b] glasses of wine ???

As far as Miracle on 34th Street goes, I'm with you, girl!

:D

GG

by shellbot

the 4 glasses was a bit of a cover up..

but to make up for it, i always have a healthy christmas breakfast..champagne and orange juice..(only when we alone for xmas tho..no kids around) i'm usually hung over by 2 pm, and ready to start another bottle :)

christmas is the only time i really drink anything more than a few...can't stand being hungover

by tig2

You aren't a nutcase. Not even close.

Christmas is for children, and adults that can allow themselves to believe. It is that very special time when we all slow up a bit and take the time to appreciate friends and family. It is the excuse that we seem to need to open our hearts just a bit.

I have been crying over "It's a Wonderful Life" and "A Christmas Carol" for years now. I don't see that changing any time soon.

You can have all of our snow. Fed Ex should do the trick.

Joy of the season to you!

by jdclyde

The old theater up town that doesn't do the serious movies anymore because it couldn't compete with the magaplexes, is now run by the historic society. They do the classics and arty flicks only, and usually for a buck or two.

Drove by there yesterday and saw that on the marque.

Will be taking my boys there this weekend!

by jdclyde

I am not the one doing anything kinky with the chicken!

That is ALL Neil's bad of dreams..... :0

(goes on the tree, don'tchaknow?) ;\

by jdclyde

It is time for you to repost your christmas list of how to avoid a hangover again!

by jamesrl

Four glasses doesn't mean much, especially in a world where you can get oversize brandy snifters that hold nearly a pint.

I will tell again my champagne and orange juice story....be warned...

I selling and acted as the buyer for hardware and software for a small company, and was invited to attend an all day conference. It started at 8 AM, and it was really a series of presentations by software and hardware vendors - they have away prizes and told us about new stuff. There were new presentations every hour.

By the time the last one came up at 5PM, it had already been a long day. My last presentation was Ashton Tate on the new release of dB IV 1.5. They gave us Champagne and OJ (I had a couple), then turned off the lights for a 30 minute powerpoint presentation.

I struggled to stay away. Others behind me lost the struggle, and one even started to snore.

I learned a valuable lesson about marketing that day.

As for alcohol, I indulge in moderation. I never drink more than one and drive that evening. My wife can't drive. So I'm pretty sober, except at home, or when I'm travelling on business and someone else is driving. Even then, I don't indulge like I did in my d=student days, when I didn't have a car and took a bus or a taxi everywhere.

James

by jdclyde

when out with friends, I will average one an hour. of course that means in the first hour I have a FEW, because the last hour I have none.

by gadgetgirl

I [b] must [/b] have a Gordons Gin and Schweppes tonic with lime (no ice!)in my hand by then, or the goose just doesn't cook properly or taste right [i] at all [/i] ! :p

(Where's a spiffy smiley when you need one.....ah....[b] JD!!! [/b])

I assume you're the same as me, Shell - those hints and tips sections that say freeze leftover wine in an ice cube tray... leftover wine....what an oxymoron! :D

GG

by jdclyde

peer me if you have any questions, or want to have me "once over" the layout before you post!


by drowningnotwaving

Dear Santa,

I've been very, very good this year.

Can I please have:

* A middle order with some bottle;
* A 'keeper that keeps; and
* A spinner that spins.

And can I open my pressies a bit early? Please?

:) :)

by hal 9000

I gave you ungrateful Poms all of those 25 years ago and have continued to give you those every year since.

But you Ungrateful Barstewards refuse to select them for your Cricket Team so starting this year I'm not giving you lot any more Presents and I'm taking back those that I've given to you over the last quarter century as you never made use of them. :p

You'll never see [b]The Ashes[/b] again. :D :^0

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

As you have all been naughty little Boys & Girls in the UK for as long as I can remember and I'm now no longer willing to give you what you ask for as a finial gesture of [b]Good Will[/b] I'll post a Link to a description of [b]The Ashes[/b] for all the UK children to see for the very last time.

I'll remove the link when this current Series has finished as you naughty UK Boys & girls have repeatedly thrown my gifts to you back in my face and complained that I never gave you what you actually asked for. Really your Selectors wouldn't know a good Cricket Player if they where hit over the head with a [b]Cricket Bat![/b]

http://tinyurl.com/a56po

You are so ungrateful that I had to alter the outcome of the second test to allow the Australians to win even though they didn't deserve to but your actions have been so naughty that you don't deserve to even have any hope of winning though I did get a good laugh when you thought that you could stand a chance of winning the Second Test and then see your reaction when your team was defeated. :D

Stop blaming the players and start looking at the coaches and selectors to fix your problems though now as I've acted early that is no longer an option. All of the players that I have given you as Christmas presents are now playing for other Commonwealth teams
and the funny thing is that you don't even remember who they where. :)

Col [i]Santa's Helper[/b]

by demo

the weight issue.

Santa of course travels through worm holes AND he can control time.

The use or worm holes solves the problem of Rudolph blowing up.

By controlling time, Santa can make an infinite amount of trips in the 31 hour available AND it also solves the weight problem as he can reload on each return visit.

Pfffft, magic corn ? Come on, get a clue :-P

by Former member

I have seen this argument before. And some qauntum physics geek had a very detailed refutation of it based on the uncertainty principle. Wish I could remember where I saw it...

This discussion is closed to new replies.