Discussion Locked

Why the Constant Arguing

0 helpful
245 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Ok, I have my favorite OS...Windows.

Others have theirs...Linux, MAC, Unix, etc.

Why the constant bickering?

If you don't like my OS, Windows, there are plenty of other choices for you. I don't discount your choice of OS, so why discount my choice?

I've picked my OS that fits my wants and needs the most among other reasons and you've picked yours.

It should stop there. I don't try to "convert" anyone. To each his own.

But the Linux crowd are like a bunch of religious zealots. I'm stupid, uninformed, lazy, dumb, etc if I choose Windows? Why?

If you don't like Windows, don't use it. It's that simple. If you don't like Microsoft, don't buy their products. It's that simple.

But we all have our wants and needs, we all have our strengths and weaknesses. We all make our decisions based on our own situation. Don't prejudge.

What works for me may or may not work for you. That's the beauty here...no one is putting a gun to your head.

245 replies

by tony hopkinson

to talk to the expert.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=189869&messageID=1983205

The constant arguments are down to people like Ernie, there are many on the linux side as well I'll admit.

They tend to make some sense though ?
LOL

By the way MS is constantly trying to put a gun to our heads at least on the pc front.
They don't want alternatives, they don't think alternatives should be available, and they've been extremely successful at achieving their desire.

by mark miller

Typically when I see people make such glowing absolutist statements about an OS I get skeptical: "Is this guy for real?" What gets me is how many get their hackles up and fall for it hook, line, and sinker. Not trying to be superior. I used to fall for it, too.

I agree. I sound like Rodney King sometimes, "Can't we all just get along?" I can remember years ago, before a lot of people were on the internet, people used to have what were called "flame wars" about whose computer was better (not which OS). The acts of superiority and the hurling of insults was the same. The thing that was different was there was no moralizing. There were no accusations of being a $hill, or sheep, or supporting a bad company.

I do get the distinct sense from some Linux/OSS advocates that they insist I join them, and I resent that. Since I'm a developer on Windows/.Net, that's what I see anyway. I'm sure it happens on the other side of the fence as well.

by tony hopkinson

Unless of coure he was really one of our linux loonies making windows afficionados look bad.

LOL

I earn my corn at the moment doing win32 with Delphi, soon possibly to migrate to C# and .NET.

I 've done years on windows, VMS, Linux and HP3000 in mixed environments, I know which box to use to do what.

Try to tell me anyone of them does everything better from an operational point of view and I'll be suspicious to say the least. To avoid suspicion you've got to back up the opinion and I aren't little Billy who just uses MSN, so facts need to be straight and present.

My favourite server OS is VMS but that might be down to familiarity, I'm pretty much a linux advocate now, if it can do the job use it.

However there still are occasions when windows is the better choice, not necessarily from a technical point of view but definitely from an operational one.

Bill didn't go for his office automation integration for a laugh, it's just a pity he had to go for exclusive, when in my opinion inclusive would have given him way more leverage.

by jmgarvin

Being an advocate for FLOSS and Free Software, I have to say that I feel the same way with MS advocates. If I don't join them, I've commited some kind of sin.

I've developed in Windows (I've actually mentioned that I like .Net) and my major beef is generally with the FUD or lack of knowledge. What really gets my back up is the idea that only MS App A can do this task. When a *nix advocate brings up that *nix App B can do the same task, the FUD typically starts.

I think the other point is that when I post that MS has a security flaw, or that I don't like the way something works, I don't know what I'm talking about. However, if I post that FC5 is bloated and buggy (it is btw), then nobody says a thing. Why is that?

by mjd420nova

I've worked with just about every OS to be released, and a few that are propriatory and not available to the public. Each has it's own
adxantages and drawbacks too. I prefer to use what is suited to the hardware best, and have
struggled with each, on different processors
and with different hardware specs. I believe that there are no hard and fast rules for what
works with what, it really comes down to the developers of the MOBO that create this environment and few of them communicate for who
or what they conceived this platform. That's
where we come in, You can't just pick parts
of the shelf and make them work together, well,
sometimes you can, with well educated guesses and
a real eye to the software makers and what specs
they wrote the code to. Too much grey area to
really nail down what does and doesn't work.

by lazerous200

Doesn't it just come down to what OS is easier for the end user to understand and what they want to use use?

by tony hopkinson

The whole point of a GUI was to be intuitive. One of the hardest things about switching to another OS is that your intuition is constantly wrong. Even switching to another version is problematic.

Rememeber when MS changed Find to search and moved it, took weeks for me to break that habit.

The biggest complaint of windows users about linux basically boils down to the function I want isn't where it was so linux kills productivity.

The easiest OS to use is the one you are familiar with. I remember seeing windows and saying this will never catch on, how do you copy a file. I was looking for the command prompt.

Copy myfile.txt hisfile.txt

Easy

by dogknees

It comes down to what will do the required job. That's non-negotiable. Ease of use is great, but you should never sacrifice bit one of the function to get the ease.

This is the same in the argument about web-based development. By all means deliver via the web, but the performance is a requirement.

No amount of ease of use is worth loosing speed and power. You can learn to use anything, but no amount of learning is going to make the slow machine fast.

by jchapple

I was wondering the same thing about a responce you made to one of my other posts.

I own a Ford, so my relatives think I hate GM, but some of my friends think I am anti-Japanese.

I use Windows, and complain about the cost, so I am accused of being a socialist. :-) Then Linux guys hate me. Most of my servers at work are Suse Linux, so the Fedora folks get mad.

The point is most of these decisions were the best choice at the time. I bought the car that I thought would be the cheapest to run with the features I wanted. I bought a Windows PC becuase my wife and child do not understand how to use Linux. i use Suse at work becuase purchasing says I have too.

The next time I have to make these purchases again, it might be the same, it might not. It will depend on the situation. Most likely it will be with what I am familiar with, and as cheap as possible. However, cheap is not alwasys fewest dollars.

I do like having the variety though. I learn some thing about Windows every time I use Linux, and vice versa. I get to see different ways to accomplish the same task. It helps me learn what problem the underlying technology is trying to solve. I especially like the "express" versions of software many companies are putting out. It allows me to play around with the software without having to buy. I can dig in and learn and decide if it is worth pursuing further. I also think it makes competing product better too, so I win in the end anyway you look at it.

by aaron a baker

I have never understood the need to run down people who are not using the same OS as you are.
They are treated "by Some" as if they illiterate morons. After awhile, it becomes downright annoying.
If I choose Windows, and I have" , and, am not in the process of running the Linux user down then why should I have to suffer the consequences of their inability to be civilized.
It's gotten to the point, where If I see the word LINUX, I keep going, because invariably someway, somehow the insults start to fly an so now, we have a fight going. Doesn't matter who started what. There always seems some with the need to put down anybody who isn't "With it" and using Linux.
I beg to differ as I happen to Love my Windows XP. However I would not run down a Linux user based on the fact that they use a different OS.
I would respond to the insults, diarhetic verbosity, innuendoes and anything else they have become expert at throwing, as I don't back down, but I think it's incredibly pathetic and childish to be fighting all the time about "My OS is Better than Yours" tsk tsk Pathetic.
I would much rather we learned from one another, but I won't sit there like a doorknob while some "Linux Type Genius" craps all over us in his/her attempt at seeming far more intellectual than they really are. It's a stupid, childish immature game and it would be lovely to see the people grow up and stop. Then perhaps we could have meaningful discussion on a professional level,regardless of OS.
That would be great ;)
Thank You
Aaron :)

by rkuhn040172

Certain TR members just can't seem to agree to disagree.

Hey, I'll be the first to admit that I've at times become quite irrate and fire back responses too but only because I can't sit back and watch the posts be taken over by the Linux fanatics.

Unfortunately, everytime I do engage in these meaningless arguments, I know I lose. Not because of the argument itself, but because it is a complete waste of my time.

I should be using TR as the valuable resource that it is instead of engaging in flame wars.

I should be reading and learning from TR or even getting back to my old ways of publishing works for other TR members to benefit from.

But instead, it seems like every post becomes a OS war and certain members (who shall remain anonymous) are usually the instigators.

I'm going to try to hold back from now on. But at times, I wish the orginal poster could simple delete those postings from their post that add zero value to the topic at hand.

by absolutely

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=190421&messageID=1959450

If it isn't an OS, you'll argue about something else. I have a preference for Linux in my home, and don't mind using Windows if I'm paid enough to do so, but mostly I engage in a different sort of meaningless arguments. I try to tell myself "it's just hot air, it's not worth my time to type the counterpoint," but I feel this "Invisible Hand" at work and it's so hard not to...

Well, my point, rickk, is that I can empathize.

"I should be using TR as the valuable resource that it is instead of engaging in flame wars."

I wish you luck beating your habit.

by rkuhn040172

But it is a little past 3:30am here (Indiana) and grant it we just had daylight savings time, but our posts are listed as 4/1/06.

Shouldn't that be 4/2/06?

Makes me curious, what time zone is this TR server in? Where is it located? Is the time on it set correctly?

Even if it is west coast (3 hour time difference), it should still say 4/2/06.

Interesting or did I miss something?

by hal 9000

To a little coral atoll just your side of the IDN so no one can get at it. :^0

That's why you see the date differently as it's still several hours behind you and if it was 3 miles to the West it would show up as a day later than what the time zone you are in is. :p

Col ]:)

by absolutely

Aaron Baker: "I have never understood the need to run down people who are not using the same OS as you are....I beg to differ as I happen to Love my Windows XP. However I would not run down a Linux user based on the fact that they use a different OS.
I would respond to the insults, diarhetic verbosity, innuendoes and anything else they have become expert at throwing, as I don't back down, but I think it's incredibly pathetic and childish to be fighting all the time about "My OS is Better than Yours" tsk tsk Pathetic.
I would much rather we learned from one another, but I won't sit there like a doorknob while some "Linux Type Genius" craps all over us in his/her attempt at seeming far more intellectual than they really are. It's a stupid, childish immature game and it would be lovely to see the people grow up and stop."

I'm not familiar with this stereotype of a Linux user, and you haven't cited any sources, so I'll just pretend to believe, within the confines of this discussion thread, that you have honestly described [b]all of your[/b] experiences with "Linux Type Geniuses". My impression of your message, FWIW, is that you give as bad as you get, but that instead of advocating for a computer operating system, you are a zealot for manners. Your insulting message exhibited all the distasteful characteristics that the same message attributed to Linux users, I consider it unlikely that you really are any more civilized toward them than you say that they are toward you.

by jmgarvin

While I do prefer XP for some tasks, typicially my complaint with Windows is their total lack of stability, scalability, and security.

However, from your post it seems you are no better than those you disagree with. Typically, Linux users will have sane discussions with those that bring up technical points rather than the touchy feely or FUD that we typically see.

'Course, other TR users (like Abs) and I will fight from time to time, but I still like the guy. Sure, I'll get frustrated that he won't see how wrong he is ;-), but all in all no hard feelings. We are just talking about the field we all love.

On that note: I hate you...not because of your post, but because you got that damn Tom Petty song in my head..."I won't back down"

by absolutely

...until [b]you[/b] put it in ""! GARVIN!!!

"No hard feelings" is mutual. If you ever want to borrow the blinders that help me to not "see how wrong he is", just PM me, I'll be happy to sell you a pair!

;)

by fsngs2

This is it in a nutshell guys.

My personal preference is Novell SuSE, because I have had only good experience from Novell, and because I like the practicality of the operating system itself. Linux is okay on it's own, but I do not dig deeper than I need to to fix problems. I use all other operating systems, because my objective, as a technical support person, is to meet the needs of the end user, not to be the best "linux h4xx0rz" ever. There are many professionals on every side, but it's not the professionals that fight. Do you guys see Linux Torvalds here bickering? Do you see the CEO of Novell saying that everybody else sucks? Sure, these guys are aiming at MS's throat, but they do not waste time with petty bickering.

Put in a nutshell, all this bickering could be put into more productive means, like being the best **** tech you can be.

Anyhow, that's just my take on life,
--Nick Schmidt

by dawgit

could it be that we're all just a bunch of over-grown kids (at heart anyway) playing in an electronic sandbox, with super-charged electro toys? I agree, that sometimes it sounds like mindless bickering, when someone is being criticle (not always a bad thing). We should all remember, critisism, only when constructive, is benificial.
I also have to say, it's easy, when one has a way that works, to just comment: 'Do it my way, and it will work.' I think we ALL have done that at one time or another.
... and grow-up -- NEVER.!. Older is wiser, yes, use a little maturity, yes. But we all need a kids sense of adventure. (and a little humor)
...just my 2 cents. :-) -d

by rkuhn040172

If the TR server is either screwed up time/date wise or indeed it is in a foreign (not US) country.

The only way it is in the US based on last night is either it is 1) time/date screwed up 2) floating in the Pacific ocean or 3) in Hawaii.

If it is #3, I'm getting my resume ready as we speak.

by hal 9000

Being a mistake as it's on Mainland USA but I could have a nice holiday at Hawaii.

I have a friend who lives there so I wouldn't even need to pay for accommodation. And it's about the right time of the year to be there as well. :D

Col

by hal 9000

The best tool for the job that I'm currently working on and when it comes to OS's that can be anything that is best for the customers needs.

There is no [b]Perfect[/b] OS and there never will be, but saying that I can still grumble about MS and their products without meaning to bash them over the head as some take it anyway. I see shortcomings in every OS it's just a matter of which tool best fits the job in hand at the time and that can vary from job to job.

As I think that this entire thread was started because of at best a badly worded thread about USB2 or it may have been a outright Flame of MS but I chose to take it as just a poorly worded question that was posted in the [b]Heat of the Moment[/b] when a solution appeared not to be forthcoming to a penitential very real problem that has arisen from MS policy.

Some may have read it differently but I read it the way that I read it and I'm sure that others read it the way that they wanted to see things. But honestly it was very badly worded and could be taken in many ways.

The things that gets to me is the way the [b]True Believers[/b] on any side just have to insist that theirs is the better option when really there is no [b]Perfect Solution.[/b]

The best that we can hope for is to have a reliable fairly secure network that isn't adversely affected every time that a new piece of nasty code is released onto the net and infects hundred of thousands of machines and is replicating out of control so we have to push through patches to avoid becoming infected without the proper testing.

Col

by hal 9000

As [b]She Who Must Be Obeyed[/b] will not let me anywhere near that State. She knows me far too well and knows that I'll not do any work but pay visits to all the Hot Up places that sell the bits that I'm constantly buying from the US to feed my habit. ;)

I can get away with crashing her car and the next day buying 8K worth of M'Board & CPU's for a test rig but there is [b]No Way[/b] I'm allowed anywhere near CA under any circumstances. It's a good thing that I'm not interested in Hot Up Parts for the Classic Mercedes that I constantly buy her so I can get away with spending money for my own play toys and allowing her to think that she owns them. :^0

But there are just too many VW and Ducati places in CA that I would spend days in and spend way too much money.

Col

by dawgit

I didn't know they had offices in Europe. Thanks. (I also never thought to look either) Now, I wonder if they have coffee for members........

by absolutely

You didn't think European office workers commuted to the Untied States every day, did you?

j/k, I understood what you meant, but I thought my first impression was amusing too

please enjoy

by ebeck

I wish this had been posted on another day than 4/1! But I completely agree. I use whatever I can get my hands on for the need, and focus on getting the job done. Competition can be healthy, but it would do us all much good to collaborate - to improve MS vs. Nix, instead of polarizing the masses. The more the brands compete, the better it will be for all of us.

by cg it

The next best selling [which equates to $$]word processor program, spreadsheet program, browser, is hard to create on a Windows platform because Microsoft also creates the same thing. Difficult to compete with a company that not only makes the O/S but all the productivity software that users use. That's what the EU is all in a twist about. $$.

Programmers like to use Linux, Unix, etc that provide them a O/S platform that they can create their own programs on, in the hopes of selling the thing. MS DOS provided such a platform back in the "good ole days" before Windows. Back then there were 3 or 4 competing word processing programs [WordPerfect, Display Writer, WordStar, MS Word,] today, the world uses MS Word. Lotus 123 was the spreadsheet program in the days of DOS. Everyone used it, but there were other ones. Boeing created their own called BoeingCalc.

Windows 95, then 98 and on up to XP allowed the average Joe User to own a computer and not be a nerd.

Windows is successful for that reason. The average Joe can own a computer,install software, surf the net and not have to understand how a computer works to get it to work.

by rkuhn040172

Ever wonder why MA is suing Walmart because they don't offer stellar health insurance to their employees but yet we are now engaged in a debate over immigration where most of the illegals coming here get zero health insurance and below minimum wage?

The politicans are asking us to have a "humane" debate and treat them with dignity and respect, yet we are really just opening the flood gates so that millions of Mexicans can come here and get used and abused by businesses.

Aren't we really just letting them come here and become citizens just so we don't have to feel as bad when they go to work everyday in their sweatshops.

Ever notice that the NBA, NCAA, NFL, or MLB never get sued for being a monoply?

About a year ago, the debate in the US was about a "living wage". How quickly we drop that and move onto the exploitation of "guest workers".

This world is sick, man.

by absolutely

CG IT: "Windows is successful for that reason. The average Joe can own a computer,install software, surf the net and not have to understand how a computer works to get it to work."

Whether they're nerds or some other category, people are stealing your identity. Why would you be willing to use a computer without understanding how it works?

by rkuhn040172

We all use products everyday that are just as important as a computer in our daily lives and most have no clue how they work.

Aside from just the very basics, I don't have a clue how a microware truly works, I only have a very rudimentary understanding of cars, and do you really think that most accountants know what makes a calculator work?

There are millions of knowledge workers around the globe that use products every day that don't require an understanding of the product itself.

Your question was swallow at best.

by hal 9000

IN the DOS days I just set up a 286 which was the latest thing at the time ran DR DOS on it and placed a menu system that loaded when the computer booted up.

She could then pick from Word Processor e-mail or whatever with out a problem but since I've moved her to 98 she can not understand why she has to click on the [b]Start Button[/b] to shut the thing down and no longer uses a computer for anything at all I have to go over there and do anything that she wants done now. I'm considering moving her P3 back to DOS and leave her to is as she understands how to work it even if she doesn't have a clue as to how it works or what is what as she constantly calls the Monitor the Computer as it is what she sees everything on so to her at least that is the important part of the entire thing. :^0

But now she is 78 years old I'm not expecting any change and I'm not willing to move her to XP as the change would be too much for her and she doesn't need all the [b]Eye Candy[/b] as currently she doesn't even use the computer her two grandchildren from my sister get more use out of it than she ever will.

Col

by hlhowell9

Like many others here I have programmed on a variety of systems, including Windows (in the past), but in the mid nineties, M/S seems to have decided to lock us all out of the competition.

Their documentation disintegrated, their programming packages grew unhelpful wizards with code bloat that made determining how to fix problems and where to fix them a real puzzle to solve.

I have enough trouble with my own code (lots of AI, graphics, DSP and so forth). Windows doubles or quadruples my work effort to get simple code working. About a year ago I had the last straw.

It took me nearly three days to port a DSP routine from a UNIX C code to VB code. Not because my code was bad, but because the darn system rebooted no less than once every 20 minutes. This was in VBA under Excel.

It was the last straw for me. I love programming, working out new tools to do difficult jobs, ensuring my code is repeatable, dependable and generally fail safe. So to have to put my craft in such an environment makes my work look less than robust. Ergo, I look bad when the problems are not of my own making. Worse there is almost no way to figure out simply where to optimize such code as VBA. I could port the routine in C, except Microsoft makes the interface so awkard that it slowed down the runtime pathetically.

I had to deliver it in VB, and even after the third day of tracing the faults and coding around the system deficiencies, I still did not have confidence that it would run reliably.

Thanks but no thanks. That was my last piece of professional programming in Windows. However I still use windows for some things, but I am reconsidering so that I need only have one OS and machine for future personal development and growth.

Regards,
Les H

by rkuhn040172

Most OS's distros, whether Linux or Windows, that are widely distrubuted, are buggy and bloated.

Yes, there are alot of Linux exceptions.

But most commonly used OS's are extremely bloated as they attempt to be everything to everyone.

It is a common problem with MS and Linux.

And both are typically buggy because both are created by humans and humans aren't perfect.

by absolutely

Careful, you kiss apotheon's butt with that mouth!

Microwaves, cars and calculators are not networked, thus cannot help thieves steal your identity.

Your answer was irrelevant, ignored the crucial reason to understand a computer before using it for anything of personal importance, and only reduced my opinion of you.

by absolutely

Windows looks like a television program, and a cartoon at that.

DOS looks like a [b]computer[/b] should.

More importantly, DOS could [b]compute![/b] Windows are just for peering, and too oftern, breaking.

by kron

We seem to have all this anti-MS on MS PC - that says alot.

Simply fix - no fret - get your fixing at Ebay - MSDOS - I am sure you can it for pennies on the dollar now - Linux - heck just download it, Apple - go pick one, Unix - go build - what?s all the fret. I am sure Billy wonders why anti-MS people fret at his products while he buys a pina colada with the last purchase of XP from a linux user.

Thank goodness for Ebay and pina coladas

by hal 9000

You've completely lost me there but just for your information MS still sells DOS I buy a couple of copies per year for some specialist work that required DOS.

As far as buying MS DOS from E Bay goes that would be breaching the MS EULA which I for one am unwilling to do but I suppose that you aren't the slightest bit concerned about MS taking you to court for Piracy are you?

I however lack the time and inclination to do this particularly as I don't need to upset MS at all as it would ruin the relationship that I have with many of their techs who ring me when they run into a unsolvable problem for a quick work around.

I just fail to see how you can take the above as an attack on MS when it's all about how a single end user sees how a system works and can understand one buy not another so she doesn't use the supposedly better option.

Perhaps you would care to enlighten me on that issue.

Col

by absolutely

"I am sure Billy wonders why anti-MS people fret at his products while he buys a pina colada with the last purchase of XP from a linux user."

Tee-hee-hee, good one! Yes, I've also bought a couple of Windows, but I prefer Linux. And to be completely honest, I don't mind at all that it looks like a Macintosh, or a certain famous Macintosh clone, it does make installation & configuration simpler, but unfortunately blurs the difference between computer and toaster. I'd rather marvel at the mega- or giga-flops per second crunching numbers than whine that I have too few of them for the latest video game. You may think this makes me ungrateful, I don't care: I appreciate pina coladas, but for all I care you can stick eBay where the sun don't shine.

by nighthawk808

And you can even make it print the words in pretty colors!

At least with DOS, when your program crashed, you were already at the command line. The difference between Windows 3.1 and Windows XP is that when 3.1 crashed, all I had to do was type "win" and press enter. When XP crashes, it takes a whole reboot (and sometimes two) to get a desktop back.

by oz_media

These diecussion forums are a place of often heated and very passionate debates, that's what they are here for. You make a 'claim'and then publicly welcome others to comment on your feelings, that's just the way it is, unless you wish to contest and support your own claims.

The opposite would be disasterous. Who wants to read a thread where everyone just agrees with the initial post? Where's the discussion/debate/meat and potatoes in that?

If you can't stand the heat, stay out of the kitchen.

by oz_media

Sorry but I don't need such friends anyway. My friends don't whine, they just get it done.

It's no worse than all the idiots who come here and complain that they haven't worked in two years because their job was outsourced. Who f****n cares? Get another job doing something else if nobody will hand you a job. Not trained for anything else? You should have considered that when you wasted thousands and years on IT training. I just have no patience for victims, sorry. There are those who succeed and there are those who are always 'victims' of something. Victims are usually quite vocal about their own ideas until they are contested, then everyone else is just being mean for not lapping up their thoughts like hungry puppies.

No time for pus*ies in my world, 'kin whiners!

by amberhaze

Personally, I use Linux about 80% and Windows about 20% but professionally, it is probably the other way around... although a majority of my new server installs tend to be LINUX.

My point? Different OS's have different strengths and weaknesses. I don't care how perfect something is designed, it will never be ideal for all situations.

Yes I am generally an advocate for LINUX since I see many situations where it would be a more appropriate choice, but is overlooked because of MS advertising / predominance. On the other hand, I have also seen Linux being used when a Windows server would have been more appropriate.

My bottom line, I try to take a step back and be truely objective in every situation. Do I succeed? Not always, but I do try.

by jmgarvin

The my toaster doesn't store personal information, and neither do any of your examples.

The second people realize that a computer is not a typical appliance, is the second people realize they have to KNOW something about them.

by hal 9000

Currently computers are sold as appliances in the white goods section of the hypermarkets and to the general public at least they are in the same department as a toaster so they are treated as such.

The number of times that I've had to rescue an old computer from being thrown out because it's no longer the top model or doesn't play the games that the owner wants is amusing particularly when they have been doing their banking on the same machine and just have no idea of what is on the HDD.

When Windows 95 Hit the streets the knowledge of the end users plummeted to new lows and with each subsequent release of Windows there is less knowledge required to use the things.

One of the best examples that I've run across was here on the TQ&A section where someone was asking for help as they where trying to reload their computer and it keep going to the same screen and formatting the HDD then loading the necessary drivers and on the reboot they kept pressing any key and ended up exactly where they started off and couldn't understand why it wasn't loading XP. :^0

While initially I did get a laugh I then began to wonder just how little that this person actually knew and why they where using a computer in the first place. :(

When you see people like this around it's hard to understand how they maintain their identity not how they get their identity stolen. ;)

Col ]:)

by rkuhn040172

Think that the more people use computers the better.

Yes, there needs to be a more organized effort at educating them, but that is our job isn't it?

But no, I don't think that end users need to be all that educated. Your opinion is biased by the fact you work in this industry.

An end user needs to know no more than is necessary to get their job done and done securely.

Sure, I'd love to train everyone to a greater depth. But that isn't going to happen.

The best we can hope for is some minimal amount that is enough to get the job done, stay relatively secure, etc.

You've got to remember that a computer is the means to an end and not the end itself.

by kron

Sure, let me start by saying my software is licensed and yes I do care about being taken to court. I didn't take the above as attack so my apologies if I came off as ranting. My point is based on your second to last sentence.

There is a lot of chatter in both direction and maybe more in one way than the other, but why, when the better option is solely left up to the user not the other guy.

by kron

Exactly - Toasters rule the day - I rather crunch a toasty sandwich than byte on a bit ;)

by nighthawk808

Oh, wait, that happens all the time. Here's a condensed typical Linux discussion:

"SuSE's better than Debian!
"Oh yeah? Well, Debian's better than RedHat!"
"Screw you. Mandriva sucks."

And on and on.... And the M$ people think we're only hard on them. They haven't even seen the flame war that would follow the line "GNOME sucks! KDE is the One and Only True window manager!"

You're right about Fedora, jmgarvin. I dropped RedHat like a hot potato after the way they handled spinning off Fedora. Their attitude seemed to be something like "We're taking our ball and going home. But since that stupid GPL says we have to keep the source code public, we'll toss you hippies a bone called Fedora. Go away now. Oh, BTW, do you mind if we incorporate all your improvements into RHEL? Too bad--we're going to anyway. You get to be our programmers AND beta testers." Novell handled OpenSuSE much more professionally.

Microsoft isn't the only company Linux users have problems with. How about Mandriva firing Gael Duval? There were a lot of Linux geeks unhappy about that.

So stop acting persecuted, M$ users. We're harder on fellow Linux geeks than we are on you. But, unlike you, we don't take it as a challenge to our manhood just because someone posts something negative about what OS we use. We actually enjoy heated debates and often even go so far as to (gasp!) try the distro that the other person is talking about!

How many M$ users have used Linux? 10%? 20%?
How many Linux users have used Windows? 99.9%?
Perhaps we feel the need to comment on your OS because we've ACTUALLY USED IT. I've used Windows for 15 years and I work in an all-Windows shop right now.

And most of us--myself included--are willing to admit that Linux isn't perfect. I myself have called SuSE a "jumbled, unintuitive clusterfsck", and that's my distro of choice! And, believe it or not, I actually changed my mind and admitted I was wrong about that later on! Have you ever heard of such a thing? Oh, the humanity!

by jmgarvin

:-) (ok, I haven't used SuSe for a few years, but it was...uh...very...European ;-) I do like how YaST works though)

Ok, now that I have THAT off my chest...I think the MS camp is so used to yes men, that they can't see past the fact that we aren't bashing, but we are complaining that IT CAN BE DONE BETTER!

Sure, AD has come a long way...sure MS has made Win2k3 more secure, but there is still a LOT to do. Let me also be the 23495739859734 to say:
MICROSOFT YOU NEED TO STOP FRIGGIN' INTEGRATING CRAP INTO YOUR OS! Not only does that add to the insecurity, but it kills the whole concept of modularity.

by joe mctroll

Sorry, I just couldn't resist it...

Ah! If feels much better now... You 2 guys are right, we Linux advocates tend to be harder on each other... And right, we tend to take a personal look on the other's OS much more so than MacOS or Win guys... but - hell!!! Who said life was fair?
I can only remember last time I was flamed when I expressed my real personal opinion on a news group, something like "Firefox is crap. Opera is nearly perfect, if only it were libre software..."
Or last time I said "In fact, I prefer OpenBSD (or FreeBSD) to Linux, but I have to use it..." Men, THOSE are flamewars!!!

by nighthawk808

Linus Torvalds himself uses SuSE at home, so if you want to argue with the 800-pound gorilla of Linux, you're a lamer and a retard. So there. I showed you! I'm sick and tired of you Gentoo fanatics shoving it down our throats--get a life!

(Just kidding, jmgarvin. You may be a lamer, but you're no retard. :) )

As for Active Directory--isn't that just yet another M$ "extension" of something that existed for years before them (in a better implementation, too), namely Novell's Directory Services? Which itself was based on LDAP which was based on X.500.... (That sounds pretty biblical, doesn't it?)

To Microsoft, "modularity" means that when one module crashes, so do the rest of them. It's one of the reasons you have to reboot a Windows box every freaking time you apply even the tiniest update. There is no reason at all why a patch to Windows Media Player should require a reboot! I updated amaroK last week and it didn't require anything more involved than clicking "Finish".

Replace the word "Gentoo" with the word "Linux" in the fourth sentence of the opening paragraph, and you get the most common argument seen from Windows users. Of course, the spelling and punctuation isn't usually so good, but you get the point.

by nighthawk808

I remembered that one of the funniest things I've ever heard about any distro was something recent on Slashdot. Just for you, jmgarvin, I dug it up:
http://linux.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=06/03/15/217259&from=rss

From madaxe42:
"What about Gentoo? Wonderful community. And you end up with plenty of time to get to know them all, while you wait for it to build!"

Seriously, though, Gentoo is actually next on my list of distros to play with when I get time. And after that: Linux From Scratch (AKA "I love pain").

by nighthawk808

You'd be perfect for those missions where you go into a country and get two sides fighting each other so the US can come in and install the dictator they wanted in the first place. You really know which buttons to push.

I'd have to agree on Opera. I started using it around 1999, and it had features then that Firefox still doesn't have (like sessions, so in case it does crash or you simply want to close it for a while, you can pick right back up where you left off). It's funny that you mention it, though. Just today I started using it again for the first time in a couple of years. I had forgotten how much I liked it. It's still the "fastest browser on Earth" after all these years.

I think one of the reasons we look at our OS more personally is because we can make each OS uniquely ours. Linux is so flexible and customizable that two people are very unlikely to have their box set up the same way. But Windows XP is Windows XP is Windows XP.

by jmgarvin

I'm a retard too...I've comes to terms with that ;-)

Linus is an idiot...uh...wait...hmmmmm...uh...well...hmmm. SuSe still sucks! ;-)

Ya, AD is really just building on Novell Directory Services...Though in Win2k3 they did extend some of what it could do and clean up some of the mess they made with Win2k.

Ya, my dad can beat up your dad is just silly. Typically MS advocates say: MS is just better, but when you try to pin them down on WHAT is better, you get nothing in return.

by nascargirl9

Great choice of questions!

I'd love to know the answer to that one myself. I'm a Windows user, an older 98SE user, and I love it. I've used other OS's in my time, but prefer Windows over-all thus far. Maybe it's because I am use to it and know my way around. Maybe it's because this is what I used at my job. Windows, to me, is kind of like an 'old shoe', it fits, it's comfortable and why get rid of it if I like it so well.

In my experience, Windows is widely used and by more people (at least where I come from it is). Windows has different versions, Profesional for 2000, XP, etc. and people have many choices, so that makes it nice. Since I do not use Linux and the others, I really don't keep up with the choices anymore. But, as you said, we (you & I and millions of others) aren't cramming our OS preference down anyone's throats, so why are they doing it to us? Doesn't make sense at all.

The only thing I can take a stab at is that many people are anti-Gates/anti-Microsoft, so in return, they are anti-Windows. That still doesn't mean Windows is a bad OS, even though it contains bugs, show us an OS that doesn't! (lol) Same goes for browsers. People use IE, Opera, Firefox, Advanced, etc. and so many try to shove their choice down our throats the same way they try with the OS. Almost like a religion, isn't it!?

We will probably never know why some feel they must "push" things at us. Again, I am in total agreement with you..leave us to ours and we'll leave them to theirs. ;)

Again, great post!

by tony hopkinson

must make walking everywhere a lot less of a problem.
LOL

You got it backwards by the way many people are anti windows so therefore they are anti MS/gates.
Many people are anti windows because they feel it is full of bugs and it is a bad OS. After all few of us know Bill or work directly for MS , most know windows very well though.

All OS's do indeed have bugs. You make your choice on the sort of bugs you tolerate and I'll make mine.

As long as you don't start quoting MS FUD that says what I feel is a bug is either unimportant or worse a desirable feature that I'd be stupid not to take advantage of, you are as welcome to your choice of OS as I am to mine.

I don't argue with people because they think windows is great.

I argue with people because they think integrating a browser into the OS was a good idea technically.

I argue with people who describe windows as a multi user OS.

I argue with people who think the user experience of activeX on the web makes the security nightmare of client side execution of foreign code palatable.

Anybody who wants to state why I'm wrong is quite welcome to. Hell, maybe I am, it would n't be the first time.

However the chorus of MS's company song, a Redmond press release or "it just is" are not arguing the point.

by rkuhn040172

Not trying to convert anyone, just counterpoints:

1) Years ago when the internet was a much more kindler and gentle place, integrating the browser did make sense. It now doesn't and they are working on that...Vista. Yes, horribly late, but nonetheless.

2) How is Win XP not a multi user OS? Standalone or domain, we have accounts and security priviledges too. Yes, it is flawed compared to Linux, but nonetheless that shoe fits most users needs.

3) Active X was a good idea back in the kindler and gentler web days. Not now, and I think MS is trying to move away from it.

At home, I manage 4 servers, 2 laptops and 2 desktops not counting neighbors (hooked into my network...add 4 more PC's). Not one piece of malware (serious malware) in 2 1/2 years. Windows can be made secure.

At work, I manage close to 100 PC's and 14 servers. No cases of serious malware since I've been there (1 1/2 years).

The doom and gloom that Linux users claim about Windows just isn't the case if Windows environments are properly setup, managed and maintained. Period.

by mark miller

Re: "What really gets my back up is the idea that only MS App A can do this task. When a *nix advocate brings up that *nix App B can do the same task, the FUD typically starts."

I can sort of relate. I think it has to do with using a minority platform, by which I mean a minority platform for certain tasks. Unix machines are generally regarded as servers, not desktop systems. You've shown a template of how the argument usually goes, but I suspect that you're saying, "Hey look, I can use Unix like a desktop platform," which is generally viewed with incredulity and derision. My last experience with Unix, as it has been for most people, was one where the machine was sitting in a server room, and people logged in from a telnet session on different machines, typing commands at a command line. This is adequate for doing server work, but not for running productivity applications. Again, in a lot of cases the client machines are not running X clients.

Many years ago I was an Atari ST user. Back when I used to see the "my computer is better than yours" flame wars, I often used to see PC and Amiga users rag on ST users about how it was inferior for one reason or another. I used to talk about how the ST did some things well, but was largely ignored outside of other ST users. I think other computer users didn't understand what I was talking about. One reason behind this is I was resourceful. I would find useful utilities on BBSes or the internet. I would shop at mail order stores for certain applications I needed, and I saw ads and reviews for applications that worked with it. So I generally knew what I could get done on it. Other ST users did too. Non-ST users knew little of this. The best they could tell it was a "game machine". When I pointed out that it did desktop publishing well (I had read about it), I usually got no response, or a more detailed challenge from someone who used desktop publishing, which I couldn't answer because I didn't know the answer.

It was frustrating, but I think their response indicated that what I was saying was irrelevant. Any response saying that my platform did something well was like asking them to switch, which they weren't going to do. They had their reasons. I think like schoolboys they just wanted to pick on somebody, or perhaps they wanted retribution from getting picked on themselves. I eventually found out Amiga and PC users were getting picked on frequently by Mac users. And Mac users were getting picked on by NeXT users. It was a friggin' pecking order!

I had a similar experience once. I found a newsgroup called alt.fan.cobol, or something like that, and I have to admit seeing the dialog on there was funny. It seemed the whole purpose of the group was to pick on the language, which I didn't mind, because I had tried COBOL a bit and didn't like it. There were supporters for it as well, who tried to defend it, like I did my ST, but I found myself agreeing with the people who were making fun of it.

What I used to find occasionally was that Linux users who were picking on Windows were doing it because they felt isolated, and they felt they knew better than everyone else. They had the feeling they knew THE TRUTH, and were shouting it from some tower or dungeon they were locked up in by ignoramuses. I found a few people who willing to admit that they were the single Linux user/administrator in an office full of Windows users. I gotta admit that sounds pretty isolating, and I can sympathize with their feeling that their "birds of a feather" were on the internet, not where they were physically.

Re: "I think the other point is that when I post that MS has a security flaw, or that I don't like the way something works, I don't know what I'm talking about."

Well, you might not. If you've been off of a platform for a while things can change. I've seen that with Windows. Windows 9x had gaping security holes mainly because there was no security infrastructure. That's changed with Win2000 and WinXP. Now it has a security infrastructure that's similar to Unix. So it's possible that even though a vulnerability exists, one can protect oneself by using these security features. WinXP has one fatal flaw in that it puts users into an administrator account by default. So it takes some knowledge to protect oneself.

Re: "However, if I post that FC5 is bloated and buggy (it is btw), then nobody says a thing. Why is that?"

If you posted it in a Windows forum, the others reading it probably said to themselves, "Figures." What have you seen if you've said that in a Linux forum? Or are you saying that WAS the response in the Linux forum, and that other people didn't try to defend it, because they agreed with you?

by tony hopkinson

until "security infrastructure similar to unix".

That particular similarity is dreadfuly misleading. 2003 was certainly an improvement, but while things like graphics and web browsers are built in to the 'kernel' that similarity of interface is effectively meaningless.

An exploit in say ooh WMF exposes the entire system no matter what the security context of the program that wished to render it has. Apparently they are beefing it up further for vista.

There's little benefit in saying User A can only run this program, when this program can do what the hell it likes and that's where the vulnerability is.
Just been reading that Linux had to build graphics into it's Kernel to use NVidia cards. Just a big red flag on that purchase, without some investigation.

A lot more redesign needed to separate kernel and user space in windows I'm afraid, when they do, then the similarity will be meaningful.

by mark miller

Re: "while things like graphics and web browsers are built in to the 'kernel' that similarity of interface is effectively meaningless.

An exploit in say ooh WMF exposes the entire system no matter what the security context of the program that wished to render it has."

This is the first time I've heard that. Have you seen this in action?

Yes, I was saying "similar to Unix" because you can set up security contexts that limit rights. I've been running programs that access the internet under limited accounts for about as long as I've been running XP. I'm sure it helps, but what you say is interesting news to me. The people I've heard about who have run XP and have gotten infected by some hack on the internet have been running everything as administrator. I haven't gotten infected once, to my knowledge. Since I've been running XP almost daily since 2002, and access the internet just as often I find it hard to believe that I've just been lucky.

by mark miller

Re: "It's no worse than all the idiots who come here and complain that they haven't worked in two years because their job was outsourced. Who f****n cares? Get another job doing something else if nobody will hand you a job."

I liked this discussion. Seems like people hardly ever ask the question.

I agree with you about the unemployment rants. I know some of it is just to blow off steam. But I've seen some others who find a cause in it, and that's where I get off the train. They want to unionize and all that crap. They complain about how the executives are fattening themselves at the expense of everyone else. What they don't get is that these things are the privileges of ownership and management. They just WISH things were different, but they never are, and never will be. They won't understand until they're fortunate enough one day to own or control a valuable asset or resource.

by tony hopkinson

I do own a valuable resource, me. I checked the patents copyrights and the deeds. They're all owned by ME.

Everybody else owns their own me as well.

There are some halfwits who think they don't, you are welcome to them.

by mark miller

Re: "I do own a valuable resource, me. I checked the patents copyrights and the deeds. They're all owned by ME.

Everybody else owns their own me as well."

I wasn't even in the vicinity of impugning people's sense of self worth. What I was talking about was this idea people have that they're entitled to a job, especially a particular job at a particular pay rate. They're not. It's up to us to find our own talents and then use them. Once we do, someone will find those talents valuable, and we can trade our talents for money.

Employers are not in the business of dispensing love and acceptance, if that's what you're getting at. Hopefully we'll have good working experiences, but it's not about benevolence. It's about working towards a common goal: to add value to each other's lives.

What I meant by owning an asset or resource was owning a business and needing to hire employees. Or owning a home or apartment building and wanting to rent it out. Or it could even be something small like a 2-bedroom apartment and the tenant wants to find a roommate. Once you're the one picking who you will associate with to share in that asset or resource, your point of view changes. Now instead of trying to get access to those resources, you're trying to pick good people to share that resource with, because the consequences of picking people who are not compatible with you tends to be bad.

Re: "There are some halfwits who think they don't, you are welcome to them."

Yeah there are some employers around the world who like to treat their employees like slaves. Personally I don't condone that kind of treatment. I wasn't even going there. Your loss.

by rkuhn040172

The last time I rebooted a Windows box was setting up a new PC for someone.

I installed 27 new updates and rebooted once.

What was your point?

by rkuhn040172

If IE had sessions you'd call it a security threat...it remembers and knows what you were doing.

If Opera does it, it's a convenience feature.

If no two people have the same Linux configuration, boy, that'd work out nicely in a corporate environment now wouldn't it?

by nighthawk808

You are so full of s--t that your eyes are brown. If you can send me an unedited video of you installing Windows XP from scratch and bringing it up to a full patch level and rebooting only once, I will personally send you $20. Considering I just installed Windows XP on a new machine less than a month ago, I know you are outright lying.

What, you think that because I use Linux to get things done that I've never installed Windows? My God, man, don't insult my intelligence by thinking I would buy that "I didn't have to reboot" crap. Did you miss the part in my profile about me being a Microsoft Certified Professional?

by nighthawk808

Or are you really this clueless, rickk? Either way, you're not making Windows's case any stronger.

Post edited to insert guilty party's name.

by rkuhn040172

Move to Houston...

I hear they'll take you in. Once there, you can bitch and complain, get free housing, free debit cards, vote in two States, have your house rebuilt even though you lack insurance, and don't forget...Democrats will take care of you.

Or, move to New Orleans. Instead of a free apartment, I hear you can shack up in a cruise ship!

by tony hopkinson

Not a good idea that. You might want to access the profile option a bit more often.
Oz doesn't work in IT, it works for him.
LOL

I can see an unload coming at you. Hope you've got a thick skin, I've a feeling the fella's going to cross the boundary from irritated towards quite annoyed.

by rkuhn040172

Weren't directed towards OZ.

They were directed towards the people who complain about losing their IT jobs.

I was agreeing with him.

by rkuhn040172

I didn't say I only had to reboot one time to have it fully patched.

I said I installed 27 patches and it required one reboot.

Including SP2 on XP, and I could be wrong, I think only 3-4 reboots are required if you select them in the proper order.

by rkuhn040172

You might has well send me the $20.

At work and at home, I do slipstream updates and patches in as well as image.

Ok, so that might be cheating but you said it couldn't be done.

Also, I did check out your profile Mr MCP. Your certs are all the easy ones: A+, Network+, i-Net+, Security+, Server+ and MCP.

Let's see, all the CompTia's take maybe one day of review for anyone in our field to pass and the A+ and Network+ combined, or the A+ and Security+ combined, or the A+ and Server+ combined equals one Microsoft elective which I think(?) qualifies one as a MCP (passing only one Microsoft test).

Your resume is as bloated as Windows and Linux are. Lots of pretty abbreviations but no real meat and potatoes.

Your only hope is good though. Your real world experience does seem to be impressive.

by tony hopkinson

Lets hope he reads it the way you meant it, not the way I thought you meant it.

Projection.

It's not real Tony, remember that.

Not real....

by jmgarvin

1) Vista will still integrate IE into the OS. However, IE will run in "protected mode." What that means? IE is still integrated.
http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2006/02/the_new_interne.html

2) No, multi-user. You cannot log in as two seperate users SIMULTANEOUSLY. The problem is that it isn't multi-user. Windows doesn't properly track or user kernel tools to be multi-user.

3) There was never a kinder gentler web. ActiveX was MS's way of trying to kill off Java. I doubt MS is trying to move away from ActiveX for a number of reasons, but the main one is that ActiveX is a HUGE geewiz factor.

Windows can only be made SOMEWHAT secure. The architecture is insecure and of poor design. The doom and gloom is real or we wouldn't STILL see Beagle running around. We also wouldn't see Windows crop up time and time again on security alerts.
http://www.computereconomics.com/article.cfm?id=1090
http://help.lockergnome.com/lofiversion/index.php/t23723.html
http://www.kakupesa.net/kakk/rant/
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2004/08/19/infected_in20_minutes/
http://www.zdnetasia.com/insight/hardware/0,39043471,39210608,00.htm
http://isc.sans.org/survivalhistory.php
http://www.sans.org/rr/whitepapers/windows/1298.php
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2004/08/16/mydoom_spam/

The long and the short of it. You have 47 minutes before someone takes over you box. You have 641 minutes with *nix before someone takes over your box.

It isn't doom and gloom, it is reality. The sooner everyone admits the emperor has no clothes, the sooner we can move on and FIX THE FRIGGIN' problem.

by tony hopkinson

I haven't had more than a heads up from my virus checker about my sons temporary IE folder since I set it up, he isn't an administrator.
AVG, SPyBot, AdAware and FF (for me) IE for him and Messenger (cringe)

You are to be commended for a a total lack of MS PR and especially the lack of chorus, bit too poptastic for me.

Providing IE free and killing the competition made definite sense business wise. Locking it in with integration was daft though. They've payed for it big time, when you add it to the monolithic architecture and then use it as a subsystem in what was orginally a single user OS. Well shake of the head on that one.

ActiveX as in widget dll with unfortunately two interface descriptions, was an eye opener technology.

Certainly in terms of web usability it really brought the inernet to the home. However it's success was due to the fact that you could do so much with it. Well no, THEY could do so much with it. Was the WEB a friendlier place, perhaps but ActiveX was the tool that armed a lot of the bad guys.
20/20 hindsight perhaps, but it was deliberately open and again another route into the monolithic single user architecture.

Multi-users systems are more than logons and profiles. XP, I wouldn't have mentioned as multi-user, multi profile perhaps, if nothing else compatibility mode disables all the improvements.

2003 is a multi-user system but it suffers from an enormous flaw which impairs all the user control at the top that they've now got done reasonably well.

If Johnny Noprivs fires up IE, looks at a web page. Web page has graphic, graphic passed to kernel process with local admin priviliges to render image, buffer overrun, foreign code injection, goodnight and thankyou.

It gets worse though, Johnny Noprivs isn't on the server, RikDeity is, he's logged on as admin with GUI, checks a web page ...... Arrgh.

Kernel space and user space, the concept MS are struggling towards and by all acounts still haven't made. In linux he you managed this exploit all you would do is ruin one user's files.

You can set up windows to be secure, well as secure as the last set of patches and the latest signatures.
You can beef up with hardware firewalls, enterprise av, intelligent procedures etc. But its a lot of work and if you get hit by a critical that targets user code foolishly integrated into the kernel, you are gone.

There's very little you can do about it because the security is reactive. Windows has a doorman, linux has a big lock. Get past the doorman you are in, get past the lock you are in a foyer with another locked door in front of you and an old TR download on an unused desktop.

Vista is going to improve on this, though I wonder what low rights IE is going to do to some web applications.

My background is HP3000, then VMS then VMS and NT that was up to 99. Since then I've done application server setups NT and Linux, but not system admin, so I no longer consider myself qualified as a network or system admin of any sort.

However before and during all that time and since I've been developing. I don't write manage your CD collection stuff, I've done a lot of cross platform integration, so I have to know a good deal of what goes on under the lid. I've been looking under lids since 1977, when there wasn't a great deal under them.

You apparently got on top of windows, where many haven't, but your job has been made much harder than it had to be.

See not all linux loonies are unreasonable louts.
Mind you I'm VMS loonie who's recently used linux, so this may account for it.
LOL

by nighthawk808

Can your grandmother slipstream? But wait, don't you Microdroids always talk about how Linux is so hard that the average user can't possibly fathom it? Then why would you use a technique that would take a level of technical competence that you or I already have? If you have to resort to tricks or changing the rules of victory midstream, you've already lost.

Go to newegg, CompUSA, Best Buy--wherever doesn't matter--and buy 1 copy of Windows XP and 1 copy of SuSE 10.0. Install Windows. Format the HDD. Install Linux. Then tell me with a straight face just how much easier Windows is.

If Microsoft took the same approach to their "Get the FUD" campaign as you did, they'd sponsor (IOW, pay for) a study where they set up a RedHat box, do no updating, no tweaking, and no optimizing it and then they'd set up a Windows 2003 server, fully update it, tweak it, and optimize it to run certain (naturally Microsoft) applications. Then they'd run benchmarks on the two and find that the Windows 2003 server was slightly faster than the RedHat one.

Hold off on emailing Bill about my idea. Microsoft has already done exactly this. Apparently they took my joke a little too seriously.

Wow, another person without certs talking about how they're so easy to get. I've seen plenty of people talk trash about how easy the CompTIA's are and then walk into the testing center and fail them. If they're so easy, then either shut up and get them or shut up about how easy they are. Pick one. Put your money where your mouth is. I did.

by oz_media

After reading Tony's comments, I chuckled and then reread yours. I figured you were pointing at the whiner, not the winner . ;)

Tony is right though, I can be pretty easy going but somehwat 'volatile' too.

by lee ö

I get a lot of heat from other designers and also some clients who think because I use a PC running windows that I am less of a professional graphic designer.

It is total rubbish. What allot of people do not realize is that MAC donates a huge number of computers every year to universities teaching design. They also offer huge student discounts. This causes most "newbie" designers to be Mac users. 97% of the population is on a pc for a reason. Clones. IBM allowed manufacturers to produce clones and that sparked manufacturing frenzy. I used a Mac for years and even kept one next to my pc. I did this mainly for beta testing on multiple os's. So I know first hand it is not a usability issue that make macs better.

Also, in a similar vein other web developers try to convert me to firefox because of security issues. Sure Vundo was a bit of a drag but after a quick search I found a fix.

In short I use Windows and IE. I have for the last 11 years and will continue to do so. I feel if any one company can be accredited with the widespread use of computers in such a short period of time it is Microsoft.

by oz_media

Well that's a nice term to use for MS.

As for MAC for graphics, I have found MAC's to be a lot faster/more robust for graphic design. Simply due to the wiser use of resources.

Og course you will disagree, why would you possibly agree? I have contradicted you afterall.

Am I a Mac user? Nope. I do find them better for graphic design though, not just for simple vector work and stuff but for rendering, rendering on a Mac is usually much faster than a PC. What can take overnight on a PC, running at much higher spec than a MAC, can take just a few hours with a MAC. Perhaps the professional design work you do does not require a lot of redering/endless processing time.

by lee ö

I agree, for 3d apps such as 3dmax or maya an out of the box Mac is faster. However I have heard it is easier to chain pc's together for shared processing than macs. PC's when custom built can be just as fast as Macs. I do think the PC's caught up in terms of proccessing power a few generations ago.

Also, you are correct in your assumption that I do not do allot of rendering is correct. I mainly do Photoshop and flash work. Even with large print files for vehicle wraps etc. the processing bog is nowhere near trying to render 3d.

I do use a pc in my home studio (music production) and have no problem running 32+ tracks of audio with real time effects on most tracks. Allot of old school studios are mac based. ProTools has only recently moved over to windows.

Really my problem is with the pseudo elitists who feel they are superior designs for the simple fact that they use a Mac.

This is even exacerbated by Mac putting out misinformation in their new Intel ads. "The chip has been trapped in boring little boxes doing boring tasks..." or something to that effect. That is insulting to non Mac creatives the world over.

Would you agree that certain individuals help perpetuate a feeling that creatives should be Mac based in certain industries?

by nighthawk808

I bought legal, genuine, straight-from-Microsoft full versions of Windows XP, Office XP, and Visual Studio in 2001. Do you know how much it cost me? $20 each. Why? Because I was in college at Cleveland State at the time and Microsoft offers huge student discounts.

But it gets better: Case Western students get FREE Microsoft products. University of Toledo students do, too. I'm sure there are plenty of other schools that also get this "Hook 'em young" treatment from M$, but these are the only three I have personal experience with.

Post edited because I acidentally clicked "Submit" too soon.

by lee ö

That's cool. I appreciate you pointing that out. However, the MS ploy is not aimed at designers.

Here on the west coast schools such as Art Center are totally MAC based. Yet when these young grads go into the work force most of them will encounter pc environments.

Thanks for the reply...

by mjwx

We are trying to get rid of Mac's here (we just don?t have the IT staff to support any more OS's) and our graphic designers are resisting (what resitsting change?).

The Mac's have been nothing but trouble from the day they arrived. But we (everyone else in the company) are getting crap from a pair of self-important (no offence lee) graphic designers who "claim" they cant work on a PC.

Windows has its issues but it works well with servers. Microshaft gets a bad rap (not all of it undeserving) but they were a major force in making IT what it is today.

Windows and Windows will work great together.

Windows and Linux will work great together.

Windows and Mac's, when you can get them to work together its not pretty.

by lee ö

I think your designers will get used to being PC based. They are probably just elitists. All of the graphics apps have the same tool bars.

One thing you might try is leaving some brochures for companies that handle outsourcing of Graphic Design. This is part of the "It could be worse strategy" in the Demotivating the work environment series I am looking into. LOL.

No offense taken. I have been a Creative Director and Senior Developer in the past. Now I have my own small multimedia marketing firm. You seem to be coming from a management standpoint. PC's are more cost effective. That is the bottom line.

I would also like to thank you for agreeing that MS has played a major role in the development and rapid growth of the tech sector.

Good luck with the stubborn designers...

by jamesrl

I wrote an article about working with Macs and PCs together in 1989 for Computing Canada magazine. It is far easier now.

I also worked in a company that had 20,000 Macs, 15,000 PCs and 15,000 Unix workstations, all on the same network.

If you can't get them to work together, try getting some information instead of blaming the platform.

James

by tony hopkinson

But that was the recently published wmf flaw. Now patched. The reason I mentioned it though is because of the architectural differences between 'nix and windows.
Things like graphics rendering are in the user space in linux, but they are built into the kernel in windows. So if you found a common exploit for both os's that used a common graphical engine. On linux it would take out the user, on windows it would take out the machine.

Did n't mean to scare you

by tony hopkinson

ownership that did me in.

Don't worry about my self esteem it's attached to my ego.
A big target, but impervious to assault from outside.

by rkuhn040172

I know there are huge technical differences, but really, if an exploit takes out a user profile or the whole machine does the end user really care?

All they know is their stuff is gone. Sure, we have file servers and backups but inevitably some of the files reside on the local PC.

From the end user point of view, they got hosed one way or the other.

by jamesrl

I was helping people set this up 13 years ago at one previous employer. You loaded a simple app on every Mac and the main machine could use their spare cycles to help render - at night when people were gone and their screen savers were running, it made a huge difference in rendering times - hours saved.

I don't use my Mac anymore. But when I was desktop publishing newspapers, flyers etc, it was muchg faster on the Mac than on the PC- Pagemaker was faster on the Mac than Pagemaker on the PC for sure.

But I do recall alot of photoshop benchmarks where Macs beat high end Pentiums. I think the fact that IBM did not continue to develop faster chips is what pushed Apple to Intel.

Sure there are Mac snobs, but there are in sheer numbers more Wintel bigots. Thats what gets the Mac snobs backs up.

I did laugh at that commercial.

James

by oz_media

That's a good point. I do extensive amounts of audio engineering as I work in the industry. I don't use ProTools, I prefer Cakewalk and CueBase, but I also do it all on a PC, even my IBM THinkpoad at times, with little effort.

Again though, this requries less rendering/processing than Maya of course.

I know exactly what you mean by th eMAC speudo elitists, and I agree wholly. I also agree almost wholly with your comments, but lets face it, each OS has it's place. One 'will do' when the other will lag, same with Linux.

EDIT: As for 'chaining together PC's", I like th eway you used the MAC term 'CHAINING' as they did perfect the daisy chain long before MS fixed their own issues.

by mjwx

what I don?t have is time. James you?re a manager, would you have me spend an inordinate amount of time doing basic tasks when I have more important work to do. Not supporting Mac?s was an ROI decision and not made by me (the lowest ranking IT employee).

Personally I'd like to crack this (MS and Mac Don?t like talking to each other because of different proprietary protocols) because I don?t like problems beating me but there are a lot of more important things (as my boss points out) than spending half a day screwing around with a Mac. I've delivered basic functionality with what I had (no extra resources were expended) even though it?s not up to spec and besides the CRM server wont upgrade itself.

by mjwx

I'll keep it in the back of my mind. We are not getting rid of the Mac?s immediately, rather we are trying to phase them out. We have 2 near new G5's (PPC's not Intel) one is in a hire contract to Jan and the other we bought in Aug last year so I?ve got a while.

While Apple marketed the first GUI and successful PC they created neither. The GUI was invented by researchers at atomic PARC (Palo Alto Research Centre) in 67 (date and spelling might be wrong but it was about then). MS created the first commercial PC from IBM parts and the first Desktop Operating System (DOS we all remember DOS) from CP/M.

Apple went down the toilet in the late 80's making way for the Windows we know (and love?). A 286 running windows 3.1 was my first PC.

Short lesson in the history of the PC for anyone who didn?t already know it.

by awfeckit2

"No amount of ease of use is worth loosing speed and power"

Well, to a lot of people, ease of use IS more important than speed and power.