Discussion Locked

Why we need to cut more trees and replant to save the environment

0 helpful
243 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

243 replies

by absolutely

Your mention of Google Earth gave me an
idea. Tree huggers should agree amongst
themselves to monitor selected areas from
week to week or month to month for illegal
logging activity. It would be an
affordable, convenient way to monitor
logging companies' compliance to their
commitments.

by oz_media

First off, as you are in Oregon, I am sure you can agree that if Canadian companies were clearing out your gorgeous state, that you'd be pretty pissed, at the US government AND Canada.

As for tree huggers, if they were actually organized and channeled that energy into a constructive system, they would probably get somewhere. Look at David Suzuki, he has made SO many enviro changes happen, simply through common sense, REAL knowledge and study and credibility. But tree huggers are like lefty extremists, they only stand to make the right look sensible because they are so disorganized. An "organized" rally is where thousands of people turn up and sit on their butts in front of logging equipment, not exactly a way to push your political views.

It's just sad and aggravating, I know it is a part of life/reality and we have seen it coming for decades, but it simply doesn't get any easier to stomache.

Did you see the Google Earth shots of the areas I described? It's ridiculous, and just keeps on going.

by Member 25348569

is that it will give everyone time to find alternatives and, because we have adopted a policy of using less, those alternatives will be more effective. I suppose it's because I'm not desperately materialistic, but I really don't see what the issue is in using less.

During the 1980s, the efficiency and, therefore, favourable economics of diesel engines made them extremely popular in the US. Now, for the obvious reason of reducing imports (and reducing emissions), you might think that the trend to diesel automobiles would be increasing in the US, yet only Mercedes Benz and Volkswagen now make diesel automobiles for export to the United States and sales account for 5% of those manufacturers sales. No US motor manufacturers make diesel automobiles.

Can you can justify this in any other terms than "you can take our lives, but you'll never take our freedom"?

I doubt it.

:)

by jdclyde

like Leo or Gore will actually DO anything about anything.....

Gore, I always get that image of him, half crazed, screaming how we were mislead.

Leo, basketball diaries anyone?

by locrian_lyric

thus they don't sell.

Remember the law of unintended consequences neil.

much of the environmental regulation in the US has resulted in MORE, not less polution, and if you go for a pragmatic solution, you get called a polluter.

One thing Prz Bush got nailed for was the heinous crime of relaxing environmental regulations.

The regulation he relaxed was one mandating powerplants who do significant upgrades to meet present day emissions standards.

The end result? Upgrades which could IMPROVE emissions, but not to current standards were not done, including upgrades which could produce more power.

Oh, we could all do more with less. We could also start euthenizing non productive members of society.

It's not about what we could do, it's about what we should do.

But, let's quantify your statement neil, HOW MUCH less should we use?

I drive my vehicle to and from work, period.

How much can I cut my gas consumption by?

by Member 25348569

Unfortunately, because of the political goal that was the driver for the original Moon landings, we'll probably never get a Moon colony now as the US couldn't get a man to the Moon with the present state of space technology.

by jamesrl

I'm not sure that diesels were "extremely popular" in the US in the 80s. Did you mean Europe?

One of the issues facing diesels in North America is the type of diesel fuel which is available is pretty high sulfur, and not compatible with many European made diesels. I believe that new standards in the near future may change this, but note that it may mean that new refineries will have to be built.

Chrysler has a small Jeep that is diesel. Diesels are popular in big pickups by GM, Ford and Chrysler(which many people use as daily transport, but thats another issue).

The Smart Car has been sold in Canada in a diesel model. When it is going to be launched in the US, it will be a gas version.

That has a lot to do with marketing perception as well.

James

by jdclyde

I have grand parents in a nursing home. Some of the "people" there have such a low quality of life, you have to wonder if medically extending a life like that is really a good thing.

Do we do it so grandma can keep on ticking, just so WE don't have to deal with the grief?

by absolutely

[i]Do we do it so grandma can keep on ticking, just so WE don't have to deal with the grief?[/i]

For the time being, these choices are still largely left to the patient, and in the absence of a living will, to their family. So, the question is, do [b]you[/b] keep [b]your[/b] grandma ticking for such reasons?

by w2ktechman

while the standard diesel engine may not be able to cut emissions enough (I do not know), there have been plenty of experiments with electric and hybrid models which do reduce pollution. In the 90's they were even testing small convoys with only 1 driver (1 driver, 3 trucks) in an all electric environment meant for cross country. This would signify that your previous statement is wrong, or at least not entirely accurate.
The problem probably lies more on the price tag than the ability to make semi's more efficient, or maybe steep hills where diesel engines are still needed.

by jdclyde

It was because they had originally taken the existing engines and converted them to diesel. They were noisy, they smelled, and they were crap that broke down all the time because they were not designed to handle the pressure.

This gave the diesel a very bad name, and at the time, they deserved that bad name. There has not been a push to revive the image, and everyone is orgasmic over the flops known as "hybrid cars". Cost a lot more up front, but don't get much return on investment over their counterparts. For someone like me that does almost all highway miles, it would do no good at all other than to lighten up my wallet by about $5k so I could pretend I was making a difference.

If Europe is so ahead of the curve than the US, why have THEY not come up with a car that runs on an "Alternate/renewable/clean" fuel source? And buying a micro "car" is not an option.

by Member 25348569

Whilst I'm not known for being particularly cynical*, I'm pretty damn certain that the tests have been slanted against diesel engine technology. By who, I don't know but that sort of thing - overt and covert lobbying - does seem to be something uniquely American. Out in the real world - that's the bit outside of your borders - it is widely accepted as fact that diesel engines outscores gas for cleanliness and level of emissions in all but PM10 particulates and no [b]real[/b] link has been found between PM10s and anything.

As to how much you can reduce consumption? Well, what car do you have?

Anyway, just change your driving habits a bit. Are you aware that, during the 1973 Oil Crisis when the US introduced the 55mph speed limits, the amount of fuel saved was less than half that would have been achieved by simply pumping up your tires to 1psi over?

Change gears 1,2,4 or 1,2,3,5 when accelerating.

Keep the tailgate up on a truck.

Close the windows and put on the aircon above 50mph. Below, aircon off, windows open.

Trust me, when gas is USD1.80 per [b]liter[/b], you learn about things like that.

I had this very discussion with Maxwell Edison and I lost a steak dinner (which I still intend to pay) when I bet him that you drove many more miles on average in the US as compared to Europe. You don't!

Really, it's simply a matter of a change in perception as to what makes a "good" car. For instance, in the US, the "muscle car" is what the lads drive. In the UK, they drive a "hot hatchback" the size of a shoe box. That's mainly because our roads are all bends and - at least the ones that I've driven - US cars have absolutely crap road-holding. Wallowing round the bends with over-soft suspension - I got seasick!

Neil :)

*That's an example of humourous British self-deprecating style of writing . I've flagged it up to indicate that it is irony!

by Member 25348569

Well, that's because they [b]can't[/b]. Fuels such as gas and diesel are portable energy sources. Hydrogen is just so difficult to handle and would need a completely new distribution system and, anyway, it needs much larger fuel tanks. Biofuels are a con and will kill people in the Third World by starvation when food supply prices go up. There are a few technologies that might help a bit but what we [b]really[/b] ought to do is to hold it all together and use less while we actually sort the problems out!

That ain't gonna happen!

Neil :)

Note to James. I should have added the words "relative to today".

European manufacturers can make efficient, powerful, clean diesel engines. Why can't you in the US?

by jamesrl

I don't disagree with your premise....

The Chrysler diesel (admittedly developed in conjunction with Mercedes) in the Jeep Liberty is the best choice for both low speed off roading and fuel economy. But no one is buying it.

And the problem is not with emissions - in the pickup application the diesels emit less overall, but more visible particulate - so its a perception problem.

The cleaner diesel fuel in NA will require new refineries and few are being built.

As for alternatives, if people picked smaller vehicles then we might not need them. I see way too many V8/V6 SUVs being used by one person to commute(that never ever leave pavement). If they had a car instead they would use much less fuel, and in the end that would lower fuel costs for all of us.

Hybrids are not yet cost effective, with the exception of some of GM's mild hybrid (can't run off battery alone) which cost only $3000 more and make the car 10% to 15% more efficient.

But Neil makes a good point, just by keeping your tires properly inflated you can save 5-10% on gas. Altering your driving style can also save money and gas.

James

by tig2

You love MY web site.

We need to turn it down. You have good things to bring to the table but are being marginalised because of a communication block.

You bring an awful lot to the TR table. I think that you are having a hard time getting the traction you deserve is that you are struggling right now. Stress=through the roof in your world.

You have brought some real value to this discussion. You have chosen to say what you believe as well as throw alternatives and your creative thinking out there. Now the task is to stay focused on the discussion. I know the people you are reacting to. Choose to respond... or NOT to the baiting.

It's a vulnerable time. Let's do what we can to insure that we can get through it. I go through this myself. Not fun.

by w2ktechman

many of us do not have a choice really. Not to say most, or anything, but many.
I have a truck, this is because I haul things occasionally, things like rock/cement/stone/sand/and dirt. I can only have 1 vehicle where I live, and I need to pay extra for the parking spot per month.
Recently I have been looking at moving, and most places are offering 1 vehicle parking for 1-4 bedroom places. This does not allow for multiple vehicles, especially when street parking is posted as "No Parking".

I would say, probably 10% of the polluters from larger vehicles may be because they can only have 1 vehicle, and have a need for it.
I commute in my truck (Dakota quad cab), I also travel in it. Personally, I chose not to get a 4x4 because I do not need the offroading for the majority of the driving.

by jdclyde

I drive a full size car, but it can still pull in about 33 mpg, if I keep it around 70 mph. I was going to convert that for you metric people out there, but didn't feel like making a spreadsheet just for this. B-)

today it is about $0.84/liter here in the US ( If I calculated correctly). [i]$3.20 per gallon divided by 3.7854118.[/i]

following that same formula, in REAL measurements, your $1.80/liter would be $6.81/gallon. That would suck ass.

with checking air pressure and driving slower, I still go through about $100 USD a WEEK in gas, and very little is for "pleasure".

I DO have to laugh at the people carting around town in a Hummer [i](wishing they could get a REAL hummer)[/i]. It is clear that when you spend THAT much for a it, your NOT going to ever take it off the road.

by tonythetiger

[i]Mandatory retirement at 65[/i]

I have never heard of this. My parents are 73 and 74 and both are still working (because they [b]want[/b] to).

[i]Deprived of their primary motivation,
people become sickly.[/i]

Most non-injury, non-infectious maladies are genetic in origin.

by absolutely

[i]I have never heard of this. My parents are 73 and 74 and both are still working (because they want to).[/i]

http://www.ncpa.org/bg/bg152/bg152.html
http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2002/09/precis.htm

The most detailed information that was easy to find (my friend Google, page 1-2) was for railroad workers:
http://www.rrb.gov/opa/qa/pub_0708.asp

I'm sure theirs is not the only system for which pension rules change drastically at age 65.

Clearly, some people feel that others are "wrong" to work past 65.
http://www.airlinepilotforums.com/showthread.php?t=12873

[i]Most non-injury, non-infectious maladies are genetic in origin.[/i]

I looked briefly for confirmation of that claim, and am not convinced. Do you have some medical or actuarial science research data to share?
http://preview.tinyurl.com/37jdr9
http://tinyurl.com/37jdr9

by Member 25348569

most of us Brits still talk in terms of miles and mpg although you have to be aware that our gallons are bigger than yours (4.55 l). Only the most rabid metric-buffs use kilometres and all UK road signs are still in miles for directions and mph for speed limits. The great levellers of the EU haven't got us yet so don't feel the need to convert!

The only reason that we price petrol (gas) in litres is that 94.9p/l translates to ?4.31/gal UK and we'd probably riot!

Neil :D

by tig2

I haven't read the entire exchange yet. I CAN tell that you are pretty stressed and it's coming out in your rhetoric.

I have a similar challenge- ADHD and menopause. And I know how to shoot and own guns. Hard times. Fortunately, my commute sucks scissors and the only person I really want to hurt is the bastard in the Audi that ran me off the road. I'm OK and the car is OK but I want that sh*thead and I want him where I can communicate effectively how badly I was scared. Perhaps by treating him to a demonstration.

Take a moment. You and Abs are very similar in intellect. Divergent views? Probably. But more alike than you are dissimilar.

Deep breath, my friend. This is a trying time. Understand that.

by locrian_lyric

Other than the fact that he is on this odd witch-hunt against me and simultaneously attempting to prove that Asperger's Syndrome doesn't exist and that I don't have Asperger's syndrome because I can understand *some* sarcasm and *some* irony.

I'm half deaf too, but just because I can hear *some* sound, I don't have any nuts running around shouting See! SEE! HE HEARD THAT!!!!

I'd be very happy to go on without the sniping.

by jamesrl

You don't have to have the last word. There is no win/lose here, though at times I might suggest there is lose/lose.

Ignoring is a fine strategy.

Walking away from an argument is not a sign of weakness. If you know the argument is pointless and unwinnable then its a sign of maturity.

You yourself lectured me when you thought I was ganging up on someone. I might suggest you read your own advice. And I'm not being snarky or self satisfied saying that. I think its applicable.

And for the record Abs, this applies every bit as much to you. Both of you need to let it go. It is sooooo far past the point where you've made your point that no one really remembers or cares what the original point was. Now its just petty squabbling. Underline petty.

James

by absolutely

I've found myself agreeing strongly with
about 50% of L_L's posts, and found those
to be uncommonly articulate and
profound.

For the next week I'll reply to those only
instead of the ones that annoy me.
Previous experience suggests that I will
thereafter be more interested and
emotionally invested in my agreements with
L_L than differences of opinion.

by absolutely

That you can recall?

[i]I have a similar challenge- ADHD and
menopause. And I know how to shoot and own
guns. Hard times. Fortunately, my commute
sucks scissors and the only person I really
want to hurt is the bastard in the Audi
that ran me off the road. I'm OK and the
car is OK but I want that sh*thead and I
want him where I can communicate
effectively how badly I was scared. Perhaps
by treating him to a demonstration.[/i]

Your short- and medium- term memory seem
functional ... Should I be fleeing?

To my dealings with Locrian_Lyric, I find
some of what he says hard to believe, but I
think more to the point, you're right that
I actually have more positive things to say
about him than negative. I just noticed
the one point of disagreement first and
haven't replied to any of his posts that I
think are right. There are a lot of those.
I noticed about a dozen just today. More
about that below.

by tonythetiger

I have issues with people who try to force their idea of what I need on me. No justification necessary or forthcoming. If you don't think my use of resources is reasonable, by all means, force me to do what you want me to do... But keep in mind that you will be giving up your right to complain when someone else does the same thing to you.

by locrian_lyric

I'm burying the hatchet with EVERYBODY now.

You made a bunch of good points.

This is degenerating (no to generous, HAS degenerated) into nothing more than "I know you are, but what am I", hasn't it?

Ah well, thank you for your insight James.

I've got quite a bit to think about.

Thank you.

by tonythetiger

[i]Are you aware that, during the 1973 Oil Crisis when the US introduced the 55mph speed limits, the amount of fuel saved was less than half that would have been achieved by simply pumping up your tires to 1psi over?[/i]

I increased my highway mileage by 5% and city mileage by 2% by putting on over-sized tires. Plus the larger tires should last longer (assuming the same tread depth and given fewer rotations per mile). There's a little less power on takeoff (the reason I did it in the first place...), and my speedometer is a little off but that's not difficult to compensate.

Of course, some trial and error is required. I found that 2 sizes up worked for me. Your results may differ.

by jamesrl

I am against arbitrary measures to force people into actions in the area, and I will provide a couple of examples.

The Canadian government just implemented a special rebate for gas misers, and tax for gas guzzlers. This has a number of issues. First of all it penalises by vehicle, and doesn't reward those who save gas by simply doing the proper maintenance, driving less, using transit etc. It also messes with the market.

For example, the Toyota Yaris gets a $1000 rebate. The Honda Fit, which gets almost as good a mileage but not quite doesn't get the rebate. Should we penalize Honda's sales? The Fit is actually larger than the Yaris, and is every bit as "efficient".

On the penalty side, putting a special tax on gas guzzlers only drives people to be them used, it doesn't take them off the market. It also doesn't recognize that some people buy them, and drive a more efficient vehicle on a day to day basis - the sports car example.

The real way to incentivise people to use less gas is to make them pay more. That will force people who drive a lot to buy smaller more efficient vehicles, encourage people to maintain their vehicles, it will encourage people to look at alternatives etc.

James

by absolutely

It's really hard to advance an argument
from authority, using as one's authority an
entity such as the UN. Good example.

by oz_media

I fully blame the governments of both Canada and the USA. The logging companies are forced to feed greedily, it's just the way big business survives these days, thanks to our most screwed up governments.

BC has protected forests, we also have forests that are still on indian land, much indian land is SUPPOSED to be indian land but is still being held by the government. So they don't even know who the trees belong to most of the time.

They let the logging company enter on some desperate agreement to grab some US dollars and make a few bucks. That same company sweeps out it's logs and then wants more, MORE money, government bends over and trees come down.

I blame the Canadian government for following the US lead and bowing to their needs. Yes, we need trade between our countries, Americans rely heavily on our oil and gas, grains, electricity etc. We rely on the income from exports, but there seems to be no boundaries that aren't constantly crossed.

The US government has even been so nice as ot offer us a DEAL. Offering to finally pay Canada a PORTION of the 5 billion owed in softwood tariffs. So why does the Canadian government continue to permit logging and exporting of softwood to the US? When I'm in business, you either pay or you don't get your next order. Not so with our governments though. I know hoards of loggers, lived at the end of a logging road in Port Hardy, they were neighbours, friends and often clients too. They have to earn a living, but the greed coming from some US companies is putting their jobs in jeopardy. The US doesn't want to buy our lumber and pay tariffs, they want to log it too.

by jamesrl

Crime of the Century:
Who are these men of lust greed and glory,
Rip off the mask and let's see
No thats not right, oh no whats the story
Look theres you and theres me (that can't be).

The UN is a member organization. The failings of the UN are the failings of the member countries.

You want to blame the UN for Rwanda? Blame the US ambassador to the UN at the time and the president who gave her marching orders to veto any UN action.

You want to blame the UN for the failings of a peacekeeping mission - the UN doesn't have an army. Members lend their armed forces to the UN. If you want to blame UN peacekeepers, you paint the US Canadian and British armies with the same brush.

If you want to blame the UN for things, pick on the UN agencies which have some level of autonomy like the World Health Organization or Unicef. But peacekeeping is all controlled by the security council and the US is a permanent member with a permanent veto.

I'm not suggesting the UN is perfect. But its too easy a target for some accusations.

James

by tonythetiger

who are already doing everything they reasonably can. Typical collectivist garbage.

If they really wanted to propose something fair, it would be on a per capita basis. They won't do that though, since (in this country at least) the biggest proponents of [i]green[/i] are also the biggest wasters of resources. They were the parents who told their children, "Do as I say, not as I do." Grown-ups have a different term ... [b]hypocrit![/b]

by absolutely

Nature is [u]not static[/u]. Extreme,
preservationist-type environmentalists
describe systems as static which are
actually described mathematically as
dynamic equilibrium. When we attempt to
petrify such systems into static
equilibrium, the same forces or factors
that had kept the dynamic system close to
an equilibrium point, then react against
our interference with events that represent
a major departure from any equilibrium
behavior. Real "ecologists" with proper
academic credentials are sure to know this,
but when somebody bright like the founder
of Greenpeace gets enough people convinced
of his "cause", they start misunderstanding
the intellectual basis of that cause,
getting it wrong, and making messes of the
systems they wish to protect. The massive
forest fires are a brilliant example to use
to illustrate that.

The political & social phenomenon described
also has critical implications on the
importance of [u]real[/u] mathematical
literacy, meaning more than the
mere "basics". The four arithmetic
operations are enough to survive in the
world, meaning hold down a respectable job
& balance a checkbook. But to speak
meaningfully about systems having
complicated interactions, such as positive
and/or negative feedback, requires much
more.

Nature doesn't give a damn about anybody's
intentions. The road to hell is paved with
opinionated ignorance.

by jdclyde

Grams is in there because of a broken hip and will never be able to walk again. Everything else is ticking away just fine.

Once the mind is gone though, it would be a hard call to make, but it would also not fall down to me to make that choice. That would be my two aunts.

As my mom is an active 60 that just got done with her month long bike trip around Lake Huron (as in peddling and sleeping in tents) I shouldn't be faced with this decision personally for quite a while.

This discussion is closed to new replies.