Discussion Locked

Why the left rules the political world

0 helpful
109 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The ideology of the "left" makes more sense than the crap that is passed from the "right." We on the left are for the little man, while those on the right want the rich to stay richer and have the poor stay under the arm of the rich. This isn't class warfare, this is common sense: the rich need to pay more in taxes, you know contribute more of their money like the rest of us; thereby empowering the entitlements we all love and don't want to lose. To the right I ask: why bite the hand that feeds you?

We are more sympathetic and tolerant. I could care less if two men want to marry each other. I don't want to marry either one of them so why do I care what they do? Sure, if a man asked me to marry him I would say no and if he persisted in asking me and was flirting with me, I would be upset, but if a man is showing affection toward another man who receives it, what is that to me? Let homosexuals marry.

Also, the white man has had his day long enough. Those of different color are held down and should be given more opportunity (I should know, being of different *color*) than they are now (I thought we were living in the 21st century...racism is so last century).

If a woman wants to abort, then let her. Like Peter Singer said, "newborns lack the essential characteristics of personhood???"rationality, autonomy, and self-consciousness"???and therefore "killing a newborn baby is never equivalent to killing a person, that is, a being who wants to go on living."

What say you?

109 replies

by jamesrl

I'm considered a conservative at least in Canada. I've been a conservative activist for some time.

I believe in the individual. We are all different and unique. I don't care at all what color your skin is, which gender you prefer. I don't think people of color should be descriminated against, but neither do I think white people should be descriminated against.

I don't believe human life begins at conception, thats a precusor. But there has to be some point at which the fetus is capable of surviving on its own. And thats where I would limit abortions. BTW I was a preemie by two months, so I would sure seen the line drawn earlier than that.

I believe that taxes should be low for everyone, and that everyone should pay a reasonable share. Too many loopholes exist, there is a huge industry based on the creation of tax dodges. Make it simpler, more flat and fairer. I don't believe in entitlements as you would put it. I think it is to the benefit of all to have certain things provided for all, including infrastructure and education.But there is a lot of pork being doled out, moreso in the US than here.

I don't think the left has a monopoly on equality, or on these issues. I know many on the right who are in general agreement about these things. We have fewer religious based conservatives in Canada.

I say Troll because I think you are being less analytical and more provactive in your analysis.

by charliespencer

Gotta wonder about a member who's profile includes one sentence about IT and a couple of paragraphs about his political positions. Nothing wrong with that, but there may be forums better suited to the political discussions he appears to be looking for.

by charliespencer

We don't all love entitlements. First, no one is entitled to them; they're tools for transferring money. Second, I don't support paying for them, and I don't support forcing others to pay for them either.

"Also, the white man has had his day long enough. ... (I thought we were living in the 21st century...racism is so last century)."

Your first sentence in that paragraph is itself racist. Would you find that sentence acceptable if I replaced 'white' with 'black', 'Latino', or 'purple with green spots'? If no, then what make my variations racist but yours not?

I agree with you regarding the personal rights of homosexual marriage, and in some cases on abortion. However, the 'left' doesn't have a lock on those positions, and many on the right support them too. Google 'Log Cabin Republicans' when you're off your soapbox.

Oh, and just because killing something may not be equivalent to killing a self-conscious, rational, autonomous adult doesn't mean that killing it is justified. Not all paintings are the Mona Lisa; does that mean destroying them is a good idea?

by jfuller05

I have to wonder if member vulwhine has heard of libertarianism? No offense to the member, but I agree with you and JamesRL about the possibility of him/her being a troll.

by robo_dev

To call yourself sympathetic and tolerant yet refer to the agenda of the other side as 'crap' is somewhat hypocritical.

I think a more nuanced approach might help the OP to win more friends and influence more people.

It's a valid argument that there is a contradiction between the idea of 'less government', except with respect to reproductive rights or marriage.

It all started in the 1960s, when the Dixiecrats, Strom Thurmond and Jesse Helms, switched to the Republican party, and the turning point was Jimmy Carter, effectively the last Democrat who had strong support among Christian voters.

Today there are scores of organizations, colleges and universities, and even media outlets which foster and promote the Christian right agenda. The big question (or fear in the case of the OP), is if this agenda will become reality.

Will the Christian right 'save' the Republican party or drag it deep underwater?

In the long run, the concern that this agenda will succeed is unfounded for two reasons, one is that the 'Barry Goldwater' conservatives are unhappy since the Republicans have been on a drunken-spending-spree since George Bush Senior. Could we see the rise of a third-party (Libertarian) as a place for 'real (fiscal) conservatives'??

The second is that the anti-immigration, anti-amnesty, evangelical Christian agenda does not win friends among the very quickly growing Latino demographic, who tend to be Democrats. Similarly, those with strong liberal social views, (with the notable exception of the Log Cabin Republicans), are also not on-board.

by john.a.wills

Marriage is a license to copulate. Two people of the same sex can't copulate.

I submit that the above argument is neither left- nor right-wing.

by jamesrl

I would agree that it isn't a left wing or right wing issue.

But if you support that argument, I'd counter thats it is a pretty narrow definition.

Should couples that can't get pregnant never be allowed to marry? What about after they are too old to have kids? Does love play no role in marriage?

by boxfiddler Hot topic

requires copulation to occur, copulation doesn't require pregnancy, nor does age preclude copulation, nor does love require copulation.

[i]Devils advocate...[/i]

by charliespencer

such as health care for one's partner, tax breaks, life or death decisions, shared property. Two people of the same sex can and should be able to do all of those and more. If it weren't for these government-created advantages, if marriage had been left strictly as a religious construct, most homosexuals would probably have never cared.

Copulation doesn't require a license; it requires genitalia. Even if marriage was a license to copulate, it doesn't mean copulation is going to occur. Plenty of married heterosexuals don't have physical sexual relations. Does that make their marriage any less valid?

Must that copulation be specifically for the purpose of creating children? Is a marriage any more or less acceptable if the partners are having sex strictly for recreational purposes, with no intent (or even specifically intending NOT) to have a child?

by john.a.wills

Palmetto says "If it weren't for these government-created advantages, if marriage had been left strictly as a religious construct, most homosexuals would probably have never cared.". Certainly in SF a great deal of the deal is religious. People do complain of the injustice of the denial of various benefits, but, long before the recent furores about gay marriage, gays were going through forms of marriage in churches and church-like settings. They want to be recognized as socially, culturally, morally and religiously equivalent to married couples. Which means that they want simulated copulation a.k.a. mutual masturbation to be recognized as morally equivalent to copulation.

by ansugisalas

I didn't know you guys still lived in the dark ages...
You get a fine for that? Tongue cut out? Nipples cauterized with hot irons?
Or what? Not much of a license without enforcement of the monopoly it creates, eh?
Jest aside, marriage has nothing to do with sex. Marriage has to do with ownership. Ownership of stuff. Ownership of land. Ownership of property.
All the sexual and romantic notions hung on top of that are just window dressing.

9 tenths of the law - and ten ninths of marriage.

by hal 9000

[i]Marriage is a license to copulate.[/i]

[b]Wrong, Wrong, Wrong, Wrong[/b]

Marriage is maybe a Christian Based License to procreate passed into LAW in the Western World but it's certainly not a License to Copulate in any sense of the word.

To Copulate you need none of the Legal Niceties that go along with Marriage and some Copulation Practices may even be downright Illegal in all Western Countries. Rape for instance.

Even then the Hypocrisy involved by many in the so called Christian Church is so abysmal that I find it difficult to contemplate. The Local Catholic Parish Priest who rants against Male Homosexuality in his Sunday Sermon yet Molests the Choir Boys at every opportunity for instance even though he insists his actions against the Boys is not Homosexual.

Or the Puritans who settled the North of the Americas who used to keep teenage girls at their homes during the night to give them what they called Advanced Bible Classes who almost always ended up pregnant.

Neither of those cases described above involved Marriage to allow or give a License to Copulate and in most understandings is downright wrong. ;)

Col

by john.a.wills

If your local Catholic priest is really molesting the altar boys, you ought to report it to someone, say the police. I remember two gay men (well, one gay and one ex-gay) in SF telling me they had known a certain priest was a child molester before he got found out, but had done nothing about it. Of course, their evidence was some faculty of gaydar, which would not be admissible in a state (or church) court. But they ought to have told someone who might investigate, e.g. a newspaper, or the bishop, or maybe even the police, who might have been moved to do some investigation. And so ought you, Col.

by jamesrl

Thats his view of copulation was that of the church he adheres to, which dictates that copulation be only done within marriage and for the purposes of having children.

by roger that

Government should never decide who should or should not marry or what the requirements are. It's none of government's business.

by jamesrl

I agree that as a Canadian Prime Minister once said, "The state has no place in the bedrooms of the nation", with the codicil that as long as the bed is full of consenting adults.

And I do think that gay marriage should not be blocked by a government.

But if the state has no requirements for marriage, then the government should not treat married people any differently than single people, and today they do - pensions, tax status and other benefits are predecated on marriage.

And given some recent court rulings on polygamy, I do think there are times when the governement has a role in establishing requirements for marriage around the age of consent and coersion.

by charliespencer

"1. Same-sex marriage is bad for children
2. Same-sex marriage is bad for civil society and business
3. Same-sex marriage is bad for public health"

Number one assumes children are involved. We've already pointed out that not all marriages are about having children. For the sake of the discussion, I'll grant that a pair of heterosexual parents is the preferred model. I won't grant that a pair of loving homosexual parents is inferior (or superior) to a single parent household. I'll maintain a stable set of homosexual parents are superior to a heterosexual household where one spouse abuses the other or the children, to a series of heterosexual foster parents, or any number of other family arrangements that exist today.

The article also makes the point that hetero marriage last longer. Last time I checked, hetero marriages in the US are only batting .500, so 'we' aren't doing too well ourselves. Surely the minority of married homosexuals can't have damaged the institution in the last few decades as much as the heretosexual majority have inflicted on it over the millennia.

The second point, about business, raises many outrageous lawsuits. Frankly, outrageous lawsuits in the US are a dime a dozen. Many groups use the legal system to advance their causes, for better or worse. From the same section,

"The law is a great teacher, and same sex marriage will teach future generations that marriage is not about children but about coupling. When marriage becomes nothing more than coupling, fewer people will get married to have children."

Again, the assumption that marriage is about children, not about love; and the assumption that a marriage without children is strictly about sex. Also,

"Norway, for example, has had de-facto same-sex marriage since the early nineties. In Nordland,the most liberal county of Norway, where they fly gay rainbow flags over their churches, out-of-wedlock births have soared"

Not a single one of those out-of-wedlock births occurred to a homosexual couple. If homosexuals are getting married and heterosexual are not, who are the ones degrading the institution; those who seek to enter it, or those who shun and deny it?

It doesn't matter who the government allows to declare themselves married; it cannot affect my marriage (or yours) in any way. [b]No one can weaken, damage, cheapen, or destroy a marriage except the two people involved.[/b] The institution would be in far better shape if more couples focused on their own marriages and ignored the (potential) marriages of others.

As to number three, alcohol and tobacco do more damage to the public health than homosexuality. How about spousal abuse between heterosexual couples? There are multiple programs to protect spouses from their abusers.

by ansugisalas

people use more sun tan lotion in the summer
people also drown more in the summer
=does sun tan lotion cause or enable drowning?

by jfuller05

good points. I'm definitely not going to argue with you over what another person wrote. While good points, I'm still in the middle ground of the debate.

by charliespencer

"They want to be recognized as socially, culturally, morally and religiously equivalent to married couples. Which means that they want simulated copulation a.k.a. mutual masturbation to be recognized as morally equivalent to copulation."

First, you seem to be unable to separate the sex act from marriage. Either can exist without the other.

Second, who's to say mutual masturbation is any more or less moral than copulation? What makes one sexual act 'moral' and another not? Is an act of mutual masturbation between two people in a loving monogamous relations less 'moral' than copulation between two strangers hooking up Saturday night? Is mutual masturbation less 'moral' between a homosexual couple than between a heterosexual pair? Is mutual masturbation between an unmarried heterosexual couple less 'moral' than if they have intercourse outside of marriage?

Social, cultural, moral and religious equivalency depends entirely on the society, culture, morality, and religion involved. None of these social constructs are fixed; all have evolved over time, and will continue to do so. As regards religion, who is to say that one is better than another? What standards are used to measure the validity of a religion, or the sincerity and faith of its followers?

by nicknielsen

.As Palmetto said: [i]Marriage is a license to government-granted privileges such as health care for one's partner, tax breaks, life or death decisions, shared property.[/i]

by charliespencer

You're the one who opened by narrowly defining it as a license to copulate. I'm more than willing to add legal to economic if you can grant that some heterosexual marriages may have never involved copulation.

Can we agree that religious principles should have no role in determining US law?

by jp85257

Peter Singer also said:

"In a 2001 review of Midas Dekkers' Dearest Pet: On Bestiality, Singer argues that sexual activities between humans and animals that result in harm to the
animal should remain illegal, but that "sex with animals does not always involve cruelty" and that "mutually satisfying activities" of a sexual nature may
sometimes occur between humans and animals, and that writer Otto Soyka would condone such activities."

Are you sure you want to be quoting him to prove your point?

by jp85257

His next post will be:

We are more sympathetic and tolerant. I could care less if a person and an animal want to marry each other. I don't want to marry either one of them so why do I care what they do? Sure, if an animal asked me to marry it I would say no and if they persisted in asking me and was flirting with me, I would be upset, but if a man is showing affection toward an animal who receives it, what is that to me? Let anyone/anything marry.

by charliespencer

I'd always heard it was ice cream that caused drowning; i.e., more ice cream is eaten in the summer. Maybe sun tan lotion contains appetite stimulants?

Either way, I agree. The cited article presents its statistics in a vacuum, ignoring other factors.

by robo_dev

In terms of marriage, if a gay couple wants to throw their life away and suffer the agonizing humiliating experience that is marriage, why do these do-gooders want to stop them?

Marriage is the reason they invented football, Internet p0rn, and beer, all job-producing industries.

I don't think those of us who chose to suffer this extreme form of self-induced pain should deny others the right to do the same.

by ansugisalas

but I remember seeing a claim that more ice cream is eaten during winter than during summer... so I wanted to proof the argument against that possibility :D

by hippiekarl

...and in this country, icy New England leads that winter abundance of ice cream consumption.

by jfuller05

Correlation is not causation. I remember hearing that over and over on a radio show one time. It stuck with me. After I heard it, I noticed how many times people use the correlation to causation line of thinking.

by ansugisalas

It's hard to imagine an actual middle ground between "It's an abominable sin, and a threat to us all" and "Consenting adults should be allowed to have what they want, if it doesn't take away from others, without undue persecution". The one side is waaaay out in brimstone-ville and the other is "meh" at best. The percentage of people advocating 100% same-sex marriages is, after all, disappearingly small, if such people even exist. So, the so-called "pro-gay" isn't really "pro" so much as anti-anti-gay. So the middle ground would be... in favor of moderate persecution? Or what?

by jfuller05

or perhaps apathy? I can understand both sides of the arguments (the secular argument against same-sex marriage and arguments for same-sex marriage), but neither side has sold me. Depending on the day I read about it in the news or see the discussion here (started by vulwhine who mysteriously isn't with us anymore) I will a) think, "I guess we can't really know or b) be indifferent toward the issue. I understand that isn't much of a middle-ground, so my wording was poor in my replies earlier, but if I were to make a middle-ground for myself it would be as follows: I certainly want to preserve freedom for individuals (Locke was a genius), so I don't think the Federal government should have a law one way or another on the issue, but the states should (which is how it is now I think) be able to vote and decide for themselves on whether to allow or ban same-sex marriage.

I'm not ever agnostic or apathetic toward freedom, just on the same-sex issue itself. Let the states decide and leave the fed out. This response of mine didn't lay out a middleground for the same-sex marriage debate in an argument, but I think the middle-ground is either a) agnosticism or b) apathy.

by john.a.wills

is not to be found, because homosexuality is an improper concept and homophobia and homosexualism, as I put it in my book Albatross, are two sides of the same counterfeit coin. Perhaps jfuller05 is trying to get off the homophobia-homosexualism axis altogether but doesn't yet know that that is what he wants. Once off the axis, or once one rejects the counterfeit coin regardless of the side proffered, one can look down at the battle and laugh at the two sides, weep at them, or occasionally try to throw in bits of sense about specific points.

by ansugisalas

is that what you mean?
Anyway, so, being off the axis, I say "Let them marry. No harm in it".

by charliespencer

What's an "improper concept"? Exactly what is 'improper' about homosexuality, either as a concept or in action?

by ansugisalas

Now, Vulwhine is a troll, and at best a burden to his chosen side, so what I am going to say is not in favor of him. What I am going to say is to counter the ridiculous implications of your argumentation, jp85257.
See, marriage is solely about possession as a human privilege. Conferring the privilege of possession upon a non-human is pointless, since non-humans don't have the legal presence that the privilege underpins. So no marriage for animals. If people leave their money to their pets, the pet in question never actually achieves ownership of that money, the result will always be a de facto testamentation of the money to a trust, which then has as its mission to handle the animal in question.
No real ownership, so no marriage.

Comparing gay couples with people having sex with animals is beyond the pale, even in jest.

I'll leave it to the US supreme court to decide for you if you can marry a corporation or not, they might feel you could, since they have such a hare-brained view of corporate entities in other instances as well...

by jp85257

But I didn't use Singer to try to prove my point; he did.

You forgot to add "In my opinion" to your statement that begins "See, marriage is solely about possession as a human privilege". Otherwise some people might consider it to be fact.

And how can you guarantee that someone won't want to marry their pet? When you're dealing with sexual deviants, all bets are off.

by ansugisalas

Fact: I have no problem with your first post along this line, that was good snooping. The second one, however, was a fail. IMHO.

Fact: If people want to delude themselves about the nature of marriage, t'aint my problem. If some people don't consider what I said to be fact, tell them "Boo hoo" from me. Crying about it won't change it either.

Fact: I said that the basis of marriage is a big fat N/A for animals, as in "humans only". Gay people is humans too, see? Whether or not anyone'd want to marry a pet is beside the point. It doesn't apply, because the pet cannot meaningfully own anything... not meaningfully in the scope that marriage is about securing, at least.

by jp85257

First make it legal and then you can work on the rest of your agenda:

On Nov. 15, the Senate Armed Services Committee had unanimously approved S. 1867, the National Defense Authorization Act, which includes a provision to repeal Article 125 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ).

Article 125 of the UCMJ makes it illegal to engage in both sodomy with humans and sex with animals.

It states: ???(a) Any person subject to this chapter who engages in unnatural carnal copulation with another person of the same or opposite sex or with an animal is guilty of sodomy. Penetration, however slight, is sufficient to complete the offense. (b) Any person found guilty of sodomy shall be punished as a court-martial may direct.???

by robo_dev

But he's a boy dog, and he's fixed,so I guess the wedding is off.

The later you arrive home, the HAPPIER the dog is to see you.

The dog does not care WHAT you wear, as long as you feed him and take him on a walk.

The dog NEVER complains, accuses you of looking at other dogs, asks you if their collar makes them look fat, or complains when their food is cold.

by charliespencer

how many other dogs you've had. Heck, the dog is happier when you have two or three other dogs.

Lock your girlfriend and your dog in the trunk of the car. See which one is happy to see you when you open it.

But you can't marry your dog; the ring won't stay on her paw.

by ansugisalas

The problem of not being able to marry one's dog is alleviated by the fact that one doesn't have to marry one's dog. :D

by hal 9000

And in some cases people in the US have married their Motorcycle so I have to ask what's different with marring your dog?

Col :D

by hippiekarl

...in the car's trunk for 1/2hr on a hot day, when you open it back up your dog is still happy to see you.

edit: Oops; didn't read the whole thread before I posted this. (redundancy demerit)

by hal 9000

Where did I say I had any personal Knowledge of any Child Molester. My exact words where

[i]The Local Catholic Parish Priest who rants against Male Homosexuality in his Sunday Sermon yet Molests the Choir Boys at every opportunity for instance even though he insists his actions against the Boys is not Homosexual[/i]

These actions have been reported in every newspaper around the western world and are not confined to any single country. How does pointing out the blatant Hypocrisy of the Catholic Church in their addressing of Homosexually in any way imply I have any personal knowledge?

Sorry but you've completely lost me with that reply John.

Col

by jp85257

OK, so according to your requirements, polygamy is OK. So is a man marrying his 12 year old daughter or a mother marrying her 12 year old son. No limitations as long as they're human.

Thanks for clearing that up.

by ansugisalas

And I'll concede that you made me overextend a bit, in the footnote.
"humans only" is exclusive, not inclusive.
Meaning, "humans only" does not equal "If {x,y,...,n} = human, then M(x,y,...,n)=1".
If in doubt, refer to the universal "if it harms another, don't".
Preferential transferral of ownership to one's children is pointless, since one's children are the default beneficiaries.
Pedofilia is illegal, for other reasons than marriage.
Polygamy is hardly something universally bannable, and theoretically is less damaging to a woman's rights than the opposite, polyandry. Polyandry means a woman has to put up with/put out for a plural of jerkwads, whereas polygamy means there is a plural of women to share the burdens imposed by the singular jerkwad. They can so gang up on him if he gets out of line.

by ansugisalas

...as they have to do with the basic rights of a citizen/human.
Those are always a matter for the judicial system, which I assume is always part of the state.
Some people will attempt the fallacy of saying that allowing gay marriage would open the door to pedofilic/incestuous marriages, but anything pedofilic or incestuous are already declared illegal, in parts of the legal code which has nothing to do with marriage.
Gay relations are no longer illegal. A state ban on gay marriages is like a state ban on mixed-race marriages - not sustainable.

by jp85257

Sodomy is illegal in many regions for reasons other than marriage, so how can you use that as an explanation for not supporting pedofilia if you support gays?

And please provide your definition of the word "harm". How do you know that being in a gay relationship doesn't "harm" one of the participants?

by jamesrl

I have heard the - why not polygamy argument. I think we can define things better than that.

by ansugisalas

I don't suggest dark age societies should allow gay marriage: if gay sex is illegal there, then they (doh) should handle that shortcoming first.

by spannerz

Are now my bro. I'm Australian - our Liberal is your Republican and our Labor is your Liberal/Democratic.

I'm Democratic, too. I'm calm, cool with anyone and everyone, and being gay myself, I'm all good. Australia is looking at enabling us to marry, and like you said, it shouldn't matter one bit if we wanna marry, it doesn't hurt straight couples one bit :)

by ansugisalas

There's a good crowd here, even some *actual* conservatives (which is a completely different beast from the neoconservative prats we see overpopulating the right wing).
Actual thinking people, left and right, who don't go polishing their haloes and making sweeping, inflammatory remarks (looking at Vulwhine, here).

I'm not trying to cock-block here, I'm just saying, look around before you commit ;)

by charliespencer

Your new bro is apparently a seagull (flies in, squawks a lot, flies away never to be seen again, leaving only crap behind). There are plenty of better representatives of our political left here; don't bother with this one.

by hal 9000

Except it's not your beloved Liberal with Tony [i]"bad"[/i] Habit in the leadership who is looking at allowing you to marry.

He is defiantly against that with every fiber of his soul and will remain that way as long as he lives.

After all he was in training to be a Catholic Priest so he was probably taught to molest Alter Boys and justify that as they where asking for it. He also was most likely taught to rationalize the same action as He's not a Homosexual as Alter Boys don't count as Males.

I'm not really sure what Hypocrisy is involved in the crap that he expounds but it's obvious hypocrisy so blatant that no one dares question his motives and continue to refer to him as [b]The Mad Monk.[/b]

So if you want to marry and remain Gay you are in for a world of Hurt being what you are in more ways than the Homosexual element. You must being a True Believer follow your Liberal Party Leader and hate yourself for what you are and completely agree with everything that he says.

Don't worry however you can always dress up as an Alter Boy and he'll chase you around all you want. ;)

Col

by ansugisalas

Catholic priests get a special decoder ring that can turn bread (or those cardboardy wafers) into the flesh of christ, plunk into the blood of christ, and altar boys into "dewhine inspiration"... to be thrusted at with a "spire" until "de whine"...

by ansugisalas

...in that the viewpoint he produced is not inherently left or right-wing.
Historically, though, there's a right-wing bias in favor of views like that.
Who knows, when the US progresses enough, maybe the gay (male) population will gravitate more to the right, like the "southern democrats" who realized that their views were actually more in line with the republicans.
That's the way it sometimes goes. After all, being gay is not a guarantee of being wiser, more empathetic or more open-minded per se. That's the effect of experiencing persecution, first hand.

Once persecution stops, there is a risk that the gay men will realize that they, too, want to have all they can have, and screw the rest. Like some other men do.

But marriage being mainly economical? That's a given. What else would it be about? After all, marriage predates Yahweh by several millennia. Even before that it was always about lining out who should be the beneficiary of material ownership transfer after the death of the present owner.
It's a way to say "My children with Wife X are to take precedent over the children of wives Y, Z, etc... in descending order". That makes it easy to make a working algorithm, without having to make a list that can be tampered with.
This can always be modified with placing a preferred heir at the top of the list with a special declaration, after that deferring to the list defined by marriage.

I would be surprised to find a culture demanding permanent monogamous marriage while not observing personal ownership.

by ansugisalas

Not that it stops them trying that angle in their defense of the status quo. They just want gay people to stay in hiding, so they don't have to face the moral dilemmas their church puts them in. Pretty messed up, really.

by charliespencer

If marriage is all about children, and two heterosexual parents is good, why wouldn't three or more be better? :-)

by charliespencer

"Fact: ... The second one, however, was a fail. IMHO."

If it's your opinion ("IMHO"), then it can't be a fact.

by charliespencer

"Preferential transferral of ownership to one's children is pointless, since one's children are the default beneficiaries."

Maybe where you live, but here the default beneficiary varies from state to state. In some, it is the spouse only, with nothing going to the children. In others, it's split with 50% to the spouse and 50% divided between the children. In still others, it's divided evenly with the spouse and each child getting an equal share.

None of this should be interpreted as my justifying child marriage. My opposition to that is based on children being unable to understand the obligations and responsibilities of entering marriage. Recent science has show that teenagers brains undergo major 'rewiring' during adolescence; see the October 2011 issue of 'National Geographic.

by ansugisalas

Marriage defers inheritance, wholly or in part, from the children to the spouse.
I see what you mean - I didn't make it very clear.

by ansugisalas

You snipped out the fact!

Even without that: whether or not something is my opinion can be a fact.
It's just that only I can attest it.

As it stands, it is a fact that I found the first post to be a good cop (and did not criticize it), but that I deem the follow-up to be a fail (and did criticize that).

by jp85257

I wonder how many "enlightened ones" still feel they are in the dark ages because people like you prohibit them from marrying children or animals. After all, they're in love, why shouldn't they be allowed to marry?

by ansugisalas

Oh, wait, you're being disingenuous...
If you feel that gay sex is so wrong, work to ban it (again).
I'll then start calling you Canute. :p

If you feel that having sex with someone not capable of legal consent is OK... well... then you need to stay way the hell over there and not talk to me any more ;)

Anyway, Love and Marriage are perpendicular to each other. One doesn't require the other, nor does the other require the one. Unless the people in love wish to ensure that the PROPERTY of each will belong to their loved one, should they themselves die. So, it's about PROPERTY. And as I said, there's no way an animal can meaningfully own property, and pedophilia is illegal... so nyah nyah.

by jp85257

If it's only about PROPERTY, why can't you leave everything to anyone you choose in a will? There's no need to marry to protect your property or your partner's right to shared property. So why do gays feel they have to be married?

by charliespencer

The government gives taxes breaks to married couples. Married couples have a property advantage denied to unmarried people. Married people divorcing are granted legal status regarding their formerly shared property that is not granted to two unmarried people who are dissolving their relationship.

Transfer of property doesn't occur just a death.

by john.a.wills

do happen - why else would an engaged woman be surprised at the message that she would mother the Messiah? - but the couple have the moral right to copulate even if they chose not to.

What principle is religious and what not? The Declaration of Independence states that all men have certain God-given rights and that to secure these is the purpose of government. Is that a religious principle? The German Basic Law is a little more general, stating that human dignity is inviolable and then going on to list the basic human rights as part of that dignity; this seems at first sight not to recognize God, but the preamble to the Basic Law states that the People is conscious of its obligations before God and man. What constitutes human dignity, and what is violative of that dignity, however much the framers try to put things in a pure natural-law context, will seem to some a religious determination. And Vulwhine has quoted the great Peter Singer, denier of natural law, which denial is presumably religious.

by charliespencer

Nay, no trickery involved. You lumped it all together under one 'Fact:' heading. If any part is not a fact, then the heading can't apply.

by charliespencer

Can we agree that religious principles should have no role in determining how US tax policy, property laws, and spousal benefits regulations define a 'marriage'?

I'm not familiar with Peter Singer, not having heard of him before this discussion. Pete Seegar, yes; Peter Singer, no.

Even if we can, I don't think we'll agree that any moral right is necessary to copulate, or that an act of copulation is inherently immoral if it occurs outside of marriage. Indeed, immoral copulation (rape) can occur within a marriage.

by ansugisalas

If so, that's my bad, I was trying to strike a tone that fitted with the transparent baiting I responded to. So, "Fact: I don't give a ..." was my attempt at striking a "No, I'm not going to answer your trick question, pull the other one"-sort of tone.
But yes, those were facts, as far as they were truthful representations, albeit simplified, of my opinions.

by michael jay

"the rich need to pay more in taxes, you know contribute more of their money like the rest of us; thereby empowering the entitlements we all love and don't want to lose"

Entitlements = transfer of cash, from the so called rich to the poor, which only really takes from the somewhat rich and gives it to the poor.

I, you, and most that post here are the somewhat rich, and I do not like this redistribution of funds out of my, your, and our pockets.

Each person must make their own way and not depend on others to support them, unless they are truly unable to make it on their own.

by ansugisalas

Starting with his name...
After that, the second transgression : "Why the Left rules the political world"
Straight out the window.

by jamesrl

Imagine this in my best Jeff Goldblum charecter from Jurassic Park...

"God creates animals"
"Some animals exhibit homosexuality"
"John hates homosexuality"
"John hates's God's creation"
fill in the blank - I'm sure we have some creative people here.

by ansugisalas

Many nations have inheritance taxes, these mean that an inheritance given to a third party is taxed more heavily than an inheritance given to a close relative.
Also, the default heirs are the children... and many nations have laws stipulating a minimal percentage of inheritance to be paid to these children, they can't be cut out entirely.
So if a gay couple have lived together for a long time, and have, say a house together, then if one dies, and that one has child from youthful "experimentation", then default law would require the sale and partition of common property.
Widows and widowers are not subjected to that kind of treatment, the household is upheld until both partners are dead, or until the survivor remarries (depending on jurisdictions).

by ansugisalas

So - if we use our imagination to decipher this "unnaturalness" - it appears that it IS copulation, after all?
Maybe they should change it to "unlicensed"? The witch-hunters of Salem would love that, wouldn't they?

But it's good to know that they have nothing against with people engaging in unnatural carnal copulation with themselves ;)

by nicknielsen

"Unnatural carnal copulation" with an animal can probably be prosecuted as cruelty to animals under Article 92, Failure to obey Order or Regulation.

by vulwhine

I didn't know there would be *this* much feedback. Yowza. Ok, where to begin...uh, I'm right and everyone else that posted here disagreeing with me is wrong? Is that a good conclusion to this discussion? Probably not.

To begin, I'm not a seagull, I've been busy. I also mentioned in my profile that I'm a raving liberal, hence the assertions in my OP and not full arguments. I'm convinced the left has the big guns and should be followed in a polarizing fashion. The people don't always know what is best for them, but government does. Government needs more power, needs to be bigger, and you will see a great nation. Those who can't help themselves need to be backed by government and the rich need to pay more in taxes so government can help those who need help.

by jamesrl

The government knows best? Says who? A little hint for you, governments are run by people, people who are just as fallable if not moreso that people in business.

If big government is such a good thing, why is Greece failing?

I'm not convinced, you have some rhetoric, but not argument to back it up.

So what percentage of the population do you think the government can support before the taxes rise to the point where the people who were well off are now poor.

by robo_dev

when people say "The Government", what does that mean?

The city hall and mayor up the block?
The services provided by police officers, firemen, and sanitation workers?
The Federal Military Industrial Complex?
The Internal Revenue Service?
The Congress, Senate, Executive, or Judicial branches of government?

I pay taxes to the Federal, State, County and City governments, and receive (or sometimes don't receive) some tangible and intangible benefits from my choice to live within the borders defined by those entities.

For those who are 'anti-government' I ask if you want some government workers with their red fire truck to come help when your house is on fire, or those government workers with their guns to come when the bad guys show up.

On the other hand, there are those who feel that the government must save everyone from all possible harm; put airbags on the kids swings, warning labels not to use your lawnmower indoors, all the while providing billion-dollar farm subsidies so that tobacco growers can earn a profit growing tobacco.

If the OP is talking specifically about welfare, medicare, social security and the like for the poor, sick, and old, that's fine, but overall, it's a much larger discussion about what role government plays in job creation, making a particular area attractive to businesses, striking the right balance between regulation and a free-market economy, etc, etc. etc.

by ansugisalas

An Agent Provocateur that is... the whole thing sounds more like something meant to antagonize than something meant... well, at all.

by jamesrl

I'm not anti Government per se. I've worked for the government. My father and brother have worked for the government.

I am for some vague notion that governments are all knowing, and benign. I don't think governments are necessarily evil either. Organizations, big business, government, religious organziations, whatever are made up of people, fallable people. They may do good, they may do harm.

I'm fine with governments providing infrastructure, education, and a social safety net. I'm not so cool about corporate welfare, trying to mess up free market economies and spending money on projects without tangible benefits. In general, the closer the level of government to the people (ie local governments) the better the service they provide.

by ansugisalas

I don't see government provided services as inherently evil, but I also don't see it as inherently evil for people or companies to make a buck or two providing similar, complementary or additional services, nor for governments to even the playing field by subsidizing such private services to make up for the tax-paid competition such service providers face. Providing a basic safety net doesn't need to be heavily top-down.

I also don't think it's ever paid off (for the society as a whole) to replace a government infrastructure monopoly with a corporate infrastructure monopoly.

I am for free competitive economy, but I am also for strict anti-trust legislation. There will always be people trying to free themselves of competition, and since a system of vendetta justice won't work against that, an impartial judicial instance is the best bet we have.

I try not to be too dogmatic about it, but I won't stand for shameless agitprop, either. Because agitprop is always about wrecking things.

by jamesrl

You are correct in that this followup really didn't address any of the considered opinions, but instead sought to fan the flames.....

by robo_dev

Where's Maxwell Edison when you need him?

Cmon, we need some tinfoil-hat-wearing gun-toting, tea-drinking wing nuts to liven up the discussion.